I liked Ricciardi's at Brownwood and Mezza Luna at Colony, I couldn't tell them apart, except one of them only makes medium size for $10, I can't remember which place it was. I had Giovanni's in the past and then again recently, they are good, but a little heavy. I've had NYPD several times, it's OK, but the last couple of times it upset my stomach so we quit going.
After going to the VA at Mulberry about 3 years ago I stopped at Sammy Joe's in Mulberry Plaza. It's between Publix and Bealls. That is my favorite hands down, and I've got to drive 11 miles up 301 or BV to get there, so it must be good. My wife loves it also. It's like Giovanni's but thinner and lighter. They make a 14" and a 16", if your hungry the 16" is no problem for two people.
Sammy Joe's, 8760 SE 165th Mulberry Lane, The Villages, FL 32162, 352-633-1949