Originally Posted by TV Tom
(Post 513092)
Harleyman,
I understand your problems with renting, which are very unfortunate, but buying does cost much more than renting for a part-timer. Your post does not address the fact that since you paid cash, you have taken away the earning power of all of the money you have spent on your home, furniture, etc. Even in a bad market, you should be able to earn at least least 4%, on average, with conservative investments (for example, $8,000 on $200,000 that you may have invested in a property). In addition, you are paying utilities, lawn maintenance, amenities fees, bond, insurance, taxes, etc. for the time you are not there.
I understand the convenience and comfort of being able to go to TV whenever you would like to a place that you love, but there is a fairly steep cost to do it.
I plan to buy in TV in the future, but even with rising home prices, I am choosing to keep my money invested and wait until I can be there full-time. Ultimately, you can afford a nicer home. I have run the numbers many times and a part-time home costs a significant amount of money vs. renting. In TV situation where you cannot rent it in the summer, it is more expensive than other locations, e.g., near the beach. There has been some appreciation in the value of homes, depending on when you bought and this obviously can't be ignored, but all things being equal, your other home has likely appreciated as well. So, if you sell it later and then buy at a higher price at TV later, this is a wash.
As I said in my previous post, if you have the money to spend and want to do it as a lifestyle decision, great. I wish I could do it. But if you are an average guy like me and want to make a decision purely based on finances, you are better off renting.
|