Talk of The Villages Florida

Talk of The Villages Florida (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/)
-   Current Events and News (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/current-events-news-541/)
-   -   Kim Potter Guilty (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/current-events-news-541/kim-potter-guilty-327532/)

Don5154 12-24-2021 09:43 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shbullet (Post 2042455)
You sound like a cross eyed lawyer!

No need to name call :bigbow:

obx2003 12-24-2021 09:46 AM

tainted conviction
 
As a retired Federal LEO who served for 28 years, I believe convicting Potter of first degree manslaughter was a major error by the jury, despite the unusual Minnesota laws. This is another example of why young adults will not consider law enforcement careers. The tables are tilted in a negative direction.

tophcfa 12-24-2021 10:03 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ChrissyI1 (Post 2042571)
Kim potter killed an unarmed young man. I feel for her because it was not an intentional act - but an accident. That being said - you can’t kill someone - accidental or not- and not be held responsible in someway. I agree with the jury - they definitely got it right.

Based on your above statements, with your logic applied consistently, Alec Baldwin should also be found guilty.

dewilson58 12-24-2021 10:10 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tophcfa (Post 2042630)
Based on your above statements, with your logic applied consistently, Alec Baldwin should also be found guilty.

:mmmm:

Petersweeney 12-24-2021 10:37 AM

Somebody had to say it….
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mikenbats66 (Post 2042566)
What would have happened if she did not have a taser ?
Tasers only became common in past 35 years.
Another reason not to have females as street cops .

Glad she’s not on the street anymore….

rshepard 12-24-2021 10:53 AM

Resisting arrest triggered events
 
I have not watched the court case so I do not have an opinion on whether I believe the verdict was the right one.
However, looking back on many of these police shootings/killings, a common thread: resisting arrest. If G.Floyd, E.Garner, M.Brown, et al., comply, like society demands they comply, they'd all be alive today.
Where are the minority leaders when this kind of leadership would save lives ?

OrangeBlossomBaby 12-24-2021 11:11 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andyb (Post 2042593)
This will set precedence that police will back off arrests in resisting criminals and many police will be quitting. It will
embolden criminals. Now, will self defense be in jeopardy for innocent victims?

I have more faith in the intelligence of police officers than you do I guess.

I think it'll set the precedence of more and superior training in the use of tasers, possibly a new design so that there's no way to confuse the two, and possibly even new holster designs so that tasers will be located at a completely different part of the uniform as a gun, making it even MORE difficult to confuse the two.

Perhaps a taser will require a different holster latch and be pulled by the officer's "off-hand" rather than their primary hand.

I think it'll make officers who use tasers in their job, more aware of which they're using. It will become more instinctual so that in that last split-second when they have to pull SOMETHING out of a holster, they'll pull the right thing.

Hacker1 12-24-2021 11:20 AM

Equivalancy?
 
A criminal with a 20-year rap sheet (out on a $500 bail), brutalizes, including running over with his vehicle, the mother of his child - is released on $2000 bail, then promptly drives into a Christmas parade, kills 6 & injures 60+ innocent victims - this time held on $2 million bail. On the other hand, Kim Potter has exemplary record including 26 years on police force with no incidents, accidentally kills a criminal, is held WITHOUT bail!! This just does not feel right nor just.

jimbomaybe 12-24-2021 12:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by rpalumberi (Post 2042653)
We couldn't agree more. I read the post about the legislature and if that is true, all the police should leave minnesota and let them defend themselves. If this hoodlum had obeyed the authority of the police, didn't resist and attempt to flee, he'd be alive today to eventually get out and terrorize others. That's what people like this do who are coddled by society. This is why more people are moving to red states, leaving the stupidity of blue states - we just hope they leave their stinking thinking behind and embrace the wholesome freedom of law abiding red states. We're not perfect, nothing is - but these folks are literally insane. Defund the police, another great liberal idea. Oh yeah, and this idea of systemic racism is pure non sense - they have just revealed their own racism and made race relations worse.

moving to another state will work, I moved from Illinois,
every day it is becoming more and more the "liberal Paradise" I had a card carrying liberal next door who told me he was considering moving after listing all the on going and increasing problems state wide, my response was "and then you will vote to do there what you have done here?"

jimbomaybe 12-24-2021 12:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by OrangeBlossomBaby (Post 2042658)
I have more faith in the intelligence of police officers than you do I guess.

