American Idol?

[Bosoxfan]

America messed up last week.Hopefully they'll get it right &send Lauren on her way home. Haley was amazing tonite.Who would've thought anyone could pull off a Zeppelin song on Idol..she rocked it!

[Barefoot]

The show tonight is under way but there is someone who is sorely missing.....James! This is not the same American Idol anymore! Waughhhhhhh!

I also missed James tonight. Scotty and James are both unique performers. The two girls, Lauren and Haley, are both lovely and very talented, but I don't find them to be really unique.

[memason]

I think Lauren has it "in the bag".

Haley was amazing, but I think her Zeppelin song will not help her cause. Of course, Haley might think she will pull in James' votes this week....maybe so. Her other 2 songs were not so amazing, in my opinion.

Scotty.... has all the tools, but in the end, will not get the votes to win it. He'll have an amazing country career without Idol.

My prediction: Haley goes home tonight...

[redwitch]

I think it could easily be Scotty tonight. Missed a few notes on his first song and the other two were just the same ole thang. Nice kid, good voice -- he'll go far.

Lauren also missed some notes. For 16, she's amazing but really boring to me. Only thing I find interesting is her hair. Haven't seen a frosted job like that since the 70s (sorry). A one-hit wonder?

Not a Haley fan -- growling only goes so far, but I think she should win it all. At least she's interesting. Another Ruben (whom I loved -- called him to win it in his audition).

[RichieLion]

I think it could easily be Scotty tonight. Missed a few notes on his first song and the other two were just the same ole thang. Nice kid, good voice -- he'll go far.

Lauren also missed some notes. For 16, she's amazing but really boring to me. Only thing I find interesting is her hair. Haven't seen a frosted job like that since the 70s (sorry). A one-hit wonder?

Not a Haley fan -- growling only goes so far, but I think she should win it all. At least she's interesting. Another Ruben (whom I loved -- called him to win it in his audition).

Have to disagree with you and the posts above yours. Scotty is the next American Idol. I would wager the voting isn't even close. It'll be Lauren or Haley who comes in last tonight.

I think it should be Lauren because she always holds back and is thinking too much when she sings, and I'm always left wanting more. Haley is a flat out performer. She takes control of that stage and beautifully belts out those songs with style and intensity.

Because of what happened to James, I think it'll be Haley who garners the fewest votes tonight. I hope I'm wrong, though, and Haley is there at the end with Scotty.

[GaDawg]

My vote goes to Haley. She seems to be the only one who is consistantly taking chances with her song choices. She slayes most of them and commands the stage in the process. Doing so she proves every week she belongs at the top. Yo GaDawg says, She's In It to Win It!!

[RichieLion]

My vote goes to Haley. She seems to be the only one who is consistantly taking chances with her song choices. She slayes most of them and commands the stage in the process. Doing so she proves every week she belongs at the top. Yo GaDawg says, She's In It to Win It!!

:agree: :coolsmiley:

[Russ_Boston]

Don't see what missing notes etc has to do with the voting. No one really thinks that the vast majority of voters base their votes on talent do you? Only one season had two women and that was way back in season 3. Young girls do most of the voting.

[2BNTV]

No one really thinks that the vast majority of voters base their votes on talent do you? Only one season had two women and that was way back in season 3. Young girls do most of the voting.

:agree::agree::agree:

There should be a voting procees that allows the best contestant to win.

[aljetmet]

Scotty will be the winner. Lauren goes home tonight.

I heard on the radio some hollywoodxxx.com has it 45% Scotty, 31% Haley balance Lauren.

[GaDawg]

Dang it Russ, why do you have to bring the "get real" part of this voting. I agree, the winner will ultimately be the one that the teens and tweens vote for. And who would that be???? Duh. Scotty is good however and I conclude that at this stage it is more of a popularity contest for those who vote. Most of the top five to seven contestants (maybe more) will wind up with a recording contract or a singing gig with a band when the dust settles. I have just so enjoyed this season. In my view it was the best group of talented singers yet on Idol.

[Russ_Boston]

Don't get me wrong - I think these guys are very talented. But as with year's past some very talented people don't make the finale. (Jennifer Hudson, Daughtry, James Durbin etc.)

[GaDawg]

Russ, reread my post and you know how you think it is supposed to be stated and how it might be misconstrued. I was trying to 100 percent agree with you about the idea that the winner is chosen by the demographic of the most voters and not necessarily by the talent displayed. I hated to see Durbin go as well. My bad if my post was taken wrong. Dang, I'm still getting used to this posting thing. Hope I get better as time goes on.

[Russ_Boston]

Russ, reread my post and you know how you think it is supposed to be stated and how it might be misconstrued. I was trying to 100 percent agree with you about the idea that the winner is chosen by the demographic of the most voters and not necessarily by the talent displayed. I hated to see Durbin go as well. My bad if my post was taken wrong. Dang, I'm still getting used to this posting thing. Hope I get better as time goes on.

No problem with your post. I really was just responding to my own post about how people vote.

Normally if I want to 'answer' a post I would quote it first, then answer.

You made good points.

[collie1228]

I don't think that talent or performance has much to do with the voting when you are down to the final three. In the end, AI becomes a personality test (the lesser talents have already been eliminated) and the voters' opinions are pretty well set by now. When there are only three contestants remaining, a performer would have to have a horrific night to have the bad performance impact their final place in the competition. So it comes down to the tween vote, and my guess is that Haley will win that. I wouldn't vote for her (I'd vote for Scotty), but I'm an old white male, and everybody knows that we don't vote!

[RichieLion]

I don't think that talent or performance has much to do with the voting when you are down to the final three. In the end, AI becomes a personality test (the lesser talents have already been eliminated) and the voters' opinions are pretty well set by now. When there are only three contestants remaining, a performer would have to have a horrific night to have the bad performance impact their final place in the competition. So it comes down to the tween vote, and my guess is that Haley will win that. I wouldn't vote for her (I'd vote for Scotty), but I'm an old white male, and everybody knows that we don't vote!

Scotty is a good ol' American boy who yesterday asked all the young girls in America if they were "gonna kiss him, or what?". I may be a grandpa, but I'm thinking he knew what he was doing.

[collie1228]

But Richie, did you get out the old Iphone and vote for him?

[Bosoxfan]

Should be teenage idol.These voters don't have an ear for music.Just a teenage popularity contest! Th Voice..now there's a show !

[Freeda]

Now it's just down to Lauren and Scotty. Both are great talents. Haley will be a success, also, I predict. My bet is on Lauren.

[RichieLion]

But Richie, did you get out the old Iphone and vote for him?

No, I don't bother to vote. I'm just a watcher. But, I mostly am on the money every week as to who is voted off. It's a gift.;)

[DaleMN]

I think they probably got the final two right though I really enjoy Haley rocking. And I think Scotty will be the last one standing. :angel:

[Barefoot]

Scotty will be the winner. Lauren goes home tonight.


So it comes down to the tween vote, and my guess is that Haley will win that.

So now it's down to Lauren and Scotty. I'm sorry that James was eliminated. As Bosoxfan said, "it's a teenage popularity contest", and there's nothing wrong with that! The final two contestants both have tons of self confidence, wonderful stage presence, great voices, and maturity way beyond their years.

