Talk of The Villages Florida

Talk of The Villages Florida (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/)
-   The Villages, Florida, General Discussion (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/villages-florida-general-discussion-73/)
-   -   Adding a closet to 3rd bedroom in Gardenia model (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/villages-florida-general-discussion-73/adding-closet-3rd-bedroom-gardenia-model-319340/)

Juliewaters 05-06-2021 04:46 AM

Adding a closet to 3rd bedroom in Gardenia model
 
We have a Gardenia model and need to add a closet to the 3rd bedroom as it does not have one.
Has anyone hired a contractor to do this?
If so, can you please provide details cost and contact details of the contractor.
Thank you very much
Julie

thelegges 05-06-2021 06:07 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Juliewaters (Post 1940218)
We have a Gardenia model and need to add a closet to the 3rd bedroom as it does not have one.
Has anyone hired a contractor to do this?
If so, can you please provide details cost and contact details of the contractor.
Thank you very much
Julie

If you have basic skills, it’s frame work and some doors, Lowe’s or HD will even cut the lumber for you. If not some handyman’s talents are pretty good, without trying to find a contractor for such a small job

vintageogauge 05-06-2021 09:20 AM

Or if you don't need a full wall closet buy a free standing unit.

shut the front door 05-06-2021 09:22 AM

How can they sell you a 3 BR home if a bedroom doesn't have a closet? I thought that was a requirement to call it a 3BR.

Stu from NYC 05-06-2021 09:27 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by shut the front door (Post 1940383)
How can they sell you a 3 BR home if a bedroom doesn't have a closet? I thought that was a requirement to call it a 3BR.

Lots of bedrooms here do not have closet.

We are in a 3 bedroom Begonia and front bedroom is closetless.

tuccillo 05-06-2021 09:38 AM

It’s not a 3 bedroom home. It is a 2 bedroom plus a den.


Quote:

Originally Posted by shut the front door (Post 1940383)
How can they sell you a 3 BR home if a bedroom doesn't have a closet? I thought that was a requirement to call it a 3BR.


New Englander 05-06-2021 10:10 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tuccillo (Post 1940396)
It’s not a 3 bedroom home. It is a 2 bedroom plus a den.

:agree: It's a den.

dhsmith 05-06-2021 10:35 AM

Closet
 
ESP installation (Jordan)386-344-2447
5 years ago the price was $1000.00
Did a great job.

Boomer 05-06-2021 11:33 AM

We bought a Gardenia. It's the version of the plan with the windowed arches above the front door, and above the kitchen window and den window. We bought pre-owned. It was all the natural light that comes into a Gardenia that sold me.

Now, you are going to make your home an official 3 bedroom. Good idea.

Mr. Boomer can do the kind of work you need -- but he is not for hire. You should be able to get some suggestions here though.

You have probably thought this all through, but I cannot resist throwing in a few things to think about -- if you have not already.

I don't know if all Gardenias have a cathedral ceiling in the den, but if you do, you might want to think about if you would like for the drywall to follow the angle of the ceiling as the finished look. (I am assuming you are thinking of using the wall that backs up to the bathroom -- but maybe not.) Anyway, you will want someone who is particular about their drywall work so the closet will look like it has always been a part of the room.

You will need to decide if you want sliding doors, bi-fold doors, or French doors. French doors can come pre-hung. Also, discuss finish trim with the person you choose.

A closet is supposed to be a minimum depth of 24 inches for clothes. Rod height has a formula to it, too. If you do not need the closet for mostly hanging clothes, you could have shelves built along the sides in addition to the top shelves and leave a smaller space in the middle for hanging.

Please forgive me for going on and on. I love a good project. And I think your idea to make your Gardenia into a 3 bedroom is brilliant. :)

Boomer

Stu from NYC 05-06-2021 12:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Boomer (Post 1940443)
We bought a Gardenia. It's the version of the plan with the windowed arches above the front door, and above the kitchen window and den window. We bought pre-owned. It was all the natural light that comes into a Gardenia that sold me.

Now, you are going to make your home an official 3 bedroom. Good idea.

Mr. Boomer can do the kind of work you need -- but he is not for hire. You should be able to get some suggestions here though.

You have probably thought this all through, but I cannot resist throwing in a few things to think about -- if you have not already.

I don't know if all Gardenias have a cathedral ceiling in the den, but if you do, you might want to think about if you would like for the drywall to follow the angle of the ceiling as the finished look. (I am assuming you are thinking of using the wall that backs up to the bathroom -- but maybe not.) Anyway, you will want someone who is particular about their drywall work so the closet will look like it has always been a part of the room.

You will need to decide if you want sliding doors, bi-fold doors, or French doors. French doors can come pre-hung. Also, discuss finish trim with the person you choose.

