Talk of The Villages Florida

Talk of The Villages Florida (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/)
-   The Villages, Florida, General Discussion (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/villages-florida-general-discussion-73/)
-   -   Are Stop Signs in The Villages really just suggestion? (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/villages-florida-general-discussion-73/stop-signs-villages-really-just-suggestion-126062/)

villagetinker 09-07-2014 09:57 AM

Two points on circles, back in PA there is one in Easton, PA, that to this day I have no idea how to use it. They actually have TRAFFIC SIGNALS on it, with only red and yellow lamps! I avoid it a all costs. They converted the intersection of route 29 and 73 to a circle a few years ago, and I must say it improved traffic flow considerably. I need to point out it is SINGLE LANE WIDE, and I believe this is the reason it works so well.

I would be a very interesting experiment to take traffic cones, and convert the existing TV circles to SINGLE LANE. I think this would eliminate a lot of problems.
Just my thoughts.

Dr Winston O Boogie jr 09-07-2014 10:00 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by villagetinker (Post 934418)
Two points on circles, back in PA there is one in Easton, PA, that to this day I have no idea how to use it. They actually have TRAFFIC SIGNALS on it, with only red and yellow lamps! I avoid it a all costs. They converted the intersection of route 29 and 73 to a circle a few years ago, and I must say it improved traffic flow considerably. I need to point out it is SINGLE LANE WIDE, and I believe this is the reason it works so well.

I would be a very interesting experiment to take traffic cones, and convert the existing TV circles to SINGLE LANE. I think this would eliminate a lot of problems.
Just my thoughts.

Really? You think that thousands of people trying to merge either before or while entering the round a bout would be safer than the simple method of just staying in your lane?

janmcn 09-07-2014 10:00 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pointer (Post 934403)
How about a sign at the Village entrances that say; You're now entering a 55 and older Golf Cart community. Please leave your old habits behind. Some of us are slowing up so you should too!
P.S. It's a law to stop for pedestrians, red lights and stop signs.

Excellent idea. Anybody that has a problem with elderly drivers, here's a hint, don't move to a retirement community. Florida, like most states, does not require anyone to retake a driving test just because they are aging. All residents are getting older, not younger.

denise adams 09-07-2014 10:12 AM

Can you provide some education to us on how to enter and exit the circles? I think I know the only legal way to do it (per the Sheriff's Dept) but wanted to hear what you'd say. If I'm right, a perfectly safe exit from the circle is impossible

"Its sometimes OK to roll through stop signs if you can clearly see no traffic coming from either direction" was one of the quotes on this thread. Where does the law say thats OK? Or is it more of an "attitude" by the driver?

Dr Winston O Boogie jr 09-07-2014 10:34 AM

I just had an interesting incident. As I was riding my bike, I was approaching and intersection to my left about 50 yards in front of me. A car came through the intersection and made a right turn. A car behind him came to a complete stop at the stop sign, looked at me, looked to his left and then pulled out right in front of me and I jammed on my brakes. As he was coming out of the intersection, he looked back toward me and cut off the corner of the intersection and stayed in the wrong lane for a little bit in order to avoid me colliding with him.

I guess for some people he was fine because he came to a complete stop at the stop sign.

As I continued my ride, I stopped at several busy intersections and noticed that not one car came to a full and complete stop with zero rotation of the wheels and not one of these cars caused any kind of a problem. They could see very well in every direction while rolling a four or five mph. They all proceeded very safely. But the guy that came to a full stop, almost caused and accident.

I go back to my point and say that it's not always about following the letter of the law and getting all the little details correct. It's about using common sense to proceed safely.

Dr Winston O Boogie jr 09-07-2014 10:40 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by denise adams (Post 934431)
Can you provide some education to us on how to enter and exit the circles? I think I know the only legal way to do it (per the Sheriff's Dept) but wanted to hear what you'd say. If I'm right, a perfectly safe exit from the circle is impossible

"Its sometimes OK to roll through stop signs if you can clearly see no traffic coming from either direction" was one of the quotes on this thread. Where does the law say thats OK? Or is it more of an "attitude" by the driver?