I think anyone who get to be in the top five is a winner and will go on to have a great career.

[2BNTV]

As Bosoxfan said, "it's a teenage popularity contest".

I agree with Bosox.

I would like for Pia to have a career. I thought she was a great singer who could really belt out a tune. :sing:

[BritParrothead]

we have just watched A I here in England. well I won the bet :wave: both my favourites are in ther finale :coolsmiley:
i always said Scotty would go through, and over the past few weeks I did go with Lauren, but not to win.
Go Scotty :) :)

[RichieLion]

As Bosoxfan said, "it's a teenage popularity contest".

I agree with Bosox.

I would like for Pia to have a career. I thought she was a great singer who could really belt out a tune. :sing:

May 29th. PBS will air a live event; a tribute the the 9-11 victims in a special concert from the Capitol Lawn in Washington D.C. hosted by Gary Sinise and Joe Mantegna.

Pia Toscano will be performing at that event FYI.

[mikeandnancy1112]

We definitely agree with you. Scotty is the one but Lauren will go far.

[chelsea24]

I've never been happier with a season of American Idol! I can see at least 5 superstars (all in different genres) coming out of this group! I was rooting for James, but really don't care who wins. Both are on my "superstar" list. Scotty couldn't be more American if he tried! And Lauren is a cute as a button. Both singing talents are amazing at such a young age!!! Wow!!

I'm happy to say we got tickets for the Live Tour. Never went out of my way before, but this group is spectacular! :)

[pauld315]

I especially like the part in this article of what Scotty told his eight grade teacher what his philosophy on life was (when he was in the eighth grade). How grounded can you be ? His parents must be wonderful.

http://www.newsobserver.com/2011/05/22/1215570/his-life-changes-but-scotty-hasnt.html

Cathy King, who taught Scotty in eighth grade at West Lake Middle School in Apex, had her students write a biography of themselves. She still has part of Scotty's: "My philosophy of life is simple. Please God, work, provide for your family and help others."

[2BNTV]

May 29th. PBS will air a live event; a tribute the the 9-11 victims in a special concert from the Capitol Lawn in Washington D.C. hosted by Gary Sinise and Joe Mantegna.

Pia Toscano will be performing at that event FYI.

RichieLion:

Thank you so very much. I will forward to watching this event. :)

[RichieLion]

You're welcome 2BNTV. Jimmy Iovine signed Miss Toscano, and with his guidance i'm sure you'll be seeing her around, and hearing her on the radio.
__________________________________________________ __________________________________________________ ______

Lauren better belt them out tonight and not hold back, because you know Scotty will be in his usual top form. I still expect him to win, but Lauren can change minds if she's fearless.

[memason]

American Idol is on a day earlier this week. The finale is tomorrow (Tuesday) with the winner (Lauren...:wave:) announced on Wednesday evening.

[aljetmet]

Well we know Scotty and Alaina were in the finals and a new season will begin next month.


But if you haven't seen this video it's pretty cool!


Haley and Casey:

http://content.usatoday.com/communities/idolchatter/post/2011/11/video-haley-and-caseys-baby-its-cold-outside/1

[tainsley]

Well we know Scotty and Alaina were in the finals and a new season will begin next month.


But if you haven't seen this video it's pretty cool!


Haley and Casey:

http://content.usatoday.com/communities/idolchatter/post/2011/11/video-haley-and-caseys-baby-its-cold-outside/1

That was good! :coolsmiley:

[pauld315]

I live within 20 miles of the McCreery's and as you can imagine Scotty is in the news quite often around here. He is trying to lead as normal a life as he can, attending his high school as much as possible as well as other things. His life is very busy. I thought you Scotty fans would find the 2 videos i am posting here of interest. One of him performing a service project at the church he has always attended and the other of him performing at his high school's Christmas performance earlier this week. A kid with 2 Gold Records so far just trying to lead as normal a life as possible.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z7u8C7RbRnQ

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6y188rd_WBI

[Taltarzac725]

Now that they whittled the crowd to just 13, anyone have any favorites in the current crop of American Idol?


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Idol_(season_11)

No one really captures my interest just yet. Probably too early in the game.

[wilkinsm1]

I just watched it last night for the first time this year...they narrowed 25 top contestants to the top 10 and then they added 3 of the judge's choices after 6 were picked to sing their hearts out to qualify. I am amazed as always at the degree of talent these youngsters possess and am now hooked...I'll have to continue watching to see who remains. (Maybe because I would be too shy to even sing kareoke ?sp. the poise and stage presence they exhibit at such a young age amazes me. It's fun to watch them grow over the course of the season also. I am glad that the judges seem to be much kinder now also)

[Happinow]

Need to see them sing next week to pick favorites. I have my eyes on a few but I need to pay more attention.

[schotzyb]

Now that they whittled the crowd to just 13, anyone have any favorites in the current crop of American Idol?


American Idol (season 11) - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Idol_(season_11))

No one really captures my interest just yet. Probably too early in the game.


For the females, I lke Skyler Laine and from the guys I like DeAndre Brackensick.

[RichieLion]

Now that they whittled the crowd to just 13, anyone have any favorites in the current crop of American Idol?


American Idol (season 11) - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Idol_(season_11))

No one really captures my interest just yet. Probably too early in the game.

For the guys; Phil Philips (very original)

For the girls; Jessica Sanchez (great voice control on her power vocals)

[Taltarzac725]

Right now I like Hollie Cavanagh from the girls. Do not really have a stand out from the boys.

[RichieLion]

Right now I like Hollie Cavanagh from the girls. Do not really have a stand out from the boys.

She is very good, and I think she'll do well.

[ajbrown]

Now that they whittled the crowd to just 13, anyone have any favorites in the current crop of American Idol?


American Idol (season 11) - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Idol_(season_11))

No one really captures my interest just yet. Probably too early in the game.

Had to ignore this thread until I caught up on DVR tonight. I cannot imagine watching this show without fast forward :).

I judge contestants based on if I would buy their CD. The only one so far for me is Phillip Phillips, but it is so early, that could change.

I may be alone here, but I so enjoyed hearing the critique by Jimmy Lovine during the final cut. I am very tired of the three judges AI has now. IMO they have very little to add except we love you and you were great.......:shrug:

[Taltarzac725]

Had to ignore this thread until I caught up on DVR tonight. I cannot imagine watching this show without fast forward :).

I judge contestants based on if I would buy their CD. The only one so far for me is Phillip Phillips, but it is so early, that could change.

I may be alone here, but I so enjoyed hearing the critique by Jimmy Lovine during the final cut. I am very tired of the three judges AI has now. IMO they have very little to add except we love you and you were great.......:shrug:

I too fast forward through AI and feel Jimmy Lovine is a much better judge than the regular judges.

