Talk of The Villages Florida

Talk of The Villages Florida (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/)
-   The Villages, Florida, General Discussion (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/villages-florida-general-discussion-73/)
-   -   Will we hit herd immunity? (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/villages-florida-general-discussion-73/will-we-hit-herd-immunity-317625/)

Neils 03-20-2021 11:21 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by charmed59 (Post 1917855)
I see in Sumter county the percent of seniors vaccinated for COVID is leveling out at just over 60%. If we need 75% to hit herd immunity we’d need over 90% of those under 65 to be vaccinated, which seems unlikely.

Is there some number of seniors that intend to get vaccinated but haven’t yet? If so, what are they waiting for? I’m hopeful seeing the Villages Health is now inoculating their members.

Data can be misleading. Add in the people that have had covid and recovered, plus unknown numbers of those that had the virus but were unsymptomatic.

Heard immunity may be much closer than it appears.

Byte1 03-20-2021 11:31 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by GoPacers (Post 1918545)
You will NEVER know if you've infected another person with COVID, the flu, the common cold or any other disease. Such a declarative statement suggests your points are emotion vs logic.
Odds are that we all have infected another person with some disease at some point in our lives.

Any of us CAN infect anyone else with any disease. Thoughtful and respectful people will take precautions to reduce that probability. What those actions are is worthy of debate as you suggest (and I agree with). As a society this is not a novel concept. We have thousands of laws whose primary intent is to protect the many from the actions of the few.

That's life. Or, if your glass is half empty.....death.

oldtimes 03-20-2021 11:35 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by golfing eagles (Post 1918356)
I agree, the ignorance is amazing

That is an understatement. It’s like the Twilight Zone.

Velvet 03-20-2021 12:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by GeriS (Post 1918315)
You are so right. The information is out there if people would research rather than following what someone like Fauci, who has ties to the Wuhan lab, says. Check the cdc site for what's in it. You will be horrified. You can also find out the thousands of people who have been injured by the vaccine. There has not been one study that proves masks work, & before you argue, please post the scientific study. Fauci continually moves the goal post. If you believe anything he says, it's sad.

And the moon is made out of blue cheese too.

doodles 03-20-2021 01:21 PM

Stop thinking about yourself, think kids and grandkids. If you were holding your infant grand child in your arms wouldn’t you want to know the person next to you had been vaccinated

charmed59 03-20-2021 01:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Finchs (Post 1918534)
Because of the lengthy delays in getting Covid Vaccinations in the county of your residence, many of us (me included) went way far away from our home counties to be vaccinated. If Sumter can say they have vaccinated 60%, that's pretty good--many of the residents already got theirs quicker elsewhere.

The published county numbers are not for the county giving out the vaccines, but the resident county where the person getting the vaccine lives. So those that went elsewhere show up in the Sumter numbers. And those seasonal folks that were vaccinated in Sumter county, but live out of state show up in the out of state category. We may have quite a few of that 112K pot.

The reason the Sumter County numbers kept rising despite GMR shutting down at the beginning of Feb was due to dedicated folks traveling about. And I, for one, appreciate that.

DeanFL 03-20-2021 01:51 PM

.
.
We got both of our Moderna shots and all set. Very happy and comfortable with the decision and Sumter Co's service.

I sent an email to my 'ex', living in N.C. with her live-in. We're 'kinda-OK-friendly', and I mentioned about our Covid shots. She wrote back this morning>>

"XXXX and I are not on board with the experimental vaccines which make changes to your DNA. My sister XXXXX who worked in the pharmaceutical industry for a long time ( she just retired last year) advises against getting the vaccine. She said she will not go near it. So we are holding out and just bolstering our immune systems with vitamins and supplements. There are good therapeutics and overall 98.5% survival rate which is better than for flu. (Also, Bill Gates has the patent on the Covid virus, the vaccine, and the testing kit- that makes this all very fishy!)"

Oh well.... I don't get it, but looks as if there IS quite a large % of Americans who feel that way and will be holdouts... for whatever reason. IMO why take the GIVEN risk of contracting Covid - esp at our age.
.
.

Velvet 03-20-2021 01:57 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DeanFL (Post 1918606)
.
.
We got both of our Moderna shots and all set. Very happy and comfortable with the decision and Sumter Co's service.

