Talk of The Villages Florida

Talk of The Villages Florida (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/)
-   The Villages, Florida, Non Villages Discussion (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/villages-florida-non-villages-discussion-93/)
-   -   Buying from China (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/villages-florida-non-villages-discussion-93/buying-china-354355/)

Ptmcbriz 11-10-2024 08:03 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by OrangeBlossomBaby (Post 2385313)
Wal-mart is where millions of people in this country can AFFORD to buy things that they need for their homes and their families. Like it or not, this country can't afford to buy American. If we could, then Wal-mart wouldn't have done so well decades after they first set up shop here.

Why would I pay $3 for a can of beans, when I can get the exact same can of beans, same size and flavor, for $1.80? Why should I pay $3.54 for a half-gallon of 2% milk at Publix when I can get a half-gallon of 2% milk for $2.45 at Wal-mart? Sure, it's just a few cents. But when you add up every item that you're saving a few cents on, then multiply it by 52 weeks you're buying it every year, you're looking at a couple thousand bucks worth of groceries that you can afford to buy.

Take those couple thousand bucks away, and you're looking at people who live on a budget, having to stop buying ANY fresh foods, buying $1.25 chicken pot pies instead of wholesome foods, using powdered milk instead of real dairy, and eating a LOT of rice and beans. Those families who are already unfortunate to be in that situation, would now have to decide which of their family members will go without lunch.

Inflation happens, no matter who is running the country. People have to pay more, but their opportunities to earn more are not as good as they were in the 1960's and 1970's. The concept of the "company man" who spends most of his adult life in one place of employment, whose employer looks after their employees, has gone the way of the dodo.

Entire party venues have gone out of business because they no longer get the annual picnics that corporations once booked them for. The "culture" of employment has changed. The lifestyles of families relying on one income have changed, and those relying on two incomes has changed. If you're wealthy, NONE of this applies to you, and you have no experience of anything the rest of the country has to endure.

But for those of us who aren't "struggling" - but are trying to maintain a "comfortable" lifestyle while not being wealthy - are having trouble doing so. For us, Wal-mart is a godsend. Walmart is the REASON why I can afford to get good beef at Publix. Walmart is the REASON we can spend money at local restaurants every so often. By saving money on groceries and other essentials, we have more available to spend somewhere else.

If you take that away, you'll see a lot of people like me, no longer spending our money outside the grocery store. We live in a global economy, whether we want to or not. And so some of us choose to make the best of what we have.

Oh it’s not just the tariffs that will raise prices, wait until there are no migrant workers to pick all the fresh fruit and vegetables in the fields. Who will pick them? Americans won’t do the job. Wait for your hand picked tomato costs $10 each, IF you can even get any because they have rotted in the fields unpicked.

retiredguy123 11-10-2024 08:23 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ptmcbriz (Post 2385449)
Oh it’s not just the tariffs that will raise prices, wait until there are no migrant workers to pick all the fresh fruit and vegetables in the fields. Who will pick them? Americans won’t do the job. Wait for your hand picked tomato costs $10 each, IF you can even get any because they have rotted in the fields unpicked.

Isn't it illegal to pay migrants less than the minimum wage, to not withhold the FICA taxes, or to not provide other mandatory employee benefits? It seems to me that the legal way to do it is to import the tomatoes.

opinionist 11-10-2024 08:44 AM

Tariffs are intended to bring jobs back into the United States, thereby balancing trade. An additional benefit is a reduction in taxes. If the size of government can be cut by 80%, then taxes can be reduced to zero like in the 1800s. Since 80% of the government is not within the enumerated powers limited by the Constitution, the reduction is required by law. It will be interesting to see what happens.

OrangeBlossomBaby 11-10-2024 08:48 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ptmcbriz (Post 2385443)
Every American made car requires parts that are manufactured in other countries to finish their assembly. There is no such thing as a 100% US manufactured car anymore. We simply don’t gave the manufacturer plants here anymore and it takes 5-8 years to build plants and train personnel for them. We are in for a world of hurt as Elon stated “necessary hardships “ ahead.

Except for Elon. He is in for a world of whirlwind profits. Such a coincidence that he backs this idea 100%, don'tcha think?