Jessica Sanchez seemed to be channeling the spirit of Whitney Houston the other night. She sounded as good as Ms. Houston was. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jessica_Sanchez

On a strange note, I was watching a news program on TV from Orlando, and heard that a Jessica Sanchez was going to do the morning news. Well that turns out right. It is just a different Jessica Sanchez. http://www.clickorlando.com/news/Jessica-Sanchez/-/1637132/1923874/-/wxoqjk/-/index.html

[ajbrown]

Jessica Sanchez seemed to be channeling the spirit of Whitney Houston the other night. She sounded as good as Ms. Houston was. Jessica Sanchez - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jessica_Sanchez)



I agree, I thought she was amazing the other night...... It would be hard to imagine she would not have some form of career in singing, hopefully she can find some different paths than Whitney if she does....

[Taltarzac725]

I agree, I thought she was amazing the other night...... It would be hard to imagine she would not have some form of career in singing, hopefully she can find some different paths than Whitney if she does....

It looks like Jessica Sanchez has already been on TV from when she was 11. She was on the first season of America's Got Talent as a wild card. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/America%27s_Got_Talent_(season_1)

[Happinow]

Jessica, Hollie and Phillip. Those are my picks. I'm leaning towards Phillip more because he is so unique. I love his "make it your own" moments!

[Bettiboop]

Jessica has been at the top of my fav list from the beginning. I'm way behind on watching my recorded AI episodes though so may have other favs when I get all caught up. I heard Jessica did fantastic job on Whitney Houstion song the other night. Can't wait to watch it. I might have to devote tomorrow to an AI marathon so I can get caught up!

[GaDawg]

Not that he is from my hometown of Leesburg, Ga. but my pick is Phillip Phillips. Very unique and is really a great kid. My daughter and her husband have seen him perform many times. Just being real, this season has some of the best talent Idol has found thus far IMHO.

[Taltarzac725]

I have the bottom three as Heejun Han, Erica Van Pelt and Shannon Magrane. With Mr. Han probably exiting.

[RichieLion]

I have the bottom three as Heejun Han, Erica Van Pelt and Shannon Magrane. With Mr. Han probably exiting.

I would agree with two of your bottom three, but I would put Deandre Brackensick instead of Erica Van Pelt in the bottom.

My wife thinks the group is still large enough for "block voters" to play a big part, and so believes that the "asian vote" will keep Heejun in play.

[Taltarzac725]

I would agree with two of your bottom three, but I would put Deandre Brackensick instead of Erica Van Pelt in the bottom.

My wife thinks the group is still large enough for "block voters" to play a big part, and so believes that the "asian vote" will keep Heejun in play.

You could be right about the block voters. Some of the contestants in the past continued on the show week after week but I never really understood that unless block voting was involved.

[Happinow]

This week Phillip Philips had surgery on Thursday and came back for a great performance on Tuesday. This guy is amazing. I want him to win the whole thing! Love him! Extremely talented and walking to the beat of his own drum.

[DaleMN]

Pretty clear separation of Jessica, Phillip and Hollie from the rest of the group. Han and Deandre and Shannon can go any time and will not be missed.

[RichieLion]

Pretty clear separation of Jessica, Phillip and Hollie from the rest of the group. Han and Deandre and Shannon can go any time and will not be missed.

I agree, and the voters sent one of those home today. I think Erica Van Pelt, as Taltarzac pointed out, is weak and needs a big moment next week or will be in deep trouble.

Heejun cannot rely on the asian voters to have the same impact the smaller the group gets. So he also needs a great performance.

All the rest are very talented and it's going to be interesting. My wife loves that Colton kid; say he reminds her of David Bowie. She also picks Phil Philips, like Happinow, to win it all.

[mikeandnancy1112]

We like him, too, and very good looking!

[mikeandnancy1112]

Ditto!

[Happinow]

Is anyone watching American Idol tonight? Once again, Phil Philips slams it home. This guy just blows me away. I would go see him in concert any day! He is a handsome dude and is off the charts vocally. He still has my vote to win it all! :super:

[Taltarzac725]

If you taped AI and have not watched it yet you may to skip this.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Idol_(season_11)

Kind of expected the result. Have not watched my recordings of AI yet but wanted to know what happened.

[DaleMN]

Erica was much, much better than the two guys who survived.

[Happinow]

They got it wrong last night. Heejun should have gone home. I think next week either Heejun or Deandre' will go home. These are still a talented group of kids.

[Bobcuse]

We all should be prepared for what always happens: older (espec female) contestants are voted off first because the majority of voting viewers are young females who vote for young guys and young gals, with the early round nods going to the guys. It is a popularity contest at this point not a singing contest. Hopefully the most talented person will eventually win but until these early rounds are done, anybody can go but especially older females. Elise is awesome but she's vulnerable because she looks older and has a bluesy style so she won't get the younger vote. I personally think Jessica is the best but I also love Philip and Colton followed by Elise, Hollie, and Joshua. My bottom three are , Heejun, Skylar and Deandre.

[Taltarzac725]

We all should be prepared for what always happens: older (espec female) contestants are voted off first because the majority of voting viewers are young females who vote for young guys and young gals, with the early round nods going to the guys. It is a popularity contest at this point not a singing contest. Hopefully the most talented person will eventually win but until these early rounds are done, anybody can go but especially older females. Elise is awesome but she's vulnerable because she looks older and has a bluesy style so she won't get the younger vote. I personally think Jessica is the best but I also love Philip and Colton followed by Elise, Hollie, and Joshua. My bottom three are , Heejun, Skylar and Deandre.

I see Deandre, Heejun, and perhaps Hollie in the bottom three with probably Deandre leaving tonight. Heejun is probably still protected by the Asian block of voters.

Joshua and Skylar also seem vulnerable. Really liked Elise and Phillip Phillips last night.

[RichieLion]

This is a hard one tonight because all the contestants excelled last night.

I think Hollie is the vulnerable one tonight. I don't have anything but a hunch.

[Taltarzac725]

This is a hard one tonight because all the contestants excelled last night.

I think Hollie is the vulnerable one tonight. I don't have anything but a hunch.

Wonder what happened with Hollie Wednesday night. I have thought she was second best of the girls the last few weeks. Guess she got overconfident.

That was a close call for her.

[RichieLion]

Wonder what happened with Hollie Wednesday night. I have thought she was second best of the girls the last few weeks. Guess she got overconfident.

That was a close call for her.

She has a great voice, but for whatever reason she's not connecting. The judges say she's not connecting to the song she's singing. I guess that could be it. I know I'm not blown away by her. I wasn't blown away by Skylar either, but she's the only country girl, and that'll take her a bit further.

A little surprised by the result. I thought, like you, Heejun had another safe week in him, but this was the right result.

[schotzyb]

She has a great voice, but for whatever reason she's not connecting. The judges say she's not connecting to the song she's singing. I guess that could be it. I know I'm not blown away by her. I wasn't blown away by Skylar either, but she's the only country girl, and that'll take her a bit further.

A little surprised by the result. I thought, like you, Heejun had another safe week in him, but this was the right result.


I have to agree, the correct choice was made with Heejun leaving. I have to stay faithful to my home state girl Skylar but I believe the top 5 is as far as she will go. I believe the winner will either be Phillip Phillips or Jessica Sanchez

[RichieLion]

I have to agree, the correct choice was made with Heejun leaving. I have to stay faithful to my home state girl Skylar but I believe the top 5 is as far as she will go. I believe the winner will either be Phillip Phillips or Jessica Sanchez

That sounds right to me. At this point I would put Colton in the Top 3 with them. i think he's very talented, and combined with his looks, will continue to get the attention of Idol voters.