I sent an email to my 'ex', living in N.C. with her live-in. We're 'kinda-OK-friendly', and I mentioned about our Covid shots. She wrote back this morning>>

"XXXX and I are not on board with the experimental vaccines which make changes to your DNA. My sister XXXXX who worked in the pharmaceutical industry for a long time ( she just retired last year) advises against getting the vaccine. She said she will not go near it. So we are holding out and just bolstering our immune systems with vitamins and supplements. There are good therapeutics and overall 98.5% survival rate which is better than for flu. (Also, Bill Gates has the patent on the Covid virus, the vaccine, and the testing kit- that makes this all very fishy!)"

Oh well.... I don't get it, but looks as if there IS quite a large % of Americans who feel that way and will be holdouts... for whatever reason. IMO why take the GIVEN risk of contracting Covid - esp at our age.
.
.

Your ex is so funny, I almost... laughing. Except it is also so serious. Wish the very best to these fearful individuals.

LiverpoolWalrus 03-20-2021 02:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dayeight99 (Post 1918150)
It’s not a vaccination against a virus. It is gene therapy. Completely different. Research and DD.

By “DD,” I think the poster means due diligence.

GoPacers 03-20-2021 03:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DeanFL (Post 1918606)
.
.
We got both of our Moderna shots and all set. Very happy and comfortable with the decision and Sumter Co's service.

I sent an email to my 'ex', living in N.C. with her live-in. We're 'kinda-OK-friendly', and I mentioned about our Covid shots. She wrote back this morning>>

"XXXX and I are not on board with the experimental vaccines which make changes to your DNA. My sister XXXXX who worked in the pharmaceutical industry for a long time ( she just retired last year) advises against getting the vaccine. She said she will not go near it. So we are holding out and just bolstering our immune systems with vitamins and supplements. There are good therapeutics and overall 98.5% survival rate which is better than for flu. (Also, Bill Gates has the patent on the Covid virus, the vaccine, and the testing kit- that makes this all very fishy!)"

Oh well.... I don't get it, but looks as if there IS quite a large % of Americans who feel that way and will be holdouts... for whatever reason. IMO why take the GIVEN risk of contracting Covid - esp at our age.
.
.

The COVID vaccine does NOT alter one's DNA. Geesh sheeple. It's amazing the cr&p that is out there and gets repeated to the point that people believe it.

tvbound 03-20-2021 03:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Villages Kahuna (Post 1918486)
Maybe not. Surveys seem to show that a high percentage of one political party are refusing to be vaccinated, enough to prevent achieving a high enough percentage of vaccinations to achieve herd immunity. I can’t figure out why politics should effect medical decisions, but there’s a lot of our national politics that I don’t understand these days.

My wife and I got the Pfizer vaccine and still use masks and practice social distancing. We feel personally safe and have high confidence that we won’t pass any virus on to others.

Agreed.

The fact that the vast majority of the current anti-Covid vaccine crowd had no problems with their kids getting childhood vaccinations and the associated booster shots, proves that it's not really about the vaccine itself.

newgirl 03-20-2021 03:36 PM

It was extremely difficult to get a appointment for everyone until last week or so.

DeanFL 03-20-2021 03:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by GoPacers (Post 1918639)
The COVID vaccine does NOT alter one's DNA. Geesh sheeple. It's amazing the cr&p that is out there and gets repeated to the point that people believe it.

.
.
Yep - I just sent her an email reply - I attempted to be somehwhat 'kind'>>>

We did a bit of research and heard from a lot of folks before getting our shots, and had not a bit of hesitiation re the Moderna vaccine. The Bill Gates-thing seems to be far-fetched, perhaps his foundation gave $$$ to pharma for research. And the DNA-change matter has been thoroughly debunked. I think these things are pushed by conspiracy groups for whatever reason.

We're happy to get the vaccine, and feel that we are protected - even planning mid-year travel now. At our age we surely don't want to take chances and live in fear.

.
.

golfing eagles 03-20-2021 04:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DeanFL (Post 1918606)
.
.
We got both of our Moderna shots and all set. Very happy and comfortable with the decision and Sumter Co's service.

I sent an email to my 'ex', living in N.C. with her live-in. We're 'kinda-OK-friendly', and I mentioned about our Covid shots. She wrote back this morning>>

"XXXX and I are not on board with the experimental vaccines which make changes to your DNA. My sister XXXXX who worked in the pharmaceutical industry for a long time ( she just retired last year) advises against getting the vaccine. She said she will not go near it. So we are holding out and just bolstering our immune systems with vitamins and supplements. There are good therapeutics and overall 98.5% survival rate which is better than for flu. (Also, Bill Gates has the patent on the Covid virus, the vaccine, and the testing kit- that makes this all very fishy!)"