A closet is supposed to be a minimum depth of 24 inches for clothes. Rod height has a formula to it, too. If you do not need the closet for mostly hanging clothes, you could have shelves built along the sides in addition to the top shelves and leave a smaller space in the middle for hanging.

Please forgive me for going on and on. I love a good project. And I think your idea to make your Gardenia into a 3 bedroom is brilliant. :)

Boomer

Call it as you wish but TV calls the closetless bedroom a bedroom.

Sitting in it now as I took it for my office but when the world returns to normal we will also use it as a bedroom. If we had regular guests would add a closet of some sort but it can be used as a bedroom if one wishes.

DAVES 05-06-2021 12:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Juliewaters (Post 1940218)
We have a Gardenia model and need to add a closet to the 3rd bedroom as it does not have one.
Has anyone hired a contractor to do this?
If so, can you please provide details cost and contact details of the contractor.
Thank you very much
Julie

We also have a Gardenia. I think you had an option to have a closet in the third bedroom that would reduce the size of what I use as an office. Looking at what we have, I would assume where you would put a closet, opposite the window would make it necessary to move the air conditioning duct, as well as rebuild the sunken ceiling.

As someone else suggested using an armoire might be an idea-a solution.

coffeebean 05-06-2021 01:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Stu from NYC (Post 1940389)
Lots of bedrooms here do not have closet.

We are in a 3 bedroom Begonia and front bedroom is closetless.

From where I’m from, that floor plan should be called a 2 bedroom plus den. A bedroom should have a closet to be called a bedroom. Right???

CoachKandSportsguy 05-06-2021 01:15 PM

They don't!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by shut the front door (Post 1940383)
How can they sell you a 3 BR home if a bedroom doesn't have a closet? I thought that was a requirement to call it a 3BR.

Yes, it is a requirement legally, to have a closet for each bedroom. So no, she didn't buy a three bedroom if the third room with a bed doesn't have a closet. .

That's the difference between lay talk and legal talk. . .

lawyer guy

JSR22 05-06-2021 01:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by coffeebean (Post 1940474)
From where I’m from, that floor plan should be called a 2 bedroom plus den. A bedroom should have a closet to be called a bedroom. Right???

The Villages Gardenia Floor Plan has it as a 2 bedroom and den.

Stu from NYC 05-06-2021 01:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by coffeebean (Post 1940474)
From where I’m from, that floor plan should be called a 2 bedroom plus den. A bedroom should have a closet to be called a bedroom. Right???

Could well be but when we purchased our Begonia beginning of 2020 all of the literature called it a 3 bedroom.

Besides look at what the Villages sales dept is selling and calling it a 3 bedroom.

JSR22 05-06-2021 01:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Stu from NYC (Post 1940486)
Could well be but when we purchased our Begonia beginning of 2020 all of the literature called it a 3 bedroom.

Besides look at what the Villages sales dept is selling and calling it a 3 bedroom.

If you look at the Begonia FP specifies 2 br and a den. My Gardenia was advertised as a 3 br but front br has a large closet across the wall opposite the window.

villagetinker 05-06-2021 02:21 PM

There were several versions for the Gardenia, we have one and we built. We wanted 3 bedroom, but the was not room for the additional 3rd bedroom, so we have a DEN, no closet, and it was described as 2 bedroom and den.

Carla B 05-06-2021 02:27 PM

Even a den needs a closet. So they should stop being so chintzy and just put a closet in that front room, period.

Garywt 05-06-2021 02:29 PM

When we were looking all these type homes were listed as 2 bedrooms and a den. Every 3 bedroom had 3 closets. Very straight forward.

If the ceiling is normal height is should be an easy job.

Boomer 05-06-2021 02:47 PM

Back in the day. . .
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Stu from NYC (Post 1940460)
Call it as you wish but TV calls the closetless bedroom a bedroom.

Sitting in it now as I took it for my office but when the world returns to normal we will also use it as a bedroom. If we had regular guests would add a closet of some sort but it can be used as a bedroom if one wishes.

I guess TV marketing has changed. We bought our Gardenia in 2013. It was built in 2007. It was called a 2 bedroom + den.

Of course, you can use it for a bedroom. You can use it for anything you want. But to be an official bedroom — in most places — it needs to have a closet.

And, now, I must digress. It is my curse to do so. . .

Up north where there are basements, people sometimes put what they call bedrooms there. . .

But where I come from, code requires a bedroom to have a window — and for a basement bedroom, not just any window — has to be a window big enough for a fully-equipped firefighter to get through. . .

A single (divorced) friend of mine, who has a whole big house to herself, had such a window put into her basement for a bedroom she did not need. . .