OrangeBlossomBaby 11-10-2024 08:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sgt Ed (Post 2385446)
I agree that we need to bring industry and manufacturing back to the States. Look at the political situation with China today. Militarly they are VERY aggressive and if things happen we will be out of luck. We can not have another country have the upper hands in our products. Look what Wal Mart did to every small business in the country. The coffee is brewing, wake up and smell it.

My coffee comes from Brazil, Columbia, Nicaragua, and Mexico. But the bags my coffee is packaged in, is made in China. Yours probably is too. Enjoy your new $4/cup kpods.

OrangeBlossomBaby 11-10-2024 08:56 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by retiredguy123 (Post 2385461)
Isn't it illegal to pay migrants less than the minimum wage, to not withhold the FICA taxes, or to not provide other mandatory employee benefits? It seems to me that the legal way to do it is to import the tomatoes.

Well then we need to just all stop eating tomatoes then, since the whole point of this thread is to encourage people to buy American-made only to avoid tariffs.

The plan is to yes - impose tariffs on China. But the plan also includes ALL imports, not just Chinese imports. Anything that comes in from outside our borders will have a tariff - a price hike - attached to it.

Y'all need to start saving up.

OrangeBlossomBaby 11-10-2024 09:02 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by opinionist (Post 2385468)
Tariffs are intended to bring jobs back into the United States, thereby balancing trade. An additional benefit is a reduction in taxes. If the size of government can be cut by 80%, then taxes can be reduced to zero like in the 1800s. Since 80% of the government is not within the enumerated powers limited by the Constitution, the reduction is required by law. It will be interesting to see what happens.

My taxes are less than my expenses. The cost of inflation is higher than any taxes saved, for MOST Americans. Only the wealthiest will benefit from this "trickle down" concept. This was proven in the Reagan Administration.

Also, in the 1800's, businesses didn't have the expense of paying their workers, or paying unemployment insurance, providing health insurance, workers compensation. Why not? Because they OWNED those workers. The workers were slaves. If they worked themselves to death, they became fertilizer and were replaced with a fresh batch right off the boat.

Actually hired employees were paid pennies, most of them worked 10-12 hour shifts just to afford to live in squalor. Disease was common, health care was mostly non-existent and experimental. Indoor plumbing was considered a luxury for the wealthy.

Not interested in going back to the 1800's, but I'm sure there are some Amish farms in the US you could move to, to enjoy that lifestyle if you really want it.

Caymus 11-10-2024 10:28 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheWarriors (Post 2385436)
That is just proof the past policies really didn’t work and you are an example of why we shouldn’t continue to ship jobs out of the Country. Many don’t care until it is their job and finances. Just wait until AI takes hold, the number of unemployed Lawyers, Accountants, Investment Analyst, etc, will skyrocket. If your job doesn’t include some hands on activity with people (Nurses, Plumbers, Doctors, Electricians, etc.) plan on large pay reductions and finally the unemployment line.

So, Boeing machinists will not be getting the 38% pay increase(over 4 years) or the $12,000 signing bonus?

SoCalGal 11-10-2024 10:56 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pondboy (Post 2384947)
So who do you blame for all the goods sourced overseas?

Richard Nixon: His visit to China in 1972 was crucial in thawing U.S.-China relations after years of isolation. While this opened diplomatic channels, it was more about normalizing relations rather than directly promoting trade.

Jimmy Carter: He furthered the normalization process by officially establishing diplomatic relations with China in 1979, which facilitated increased trade but was more about political engagement.

Bill Clinton: He played a significant role in the normalization of trade relations with China, especially by signing into law the U.S.-China Relations Act in 2000, which paved the way for China's entry into the WTO in December 2001. However, this was more about facilitating China's integration into global trade frameworks rather than initiating China's trade engagement.

ElDiabloJoe 11-10-2024 11:44 AM

The thing about less expensive stuff from China, is that China has a loonnnggg history of corporate espionage, stealing our R&D and then ignoring intellectual property rights.

They have very cleverly (and purposefully) placed their students into our top research universities and aerospace companies since at least the 1980's. How do you think they went from complete isolation in the 1970's (Nixon era's ping-pong diplomacy) to nearly matching our jet, nuclear sub, and aircraft carrier technologies? I know they are historically credited with creating fireworks (gun powder) and pasta, but I suspect they stole those from other cultures hundreds of years ago also. Aside from art or literature, I cannot think of anything modern they have actually invested in, developed, and created from scratch. They are thieves of other cultures.