Oh well.... I don't get it, but looks as if there IS quite a large % of Americans who feel that way and will be holdouts... for whatever reason. IMO why take the GIVEN risk of contracting Covid - esp at our age.
.
.

Good luck to her
But for everyone else, so they don't get misinformed, this is a PSA:

The vaccine is no longer "experimental", it is the standard of care
It DOES NOT alter your DNA
The survival rate of seasonal flu is 99.9%+
And "vitamins and supplements" are fine, but they won't protect you from COVID

nick demis 03-20-2021 05:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Boffin (Post 1917875)
Given the general definition: immunity or resistance to a particular infection that occurs in a group of animals when a very high percentage of individuals have been vaccinated or previously exposed to the infection, yes, herd immunity, including variants, will likely occur sometime.

Herd immunity occurs when a combination of vaccines and natural immunity occurs. We may already be there.

GoPacers 03-20-2021 05:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by golfing eagles (Post 1918684)
Good luck to her
But for everyone else, so they don't get misinformed, this is a PSA:

The vaccine is no longer "experimental", it is the standard of care
It DOES NOT alter your DNA
The survival rate of seasonal flu is 99.9%+
And "vitamins and supplements" are fine, but they won't protect you from COVID

To be fair, none of the vaccines have received full FDA approval. All have been given Emergency Use Authorization (EUA) to date. This is a nuance of the FDA but there is no way we'd have the vaccines today if we required full FDA approval. That process simply takes much longer. This doesn't make the vaccine unsafe or ineffective. It just means all the steps for FDA approval have not been met.

Our government did what they were supposed to do, working with corporate America, regulatory agencies and scientists to bring a much needed vaccine to market as quickly as possible. If one cares, they can read exactly what EUA means but many very important medical advances were initially cleared this way. That is what the EUA process is for.

And yes, this is most definitely the standard of care and absolutely should be from all that I have read and continue to read.

charmed59 03-20-2021 06:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by nick demis (Post 1918704)
Herd immunity occurs when a combination of vaccines and natural immunity occurs. We may already be there.

If we were already there we would have no new cases most days.

I am hopeful given small number of cases the last two days in the 65 and over group. For 10 days that age group in Sumter County was averaging 9 new cases per day. Yesterday and today there were only 3 cases in those 65+.

Boffin 03-20-2021 06:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DeanFL (Post 1918606)
.
.
We got both of our Moderna shots and all set. Very happy and comfortable with the decision and Sumter Co's service.

I sent an email to my 'ex', living in N.C. with her live-in. We're 'kinda-OK-friendly', and I mentioned about our Covid shots. She wrote back this morning>>

"XXXX and I are not on board with the experimental vaccines which make changes to your DNA. My sister XXXXX who worked in the pharmaceutical industry for a long time ( she just retired last year) advises against getting the vaccine. She said she will not go near it. So we are holding out and just bolstering our immune systems with vitamins and supplements. There are good therapeutics and overall 98.5% survival rate which is better than for flu. (Also, Bill Gates has the patent on the Covid virus, the vaccine, and the testing kit- that makes this all very fishy!)"

Oh well.... I don't get it, but looks as if there IS quite a large % of Americans who feel that way and will be holdouts... for whatever reason. IMO why take the GIVEN risk of contracting Covid - esp at our age.
.
.

People who think the RNA COVID vaccines alter DNA should see this as an opportunity.

Astron 03-20-2021 08:22 PM

Tell that to health care workers
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by camaguey48 (Post 1918054)
It's very healthy to re-breathe your own carbon dioxide.

Sarcasm noted. That is an urban myth. Health care worked have been wearing masks for extended periods for decades without issue. I have personally checked my O2 levels after wearing a mask for hours and found practically no difference.
Finding an excuse to not wear a mask, not social distance or not get a vaccine is just helping the virus by giving it a chance to mutate into something far worse. Odds are it won’t, but it could.

coffeebean 03-20-2021 08:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DeanFL (Post 1918606)
.
.
We got both of our Moderna shots and all set. Very happy and comfortable with the decision and Sumter Co's service.