If you are entering the round about at six o'clock and are going to exit it at three o'clock should use the left hand lane. If you're planning on exiting it at 12:00 you can use either lane. If your going to exit at 9:00 or continue all around and exit where you entered, you should use the left hand lane. How is it that a perfectly safe exit is not possible?

A driver obviously needs to be aware of other cars around him and sometimes we need to make a decision on whether to go in front of a car or slow down and let that car pass. These decisions are made all the time whether or not you're in a round a bout.

tommy steam 09-07-2014 01:20 PM

People will roll thru stop signs until the get a ticket for a moving violation and their insurance goes up. I always stop, full at stop signs. I don't interpret the law to suit myself.

Christine G 09-07-2014 02:22 PM

Lol, taxi or tax, cost you dollars to pay for either.

justjim 09-07-2014 02:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dr Winston O Boogie jr (Post 934446)
If you are entering the round about at six o'clock and are going to exit it at three o'clock should use the left hand lane. If you're planning on exiting it at 12:00 you can use either lane. If your going to exit at 9:00 or continue all around and exit where you entered, you should use the left hand lane. How is it that a perfectly safe exit is not possible?

A driver obviously needs to be aware of other cars around him and sometimes we need to make a decision on whether to go in front of a car or slow down and let that car pass. These decisions are made all the time whether or not you're in a round a bout.

Dr. I think you meant right lane if you enter the round about at 6:00 and exit at 3:00. Studies do show the round abouts are efficient.

JCMSr 09-07-2014 04:43 PM

While I agree that "most" of the time it is possible to perform a safe right hand turn at an intersection without coming to a complete stop this still does not make this action legal! If the sign says Stop then do so or face the consequences. If the sign say Yield you can proceed without first stopping.

KeepingItReal 09-07-2014 07:14 PM

Additions To Stop Signs
 
1 Attachment(s)
Maybe we need a few of these.....

Christine G 09-07-2014 07:47 PM

Yes!

denise adams 09-07-2014 08:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by justjim (Post 934552)
Dr. I think you meant right lane if you enter the round about at 6:00 and exit at 3:00. Studies do show the round abouts are efficient.

Like you, I also hope Dr. meant the right lane. But, to continue with his scenario, think about this:
Car enters from 6 o'clock and wants to exit at 12 o'clock (get in the left or right lane per Dr. instructions). At the same time, another car enters at 3 o'clock and wants to exit at 9 o'clock (right lane per Dr.). How does the car coming from 3 o'clock continue past 12 o'clock if the 6 o'clock vehicle is in the left lane?
BTW, the sheriff says if you go 1/4 or 1/2 the way around, use the right lane. if you go 3/4, use the left lane. But, wait a minute, they also say STOP at STOP signs, not slow and go so they can't be right:police:

Dr Winston O Boogie jr 09-07-2014 09:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by justjim (Post 934552)
Dr. I think you meant right lane if you enter the round about at 6:00 and exit at 3:00. Studies do show the round abouts are efficient.

Of course you are correct. sorry about that.

Dr Winston O Boogie jr 09-07-2014 09:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by denise adams (Post 934698)
Like you, I also hope Dr. meant the right lane. But, to continue with his scenario, think about this:
Car enters from 6 o'clock and wants to exit at 12 o'clock (get in the left or right lane per Dr. instructions). At the same time, another car enters at 3 o'clock and wants to exit at 9 o'clock (right lane per Dr.). How does the car coming from 3 o'clock continue past 12 o'clock if the 6 o'clock vehicle is in the left lane?
BTW, the sheriff says if you go 1/4 or 1/2 the way around, use the right lane. if you go 3/4, use the left lane. But, wait a minute, they also say STOP at STOP signs, not slow and go so they can't be right:police:

It's very simple. You have to either go in front or or behind the other car. You check your mirror before entering the round a bout and make a decision. In fact when I see another car entering the roundabout I start planning on where I'm going to go.

