Talk of The Villages Florida

Talk of The Villages Florida (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/)
-   Current Events and News (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/current-events-news-541/)
-   -   Critical Race Theory in schools (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/current-events-news-541/critical-race-theory-schools-320528/)

Topspinmo 06-13-2021 12:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bucco (Post 1959033)
First, because you brought it up. I am an Independent, after not only being registered in the party you seem to espouse for over 60 years, but being a paid employee. I changed, but not to what you refer.

Second, CRT is something BOTH groups wanted. It is not, in any way a subject to be taught. The changes that are being made and solicited are now a party movement to erase history as it happened. Really you should read the law. Full of platitudes, nothing of substance and was only even brought up to have it worked out as a party issue, adding a few words like Marxism to really generate those who are not really concerned with the country, but the party.

So, you have completely and totally flipped the truth.

Erasing history to serve a party is a very scary thing to endorse.

After 40 years of no problem in the schools, you now suggest that you want every party change in legislature to generate a new history. That CRT was done to keep this from happening.

But, again....you don't care and that is your right

You’re truth

Topspinmo 06-13-2021 12:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by GrumpyOldMan (Post 1959040)
None of what you said has been proven, 60 some court cases, and only 1 agreed with any of your assumptions. And hundreds of millions donated to prove the election fraud, and 6 months in and no proof yet forth coming. Keep donating, keep searching, I hope for your sake you actually find some proof. Otherwise, it will be a sad waste of time and a serious detriment to democracy.


Nothing was proven either cause it was never heard.

Taltarzac725 06-13-2021 01:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Taltarzac725 (Post 1959036)
I had Native America studies at Earl Wooster HS (Reno, Nevada) in 1975-1976 or thereabouts. We went over a lot of battles in which the Native Americans won and we had three or four field trips to movies that featured the point-of-view of various Native American tribes like Little Big Man, A Man Called Horse and some others. Our teacher did favor the Native Americans but then again many of the kids in the class were Paiutes. This one too probably as it is about a Paiute-- Tell Them Willie Boy Is Here - Wikipedia

Recall that this teacher was not a favorite of many of the parents but many of his students liked him. I had him Junior year as I skipped my Senior year by taking correspondence courses offered by another Reno, Nevada area high school. And went onto the University of Reno, Nevada and took history classes and had one African-American history professor who did teach kind of a Marxist approach to history but that is very different from Critical Race Theory.

Bucco 06-13-2021 01:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Topspinmo (Post 1959064)
Nothing was proven either cause it was never heard.

Gee.....hate to be personal, but even you must know that you must have a reason for a lawsuit....that is how the courts work.......

NO REASON....it gets tossed and NO reason was ever given. All dismissed with prejudice

"When a lawsuit is dismissed with prejudice, the court is saying that it has made a final determination on the merits of the case, and that the plaintiff is therefore forbidden from filing another lawsuit based on the same grounds."

Dismissal with Prejudice | Wex | US Law | LII / Legal Information Institute

Bucco 06-13-2021 01:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Byte1 (Post 1959062)
Truth? According to? I guess I just see all the good that has happened in this country in my lifetime instead of dwelling on all the negative that may have occurred before I was born, and on the negative fears that might happen in the future. I certainly do agree with one part, "propaganda" and that is exactly what this is all about. CRT is a propaganda tool, not worthy of our education system.

Is that how your children were educated ? Is that how you want your grandchildren educated ?

NO FACTS allowed unless elected officials decide it is ok to teach.

Right

Bucco 06-13-2021 01:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Byte1 (Post 1959062)
Truth? According to? I guess I just see all the good that has happened in this country in my lifetime instead of dwelling on all the negative that may have occurred before I was born, and on the negative fears that might happen in the future. I certainly do agree with one part, "propaganda" and that is exactly what this is all about. CRT is a propaganda tool, not worthy of our education system.

Simple question....define CRT !