From my previous professional life, I have first hand experience they have sent over hundreds of pregnant women to have their babies born as U.S. citizens, only to return them to China shortly after birth. Imagine! Future Chinese government officials and military officers who are also American citizens who cannot be denied access or employment.

This may sound far-fetched, or paranoid, or "conspiracy-theory" to some but look back over the last 5 decades. China and Chinese citizens have almost always played the long game. Remember the old saying, "Three generations from Shanghai to Stanford?"

We have caught many of their government and military members and their families acting on China's behalf in our country. Even Nancy Pelosi's chauffeur and the New York Governor's Chief of Staff. Here's the thing: you send over one Romanian gymnast or one Cuban baseball player or one Russian ballerina, and they are slipping their handlers and seeking asylum. Hundreds of thousands of Chinese in America, from one of the most repressive communist nations on the globe, and no one is seeking asylum? Why is that? Family members at home threatened with imprisonment and torture, maybe? They've set up police stations on United States territory for the sole purpose of enforcing their laws on their citizens who are here for God's sake!

If one doesn't see the danger of casually buying Chinese stuff, even though it is cheaper, I fear one is short-sighted, anti-American, or ignorant. Maybe all three. Essentially you're buying cheaper things (cameras, electronics, pharmaceuticals, etc.) that were stolen from us in the first place, and now you're helping them make their thefts profitable. We're buying back from the thieves the very things they stole from us. They think we are suckers coming and going. They are right.

They are giving us something though. New York City has 2.5 times the national average in T.B. cases. A staggering 89% of their T.B. cases are from foreign born immigrants. According to New York City's most recent Annual Tuberculosis Survey, the largest single origin country of that 89%? Chinese immigrants. https://www.nyc.gov/assets/doh/downl...ual-report.pdf

Do I still buy things that are Chinese made that I can't find made in America? Yes, but I do so knowing full well I have little other option. I will pay more for American made when I have the opportunity to do so, and I strongly encourage you to do the same.

jimjamuser 11-10-2024 02:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bogie Shooter (Post 2384916)
If tariffs…then you can buy US made. That’s the plan right?

How long will it take for the US to switch to making the things that China makes? One year? 5 years?

jimjamuser 11-10-2024 02:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by phylt (Post 2384923)
IMO much ado about not much.

I feel that many of these tariffs will be targeted, and not sweeping anti-China etc.

For sure, vehicles from China and probably Mexico would be targeted - as they should be.

We DO need to manufacture MUCH more in our domestic production, especially critical pharmaceutical etc.

Our country needs to be completely prepared and focus on OUR country. So many others have taken advantage of us over the years. Especially allowing Corps et al to run amok exporting jobs and enriching themselves despite endangering the country.

Myself, I'll wait and see what happens. The sky is NOT falling. IMO the clouds are opening and the sun will shine brighter.

I agree about the "critical pharmaceutical". And "Corporations enriching themselves."

jimjamuser 11-10-2024 02:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by rustyp (Post 2384945)
And greatly increase the price of goods to us. Then we will demand wage increases to keep even. Thus the inflation spiral will begin. When it comes it comes in on an express train.

That's why top economists are against the concept.

eyc234 11-10-2024 02:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cuervo (Post 2385298)
I understand your concern, but if we focus more on buying our own products unemployment will drop across the board and wages will rise. Today a person buys a product manufactured from a foreign country, that means one less American employee and that also means one less shopper to purchase whatever your employer is selling. Buying American products is a win, win, situation for everyone. Tariffs will end up with prices going up anyway and if you remember the last time we went down this road China retaliated and started importing soybeans from South America hurting U.S. farmers.

Without all wages going up how is anyone going to afford these no existent American made products. The last time the US hit China as stated and stopped buying Soybeans from the US the US government had to give farmer $18 billion to keep them from going under. That money was our tax money that should never have been needed to prop up farmers. On top of all this we would not have enough workers to fill half the new jobs that would come back to America.

jimjamuser 11-10-2024 02:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pondboy (Post 2384947)
So who do you blame for all the good sourced from overseas?