I've been here for a year and a half and have never had a problem.

Are people driving with blindfolds on? Can they not see the other cars? Do they not have mirrors on their cars?

It's not rocket science. Make sure that your car and another car don't try to occupy the same space at the same time.

Mikeod 09-07-2014 09:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by denise adams (Post 934698)
Like you, I also hope Dr. meant the right lane. But, to continue with his scenario, think about this:
Car enters from 6 o'clock and wants to exit at 12 o'clock (get in the left or right lane per Dr. instructions). At the same time, another car enters at 3 o'clock and wants to exit at 9 o'clock (right lane per Dr.). How does the car coming from 3 o'clock continue past 12 o'clock if the 6 o'clock vehicle is in the left lane?
BTW, the sheriff says if you go 1/4 or 1/2 the way around, use the right lane. if you go 3/4, use the left lane. But, wait a minute, they also say STOP at STOP signs, not slow and go so they can't be right:police:

The car coming from 3 o'clock should not enter until after the cars that entered at 6 o'clock have passed. You don't enter if there are cars in either lane to your left already in the roundabout. That means that even if there is only a car in the inside lane, you still don't enter the outside lane until they have passed. This prevents the scenario you described from happening.

Bonanza 09-07-2014 09:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Christine G (Post 934371)
I don't need a taxi thanks, I obey the rules of the road and the laws of the state , thanks very much!

NYGUY didn't say taxi . . .

He said T A X !!!

NYGUY 09-07-2014 09:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dr Winston O Boogie jr (Post 934717)
....It's not rocket science....

Don't be so sure....:22yikes:

NYGUY 09-07-2014 09:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bonanza (Post 934731)
NYGUY didn't say taxi . . .

He said T A X !!!

Thanks Bonanza, I tried, but somedays it does no good!!

dotti105 09-08-2014 12:37 AM

Anywhere you might be, you will find drivers who think the laws do not apply to the. Thus the stop sign issues.

Cameras would be very effective in catching those offenders. Word would spread like wildfire and The Villages would be a safer place to drive, certainly.

The "round a bouts" are a very effective means of traffic control. There are simply too many drivers who do not understand how to use them and want to make up their own rules. That is what makes them dangerous. If everyone drove them as intended, there would not be a problem.

Pedestrians do have the right of way. Coming out of a store where there is a marked crosswalk it is the drivers responsibility to yield to the pedestrians. There is often a series of shoppers leaving and it can be frustrating to wait. But it is the drivers who are to yield.

I'm not talking about "jay walkers". I'm talking about marked crosswalks in shopping areas.

Many people have a "me first" attitude and feel entitled behind the wheel. We all need to drive very defensively and with courtesy. That would solve any of the problems we see here. Oh yes, and call about getting cameras put in at major intersections. It would be safer and a real moneymaker for these small counties.

Pointer 09-08-2014 04:58 AM

I don't think that putting camera's on stop signs is a very good idea. The cost would be prohibitive. I'd rather think that we don't need more big brother monitoring our behavior, but that we can manage without it.

CFrance 09-08-2014 07:13 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mikeod (Post 934721)
The car coming from 3 o'clock should not enter until after the cars that entered at 6 o'clock have passed. You don't enter if there are cars in either lane to your left already in the roundabout. That means that even if there is only a car in the inside lane, you still don't enter the outside lane until they have passed. This prevents the scenario you described from happening.

That's the part that a lot of folks don't get, or adhere to. The yield signs at the roundabout entrances mean yield to both lanes. If there is someone in either lane, don't enter till they've passed and both lanes are clear. And don't pass anyone, either.

JCMSr 09-08-2014 08:16 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CFrance (Post 934797)
That's the part that a lot of folks don't get, or adhere to. The yield signs at the roundabout entrances mean yield to both lanes. If there is someone in either lane, don't enter till they've passed and both lanes are clear. And don't pass anyone, either.