I think it'll set the precedence of more and superior training in the use of tasers, possibly a new design so that there's no way to confuse the two, and possibly even new holster designs so that tasers will be located at a completely different part of the uniform as a gun, making it even MORE difficult to confuse the two.

Perhaps a taser will require a different holster latch and be pulled by the officer's "off-hand" rather than their primary hand.

I think it'll make officers who use tasers in their job, more aware of which they're using. It will become more instinctual so that in that last split-second when they have to pull SOMETHING out of a holster, they'll pull the right thing.

I think you are right to depend on the intelligence of the average police officer, our society has decided it doesn't want the police to be proactive, they need to think like a defense attorney, if you can think of ANY possible reason not to make a traffic/street stop don't, if you can think of ANY reason not to make an arrest don't, if there is ANY reason to think what you see isn't criminal don't interfere, there buy keeping themselves safe, complying with what is required, of course you have a 30% increase in homicides nation wide (statically higher in areas where is has been a bigger problem ) as we march towards nirvana finding the perfect way to train for the chaos of unscripted violent confrontations

Byte1 12-24-2021 12:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by crash (Post 2042559)
Wow quite a mistake killed someone. What would you think if it was the other way around and it was the cop who was mistakenly killed.

What would you say to someone that backs out of a driveway and runs over and kills someone? That is vehicular manslaughter. Should they go to jail?
What if a drunk stumbles into your home and you shoot him? He made a mistake and had no intention of breaking into your home. He thought he was home when he broke into your home. You killed him, so should you go to jail for it?

I don't know all the specifics of this case, but there is many times in a police career where that officer must make a split second decision to act on an exigent circumstance. The totality of the circumstances should be considered. If there was no intent, then it is manslaughter. If it was accidental then it would be involuntary manslaughter. Was it negligent or not? Was the officer attempting in good faith to do her job when it occurred? Was she distracted? Was she scared?
Circumstances.

Stu from NYC 12-24-2021 01:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tophcfa (Post 2042630)
Based on your above statements, with your logic applied consistently, Alec Baldwin should also be found guilty.

Involuntary manslaughter seems to fit what he did.

Stu from NYC 12-24-2021 01:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jimbomaybe (Post 2042675)
I think you are right to depend on the intelligence of the average police officer, our society has decided it doesn't want the police to be proactive, they need to think like a defense attorney, if you can think of ANY possible reason not to make a traffic/street stop don't, if you can think of ANY reason not to make an arrest don't, if there is ANY reason to think what you see isn't criminal don't interfere, there buy keeping themselves safe, complying with what is required, of course you have a 30% increase in homicides nation wide (statically higher in areas where is has been a bigger problem ) as we march towards nirvana finding the perfect way to train for the chaos of unscripted violent confrontations

Many of the people who thought it was a good idea to defund the police are coming to the realization of what they have done.

toeser 12-24-2021 01:34 PM

Parking someone with no criminal history in jail for many years for a mistake accomplishes absolutely nothing and just takes up good jail space.

A sentence of five years of community service would allow some good to come out of this terrible situation.

manaboutown 12-24-2021 02:06 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by retiredguy123 (Post 2042437)
I could not have voted to convict. She was doing her job, and made a mistake. Surgeons make mistakes that result in death, but they never go to jail.

It seems no good deed goes unpunished these days.

Given the thug's criminal past, armed robbery and much more, it is possible he could have been going for a gun, which would justify shooting him. Perhaps if she would have called out "Stop or I'll shoot!" (meaning my gun) and then shot him she might still be a LEO. Instead, to be a nice gal, she only threatened the violent thug evading arrest with a non-deadly taser and in the heat of a split second act mistakenly pulled out her sidearm and shot him.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:08 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Search Engine Optimisation provided by DragonByte SEO v2.0.32 (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2025 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.