The people who just look at the cheap price vs. the quality and origin of the goods…..or the manufacturers who outsourced the goods because they didn’t want to pay a fair wage (and benefits) to the American workers…..or the US manufacturers who did not have smart and creative employees (due to a poor educational system) to develop new cutting “edge technology”to the market.

When was the last time you sought out goods made in American and knowingly paid more for them ?

Also, who do you think is paying all those tariffs? We are, the consumer.

Don’t blame China or the rest of the world, they are just filling a need.

We should blame the poor US public school system (keeping property taxes down for the benefit of large property owners). Also to blame is the US healthcare system controlled by insurance executives and NOT Medical Doctors.

jimjamuser 11-10-2024 02:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by OrangeBlossomBaby (Post 2385004)
There are lots of things that people consume or purchase, that aren't made in the USA at all. And many of those things that ARE made in the USA, use components that are made in China.

Prices will be going up on just about everything other than LOCAL produce and meats. Why? Because trucks that deliver stuff to the supermarket are made with components that come from China.

In addition, the whole reason we all buy things from China instead of manufacturing here in the first place - is because no one here wants to work for the low wages needed to provide these products to us, for the same prices that we pay from Chinese imports. So we'll be looking at either a) a massive increase in prices for products newly-manufactured in the US to accommodate the pay, insurance, and other expenses involved in having American employees, or b) a massive drop in pay and massive increase in people who can no longer pay their bills.

It's just so myopic to assume that we'll be fine if we just buy from US manufacturers.

The US has an edge in robotics and A.I. For labor, machines have advantages over human labor. Examples would be no sick leave, no health care costs, no transportation to work, and no personality friction.

JMintzer 11-10-2024 02:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ptmcbriz (Post 2385439)
US doesn’t manufacture most things we bring in from China.

You forgot to add "anymore"...

JMintzer 11-10-2024 02:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ptmcbriz (Post 2385449)
Oh it’s not just the tariffs that will raise prices, wait until there are no migrant workers to pick all the fresh fruit and vegetables in the fields. Who will pick them? Americans won’t do the job. Wait for your hand picked tomato costs $10 each, IF you can even get any because they have rotted in the fields unpicked.

Why will there no longer be "migrant workers"?

The US issues hundreds of thousands of migrant agricultural visas each and every year... No one has ever suggested that program should or will stop...

jimjamuser 11-10-2024 03:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Marine1974 (Post 2385130)
Tariffs and decreasing the corporate tax to 15% tax on corporations in the US is a great thing for American manufacturing jobs . John Deere was going to move manufacturing to Mexico but now are staying here in the USA . Prices will come down on products manufactured in the US due to the lower tax .

That's probably true, but US executives may keep a lot of that tax money. And the US government will get less tax REVENUE. So the national debt MAY (?) go up and/or government agencies that provide help and support for middle class citizens may go away. Or both things may happen ?

jimjamuser 11-10-2024 03:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Wondering (Post 2385201)
Any legitimate economist or financial specialist has stated that tariff's only hurt consumers. Shows you how dumb the person who is pushing for them is in reality. I would be more concerned about the potential increase in produce, meats and dairy when there will be no immigrants to do the work!

Immigrants keep the cost of labor DOWN for the BIG employers and raise up the costs of education, rents, road traffic, and hospital costs. The US needs to determine its most efficient population.

jimjamuser 11-10-2024 03:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Joe C. (Post 2385206)
Most of the manufacturing facilities in China are owned or partially owned and totally controlled and regulated by the Chinese government which is known as the Chinese Communist Party. The CCP employs slave labor, and much of the profit from all these factories is garnished by the military. That is why China now has the worlds largest Navy, and is building warships faster than any country in the world. Their ultimate goal is domination and control worldwide. They love American greed. The "what's in it for me?" attitude that permeates the masses. In the long run, if left unchecked, it will be our downfall.
Buy American when possible. If not, buy Mexican (it employs the Mexicans, and helps keep them south of the border). Otherwise if possible support any country that is an ally of the U.S.

We should start many factories in all the South American countries in order to keep those population from traveling north.