You always refer to it as something that is taught, and its not, but you obviously dont even know what this is all about.

joelfmi 06-13-2021 02:08 PM

Critical Race Theory… believes racism is present in every aspect of life
 
Critical Race Theory…

*believes racism is present in every aspect of life, every relationship, and every interaction and therefore has its advocates look for it everywhere
*relies upon “interest convergence” (white people only give black people opportunities and freedoms when it is also in their own interests) and therefore doesn’t trust any attempt to make racism better
*is against free societies and wants to dismantle them and replace them with something its advocates control
^only treats race issues as “socially constructed groups,” so there are no individuals in Critical Race Theory
^believes science, reason, and evidence are a “white” way of knowing and that storytelling and lived experience are a “black” alternative, which hurts everyone, especially black people
^rejects all potential alternatives, like colorblindness, as forms of racism, making itself the only allowable game in town (which is totalitarian)
^acts like anyone who disagrees with it must do so for racist and white supremacist reasons, even if those people are black (which is also totalitarian)
^cannot be satisfied, so it becomes a kind of activist black hole that threatens to destroy everything it is introduced into

jimjamuser 06-13-2021 02:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by OrangeBlossomBaby (Post 1958719)
No I'm saying I remember learning about systemic racism in the 70's, however I don't remember that we were taught that particular phrase. We learned the subject. It isn't a new subject. It's an important subject to learn. I just don't recall that we called it "systemic racism" and I don't recall that our lessons in school were called "critical race theory."

Sort of like if you learn all about the color blue, but they never mention to you that this color is called blue. You still know all about the color. Just not its official name.

That's all I meant by that.

The point of my post was that these lessons aren't new, and that I'm confused as to why all of a sudden people are against it. Are they also against teaching that the south lost the Civil War? Are they against learning that George Washington was our first president? Are they against learning that blue is a primary color?

I mean - this stuff shouldn't be shocking to anyone. I do have to say that learning about the Tulsa massacre only in the past year or so was sad to me. I should have learned about that in the 1970's too when we were learning about race relations (I believe that was the term we used, as a catch-phrase for the overall topic). It's possible that we were taught about Tulsa and that I merely forgot about it. Our country has been through trauma every which way since its inception. We have been victimized, and we have victimized others. We have had horrific crimes committed against us, and we have committed horrific crimes against others.

How can we learn from our mistakes, if we are ordered not to learn what we did wrong? We MUST know what we've done that was horrible and traumatizing and cruel and unjust, if we are ever to evolve as a society. Those who cannot learn from their mistakes are doomed to repeat them.

40% of America does NOT want to "evolve". They want it to STAY the same with THEMSELVES in POWER. NEW ideas like CRT threaten their POWER so they pass laws against it. "Make the world stay the SAME because I am comfortable with it with ME on TOP".

jimhurtt@twc.com 06-13-2021 02:19 PM

Please tell me how voting is being suppressed today. Every citizen of the United States can vote.

miharris 06-13-2021 02:21 PM

Truths and non-truths
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by tvbound (Post 1958669)
THE truth.

- The truth of the our early economy being based on free slave labor.
- The truth of segregation, with inferior or non-existent amenities for blacks.
- The truth of the Tulsa race riots.
- The truth of systemic racism that has existed in government and private enterprise.
- The truth of the rise of white supremacism and our own intelligence agencies saying that the biggest internal threat is white extremist groups.
- Etc., etc., etc.
- The truth that privileged whites are doing everything possible to ensure our children don't hear of any of this.

THOSE kind of truths.

Now it's time to hear from those who say slaves actually had it pretty good, who would also refuse to truthfully answer whether they would prefer to be enslaved and have 3 meals - or to be free and struggling.


- Our early economy was not based on "free slave labor" Slave labor was used almost exclusively in the south for cash crops - primarily cotton and tobacco. In terms of the overall economy of the US, the south was miniscule compared to the industrialized northern states. In fact, the cause of the civil war was not primarily slavery, it was the fact that the south was being increasingly marginalized by the northern states, who favored high import and export tariffs, which kept agricultural prices low (fewer export markets) and the price of manufactured goods high (difficult to import from other industrialized countries). There is no question that slavery was and is abhorrent, but it is true that it existed for thousands of years in hundreds of cultures.