I suspect she is waiting for that fully-equipped firefighter (like the ones on calendars) to come through.

Boomer

dewilson58 05-06-2021 03:04 PM

ToTV thread.................way off topic.
OP, we all know what you mean by 3BRM and adding a closet.
Hope you can find an answer within.

Stu from NYC 05-06-2021 04:08 PM

Decided to pull out the info that came with the house and see what we actually purchased.

The literature that was put out by a properties of the Villages sales rep says the house is 3 bedroom and 2 bath. The reps picture is even on the literature.

The Begonia floor plan does say what we thought was the third bedroom is actually a den. Strangely enough the third bedroom (as we will continue to call it) is actually a drop bigger than the second bedroom (which does come with a closet).

Not going to do anything about it but wow were we misled.

retiredguy123 05-06-2021 04:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CoachKandSportsguy (Post 1940478)
Yes, it is a requirement legally, to have a closet for each bedroom. So no, she didn't buy a three bedroom if the third room with a bed doesn't have a closet. .

That's the difference between lay talk and legal talk. . .

lawyer guy

What law are you referring to?

Florida has adopted the International Residential Code, which is part of the Florida Building Code. The International Residential Code does not require a bedroom to have a closet.

Boomer 05-06-2021 05:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Stu from NYC (Post 1940534)
Decided to pull out the info that came with the house and see what we actually purchased.

The literature that was put out by a properties of the Villages sales rep says the house is 3 bedroom and 2 bath. The reps picture is even on the literature.

The Begonia floor plan does say what we thought was the third bedroom is actually a den. Strangely enough the third bedroom (as we will continue to call it) is actually a drop bigger than the second bedroom (which does come with a closet).

Not going to do anything about it but wow were we misled.

Oh well. Just keep enjoying your room and don’t give its name another thought.

In one of the houses we have had up north, the office/den/no-closet room was called a bedroom by not only the real estate agent, but also by the property tax site. I knew it was not a bedroom, but we liked the house and it had enough bedrooms — and the last thing I wanted to do was rattle the tax guy’s cage to try to get the assessment to list fewer bedrooms. The room became my office and was used by me to type many a TOTV post.

(Btw, yes, like somebody here said, this thread might be slightly off track — but that’s OK. My people call this kind of thing a nice conversation. And nobody is mad at anybody over closet/no closet — although, the evening is yet young. )

And, now, for a segue into TOTV history — about threads jumping the track:

Many years ago when the room here was small because the site had just started, threads would get a little sideways into conversations.

There were those who would holler, “Hijack!” It was hollered in good fun — well. . .usually in good fun.

Anyway, that was when the long-running “Girl Talk” thread was started by Barefoot. “No Boys Allowed” — because everybody knows that women can follow at least 3 — maybe more — conversations at one time — and participate in all of them — and there will be no complaints about staying on topic.

Haven’t any of you guys ever noticed that when you are out to dinner with a woman, she can talk with you while filtering conversations from another table and/or the booth behind you — and fill you in. We can’t help it.

The “Girl Talk” thread is in the Feminine Forum. There you can see the archives of TOTV. It goes way back, jumps from topic to topic, and everybody involved does just fine. (I have not looked at the thread lately. I hope it is still up and running. Maybe I will go check.)

Anyway, thanks for the conversation, and for the OP, I wish all the best with the closet project.

Boomer

dewilson58 05-06-2021 05:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Stu from NYC (Post 1940534)
Not going to do anything about it but wow were we misled.

You can call it what you want...............In-law Suite. :coolsmiley:

It's a perfect Guest Suite...........no closet space so they can't stay toooooo long.

retiredguy123 05-06-2021 05:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dhsmith (Post 1940419)
ESP installation (Jordan)386-344-2447
5 years ago the price was $1000.00
Did a great job.

Wow! That was a real bargain. I would estimate that the materials alone would be close to $1,000.

CoachKandSportsguy 05-06-2021 06:57 PM

Per realtor license school - Section 200 of the Florida building code
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by retiredguy123 (Post 1940540)
What law are you referring to?

Florida has adopted the International Residential Code, which is part of the Florida Building Code. The International Residential Code does not require a bedroom to have a closet.

Realtor license school references Section 200 of the Florida Building code.

What is a Bedroom as Defined by Florida Building Code?

but then again, if the TV marketing reps aren't licenses realtors, then they can call it whatever they want, as they have no code of ethics. . .

legal guy who stayed at a Holiday Inn last night :popcorn:

dhsmith 05-06-2021 06:59 PM

Closest
 
A dozen 2by 4s, 48 inch bifold door, 2 sheets of sheetrock and 1/2 gal of paint.