JMintzer 11-10-2024 03:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jimjamuser (Post 2385584)
We should start many factories in all the South American countries in order to keep those population from traveling north.

How's that working after all the factories we started in Mexico?

retiredguy123 11-10-2024 03:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jimjamuser (Post 2385582)
Immigrants keep the cost of labor DOWN for the BIG employers and raise up the costs of education, rents, road traffic, and hospital costs. The US needs to determine its most efficient population.

As I understand it, the Florida minimum wage is $13 per hour plus the FICA taxes of about 7 percent, so a migrant worker makes about $30K per year. Also, the employer must offer affordable health insurance for the worker as per the ACA law. Are you suggesting that employers are not compling with these requirements?

Bogie Shooter 11-10-2024 03:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jimjamuser (Post 2385559)
How long will it take for the US to switch to making the things that China makes? One year? 5 years?

My point exactly………too long .

jimjamuser 11-10-2024 04:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheWarriors (Post 2385221)
Ye, let’s import everything and put everyone out of a job! Funny, maybe tariffs are a way of bringing back some jobs to our Country and having Americans actually pay a little more to have less people on the unemployment line. If you’re not for helping fellow Americans, maybe our way of life doesn’t mean much to you. Just because I can get away with a little theft doesn’t mean I should.

The US is practically at full employment. We are the envy of the whole world. If we invested more money in public primary and secondary schools, we would all have higher salaries and benefits.

jimjamuser 11-10-2024 04:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jimhoward (Post 2385270)
Tariffs have never worked as intended. proponents hope that tariffs combined with tighter immigration will boost demand for US manufacturing labor and consequently wages and produce more jobs for us citizens. But it doesn’t work that way and it shouldn’t.
But we will see because increased tariffs are definitely coming.

We need tighter immigration because we have too many people in the US. Just look at the traffic. And since the Us is a top polluter, then less population means less cars.

Stu from NYC 11-10-2024 04:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jimjamuser (Post 2385604)
The US is practically at full employment. We are the envy of the whole world. If we invested more money in public primary and secondary schools, we would all have higher salaries and benefits.

Or spend the money that goes to schools more efficiently getting rid of most of the administrators and the dept of education and giving that money to teachers who can teach.

Pballer 11-10-2024 04:57 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tophcfa (Post 2385369)
Yup, that and no environmental controls allow them to make stuff much cheaper than we can. Even when the cost of transporting goods half way across the planet is added, still much cheaper. Tariffs will help even the pricing playing field, but will also contribute to inflation.

Don't worry. No environmental controls is coming here.

OrangeBlossomBaby 11-10-2024 10:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jimjamuser (Post 2385610)
We need tighter immigration because we have too many people in the US. Just look at the traffic. And since the Us is a top polluter, then less population means less cars.

We should take the worst repeat offender criminal American citizens, strip them of their citizenship, and deport them.

We also should stop restricting women's rights to their bodily autonomy. If a woman doesn't want to breed, she should be allowed to - not breed. No matter how she ended up pregnant in the first place. HOW - is none of your business. But if the concern is "too many people" then one very obvious solution is to get out of the way of a pregnant female who doesn't want to be pregnant.

Kelevision 11-11-2024 07:03 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jimjamuser (Post 2385604)
The US is practically at full employment. We are the envy of the whole world. If we invested more money in public primary and secondary schools, we would all have higher salaries and benefits.

No, the US is not at full employment:

Unemployment rate
In October 2024, the unemployment rate was 4.1%, which is higher than the 3.8% rate a year earlier.

Prime-age workers
The employment rate for prime-age workers (25–54 years old) was 80.6% in January 2024, which is below its peak of 81.9% in April 2000.

Long-term unemployed
The number of long-term unemployed (those jobless for 27 weeks or more) was 1.6 million in October 2024, which is up from 1.3 million a year earlier.

The US government is committed to full employment, and the government is empowered to achieve this goal

As for the envy of the world…….we definitely aren’t that


Quality of Life…

Beyond the essential ideas of broad access to food, housing, quality education, health care and employment, quality of life also may include intangibles such as job security, political stability, individual freedom and environmental quality. Through all phases of life, these countries are seen as treating their citizens well.

https://www.usnews.com/news/best-cou...uality-of-life

Best countries to live for quality of life…..