[aljetmet]

Our household of two thought it was time to say goodbuy to Deandre (sp?) last night as well. No tear shed to see Heejun go.

We are big Philip fans ever since his first audition when the judges asked him to sing a song with his guitar.

Elise had her best night by far.

Also didn't think Hollie or Skylar belonged in the bottom three.

[RichieLion]

Our household of two thought it was time to say goodbuy to Deandre (sp?) last night as well. No tear shed to see Heejun go.

We are big Philip fans ever since his first audition when the judges asked him to sing a song with his guitar.

Elise had her best night by far.

Also didn't think Hollie or Skylar belonged in the bottom three.

i would have put Deandre in the bottom three before Skylar. I think he's a good singer, but his style is not my cup of tea. There hasn't been a great falsetto since Frankie Valli in his prime.

Holly doesn't move me, is the only way I can explain it. Jessica has such a rich quality to her voice and her phrasing is impeccable, and she's incredibly only 16 years old. What an amazing natural talent.

[DaleMN]

If I were a betting man I would put my wager on Phillip Phillips. Genuine and tremendously talented.

[RichieLion]

If I were a betting man I would put my wager on Phillip Phillips. Genuine and tremendously talented.

He would be my choice also. He's got a great career ahead of him whether he's the next "American Idol" or not.

[Taltarzac725]

Hope not as she was great last week, but see Elise Testone going home tonight. DeAndre Brackensick probably will get enough of the young female votes to save him for at least another week. Also see Hollie Cavanaugh in the bottom three.

Jessica Sanchez still has my pick to win AI this season.

[schotzyb]

My gal Skylar was great this week. No way should she be in the bottom 3 this week. I 've had enough of DeAndre; should go this week.

[RichieLion]

My gal Skylar was great this week. No way should she be in the bottom 3 this week. I 've had enough of DeAndre; should go this week.

This was actually a good night for Deandre, but I don't think his style appeals to we older generation folks. They compare him to DeBarge, and I've never bought a DeBarge album, so that explains that.

My favorite of the evening was Colton Dixon. I think his change-up performance of "Time After Time" was brilliant; and his duet with Skylar Laine was excellent.

I think the weakest performance of the night belonged to Elise Testone, which is a shame considering her stand-out performance last week.

Hollie Cavanagh was also a little disappointing. She has such a big voice, but I think she ruined her performance with all her moving about the audience. She would have been better just to stay put her energy into the vocals, which were a little washed out with the constant movement.

My picks for bottom three this week would be Elise, Hollie and Deandre.

[DaleMN]

Same three as Richie picked for bottom 3. Between Elise and Hollie to go and unfortunately Deandre will survive for another week or two. I'm thinking Hollie will go. A great voice but had trouble connecting with people I think.

[mikeandnancy1112]

Ditto!

[De Lis]

Where I came from, TV was a bit slow, so I had A.I. parties at my home. Everyone brought a dish and we all had an absolute ball.

How could we arrange something like that for the entire Village or a few of them? Seems as though the turn out would be tons of fun.

[Taltarzac725]

Anyone have any picks as to who goes home tonight? Believe it is two today?? Could see Colton and Elise exiting would be my picks.

[DaleMN]

I think Elise will go. If two are scheduled to leave because of the save last week I think it should be Colton but could be surprised by Jessica once again not getting the support she deserves.

[Bettiboop]

I look for Colton to be there til the end mainly because he has the vote of the young teenie boppers.

I feel like Hollie and Elise might be in danger, but it is very unpredictable at this point!

[OpusX1]

The talent this year is great. Everyone had a good/great night last night. I thought Elise was going home a month ago, she is getting better and better. With the way the votes went last week no one is safe, Holly whom I thought was the weakest performer of the top twelve was great last night. They have all improved over the past month. I can see most of the top seven having good careers in music if they want it.

[Taltarzac725]

Probably see the last of Hollie tonight at least as a contender for this year's American Idol.

[DaleMN]

I would think Hollie is headed home though I really don't understand the love affair the judges have with Joshua. A big surprise could be the eliminatin of Skylar.

[Bobcuse]

Who would have ever thought Colton would be eliminated last week?? I still believe that voting lately has been as much against the judges favorites as for their favorite singer. Their love affair with Joshua is over the top, and I like Joshua but not to win. I can't stand J-Lo and her worthless comments and she believes she is the center of the show, not the contestants. I would normally say that Elise or Hollie will probably go but do not be shocked if Joshua bites the dust. I am one of the great minority who doesn't like Skyler because of her "in your face" style of singing and jerky movements, but she won't go.

[Augie]

I'd put the bottom three as: Skylar, Elise, and Phillip. Phillip is a star, but he really isn't changing it up enough to last I fear. I'd hate to see him go. Skylar has a lot of support and I really think she'll make in in the Country Music genre. She may get the barnyard gate tonight. :wave:

[Taltarzac725]

I'd put the bottom three as: Skylar, Elise, and Phillip. Phillip is a star, but he really isn't changing it up enough to last I fear. I'd hate to see him go. Skylar has a lot of support and I really think she'll make in in the Country Music genre. She may get the barnyard gate tonight. :wave:

Phillip has been the love child of the Vote for the Worst site for a number of weeks. That site's writer can be incredibly mean spirited but he/she is very witty. Vote for the Worst (http://www.votefortheworst.com/)

Would hate to see Phillip Phillips go too. He does not look like someone a lot of teen girls would vote for over and over again.

[Golfer in Sanibel]

Phillip has been the love child of the Vote for the Worst site for a number of weeks. That site's writer can be incredibly mean spirited but he/she is very witty. Vote for the Worst (http://www.votefortheworst.com/)
.

His Mother never told him "If you can't say something nice, don't say anything at all." In Ohio we'd call him a negative jerk. :doh:

[De Lis]

Who would have ever thought Colton would be eliminated last week?? I still believe that voting lately has been as much against the judges favorites as for their favorite singer. Their love affair with Joshua is over the top, and I like Joshua but not to win. I can't stand J-Lo and her worthless comments and she believes she is the center of the show, not the contestants. I would normally say that Elise or Hollie will probably go but do not be shocked if Joshua bites the dust. I am one of the great minority who doesn't like Skyler because of her "in your face" style of singing and jerky movements, but she won't go.

Agree 100%.

[BarryRX]

If you mixed David Ruffing, Marvin Gaye and Otis Redding into one incredible soul singer you would get Joshua Ledet.

[Taltarzac725]

American Idol (season 11) - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Idol_(season_11))

Wonder who will go tonight? Could we get a really big surprise and see the exit of Phillip Phillips??

Or, will it be Joshua, Hollie, and Skylar in the bottom three with Hollie leaving based upon the way this season's elimination chart has been going?

[DaleMN]

I think we could be in for a surprise with either Jessica or Phillp exiting. I also believe the judges are pretty transparent in who they want to win- Joshua.