Could not agree more with this! Cannot count the number of times I have watched a driver enter the roundabout from the right lane, move to the left land at 3:00 and then back to the right to exit at 12:00. For what? Just so they can speed through the roundabout a few miles an hour faster??? I just wait until both lanes are clear and proceed.

Christine G 09-08-2014 11:08 AM

This topic has been going on too long, tax, taxi, who cares, just be careful out there!

slipcovers 09-08-2014 12:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bonanza (Post 934328)
Yes, I'm one of those people!

The circles are a hazard because everyone drives them differently and they are too small in diameter for the purpose they were designed to handle.
Or were they simply put in as eye candy for would-be buyers to say how beautiful they are???
Did you have all these circles where you came from? No! No one did.
You had traffic lights and stop signs.
Were they a problem?
I'm sure not, with perhaps an issue or two here and there which could happen anywhere.

The truth of the matter is that the circles are a nightmare.
They do not control traffic; they only confuse and intimidate most driveers.
No one knows how to drive around them.

So why would stop signs be so terrible here when stop signs are what everyone that lives here is used to and probably what they grew up with their entire life.

Huh?


HELLO !! Everyone posting on this thread is saying how dangerous stop signs are.

If you get rid of the circles and wanted to go in the opposite direction, one would have to turn right and go to the next traffic light and make a u turn...of course there would have to be another lane for turning,,, making BV or Morse a 3 lane each side. People would still try to run the light or perhaps drive across 6 lanes of traffic. But of course, you are the expert.

People need more education on the circles....homeowners need to leave very detailed instructions for renters. Daily Sun also should. There are no more traffic problems in TV than any other desirable part of Florida. Old people are very dangerous so, as someone posted, Drive defensively.


There are plenty of circles where I come from in different sizes. Cape Cod has them everywhere and traffic in the Summer is worse than TV. Circles are all over the UK and Australia....Mostly small ones. Encountered many in California.

Bonanza 09-08-2014 10:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by slipcovers (Post 934947)
HELLO !! Everyone posting on this thread is saying how dangerous stop signs are.

If you get rid of the circles and wanted to go in the opposite direction, one would have to turn right and go to the next traffic light and make a u turn...of course there would have to be another lane for turning,,, making BV or Morse a 3 lane each side. People would still try to run the light or perhaps drive across 6 lanes of traffic. But of course, you are the expert.

People need more education on the circles....homeowners need to leave very detailed instructions for renters. Daily Sun also should. There are no more traffic problems in TV than any other desirable part of Florida. Old people are very dangerous so, as someone posted, Drive defensively.

There are plenty of circles where I come from in different sizes. Cape Cod has them everywhere and traffic in the Summer is worse than TV. Circles are all over the UK and Australia....Mostly small ones. Encountered many in California.

HELLO!!!

EVERYONE posting on this thread is not saying how dangerous stop signs are. Everyone means 100%.
I never said I was an expert. You said it and that comment is offensive.

Removing a circle would create tons of room for making a left or right hand turn.
You would not have to make Buena Vista and Morse three lanes; there would not be a reason to do that.
Of course removing them would never happen and we are only speaking hypothetically.
However, unless there's something wrong with my thinking, if a circle was removed and you wanted to go in the opposite direction,
you simply make a U-turn at the intersection.
And yes -- a turn lane could be created because it would be so easy to do.

People do not need more education regarding navigating circles.
Everyone drives them in a different way and you will never convince the public at learge to all do it the same way.
It's always "the other guy" who is wrong.

Homeowners and the newspaper need to leave detailed instructions to renters? Isn't that going a little too far?
Having lived in Florida for many years, yes -- there are more traffic problems here than other parts of Florida,
particularly in areas which are flooded with snowbirds in season.

People run red lights and stop signs all over the world and nothing is going to change.
It happens and will continue to happen. Nothing new there.

Where is it that you are from that there are plenty of circles?
You mention other specific areas but failed to mention that.

There are circles in all areas of the country, but there is no place that is overwhelmed with them as here.
Yes, Australia has some and in the UK they are very old. Not a good example.
I don't know what part of California you mean, but I have never encountered "many of them."
I think some of your comments are exaggerations.