1. Denmark
2. Sweden
3. Switzerland
4. Norway
5. Canada
6. Finland
7. Germany
8. Australia
9. Netherlands
10.New Zealand
11. UK
12. Austria
13. Belgium
14. Japan
15. Ireland
16. France
17. Luxembourg
18. Spain
19. Iceland
20. Portugal
21. Italy
22. UNITED STATES….
23. Singapore
24. Poland
25. South Korea
26 China

biker1 11-11-2024 07:09 AM

This is nonsensical. Deport them to where? Have you ever heard of the 14th amendment?

Quote:

Originally Posted by OrangeBlossomBaby (Post 2385658)
We should take the worst repeat offender criminal American citizens, strip them of their citizenship, and deport them.

We also should stop restricting women's rights to their bodily autonomy. If a woman doesn't want to breed, she should be allowed to - not breed. No matter how she ended up pregnant in the first place. HOW - is none of your business. But if the concern is "too many people" then one very obvious solution is to get out of the way of a pregnant female who doesn't want to be pregnant.


retiredguy123 11-11-2024 07:11 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Stu from NYC (Post 2385613)
Or spend the money that goes to schools more efficiently getting rid of most of the administrators and the dept of education and giving that money to teachers who can teach.

Wouldn't you need to get rid of the unions first?

Caymus 11-11-2024 08:26 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kelevision (Post 2385681)
No, the US is not at full employment:

Unemployment rate
In October 2024, the unemployment rate was 4.1%, which is higher than the 3.8% rate a year earlier.

Prime-age workers
The employment rate for prime-age workers (25–54 years old) was 80.6% in January 2024, which is below its peak of 81.9% in April 2000.

Long-term unemployed
The number of long-term unemployed (those jobless for 27 weeks or more) was 1.6 million in October 2024, which is up from 1.3 million a year earlier.

The US government is committed to full employment, and the government is empowered to achieve this goal

As for the envy of the world…….we definitely aren’t that


Quality of Life…

Beyond the essential ideas of broad access to food, housing, quality education, health care and employment, quality of life also may include intangibles such as job security, political stability, individual freedom and environmental quality. Through all phases of life, these countries are seen as treating their citizens well.

https://www.usnews.com/news/best-cou...uality-of-life

Best countries to live for quality of life…..

1. Denmark
2. Sweden
3. Switzerland
4. Norway
5. Canada
6. Finland
7. Germany
8. Australia
9. Netherlands
10.New Zealand
11. UK
12. Austria
13. Belgium
14. Japan
15. Ireland
16. France
17. Luxembourg
18. Spain
19. Iceland
20. Portugal
21. Italy
22. UNITED STATES….
23. Singapore
24. Poland
25. South Korea
26 China

And yet many people promise to leave, but don't follow through.

ElDiabloJoe 11-11-2024 09:07 AM

I can think of three steps to making this country secure.

Codify via Amendment:

1. USSC = 9;

2. Even if you were born here, if one or both parents (up for debate) were not citizens at the time of your birth, neither are you. No anchor babies;

3. Outlaw foreign ownership of property/land and American based corporations- especially strategic industries (energy, food, pharma, etc.).

Sure, Taiwan can have a few 85°C outlets here, but that corporation is based in Taiwan. They cannot own our meat producers or our food facilities. Two sea-salt foam coffees, please.

blueash 11-11-2024 09:13 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by retiredguy123 (Post 2385589)
As I understand it, the Florida minimum wage is $13 per hour plus the FICA taxes of about 7 percent, so a migrant worker makes about $30K per year. Also, the employer must offer affordable health insurance for the worker as per the ACA law. Are you suggesting that employers are not compling with these requirements?

There is a lot of evidence that undocumented workers are not being paid minimum wages, rather being paid in cash. Tell me how many people here have been asked by those they hired to please make the payment in cash, or to make out the check to them personally, not the name of their company. Some of that is tax fraud, some is to avoid other gov't regulations like minimum wage.

The ACA absolutely does not require most employers to provide health insurance. What made you think it did? ACA only requires employer coverage IIF there are 50 or more full time employees. So keep your work staff at 49 and no requirement. Additionally there is no requirement for full employer coverage and everyone still in the workforce knows how the employer who used to pay 100% of the bill went to 90% then 80% etc even while the cost went up.