[Bobcuse]

This is getting very hard to guess who will go. I cannot stand Skylar's style and her screaming nasal voice so I hope she goes, but Phillip gave the poorest performance last night. I never thought he'd go, but if Colton can be voted off Phillip certainly can. Having his girlfriend there may have cooked his goose with all of the jealous teenyboppers!

[Taltarzac725]

This is getting very hard to guess who will go. I cannot stand Skylar's style and her screaming nasal voice so I hope she goes, but Phillip gave the poorest performance last night. I never thought he'd go, but if Colton can be voted off Phillip certainly can. Having his girlfriend there may have cooked his goose with all of the jealous teenyboppers!

The young girls sure do seem to have a lot of influence on who wins AI. I still cannot really understand the last couple of winners without the teenyboopers playing a huge role in voting for good looking but really not extremely talented young men. These same young girls then buy the albums of the AI winners... which keeps the AI marketing juggernaut going.

[De Lis]

- I think the judges are practically salivating for diversity in this year's winner. Remember the Korean guy? They were trying last year, as well.
- As much as I love Phillip's style, it appeared to me that he really didn't care about the 2nd song. He may be off tonight...
- I didn't think Skylar's 2nd song was all that great either, contrary to what the judges said. Hmmm, what else is new?
- Can't stand JLo. She almost ruins the show for me.

[RichieLion]

Jessica Sanchez's second song was really good. I thought Hollie Cavanaugh had a solid outing with both songs sung nicely.

Like the judges, though, I think that Joshua Ledet is head and shoulders over the other performers in sheer vocal talent combined with a showman's stage presence. He's come a long way.

[Trish Crocker]

I think Joshua is incredible...I agree about Skyler, I don't know why they keep saying she is so good...Jessica is fantastic but so young, I think she has a good future in music. Phil sounds the same in every song, they compare him to Dave Matthews and I don't like Dave either. I can't see Holly winning altho she's extremely talented. I record all of the shows so I don't have to watch all of the stuff going on between songs...then on Thursdays I just skip ahead to the end to see who's off.

[aljetmet]

I think Joshua is incredible...I agree about Skyler, I don't know why they keep saying she is so good...Jessica is fantastic but so young, I think she has a good future in music. Phil sounds the same in every song, they compare him to Dave Matthews and I don't like Dave either. I can't see Holly winning altho she's extremely talented. I record all of the shows so I don't have to watch all of the stuff going on between songs...then on Thursdays I just skip ahead to the end to see who's off.

OK Trish gonna have to take you on... IMHO

Joshua is incredible, but only about half of the time. Same goes for Jess.

The reason the judges say Skylar is so good is very simply, she is... Us southerners have to stick together you know.

Have been a big Philip fan but I agree he does sound the same most of the time. I don't know about the Dave Mathews thing either

I agree that Holly has talent but she ain't gonna win.
OK, my picks for the bottom:

Hollie
Skylar
Jessica

Hollie to go home

The guys have the girly vote.

Now we tape the show also but can't miss all that drama.

Besides Carrie U is singing tonight. You can't miss that can you?
:shrug:

[Taltarzac725]

OK Trish gonna have to take you on... IMHO

Joshua is incredible, but only about half of the time. Same goes for Jess.

The reason the judges say Skylar is so good is very simply, she is... Us southerners have to stick together you know.

Have been a big Philip fan but I agree he does sound the same most of the time. I don't know about the Dave Mathews thing either

I agree that Holly has talent but she ain't gonna win.
OK, my picks for the bottom:

Hollie
Skylar
Jessica

Hollie to go home

The guys have the girly vote.

Now we tape the show also but can't miss all that drama.

Besides Carrie U is singing tonight. You can't miss that can you?
:shrug:

Do also really like Carrie Underwood. Of the various AI winners, she seems to have the brightest career.

[Bobcuse]

Now that Skylar has finally exited (phew...took long enough), it is very hard because any of these final four could muster up enough votes to win. Hollie is definitely the underdog but the other three is like picking the Kentucky Derby winner.....how many times does the 4-1 favorite lose??

[Taltarzac725]

Now that Skylar has finally exited (phew...took long enough), it is very hard because any of these final four could muster up enough votes to win. Hollie is definitely the underdog but the other three is like picking the Kentucky Derby winner.....how many times does the 4-1 favorite lose??



Still think it will be Jessica Sanchez if she can get over the female teenybopper voting hump. If not, it will probably be Joshua.

[Bobcuse]

Still think it will be Jessica Sanchez if she can get over the female teenybopper voting hump. If not, it will probably be Joshua.

I agree with you 100% Taltarzac

[Russ_Boston]

They're all good but not sure what market they will target. I would think Skylar has the best chance of becoming a star in her field (Country) than the others. I don't see a well rounded pop star (like Clarkson) or any rock stars (like Daughtry) or R&B stars (like Fantasia). I guess Sanchez has a shot at pop but what type of album will Josh make? Will Phillips be on the same level as a John Mayer or Dave Matthews? Hollie? Pop I guess.

[George Bieniaszek]

American Idol has completely gone downhill this year. Why is there a need for the three judges?? They don't offer good critiques of the performance. JLo will do so sometimes. Steven Tyler is on another planet with some of the comments he made. On the last show, he said that Joshua was one of the top 2 Idols ever. OK, so which one we toss out of the top 2, Kelly Clarkson or Carrie Underwood???

Skylar was voted out yesterday, probably the most marketable talent of this season. She will have a more sucessful career than any of the 4 that remain.

[Taltarzac725]

American Idol has completely gone downhill this year. Why is there a need for the three judges?? They don't offer good critiques of the performance. JLo will do so sometimes. Steven Tyler is on another planet with some of the comments he made. On the last show, he said that Joshua was one of the top 2 Idols ever. OK, so which one we toss out of the top 2, Kelly Clarkson or Carrie Underwood???

Skylar was voted out yesterday, probably the most marketable talent of this season. She will have a more sucessful career than any of the 4 that remain.

Jessica Sanchez could do very well in the Pacific Rim market. There was a previous Asian-American AI contender who did extremely well in the Asian music industry. Jasmine Trias - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jasmine_Trias)

[DaleMN]

Judges remarks are causing me to lose interest in AI. Simon Cowell made the show.....he may have been caustic but he was honest about the talent.
Ellen, Kara, JLo, Stephen....none were very interesting...Ellen was a huge mistake.

[Taltarzac725]

Judges remarks are causing me to lose interest in AI. Simon Cowell made the show.....he may have been caustic but he was honest about the talent.
Ellen, Kara, JLo, Stephen....none were very interesting...Ellen was a huge mistake.

I actually liked AI because of Simon Cowell. The judges are OK this Season but then again I usually just fastforward through most of the judges as well as Ryan Seacrest's bantering.

[aljetmet]

One of the most important aspects of the judges is to pick the talent.

They did a wonderful job this year and this year's group is one of the strongest ever. Time will tell how their careers work out.

The judges remarks as well as when the last few contestants are voted off in my book is immaterial... I just enjoy the show and :popcorn: :popcorn:

[DaleMN]

I actually liked AI because of Simon Cowell. The judges are OK this Season but then again I usually just fastforward through most of the judges as well as Ryan Seacrest's bantering.

