Pie:
 

[You should learn to make a pie yourself I’m sure it would be much more meaningful to her if you made a pie for her while she was out there not hard to make just remember when you make your pie do use ice cold waterQUOTE=GpaVader;2091607]My wife is having a birthday and she isn't a cake person she's a pie person. Usually I would just go to a Baker's Square back home and get her a lemon supreme pie, but I have no idea where I can find something like that here. The pies at Publix are all pre-made and they are all fruit pies as in apple, cherry, etc... Does anyone have any recommendations for good pies in the area?

Thanks[/QUOTE]

Best pie in the area, although it's not cheap but it is made from scratch, is the sweetery on 301 in Wildwood. We bought the apple pie for an occasion and everyone thought we made it. Best pie I've had in a very long time, better than anything sold at Publix, perkins, sams, etc

go check them out, if you want to try the pie, the restaurant on the corner there does serve it.

I Cakes
Cupcakes
Pies
Pastries
For all occasions
Small Heading
Donna's Dream Cakes

Pies
 

Betty Cakes in Ocala has some delicious cakes, but they also have some great looking pies.

Best pies at Perkins
 

Best Pies at Perkins ❤️

Perkins makes a great lemon pie.

Make one. Its a piece of cake.
Village Inn Lemon Supreme Pie Recipes

Fresh market!!!
 

Fresh market!!!

Call this place in Wildwood. If they don’t have one ask if they make one for you. It’s a restaurant with bakery next door. Southern Food & Amazing cakes | Miz Kathi s Cotillion Southern Cafe & Sweetery

Pie
 

Rose Plantation. Famous for home made pies.

Perkins.

Worth the drive
 

Great pie at the Front Porch in Dunnellon! It’s an hour drive from my house in Poinciana village but totally worth the drive. It’s also a restaurant, so you can take your wife for a birthday meal too. Enjoy!

Perkins has delicious pies!

Try giving Publix a call and ask if they would make a lemon supreme pie. You never know, maybe they could do that for you. If not, someone else mentioned Perkins and they have great pies. Maybe they would be willing to make a lemon supreme pie just for your wife's special day.

Thanks for all the suggestions and ideas. This is a surprise party so making the pie really isn't an option. I ended up ordering one with Donna's Dream Cakes. The places either didn't make or didn't respond to my VM or messages on FB. I'll let you know how it goes.