I sent an email to my 'ex', living in N.C. with her live-in. We're 'kinda-OK-friendly', and I mentioned about our Covid shots. She wrote back this morning>>

"XXXX and I are not on board with the experimental vaccines which make changes to your DNA. My sister XXXXX who worked in the pharmaceutical industry for a long time ( she just retired last year) advises against getting the vaccine. She said she will not go near it. So we are holding out and just bolstering our immune systems with vitamins and supplements. There are good therapeutics and overall 98.5% survival rate which is better than for flu. (Also, Bill Gates has the patent on the Covid virus, the vaccine, and the testing kit- that makes this all very fishy!)"

Oh well.... I don't get it, but looks as if there IS quite a large % of Americans who feel that way and will be holdouts... for whatever reason. IMO why take the GIVEN risk of contracting Covid - esp at our age.
.
.

Please let your ex know that mRNA vaccines do not interact with DNA and can not make changes to DNA. She is misinformed about DNA. This is an excerpt from the CDC website.......

mRNA from the vaccine never enters the nucleus of the cell and does not affect or interact with a person’s DNA.

The excerpt is from this page.....

Understanding and Explaining mRNA COVID-19 Vaccines | CDC

Boffin 03-20-2021 09:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by nick demis (Post 1918704)
Herd immunity occurs when a combination of vaccines and natural immunity occurs. We may already be there.

Correction: Herd immunity may occur when a combination of vaccines and natural immunity occurs. We may, or may not, already be there.

Velvet 03-20-2021 10:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Boffin (Post 1918762)
Correction: Herd immunity may occur when a combination of vaccines and natural immunity occurs. We may, or may not, already be there.

1000 people dying every day ... hope that’s not the definition of herd immunity.

jimjamuser 03-21-2021 11:36 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by charmed59 (Post 1918603)
The published county numbers are not for the county giving out the vaccines, but the resident county where the person getting the vaccine lives. So those that went elsewhere show up in the Sumter numbers. And those seasonal folks that were vaccinated in Sumter county, but live out of state show up in the out of state category. We may have quite a few of that 112K pot.

The reason the Sumter County numbers kept rising despite GMR shutting down at the beginning of Feb was due to dedicated folks traveling about. And I, for one, appreciate that.

I appreciate that taxpayer dollars were wasted and did NOT resolve the problem for which those dollars were given / taken away.

jimjamuser 03-21-2021 11:42 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DeanFL (Post 1918606)
.
.
We got both of our Moderna shots and all set. Very happy and comfortable with the decision and Sumter Co's service.

I sent an email to my 'ex', living in N.C. with her live-in. We're 'kinda-OK-friendly', and I mentioned about our Covid shots. She wrote back this morning>>

"XXXX and I are not on board with the experimental vaccines which make changes to your DNA. My sister XXXXX who worked in the pharmaceutical industry for a long time ( she just retired last year) advises against getting the vaccine. She said she will not go near it. So we are holding out and just bolstering our immune systems with vitamins and supplements. There are good therapeutics and overall 98.5% survival rate which is better than for flu. (Also, Bill Gates has the patent on the Covid virus, the vaccine, and the testing kit- that makes this all very fishy!)"

Oh well.... I don't get it, but looks as if there IS quite a large % of Americans who feel that way and will be holdouts... for whatever reason. IMO why take the GIVEN risk of contracting Covid - esp at our age.
.
.

"Holdouts" are loved by the Virus. And the "ex" may have parroted back propaganda that originated in a hacking farm in Moscow. The weapon of disinformation is easy to build and less costly than conventional weapons.

jimjamuser 03-21-2021 12:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Byte1 (Post 1918455)
Mass hysteria at it's finest. So many needy people that insist that the gov. protect them, instead of being able/responsible for themselves. Use some common sense and protect yourself from the boogieman. If you do not get the vaccination, then don't expect me to protect you. You have already decided and have to reap the results one way or the other. It's your decision and should NOT be the gov's. Wear a mask or don't wear one. It will have absolutely no effect on me. I have my vaccination, but doubt if I would have become infected anyway. That is my decision and the gov did not make it for me. I have no intention of wearing a mask now, other than if I wish to shop at a place where a mask is requested. And then, I wear it below my nose. If that offends you, cry me a river. If you don't like it, stay a safe distance away, preferably at your home. My children and grandkids have had the virus and shrugged it off in a couple of days or so. They can visit me and I have no fear of infection whatsoever. Want to disagree, that is your prerogative.
The experts I am listening to right now, state that once vaccinated you cannot pass on the virus, period. According to them (whether right or wrong) once the virus enters your system, it is destroyed so you cannot pass it on. Like I have said before, I am not an expert. But, I refuse to listen to gov experts that are nothing more than political hacks. Regardless of credentials, I don't trust them. That is my opinion. So, go on your cruise and feel safe because someone mandates proof of vaccination. But, remember it was the cruise that was one of the first points of infection into the U.S. And remember, many cruises come back to port with a whole ship full of sick folks. There are other diseases out there besides Corona. Same goes with airlines and flying. If you are scared, stay at home. Quit expecting others to conform to your fears.