Good point. Why Ryan Seacrest enjoys the popularity he does is way beyond me. I think he is a dufus.

[Russ_Boston]

American Idol successes by the numbers:

American Idol alumni album sales - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Idol_alumni_album_sales)

American Idol Album Sales (http://www.scribd.com/ChartJames/d/9189004-American-Idol-Album-Sales)

[BarryRX]

O.K. I don't care what anyone else says. Joshua singing "It's a Man's World" was head and shoulders above everyone else, including the James Brown original.
Ooops!...now I have to modify my opinion a bit, because 16 year old Jessica has got an amazing set of pipes! What a voice! If this contest has anything to do with talent it should come down to Joshua and Jessica.

[RichieLion]

O.K. I don't care what anyone else says. Joshua singing "It's a Man's World" was head and shoulders above everyone else, including the James Brown original.
Ooops!...now I have to modify my opinion a bit, because 16 year old Jessica has got an amazing set of pipes! What a voice! If this contest has anything to do with talent it should come down to Joshua and Jessica.

I agree with what you've said, but you can't discount the beautiful song "Volcano" by Philip Philips. It wasn't a power song like Jessica Sanchez' or Joshua Ledet's, but still so very good.

I think Hollie Cavanaugh has come to the end of the road this week, and we know who the Top 3 are.

[jblum315]

I watched American Idol through the first season. I decided it was a show for deluded teenagers. Most of them know no music earlier than the 1970s. Not for me. No interest.

[Bobcuse]

American Idol successes by the numbers:

American Idol alumni album sales - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Idol_alumni_album_sales)

American Idol Album Sales (http://www.scribd.com/ChartJames/d/9189004-American-Idol-Album-Sales)

Firstly, thanks to Russ for this info. I've always wondered how some of the former AI contestants other than Carrie and Kelly did in the music business. I am disappointed that the judges slammed Hollie last night. I agree she should be the one to go, but not because of her performance but rather because the others were BETTER last night. They have tried to dump her several times this year (other than last week because she was exceptional). If she screwed up, fine, but she did a beautiful job so who needs J-Lo's worthless ramblings (who thinks she's an expert about singing?) and Randy's scripted "Yo Dude she's in it to win it" opinion. Let America decide without crushing a 16 year old on national television after gushing over the others! Josh and Jessica to the finals I hope.

[George Bieniaszek]

This year's AI was probably one of the better seasons with the singing talent, no doubt, BUT I just cannot see a successful career with any of the 4 contestants. Song choice seems to knock the contestants out. The judges do absolutly nothing as far as their comments to help these singers out.

Jessica sings songs that do not appeal to the younger crowd, so are the teens going to buy her albums?? Joshua sings well until he starts SCREAMING the lyrics. Phillip is in his own world. He has great moments but those are very few. He tanks on most of the songs he sings. Hollie sings well but does not seem to have the connection with the audience.

The most marketable contestant was Skylar in my opinion. Her country/rock style would be the most marketable after her stint with AI.

Success will be determined how well they do after AI. Carrie Underwood, Kelly Clarkson, Daughtry are doing very well, the rest seemed to have fallen off the face of the earth.

[Trish Crocker]

I watched American Idol through the first season. I decided it was a show for deluded teenagers. Most of them know no music earlier than the 1970s. Not for me. No interest.

J, I understand what you are saying but talent is ageless. I like a lot of 'old' stuff but I also love to discover new artists. There is music that I don't particularly like but I appreciate the ability of the singer, that's what they are looking for. I don't care if it's Frank Sinatra, Patsy Cline, the Beatles or Eminem, talent is talent.

[shcisamax]

Not to be rude but, if this is a show for deluded teenagers, then I guess it stands you feel everyone on here is a deluded teenager..or a wannabee deluded teenager?

[mikeandnancy1112]

Trish, well said!

[RichieLion]

J, I understand what you are saying but talent is ageless. I like a lot of 'old' stuff but I also love to discover new artists. There is music that I don't particularly like but I appreciate the ability of the singer, that's what they are looking for. I don't care if it's Frank Sinatra, Patsy Cline, the Beatles or Eminem, talent is talent.

Just like mikeandnancy I agree with your view. I've always kept up with the music scene and there are plenty of great performers and songwriters out there today.

If you missed seeing Jessica Sanchez perform her brilliant version of Jennifer Holliday's "I Am Not Going", the song that made a star of Jennifer Hudson, you missed a great moment in television.

[Taltarzac725]

Just like mikeandnancy I agree with your view. I've always kept up with the music scene and there are plenty of great performers and songwriters out there today.

If you missed seeing Jessica Sanchez perform her brilliant version of Jennifer Holliday's "I Am Not Going", the song that made a star of Jennifer Hudson, you missed a great moment in television.

I'll have to watch the tape of the show of Jessica Sanchez' performance.

[Bobcuse]

Just like mikeandnancy I agree with your view. I've always kept up with the music scene and there are plenty of great performers and songwriters out there today.

If you missed seeing Jessica Sanchez perform her brilliant version of Jennifer Holliday's "I Am Not Going", the song that made a star of Jennifer Hudson, you missed a great moment in television.

I fully agree especially after watching Jessica in the highlites review...it was a spectacular performance, especially for a seasoned performer like Jessica.....oh that's right...she's only 16! What a future she has. Phillip is so unique but very predictable. Jessica and Joshua should be a fantastic show, especially if Joshua takes Jimmy's advice and cuts back on the screaming growls in every song. Gotta love 'em both.

[Taltarzac725]

Sad to see Hollie go. But it was probably her time. She was one of my favorites when the season started.

[Russ_Boston]

Anyone who thinks Phillips isn't going to the finals is...


Have you heard the way the girls in the audience react every time he smiles (which is way too often BTW). Those young girls vote and vote often!

Not as vocally talented as the other two but still the winner. And he might even have a great pop career in the style of John Mayer and Dave Matthews.

[Taltarzac725]

Anyone who thinks Phillips isn't going to the finals is...


Have you heard the way the girls in the audience react every time he smiles (which is way too often BTW). Those young girls vote and vote often!

Not as vocally talented as the other two but still the winner. And he might even have a great pop career in the style of John Mayer and Dave Matthews.

Judging by the last two cute boy factor winners of AI, you are probably right about Phillip Phillips. Personally, I never really caught onto his style of singing.

[msllicata]

I think Phillip Phillips has such a different kind of sound then the others... Definitely should win.

I got to see the top 10 from last year in concert .... It was great.

[RichieLion]

Joshua and Jessica have great voices, but the only one of the three I can envision buying music from is Philip Philips.

[Bobcuse]

Strong arguments for Phillip Phillips (whom I like very much also), especially the one about the screaming girls who vote the most, but if I were in Vegas I would still bet on Joshua and Jessica in the finals. If Phillip makes it, will Jessica go or will Josh?

[Bobcuse]

Another case on Idol of voter rebellion against the judges who kept pushing Joshua with their standing O's and gushing praises, and coupled with a sharp critique of Jessica which was the only negative critique all evening to ensure she got voted off. But these voters don't like someone shoved down their throats and Joshua paid the price for the judges attempt to control the finals. Phillip finished with his best and deserves to be there, but Jessica has the best voice. Phillip by a landslide because of his huge female following. Judges should be replaced.

