The South one is the best. North (from many sources) has gone downhill

Sumter Tire & Auto
707 South Main St.
Wildwood, FL 34785

Mikes Auto, Fruitland Park

Accurso Auto Repair
352-748-9004

Jason is the owner. They are honest and reasonable. We’ve used them for years.

Don Hilton. Good guy

Sumter Tire in Wildwood. The most honest, reasonably price auto repair shop around.

Hilton Auto Repair on 441/27 - 1 block north of 42. Family owned. Been going there for over 15 years.

Sumter Tire on 301 in Wildwood , two locations, but great service and honest prices

Good service is one thing.
You know if you were serviced good based on the experience and how your repair held up.


But how do you know who is honest?
If you didn't get at least a few estimates on your repair/service you can't possibly know.
And who gets estimates when your car needs repair? Not many. Way too time consuming.
It's basically, luck of the draw.

I agree, Hutson is family run and do awesome work. They don’t rip you off and try to sell you something that you don’t need 👍👍👍👍

Hilton Automotive on 441 just above 42 owned by Don Hilton

Wildwood Tire, just east of 301 on 44

I think when you talk about honesty it means you feel you were treated fairly. Unless one estimate is way higher you really can't tell if you were taken. An estimate may be higher if they price quoted dealer parts vs aftermarket, garage rate may be higher etc. It doesn't mean they're dishonest they just charging what they feel their work is worth.

You can save, sometimes a lot of, money by using an aftermarket part. Couple years ago my steering arms needed replacing on the car I had. The dealership cost per arm was $225. The aftermarket cost through Advanced Auto was $75. Same part just didn't have a Mopar logo.

Sumter tire and auto 301 in Wildwood

That’s really an oxymoron!! 😄

Wildwood Tire on 44. Using them for 10 years