CFrance 05-06-2021 07:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Boomer (Post 1940554)
Oh well. Just keep enjoying your room and don’t give its name another thought.

In one of the houses we have had up north, the office/den/no-closet room was called a bedroom by not only the real estate agent, but also by the property tax site. I knew it was not a bedroom, but we liked the house and it had enough bedrooms — and the last thing I wanted to do was rattle the tax guy’s cage to try to get the assessment to list fewer bedrooms. The room became my office and was used by me to type many a TOTV post.
(Btw, yes, like somebody here said, this thread might be slightly off track — but that’s OK. My people call this kind of thing a nice conversation. And nobody is mad at anybody over closet/no closet — although, the evening is yet young. )

And, now, for a segue into TOTV history — about threads jumping the track:

Many years ago when the room here was small because the site had just started, threads would get a little sideways into conversations.

There were those who would holler, “Hijack!” It was hollered in good fun — well. . .usually in good fun.

Anyway, that was when the long-running “Girl Talk” thread was started by Barefoot. “No Boys Allowed” — because everybody knows that women can follow at least 3 — maybe more — conversations at one time — and participate in all of them — and there will be no complaints about staying on topic.

Haven’t any of you guys ever noticed that when you are out to dinner with a woman, she can talk with you while filtering conversations from another table and/or the booth behind you — and fill you in. We can’t help it.

The “Girl Talk” thread is in the Feminine Forum. There you can see the archives of TOTV. It goes way back, jumps from topic to topic, and everybody involved does just fine. (I have not looked at the thread lately. I hope it is still up and running. Maybe I will go check.)

Anyway, thanks for the conversation, and for the OP, I wish all the best with the closet project.

Boomer

"Haven’t any of you guys ever noticed that when you are out to dinner with a woman, she can talk with you while filtering conversations from another table and/or the booth behind you — and fill you in. We can’t help it"


My husband can do this. That's why I married him!:)

thevillages2013 05-07-2021 05:08 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Stu from NYC (Post 1940534)
Decided to pull out the info that came with the house and see what we actually purchased.

The literature that was put out by a properties of the Villages sales rep says the house is 3 bedroom and 2 bath. The reps picture is even on the literature.

The Begonia floor plan does say what we thought was the third bedroom is actually a den. Strangely enough the third bedroom (as we will continue to call it) is actually a drop bigger than the second bedroom (which does come with a closet).

Not going to do anything about it but wow were we misled.

First thing you learn as a real estate agent is how to lie:faint:

mainelovr 05-07-2021 05:21 AM

We had a wall bed installed in our first house. When we moved to a Camelia (same floor plan as a Gardenia) we had another wall bed installed. One difference from the old house: we had a closet put in one side of the bed and 2 drawers instead of a dresser. Works great for us!

FromNY 05-07-2021 05:29 AM

Build in draws as well This will eliminate the need for a dresser. Bifold doors work great. Allow for full access.
Lowe's or Home depo have closet section. Go check it out for ideas.

crash 05-07-2021 05:57 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Stu from NYC (Post 1940389)
Lots of bedrooms here do not have closet.

We are in a 3 bedroom Begonia and front bedroom is closetless.

Then it is not a bedroom it is a den. The description would be 2 bedrooms and a den.

crash 05-07-2021 06:00 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Carla B (Post 1940502)
Even a den needs a closet. So they should stop being so chintzy and just put a closet in that front room, period.

It has to do with size of the room not the cost to put in the closet. The room would be very small if they took out 2.5 feet for the closet.

J1ceasar 05-07-2021 06:02 AM

Correct it's a two bedroom plus den, all the real estate agents will tell you otherwise but that's a load of b - s

TheWarriors 05-07-2021 06:12 AM

Just review the tax records for the correct description.

mydavid 05-07-2021 06:12 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by shut the front door (Post 1940383)
How can they sell you a 3 BR home if a bedroom doesn't have a closet? I thought that was a requirement to call it a 3BR.

Technically its a den that could be used as a bedroom.:welcome:

Stu from NYC 05-07-2021 06:32 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by thevillages2013 (Post 1940607)
First thing you learn as a real estate agent is how to lie:faint:

But this lie was in writing.

dewilson58 05-07-2021 06:44 AM

Different locations have Different requirements to be defined as a bedroom.

Some locations DO NOT require a closets.

:ohdear:

Pat2015 05-07-2021 06:55 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by shut the front door (Post 1940383)
How can they sell you a 3 BR home if a bedroom doesn't have a closet? I thought that was a requirement to call it a 3BR.

In the absence of a closet it’s really a 2BR with a den.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:23 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Search Engine Optimisation provided by DragonByte SEO v2.0.32 (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2025 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.