- Segregation was in fact true, and an unfortunate part of US history, but our current system provides abundant opportunities for people of color in education and employment. In fact, the most successful 'race' in the US currently is Asian, not white.

- The Tulsa race riots were a travesty, true, but they happened in 1921 for gods sake. Are you seriously implying that the country where that happened is the same country that elected a Black man president? Twice??

My biggest issue is that the current extreme left wing movement, including things like CRT, is to the push to equality of outcome, as oppose to equality of opportunity. That is not what made this county the envy of the world. And before you object to that phrase, tell me why our boarder is being over-run by people from central and south America? Why aren't they flocking to Venezuela? Mexico? Brazil? North Korea?

jimhurtt@twc.com 06-13-2021 03:07 PM

Oh, so there should be a polling place on every block in every city? Or every 1/4 mile in the country?

Byte1 06-13-2021 03:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by miharris (Post 1959094)
- Our early economy was not based on "free slave labor" Slave labor was used almost exclusively in the south for cash crops - primarily cotton and tobacco. In terms of the overall economy of the US, the south was miniscule compared to the industrialized northern states. In fact, the cause of the civil war was not primarily slavery, it was the fact that the south was being increasingly marginalized by the northern states, who favored high import and export tariffs, which kept agricultural prices low (fewer export markets) and the price of manufactured goods high (difficult to import from other industrialized countries). There is no question that slavery was and is abhorrent, but it is true that it existed for thousands of years in hundreds of cultures.


- Segregation was in fact true, and an unfortunate part of US history, but our current system provides abundant opportunities for people of color in education and employment. In fact, the most successful 'race' in the US currently is Asian, not white.

- The Tulsa race riots were a travesty, true, but they happened in 1921 for gods sake. Are you seriously implying that the country where that happened is the same country that elected a Black man president? Twice??

My biggest issue is that the current extreme left wing movement, including things like CRT, is to the push to equality of outcome, as oppose to equality of opportunity. That is not what made this county the envy of the world. And before you object to that phrase, tell me why our boarder is being over-run by people from central and south America? Why aren't they flocking to Venezuela? Mexico? Brazil? North Korea?

Excellent response! I don't know whether to say "drop the mic", "case closed" or :boom:

Byte1 06-13-2021 03:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Briand (Post 1959050)
Anyone prepared to be introspective will see that hiding our history is not a good idea. I am a ‘Brit’ and the first to admit the building of the biggest empire in History was not carried out without a lot of evil actions on our behalf and suffering for many in the British Empire. Knowing this and understanding the suffering of those who were ‘conquered’ is vitally important to becoming an active and sympathetic member of society today.

We don't hide our history. CRT is NOT history.

Byte1 06-13-2021 03:36 PM

Our public schools teach Black history, along with U.S. History. History is supposed to be fact based on a timeline, not theory. I have yet to read or see anything positive about CRT and it does not belong in a fact based history lesson(s) given to our children. I have no qualms on slavery, equal rights amendments or other fact based historical moments being taught our children, but I do object to our children being taught a "theory" of how racist ALL whites are (white privilege and white supremacy). I also object to Black children being taught that they are inferior and that they are victims today. And before anyone pipes in with how blacks are being killed by the cops, let me remind you that there are two white victims of police shootings to every black shot by law enforcement. The only way that is racist is if those whites were killed by black cops, and we know that is not true.

jimjamuser 06-13-2021 03:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Swoop (Post 1958867)
I’m curious, how do you feel black voters are “suppressed” today?

Blacks and Browns are suppressed by gerrymandering for one thing. And by the NEW laws passed by Arizona, Utah, Georgia, and Florida. We ALL remember voting lines in Atlanta stretching back for four blocks. That's Suppression with a capital S.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:23 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Search Engine Optimisation provided by DragonByte SEO v2.0.32 (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2025 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.