[ajbrown]

I watch both AI shows for the week on results night. I always fast forward through the judges (thank you DVR :)). I will admit I look forward to Jimmy's analysis. I may not always agree with it, but IMO always interesting.

I actually had this week the same as the voters. I listened this week, asking myself if I heard that song on the radio would I listen or look for the next channel.

At the end of the show I felt that Jessica separated herself a bit from the boys but Phillip would be my second choice. Not sure if that is how the votes went, but those two stayed.

I think that Josh is an amazing talent, but FOR MY PERSONAL TASTE, he needs to pull back a bit.

[aljetmet]

I read a rumor that JLO is calling it quits after this season.

By the way I agree with the assessment that Philip is in it to win it. Actually he's very lay back and it seems will accept whatever comes.

Very interesting that his two best songs by far this week were the ones chosen for him....

[DaleMN]

Another case on Idol of voter rebellion against the judges who kept pushing Joshua with their standing O's and gushing praises, and coupled with a sharp critique of Jessica which was the only negative critique all evening to ensure she got voted off. But these voters don't like someone shoved down their throats and Joshua paid the price for the judges attempt to control the finals. Phillip finished with his best and deserves to be there, but Jessica has the best voice. Phillip by a landslide because of his huge female following. Judges should be replaced.

I totally agree that it was voter backlash against the judges for their obvious bias towards Joshua. I believe the final two are the two that should be there and I give Phillip the edge to win it.

[RichieLion]

I think many are underestimating the talent and creativity of Philip Philips. Not only was his cover of Bob Seger's "We Got Tonight a masterful performance, but his recreation of The Four Seasons "Beggin", leaning heavy on the feel of Madcon's take on this song, was the most all out rockin' jump up and down performance of the night, in my opinion. I just loved it.

Joshua and Jessica have big voices, but Philip stands alone in his uniqueness. Phil Philips is the next American Idol.

[teachnmo]

I have been wondering why Phillips has not been in the Ford commercials. At first I thought it was because he was sick the first time. But he hasn't been in about the last four times. Perhaps he is not a Ford man and thus doesn't want to be in it. Anyone seen the reason why?

[aljetmet]

I googled and could not find a reason Philip is not doing the Ford commercial.
The two finalists get a Ford next week. That will be interesting to watch.

Richie mentioned Phil's first song Beggin'. I probably had more Four Season albums in the 60s than any other group.

I googled it and enjoyed.

[Trish Crocker]

Doing the Bob Seger song won me over..and I don't feel bad about any of them going "home" because with the talent they have all shown I'm sure they will have great futures. I thought I heard something about Jimmy already signing Joshua (or maybe I'm making it up??:) ). I think Jessica is something of an enigma...her voice and style of singing are so mature for a 16 year old but when she is allowed to do the old classics she is incredible. It is going to be hard for her to find her niche but when she does, she will be around for a long time if managed properly. I would definitely buy a CD (I almost said album) of her singing the old bluesy, Etta James type of music. Not too sure if I would buy Phillips..his singing is great but he reminds me too much of Dave Matthews whose voice gets on my nerves after about 5 minutes.

[aljetmet]

Doing the Bob Seger song won me over..and I don't feel bad about any of them going "home" because with the talent they have all shown I'm sure they will have great futures. I thought I heard something about Jimmy already signing Joshua (or maybe I'm making it up??:) ). I think Jessica is something of an enigma...her voice and style of singing are so mature for a 16 year old but when she is allowed to do the old classics she is incredible. It is going to be hard for her to find her niche but when she does, she will be around for a long time if managed properly. I would definitely buy a CD (I almost said album) of her singing the old bluesy, Etta James type of music. Not too sure if I would buy Phillips..his singing is great but he reminds me too much of Dave Matthews whose voice gets on my nerves after about 5 minutes.

Now you're gonna make buy his CD and make me play it for you when we settle in. :pepper2::pepper2::2excited::wave::wave::laugh::la ugh:

[senior citizen]

...

[aaffmom]

I agree about Phillip. He has something special.

[senior citizen]

...

[senior citizen]

...

[Bobcuse]

Overall an entertaining show, except for the latest J-Lo 10 minute promotion of her latest whatever. I'm glad I had the Yankee game on the flip channel during that self engrandizing nonsensical crap. Congrats to Phillip. I was pulling for the voice (Jessica) but he's a special talent for sure.

Can somebody tell me what the hell was that insane performance(?) by Fantasia Burrino??? It was a screamfest between her and Joshua (whom I usually like very much, but not this time) and she was acting like someone who had something very wrong with her. Too weird for me.

[Taltarzac725]

I totally agree that it was voter backlash against the judges for their obvious bias towards Joshua. I believe the final two are the two that should be there and I give Phillip the edge to win it.

Well Phillip Phillips won. My personal choice would have been Jessica Sanchez but with all the young girls voting so many times; it is usually the attractive teen to twenty male who wins. That's been the case in the last three AI winners.

[senior citizen]

...

[RichieLion]

I had Philips pegged to win because of his uniqueness and his musicianship. He reimagined other artists songs in a way that made them seem new, and you couldn't help moving when he turned a song into a rocker.

Jessica and Joshua have good voices when they can keep them under control. Phil Philips was the only true music artist of the whole group. (except for Colton Dixon, who should have been there at the end)

[Trish Crocker]

I am quite cynical about all reality shows...this one included. I love watching AI and watching how these talented young people grow during the course of the show. When Jessica was voted off the show, then saved by the panel, it seemed scripted. It only makes sense to me that the Phil was chosen over the incredibly gifted Jessica because Phils style will appeal to a larger audience, therefore making lots of money for the American Idol corporation. (I have to admit, I grew to really love Phil these past few weeks, especially when he did our hometown guy's song..We've Got Tonight.). This is where the cynical part comes in...they could tell us ANYTHING about the voting and we have no way of knowing what the truth is. This is all a money making business and we are fortunate enough to be able to enjoy it.

[Happinow]

I was a fan of Philip from the beginning. He is an artist, not just a singer. He can take most any song and make it a "Phil Phillips" song and it takes talent to be able to rework a famous song and have people like it. He is very humble, and I don't believe he knows how good he really is. Last night when he sang after he won and then couldn't finish the son due to emotion, my heart went out to him because I think he may have been struggling more than the other contestants due to his illness. I think the world finally came down on him last night and he just let his emotions go and his guard down. These contestants are under a lot of pressure, get little sleep and are away from home for a long time. I think we forget that most of them are just "children" in a big people's world with huge expectations of them. My hat goes off to all of them for a great job.

[lanabanana73]

I agree, Kathy. I think these kids are under tremendous pressure and stress. It's amazing that they don't fall apart more often! I was a Colton fan all along and was shocked that the "young girl" contingent didn't keep him around longer. Just seemed to me that his style would have appealed to them more than Phillip's but that just goes to show how much I know!!

No one will ever take the play of Clay Aiken in my heart. I've seen him in concert 5 times and loved watching him on Celebrity Apprentice this season (and he SO should have won!!).