So when the cost now is 25000 for family coverage and the employee is paying 8000 plus of course the copays and deductibles.

For real numbers, see the Bureau of Labor Statistics data for this year
For persons employed in private sector at businesses with fewer than 50 workers:
Only 56% have an option to get coverage and only 60% of workers elected to get that coverage. The employee is charged 1/3 of the premium for family coverage across all size private employers.

ElDiabloJoe 11-11-2024 09:28 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by blueash (Post 2385728)
There is a lot of evidence that undocumented workers are not being paid minimum wages, rather being paid in cash. Tell me how many people here have been asked by those they hired to please make the payment in cash, or to make out the check to them personally, not the name of their company. Some of that is tax fraud, some is to avoid other gov't regulations like minimum wage.
...

Some of that is to avoid reporting income. Not only for tax purposes, like you stated, but for lowering or eliminating child support orders and for accessing more welfare eligibility as well.

retiredguy123 11-11-2024 09:36 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by blueash (Post 2385728)
There is a lot of evidence that undocumented workers are not being paid minimum wages, rather being paid in cash. Tell me how many people here have been asked by those they hired to please make the payment in cash, or to make out the check to them personally, not the name of their company. Some of that is tax fraud, some is to avoid other gov't regulations like minimum wage.

The ACA absolutely does not require most employers to provide health insurance. What made you think it did? ACA only requires employer coverage IIF there are 50 or more full time employees. So keep your work staff at 49 and no requirement. Additionally there is no requirement for full employer coverage and everyone still in the workforce knows how the employer who used to pay 100% of the bill went to 90% then 80% etc even while the cost went up.

So when the cost now is 25000 for family coverage and the employee is paying 8000 plus of course the copays and deductibles.

For real numbers, see the Bureau of Labor Statistics data for this year
For persons employed in private sector at businesses with fewer than 50 workers:
Only 56% have an option to get coverage and only 60% of workers elected to get that coverage. The employee is charged 1/3 of the premium for family coverage across all size private employers.

It seems hypocritical to promote immigrant workers to compete with China when we don't enforce our own minimum wage law. Also, paying employees in cash is illegal. So, we are promoting illegal activity to compete with China.

I knew about the 50 employee rule for the ACA, but many people don't know that, before the ACA, there was no requirement for employers to provide any health insurance to employees.

OrangeBlossomBaby 11-11-2024 09:41 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by biker1 (Post 2385682)
This is nonsensical. Deport them to where? Have you ever heard of the 14th amendment?

The Heritage Foundation has determined that the Constitution is no longer appropriate and needs to be changed. They are running this country as of January 20, 2025 (one might argue they're already running it, but I try to avoid hyperbole).

The Constitution can be further amended, and the 14th can be repealed with new amendments. Just like the amendment that created the prohibition, and the one that repealed it.

They can be deported anywhere, really. Whether the country on the other end accepts them or not is not America's problem. They could be deported to an island somewhere. Or America could vote to annex Guam as a military prison (it's already an American territory) and send them all there.

Stu from NYC 11-11-2024 09:46 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by retiredguy123 (Post 2385683)
Wouldn't you need to get rid of the unions first?

That would be item 1 on improving schools.

graciegirl 11-11-2024 09:48 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pballer (Post 2385616)
Don't worry. No environmental controls is coming here.

I think it should read;

No environmental controls "Are" coming here.

But......Most of us do believe strongly in Global Warming and for years we have reused, reconditioned, saved, recycled and worn clothes until they faded or wore out. We don't take Aluminum throw aways to pot lucks and many of us drive Hybrid cars. We save our money and we try to take care of our possessions and keep them both clean and working. Our parents sent our lunches in Wonder bread sacks and we used bread bags inside our boots too, when we were small. I don't think that most of us are unaware of the causes of Climate change but we just do not see a plausible way to stop it as the world is involved and people will not soon give up gas engines. They are used to manufacture things we all need. It is a very difficult thing to try to solve. But some of us carry reusuable bags to the grocery and some of us reuse the plastic bags for when we walk the dog.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 10:30 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Search Engine Optimisation provided by DragonByte SEO v2.0.32 (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2025 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.