The experts do NOT say that once vaccinated you can not pass on the CV. That is a fabrication! 5% likely can pass it on. If someone hates the government THAT much, they should go try to find an island of anarchy to live at instead of among civilized adults. Stop paying your taxes. Then you will get placed in a suitable island of anarchy. Good luck! And anyone that goes to the charade of wearing their mask below their nose is like someone with a gun shooting down people in Publix. They are just shooting S L O W bullets of death (droplets)! CDC advice is NOT the enemy of real people. Just those preaching risk and death!

graciegirl 03-21-2021 12:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jimjamuser (Post 1919136)
The experts do NOT say that once vaccinated you can not pass on the CV. That is a fabrication! 5% likely can pass it on. If someone hates the government THAT much, they should go try to find an island of anarchy to live at instead of among civilized adults. Stop paying your taxes. Then you will get placed in a suitable island of anarchy. Good luck! And anyone that goes to the charade of wearing their mask below their nose is like someone with a gun shooting down people in Publix. They are just shooting S L O W bullets of death (droplets)! CDC advice is NOT the enemy of real people. Just those preaching risk and death!

I am replying with quote. I agree with some parts of your post but I do not agree with the attitude. When in a debate, one is taken more seriously if one debates in a tone with valid information without rancor and SOMETIMES light humor is tolerated. Any breach of this and there will be someone who is ****ed and they will answer in a strident tone and then the O.P. will get more in your face and pretty soon there will be marching and burning and looting and that is never acceptable no matter what the issue is. Actually Marching is acceptable but I think it is a worthless endeavor myself.

Carry on.

tvbound 03-21-2021 04:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by graciegirl (Post 1919154)
I am replying with quote. I agree with some parts of your post but I do not agree with the attitude. When in a debate, one is taken more seriously if one debates in a tone with valid information without rancor and SOMETIMES light humor is tolerated. Any breach of this and there will be someone who is ****ed and they will answer in a strident tone and then the O.P. will get more in your face and pretty soon there will be marching and burning and looting and that is never acceptable no matter what the issue is. Actually Marching is acceptable but I think it is a worthless endeavor myself.

Carry on.

"Actually Marching is acceptable but I think it is a worthless endeavor myself."

Women who marched to gain the right to vote, black Americans who marched for equal rights and those who marched to end the Vietnam War - would all disagree with you.

DAVES 03-21-2021 05:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by charmed59 (Post 1917855)
I see in Sumter county the percent of seniors vaccinated for COVID is leveling out at just over 60%. If we need 75% to hit herd immunity we’d need over 90% of those under 65 to be vaccinated, which seems unlikely.

Is there some number of seniors that intend to get vaccinated but haven’t yet? If so, what are they waiting for? I’m hopeful seeing the Villages Health is now inoculating their members.

So much of the information we have is guesses. What is herd immunity? It is a concept and it is not 100%. If, 75% is the number there are roughly 350 million people in the US
side stepping illegal aliens, which that count is also an unconfirmed guess. Thus, 75% of 350 million is 263 million people. The two top suppliers Moderna and Pfizer are two shots so 263x2=525 million shots.

All we can do is the best we can. So far what has been done while not perfect is truly impressive.

It has been done without resorting to forcing people to take a vaccine as was done with polio and small pox shots.

Byte1 03-22-2021 06:58 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jimjamuser (Post 1919136)
The experts do NOT say that once vaccinated you can not pass on the CV. That is a fabrication! 5% likely can pass it on. If someone hates the government THAT much, they should go try to find an island of anarchy to live at instead of among civilized adults. Stop paying your taxes. Then you will get placed in a suitable island of anarchy. Good luck! And anyone that goes to the charade of wearing their mask below their nose is like someone with a gun shooting down people in Publix. They are just shooting S L O W bullets of death (droplets)! CDC advice is NOT the enemy of real people. Just those preaching risk and death!