Alanna

[RichieLion]

I am quite cynical about all reality shows...this one included. I love watching AI and watching how these talented young people grow during the course of the show. When Jessica was voted off the show, then saved by the panel, it seemed scripted. It only makes sense to me that the Phil was chosen over the incredibly gifted Jessica because Phils style will appeal to a larger audience, therefore making lots of money for the American Idol corporation. (I have to admit, I grew to really love Phil these past few weeks, especially when he did our hometown guy's song..We've Got Tonight.). This is where the cynical part comes in...they could tell us ANYTHING about the voting and we have no way of knowing what the truth is. This is all a money making business and we are fortunate enough to be able to enjoy it.

I think it would be really cynical to think there was any hanky-panky in the counting of votes.

FOX Network could never get away with it.

People are able to vote numerous times each, It depends how dedicated the fans of any contestant are. If you want to spend hours voting, you can get a lot of votes in. You can vote numerous times on the internet and numerous times o the phone.

[Trish Crocker]

Happinow, I agree, the reality just hit Phil Phillips. Didn't you just want to give him a hug???

[Happinow]

I cried with him! :(

[Bosoxfan]

I'll be surprised if we ever hear anything from Philip .Another Taylor Hicks!

[tainsley]

Taylor hicks? No comparison! Love Phil Phillips. I think he will have a great career. I agree with Tyler when he said he could hear a little Paul Simon. Paul Simon, Chris Martin (Coldplay), Dave Matthews and A little Bob Seger all wrapped up into one single talent. Can't wait until he does his first CD!

[BritParrothead]

Watched th finale last night, not a bad show. Liked Philips new song, dont think I will be buying it though.
I still think Holly was the best. Do you know why she sang You'll never walk alone?
It is the song that is sung in Liverpool more than any other I would think! So nice that she gave a nod to her old home town. :clap2:

[RichieLion]

Philip Philips, recovering nicely from his crippling kidney ailment and subsequent surgery, will perform at his first post-Idol concert at the annual July 4th concert at the National Mall in Washington DC to be broadcast live on PBS television and NPR radio.

This is a DVR alert for fans of American Idol, and Philip Philips.

APNewsBreak: 'Idol' Winner To Make Comeback In DC : NPR (http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=155261639)

[Taltarzac725]

This has been in the news the past few days that the two newest judges are leaving American Idol. Cannot say that I will miss these two all that much. http://www.eonline.com/news/329968/jennifer-lopez-leaving-american-idol

[tainsley]

I will miss Tyler. Added humor..always been a fan!

[Happinow]

At first, when they announced Steven Tyler as a judge I thought I wouldn't like him. But after this season I think he adds the bit of unexpected to the panel. Won't miss Jlo....

[gerryann]

I'll miss both of them.

[Bill & Carolyn]

I agree, Kathy. I think these kids are under tremendous pressure and stress. It's amazing that they don't fall apart more often! I was a Colton fan all along and was shocked that the "young girl" contingent didn't keep him around longer. Just seemed to me that his style would have appealed to them more than Phillip's but that just goes to show how much I know!!

No one will ever take the play of Clay Aiken in my heart. I've seen him in concert 5 times and loved watching him on Celebrity Apprentice this season (and he SO should have won!!).

Alanna



lanabanana73,
I really liked Clay Aiken on Celebrity Apprentice and yes, he should have won.
When the media started talking about new judges for AI, I immediately thought about Clay's personality on Apprentice. His critiques were the best and he was so funny.

We're moving permanently to our home in Pennecamp the beginning of Nov. We'll have to meet, so we can talk about Clay.

[2BNTV]

Article on CNN.com



How much is Mariah's rumored 'Idol' payday? – The Marquee Blog - CNN.com Blogs (http://marquee.blogs.cnn.com/2012/07/24/how-much-is-mariahs-rumored-idol-payday/?hpt=hp_t3)

[Taltarzac725]

Article on CNN.com



How much is Mariah's rumored 'Idol' payday? – The Marquee Blog - CNN.com Blogs (http://marquee.blogs.cnn.com/2012/07/24/how-much-is-mariahs-rumored-idol-payday/?hpt=hp_t3)

With how much money AI rakes in, I am sure that she is worth this much. Have to wait and see what kind of judge she makes though.

[2BNTV]

With how much money AI rakes in, I am sure that she is worth this much. Have to wait and see what kind of judge she makes though.

18 million is a lot of peppers - IMHO.

[De Lis]

I don't want whatshername, but let's just NOT have her Non-Talented-Husband in with the deal!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Taltarzac725]

idolbloglive.com - Season 11 | Keith Urban Joining American Idol (http://idolbloglive.com/idolblog/keith-urban-joining-american-idol/)

[Taltarzac725]

Anyone been watching Hollywood week on this Season's American Idol? I skipped the city auditions because of the constant bickering of the two female judges. At least, you get to see less of the judges and more of the contestants during Hollywood week.

[barb1191]

I usually record the program and watch by MY choice, i.e., commercials, horrible talents is a huge fast fwd....

I never gave any thought to Kieth Urban, however he has an amazing personality and one can see the music in his soul which is so pure and for real, not at all a phony.

Haven't picked fav contestants yet as the weeding out tells all at that time.

[jnieman]

I was shocked for them to allow the girl to slaughter the national anthem then the judges laughed about it and put her through. I vowed not to watch the show anymore, but here I am watching Hollywood week. She is still in it and I can't figure out why unless it is the drama she causes.

[Taltarzac725]

I was shocked for them to allow the girl to slaughter the national anthem then the judges laughed about it and put her through. I vowed not to watch the show anymore, but here I am watching Hollywood week. She is still in it and I can't figure out why unless it is the drama she causes.

I agree with you on that one. They still seem to be going for the teen ratings still more than anything else. Some very odd talents have been put through while others are yanked.

Actually like Keith Urban as a judge. Not very impressed with the other three as judges.

[Taltarzac725]

Now that they have their Top 40 on American Idol has anyone stood out for you so far as a potential winner or is it still too early?

I have been really surprized by the last 5 or so AI winners. Seems the tween-young teen voting bloc has had the last word with all of these. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_American_Idol_finalists

[Taltarzac725]

American Idol 2013 Spoilers: Could a Wild Card Option Be in the Works? - American Idol (http://www.wetpaint.com/american-idol/articles/american-idol-2013-spoilers-could-a-wild-card-option-be-in-the-works)


They may eliminate 10 men and women from the Top 20 over the next three days. Have not looked at their calender of when shows were on this Season if they will stick in one or a couple of wild cards.

[DaleMN]

I'm thinking Idol may have run its course. Bad judges. Bad singers. Ridiculous try-outs. I will, however, watch as it nears this years winner.

[Taltarzac725]

I'm thinking Idol may have run its course. Bad judges. Bad singers. Ridiculous try-outs. I will, however, watch as it nears this years winner.

I agree that the judges leave lot to be desired. Their selection process of cutting The Top 40 so drastically too through the process they used forced them to axe singers that probably would have developed through all the training they give these talents. The judges also seem to be putting some people who are just flat out rating's developers.

They really do not need equal numbers of boys and girls at this stage as this is not a dancing competition where they have to pair up different sexes into teams.