Navy Federal Credit Union is rated #1 and Pentagon Federal Credit is #2.
I'm in both of them. Their service is outstanding.

Suncoast and Vystar have new locations in this area.
 

Both Suncoast and Vystar are large credit unions with many locations around the state. Vystar are mostly located to the north and Suncoast has many locations near Tampa and south, I have accounts at both credit unions and they provide good services. Vystar has a coin machine that is free to use for members.

Campus USA is the best. Been dealing with them for years with no problems whatsoever!

we are members of Vystar Credit Union on 466A.

I agree

I became a Vystar member in Jacksonville as a Navy man in 1981 when it was called Jax Navy credit union and stayed a member till we moved out of state in 2008. I reopened my account when we moved back in 2019 and they opened the branch in TV. They have always been very easy to work with on all aspects of banking. Loans are very easy with them, especially vehicles. They use a program they call VIP where you are pre-approved to a certain amount and you have a check that you write for the amount of the vehicle at the dealership. I have been very pleased with them.

Midflorida is great. New around here but I have had an account for a few years in St Pete. On the Bay Pines VA Campus there. 2 or 3 just opened here

Check to see if your current credit union is part of the co-op. Ours in Michigan is and we can go to Campus without ATM charges, can get cash easily without having to open new accounts. There us a daily limit on how much cash you can withdrawal but very convenient.

Hands down...Suncoast Credit Union. The service we have received has always been top notch.

Most all the Credit Unions honor the Credit Union Network. No matter which Brand you choose you can enter into almost any of them and conduct your banking as if that other Brand was your personal brach office. I'm a Credit Union User since 1991 of Coca-Cola Credit Union which only has the office in Atlanta but I use any local brands down here as needed because most are in Network.

That is not true. Only credit unions that are members of the Credit Union Co-Op can access other branded credit unions. I just checked and there are two credit unions in the Villages that are members of the Co-Op: Campus USA and MidFlorida

We continue to use our CU in NY. We have since 2007 and it's hassle-free and has no issues I can determine. We use a variety of local Villages credit unions and they will accept all transactions just like being at our NY branch. Not sure if we are missing anything, it seems to work well. We might at some point join a local CU but I have plenty of other things that aren't working as smooth that I can spend my wheels on or leave this one for later when I run out of things that don't run as smooth > That might be awhile out.

Don't have one here but alliant in Chicago has been excellant