You can also have YOUR opinion. Sorry to disagree with you, but I DON'T hate the gov. Just disagree with a big brother lording over me to tell me how to live my life, when they also espouse "freedom." Like I said before, if one does not feel safe after getting the vaccination, they should stay home. I did my "duty" by getting vaccinated when I really didn't think it was necessary in my case, so it is up to everyone else to do what they deem necessary to protect themselves. It is not my duty to protect everyone else. And I am of NO danger to anyone if I am not infected. Some folks (glass half empty) believe that everyone is infected. Those folks need some personal assistance, in my opinion.
Some folks ought to consider their demeanor before posting, less their anger get the better of them. By the way, I am not the one that consistently posts on here about how other countries are better than ours....wink, wink.
And, if it is so easy to pass on the virus after being vaccinated, explain how that works. Explain how if a person is not infected, and if the virus is ingested and destroyed, how they can pass it on. I am not the expert and some experts suggest that it can't be passed on. Granted, if you get it on your hands and touch something that someone else then touches shortly thereafter, it may be passed on. How does one do that, IF they are constantly washing their hands? If a person covers their mouth, how does one pass it on, even if they do ingest some virus matter? Like I said, MASS HYSTERIA. I guess anything is possible, but I do not limit basic day to day activities due to someone else's hysteria and fears. I evaluate the current situation and modify my actions according to common(?) sense. By the way, I have NEVER had the flu. Does that mean that I am immune to it, or maybe it means that I am more careful than the average person? And no, I do not get and I have not had the flu shot. No one has ever accused me of "passing on" the flu to them.
Have a great day.

Jerseygirl08 03-23-2021 09:21 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tuccillo (Post 1917937)
You can’t compare HIV with the coronavirus. HIV is not transmitted through the air while the coronavirus is transmitted through the air. If you are not exchanging blood or having sex with the person next to you then you aren’t going to contract HIV.

He was just using it as an example. How about tuberculosis, would that meet your standard? Actually, TB is very treatable if caught soon enough. The point is .... the slippery slope. Having a firearm, being a conservative, being a Christian, Catholic, or Jew, being black, white, Chinese, Iranian, Indian, behind in your taxes, statues in your front yard, and on and on. This list is pretty ridiculous right? Well look at what has happened with the Corona-19 virus. Things spiraled out of control. Power hungry politicians made decisions and enacted edicts that destroyed peoples businesses and even caused death to many (look at suicides alone). Does anybody remember that our social security number was never supposed to be used for anything other than a "social insurance program"? The Social Security Act was enacted by President Roosevelt in 1935 in an attempt to limit poverty in the elderly population. Well then, we see now how Roosevelt's promise has been kicked to the curb. I don't want a "Vaccination Passport". I'm sure many of you don't want one either.

tuccillo 03-23-2021 09:24 AM

Go back and reread my posts. They have nothing to do with what you posted and everything to do with the differences between how the coronavirus and HIV are transmitted. Focus.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jerseygirl08 (Post 1919976)
He was just using it as an example. How about tuberculosis, would that meet your standard? Actually, TB is very treatable if caught soon enough. The point is .... the slippery slope. Having a firearm, being a conservative, being a Christian, Catholic, or Jew, being black, white, Chinese, Iranian, Indian, behind in your taxes, statues in your front yard, and on and on. This list is pretty ridiculous right? Well look at what has happened with the Corona-19 virus. Things spiraled out of control. Power hungry politicians made decisions and enacted edicts that destroyed peoples businesses and even caused death to many (look at suicides alone). Does anybody remember that our social security number was never supposed to be used for anything other than a "social insurance program"? The Social Security Act was enacted by President Roosevelt in 1935 in an attempt to limit poverty in the elderly population. Well then, we see now how Roosevelt's promise has been kicked to the curb. I don't want a "Vaccination Passport". I'm sure many of you don't want one either.


Bill14564 03-23-2021 10:16 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tuccillo (Post 1919980)
Go back and reread my posts. They have nothing to do with what you posted and everything to do with the differences between how the coronavirus and HIV are transmitted. Focus.

Actually, jerseygirl08 seems to understand my exact point. There is no need to reread your posts, I readily acknowledge that you are missing the point.

