Living in Buttonwood and attending St Vincents we always marvel that there is not a straighter route. I can see problems for those that live there as mentioned above. The only way I would be for it is if it was truly a residents only gated entrance with someone at the house all the time, Have you noticed that at many residence gates that are not staffed the gate goes up automatically, pass or no pass, if one sits there for a short time. At least the ones going west do.