Bonanza 09-08-2014 10:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rango (Post 934025)
I'm seasonal. In my home county everyone uses turn signals and stop at stop signs.

We also have 3 reported rapes a week and average 20 murders per year.

We sure have a serious problem here in The Villages

Quote:

Originally Posted by slipcovers (Post 934396)
Excuse me,BONANZA, my question was to Rambo.....what County would have 20 murders? And there is nothing humorous about rapes and murders.

Rambo made a post for anyone to read.
Everyone is entitled to comment to a post made on this forum because it is public.

Rambo did not say there was anything humorous about rapes and murders.
However, his comment, if understood, was funny.
He was simply pointing out how insignificant the issue of stops signs,
turn signals, etc., is when compared to rapes and murders.

Obviously, he was being facetious in saying we have a serious problem here in TV!

dotti105 09-09-2014 12:08 AM

Wow! People are really blowing this out of proportion. I don't think any comments are to be taken personally. It is a topic of concern and various viewpoints will be expressed.

Why are some of you on the offense here? Very odd.

Lots of roundabouts in the Salt Lake City suburbs in Utah. Lots in Clearwater, Florida, lots in Folsom, El Dorado Hills, Roseville, areas of Ca. Many places with newer neighborhoods are using roundabouts to expedite traffic control. My hubby retired from Utah dept of transportation and we see them everywhere we travel.

They are new to many and seem strange at first, but are a great way to keep traffic in all directions moving. Caution is the key, as always, when driving.

Drive defensively and with courtesy!! Simple as that! Oh, good idea to obey traffic laws too. Like stop signs!!!

slipcovers 09-09-2014 09:09 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bonanza;93***0
It's pretty obvious that Rango thinks there isn't any problem here in TV,
when you take into consideration what is going on in other cities.

What's happening here is "small potatoes" in comparison.

Rango, I like your humor!

No, Rango did not find it humorous,...this was your quote.


According to Wikapedia "At junctions with stop signs or traffic lights, the most serious accidents are right angle, left turn or head on collisions, where vehicles move fast and collide at high impact angles, e.g. head on. Roundabouts virtually eliminate those types of crashes. Instead, most crashes are glancing blows at low angles of impact."


I cant imagine trying to make a u turn at a stop sign, proceeding across 4 lanes of traffic to head in the opposite direction. One would definitely need side air bags.

Bill Tasker 09-09-2014 11:56 AM

We have vacationed at TV for years (18+) and I have to say as far as driving goes, this vacation was the rudest I have ever experienced at TV. Aggressive, short tempered, horn blowing, bird flying, ignoring stop signs, yelling, etc.. On one occasion I was cut off by a cart driver at LSL, making an illegal left turn on a red light almost causing the tailgater behind me to hit us. He then proceeded to yell he has the right of way “because he lives there.” At another intersection as soon as the light turned green, the gal behind me in her SUV blows her horn. I guess she was late for her tee time.

Chazz 09-09-2014 08:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by JCMSr (Post 934823)
Could not agree more with this! Cannot count the number of times I have watched a driver enter the roundabout from the right lane, move to the left land at 3:00 and then back to the right to exit at 12:00. For what? Just so they can speed through the roundabout a few miles an hour faster??? I just wait until both lanes are clear and proceed.

Ahh, lane surfing! That's a pet peeve of mine, and can be very dangerous.

Regarding our roundabouts and the rules for traveling in them, there are signs that indicate the proper usage in the approaches to each of them

Kahuna32162 09-09-2014 08:42 PM

And how do those signs help you when someone cuts in front of you to because you were following the rules and they didn't have a clue? This is not a snow bird thing, it happens everyday.

Kahuna32162 09-09-2014 08:48 PM

Also, I think we should put this to rest, it's getting ugly!

Bonanza 09-10-2014 01:25 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CFrance (Post 934797)
That's the part that a lot of folks don't get, or adhere to. The yield signs at the roundabout entrances mean yield to both lanes. If there is someone in either lane, don't enter till they've passed and both lanes are clear. And don't pass anyone, either.