If a vaccination passport is determined to be essential to protect us from today's virus of the month then it won't be long before it is determined to be essential to protect us from all communicable diseases.

Tuberculosis and meningitis are also transmitted through the air so they should be added to the vaccination passport too. Sure, the risk is low but with all the other precautions being taken and after having the COVID vaccination, the risk of contracting COVID is small too. If proof of vaccination against one is to be required then is it hard to imagine that being extended to require proof of vaccination against all?

While HIV is transmitted differently, who is to say I won't be exposed to blood through some minor accident with the wrapper on the peanuts or a scratch from the armrest or even something more severe like an item dropping from the overhead bin or a plane crash? Accidents happen and I may want to feel safe from even the remote possibility of contracting HIV. If it isn't too much to demand that I prove my COVID vaccination status then there will come a day when it won't be too much to demand that you prove your HIV status.

COVID is the today's super virus but it isn't the first and it won't be the last. We have to be careful that the efforts we propose to make us feel comfortable today aren't something that will make us feel very uncomfortable tomorrow. Once we make it easy to ______ it will also be easy to _____ but we may not like that as much.

tuccillo 03-23-2021 10:22 AM

The chances of contracting HIV from the person sitting next to you is beyond remote. Why do you insist on repeatedly bringing that up? It is irrational to do so. Diseases that can be transmitted through the air are another thing.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bill14564 (Post 1920027)
Actually, jerseygirl08 seems to understand my exact point. There is no need to reread your posts, I readily acknowledge that you are missing the point.

If a vaccination passport is determined to be essential to protect us from today's virus of the month then it won't be long before it is determined to be essential to protect us from all communicable diseases.

Tuberculosis and meningitis are also transmitted through the air so they should be added to the vaccination passport too. Sure, the risk is low but with all the other precautions being taken and after having the COVID vaccination, the risk of contracting COVID is small too. If proof of vaccination against one is to be required then is it hard to imagine that being extended to require proof of vaccination against all?

While HIV is transmitted differently, who is to say I won't be exposed to blood through some minor accident with the wrapper on the peanuts or a scratch from the armrest or even something more severe like an item dropping from the overhead bin or a plane crash? Accidents happen and I may want to feel safe from even the remote possibility of contracting HIV. If it isn't too much to demand that I prove my COVID vaccination status then there will come a day when it won't be too much to demand that you prove your HIV status.

COVID is the today's super virus but it isn't the first and it won't be the last. We have to be careful that the efforts we propose to make us feel comfortable today aren't something that will make us feel very uncomfortable tomorrow. Once we make it easy to ______ it will also be easy to _____ but we may not like that as much.


Bill14564 03-23-2021 11:08 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tuccillo (Post 1920036)
The chances of contracting HIV from the person sitting next to you is beyond remote. Why do you insist on repeatedly bringing that up? It is irrational to do so. Diseases that can be transmitted through the air are another thing.

The chances of contracting HIV from the person sitting next to me is beyond remote in your scenario. But I'm not considering your scenario, I'm considering other realistic possibilities.

Your argument seems to be what if the random person sitting next to me is infected and what if they are not wearing a mask and what if the airflow moves the virus into my space and what if I take a breath at the right time and what if I am one of those that vaccine doesn't work for and what if I am one of those who will develop symptoms and what if the symptoms I develop are severe? With all those "if"s I would say that the chances of me, a vaccinated person, contracting COVID from the random person sitting next to me is also beyond remote.

It is irrational to think that a vaccine passport, once adopted, will only be required for COVID. Once that door is opened the Govt (and frightened people) will find more and more conditions that absolutely need to be on that passport. Today, you plan to be vaccinated so the passport will only affect those people (and good riddance to them). However, tomorrow there will be that other thing that is added to the passport that affects you. THAT is what I'm worried about. How do the sayings go....

- the road to hell is paved with good intentions.

- absolute power corrupts absolutely

- it seemed like such a good idea at the time

tuccillo 03-23-2021 11:28 AM

Stop putting words in my mouth and inventing scenarios. My argument is that the chances of contracting HIV from the person sitting next to you is beyond remote. I have already stated that diseases that can be transmitted by air are different. Please stop conflating HIV with the coronavirus.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bill14564 (Post 1920058)
The chances of contracting HIV from the person sitting next to me is beyond remote in your scenario. But I'm not considering your scenario, I'm considering other realistic possibilities.