Quote:

Originally Posted by JCMSr (Post 934823)
Could not agree more with this! Cannot count the number of times I have watched a driver enter the roundabout from the right lane, move to the left land at 3:00 and then back to the right to exit at 12:00. For what? Just so they can speed through the roundabout a few miles an hour faster??? I just wait until both lanes are clear and proceed.

You are absolutely correct in what you are saying. But here's where the real problem is:

The green sign as you approach the circle, tells you how you should drive around the circle. But then you get to the actual circle where we have painted lines within the circle. The painted lines belie what the green signs say. Dotted lines on any road, say you can change lanes.

Is it any wonder the circles are a problem? In actuality, the guy who was changing lanes was within his legal right, according to the dotted lines.

So which do you follow . . . the green sign or the dotted lines???
:shrug:


Bonanza 09-10-2014 02:04 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by slipcovers (Post 935341)
No, Rango did not find it humorous,...this was your quote.


According to Wikapedia "At junctions with stop signs or traffic lights, the most serious accidents are right angle, left turn or head on collisions, where vehicles move fast and collide at high impact angles, e.g. head on. Roundabouts virtually eliminate those types of crashes. Instead, most crashes are glancing blows at low angles of impact."


I cant imagine trying to make a u turn at a stop sign, proceeding across 4 lanes of traffic to head in the opposite direction. One would definitely need side air bags.

You need to make your posts more clear. It appears that your quote was referencing me when you mentioned Rango's comment about rapes and murders. This was your quote verbatim:


Originally Posted by slipcovers View Post

Excuse me,BONANZA, my question was to Rango.....what County would have 20 murders? And there is nothing humorous about rapes and murders.


Regarding the Wikipedia (correct spelling) quote. Where did the quote come from. Wikipedia always makes reference to the source.

Also, I never said anything regarding making a U-turn at a stop sign. A U-turn can be at a traffic light or in the middle of a road or actually, anywhere there is a turn lane.

You still haven't mentioned what city you were from where you said there are many circles. Where is this?

Jaggy 09-10-2014 06:42 AM

I am making a public vow to quit reading this thread, It is hurting my brain .

yabbadu 09-10-2014 08:16 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kahuna32162 (Post 935705)
And how do those signs help you when someone cuts in front of you to because you were following the rules and they didn't have a clue? This is not a snow bird thing, it happens everyday.

No different than when one cuts you off on any road anywhere!

Djembe dude 09-10-2014 03:21 PM

It is just like the people who have golf carts that go over 20 mph. You can't fix stupid.

coffeebean 09-15-2014 04:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bonanza (Post 934328)
Yes, I'm one of those people!

The circles are a hazard because everyone drives them differently and they are too small in diameter for the purpose they were designed to handle.
Or were they simply put in as eye candy for would-be buyers to say how beautiful they are???
Did you have all these circles where you came from? No! No one did.
You had traffic lights and stop signs.
Were they a problem?
I'm sure not, with perhaps an issue or two here and there which could happen anywhere.

The truth of the matter is that the circles are a nightmare.
They do not control traffic; they only confuse and intimidate most driveers.
No one knows how to drive around them.

So why would stop signs be so terrible here when stop signs are what everyone that lives here is used to and probably what they grew up with their entire life.

Huh?

Have you ever come to a four way stop and no one knows who's turn it is to proceed? It is anxiety producing to say the least. IMHO, the RABs are very safe if you drive them defensively. That is the key. I NEVER allow anyone to drive beside me. I will alter my speed so NO ONE is ever beside me.....EVER. I've never had a problem in the RABs and I'm here during the winter months when it is busiest on the roads.

coffeebean 09-15-2014 04:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Christine G (Post 934371)
I don't need a taxi thanks, I obey the rules of the road and the laws of the state , thanks very much!

The word is TAX not TAXI. I think you might have misread that. LOL.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:32 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Search Engine Optimisation provided by DragonByte SEO v2.0.32 (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2025 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.