Your argument seems to be what if the random person sitting next to me is infected and what if they are not wearing a mask and what if the airflow moves the virus into my space and what if I take a breath at the right time and what if I am one of those that vaccine doesn't work for and what if I am one of those who will develop symptoms and what if the symptoms I develop are severe? With all those "if"s I would say that the chances of me, a vaccinated person, contracting COVID from the random person sitting next to me is also beyond remote.

It is irrational to think that a vaccine passport, once adopted, will only be required for COVID. Once that door is opened the Govt (and frightened people) will find more and more conditions that absolutely need to be on that passport. Today, you plan to be vaccinated so the passport will only affect those people (and good riddance to them). However, tomorrow there will be that other thing that is added to the passport that affects you. THAT is what I'm worried about. How do the sayings go....

- the road to hell is paved with good intentions.

- absolute power corrupts absolutely

- it seemed like such a good idea at the time


Byte1 03-23-2021 11:59 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tuccillo (Post 1920066)
Stop putting words in my mouth and inventing scenarios. My argument is that the chances of contracting HIV from the person sitting next to you is beyond remote. I have already stated that diseases that can be transmitted by air are different. Please stop conflating HIV with the coronavirus.

I believe you have once again missed the point. You seem to be hung up on the HIV example and missed the whole theme/object of the post. A post that BTW was repeated over and over again for your edification. Try eliminating the "HIV" from the post and read it again. If you still can't understand it, maybe you should just relax and call it a day. I believe that the rest of us caught the idea on the first go around. :)

tuccillo 03-23-2021 01:56 PM

No, you missed the point. My response to an earlier post was with regard to contracting HIV from the person sitting next to you. Period. Nothing more, nothing less. I was responding to an absurd statement. You can read more into than that if you wish but that would be your mistake.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Byte1 (Post 1920072)
I believe you have once again missed the point. You seem to be hung up on the HIV example and missed the whole theme/object of the post. A post that BTW was repeated over and over again for your edification. Try eliminating the "HIV" from the post and read it again. If you still can't understand it, maybe you should just relax and call it a day. I believe that the rest of us caught the idea on the first go around. :)


golfing eagles 03-23-2021 02:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tuccillo (Post 1920102)
No, you missed the point. My response to an earlier post was with regard to contracting HIV from the person sitting next to you. Period. Nothing more, nothing less. I was responding to an absurd statement. You can read more into than that if you wish but that would be your mistake.

OK children, let's end this pointless dialog. T, just substitute the word meningococcemia for HIV, and then tell us if you would want meningococcal vaccine added to your "passport"? In case you don't know, it is probably 100x as contagious as COVID and 100x as fatal. Do you feel safe sitting next to someone who has not been vaccinated? How dare the airlines and government not protect you and demand proof of vaccination to get on an airplane. Kann Ich deine Papiere sehen, bitte.

tuccillo 03-23-2021 07:41 PM

I was responding to the comment about HIV, not meningococcemia or the concept of a "vaccination passport". If you want to change the subject that is fine but I was not commenting about your change.

Quote:

Originally Posted by golfing eagles (Post 1920113)
OK children, let's end this pointless dialog. T, just substitute the word meningococcemia for HIV, and then tell us if you would want meningococcal vaccine added to your "passport"? In case you don't know, it is probably 100x as contagious as COVID and 100x as fatal. Do you feel safe sitting next to someone who has not been vaccinated? How dare the airlines and government not protect you and demand proof of vaccination to get on an airplane. Kann Ich deine Papiere sehen, bitte.


Aloha1 03-23-2021 08:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Advogado (Post 1918036)
Just a word of warning to readers who have been infected by COVID and believe that they are now immune. It ain't necessarily so-- as my son and his wife found out the hard way, having been reinfected less than a year after their first bout. The ER doctor attributed the reinfection to one of the variants. He said that he had encountered no one reinfected with the original strain.

BTW, despite having been infected, they had been practicing the usual precautions-- until my son decided that it would be reasonably safe to fly on a ski trip, where he apparently picked up the reinfection and brought it home.

Fortunately, the reinfection, at least so far, has been a lot less severe that the first bout, and I only bring up their story in the hope that it will cause former COVID victims to continue to be careful.

The bottom line: achieving herd immunity may be more difficult than some had hoped.

Well, duh. Two different strains. Get the shot.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 03:09 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Search Engine Optimisation provided by DragonByte SEO v2.0.32 (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2025 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.