Talk of The Villages Florida

Talk of The Villages Florida (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/)
-   Restaurant Discussions (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/restaurant-discussions-90/)
-   -   Best fish and chips (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/restaurant-discussions-90/best-fish-chips-342052/)

margaretmattson 06-14-2023 08:18 PM

Best fish and chips
 
I am having a hankering for some great fish and chips, anyone know the best place to go? I prefer plain batter (not beer batter), freshly cut fries, and a mug of great beer to chug it down. Your suggestions would be appreciated! Thanks in advance!

Stu from NYC 06-14-2023 09:23 PM

Havana CC has good fish and chips. Ask for mushy peas and you will get a blank stare.

margaretmattson 06-14-2023 11:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Stu from NYC (Post 2226452)
Havana CC has good fish and chips. Ask for mushy peas and you will get a blank stare.

Thanks! I had a British friend who turned me on to good fish and chips. Your mushy peas comment makes me realize you too must understand good fish and chips. Must be a British thing! Here's hoping Havana CC is what I am looking for! (Fingers crossed)

Kelevision 06-15-2023 02:22 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by margaretmattson (Post 2226443)
I am having a hankering for some great fish and chips, anyone know the best place to go? I prefer plain batter (not beer batter), freshly cut fries, and a mug of great beer to chug it down. Your suggestions would be appreciated! Thanks in advance!

I don’t know what area you’re in but south of 44 has 2 options. Fenney Grill has good Fish and Chips but I always get the potato chips because they’re homemade. I’ve never had the fries. Or you could go to McGrady’s Pub at Sawgrass which even comes with mushy peas but I’m not sure about the fries.

swooner 06-15-2023 05:13 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kelevision (Post 2226462)
I don’t know what area you’re in but south of 44 has 2 options. Fenney Grill has good Fish and Chips but I always get the potato chips because they’re homemade. I’ve never had the fries. Or you could go to McGrady’s Pub at Sawgrass which even comes with mushy peas but I’m not sure about the fries.

Been there, done that. Just awful! McGradys!

ohioshooter 06-15-2023 05:51 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by swooner (Post 2226483)
Been there, done that. Just awful!

Agreed, I like Cody’s and O’Shucks in addition to Havana.

margaretmattson 06-15-2023 06:36 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by swooner (Post 2226483)
Been there, done that. Just awful!

This is why I am asking. Spent quite a bit of money on Vilages restaurant food only to leave it on the table. Some restaurants seem to be hit or miss while others are just not up to par. Am I too picky? Is it just me?

Altavia 06-15-2023 06:40 AM

Little Fin at Sawgrass is our favorite, very crispy.

mrf0151 06-15-2023 06:49 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by swooner (Post 2226483)
Been there, done that. Just awful!

Agree! Their fish is mushy. Worst ever.

Michael 61 06-15-2023 06:54 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mrf0151 (Post 2226547)
Agree! Their fish is mushy. Worst ever.

I’m going to have to add my voice here as well - simply bad! I couldn’t finish it. My server actually told me afterwards that they had fried quite a few batches already in the fryer, so the oil was getting old - tasted like it too - plus the breading was the worst.

asianthree 06-15-2023 08:00 AM

O shucks has good fried fish, not the best, since that was in London and outskirts. I think I had fish in London 5 days a week while we there. It’s hard to beat that foodie experience

Stu from NYC 06-15-2023 08:06 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ohioshooter (Post 2226499)
Agreed, I like Cody’s and O’Shucks in addition to Havana.

Been to Cody in LSL worst service we have ever seen in a restaurant and lots of people have told us the same so not going back.

O;Shucks had good fish and chips but we made the mistake of sitting outside. Borders a garbage dump apparently and flying insects ate more than we did. Finally waitress came over to us with a can of insect repellent but too little too late. If we do go back would only sit inside

Stu from NYC 06-15-2023 08:07 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by asianthree (Post 2226601)
O shucks has good fried fish, not the best, since that was in London and outskirts. I think I had fish in London 5 days a week while we there. It’s hard to beat that foodie experience

Pubs in London do make it very well.

dtennent 06-15-2023 08:09 AM

You might try McCracken’s Irish Pub on Main St. in Leesburg. While the fries were freshly cut, they come with Parmesan cheese. You could ask to have the cheese left off.

asianthree 06-15-2023 08:12 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Stu from NYC (Post 2226610)
Pubs in London do make it very well.

Pubs or street vendors, both were addictive. Guessing it was the light almost tempura thin batter that allowed the fish to be perfectly flaky. :mmmm:

drbales 06-15-2023 08:14 AM

[QUOTE=margaretmattson;2226443]I am having a hankering for some great fish and chips, anyone know the best place to go? I prefer plain batter (not beer batter), freshly cut fries, and a mug of great beer to chug it down. Your suggestions would be appreciated! Thanks in advance![/
Clermont Fish House in Clermont.
Great

Two Bills 06-15-2023 08:24 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Michael 61 (Post 2226551)
................................. - plus the breading was the worst.

There was the first red flag.
Bread crumbs!!! :ohdear:
Fried fish for fish and chips should be in batter only.

PS. It is even hard to find good fish and chips in UK nowadays.

bimmertl 06-15-2023 08:39 AM

It's amazing that not one person commented on what type of fish is being served. Haddock, Cod, Tilapia, Swai or whatever.

Type of fish can make a big difference.

asianthree 06-15-2023 08:41 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bimmertl (Post 2226632)
It's amazing that not one person commented on what type of fish is being served. Haddock, Cod, Tilapia, Swai or whatever.

Type of fish can make a big difference.

Not all restaurants want to share that info, and wait staff is usually not in on the secret, but it’s the batter for me that makes a difference

ohioshooter 06-15-2023 08:44 AM

By far, I like Haddock breaded not battered.

Stu from NYC 06-15-2023 09:23 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Two Bills (Post 2226620)
There was the first red flag.
Bread crumbs!!! :ohdear:
Fried fish for fish and chips should be in batter only.

PS. It is even hard to find good fish and chips in UK nowadays.

Piccadilly circus has a really good pub serving fish and chips but have no clue as to address. Just remember it is around the corner from a half price theater booth.

Agreed that it must be made using a good batter.

marynealmichigan 06-15-2023 09:30 AM

The Friar Tuck
 
"The Friar Tuck" in Clermont FL

An authentic British Pub own by a couple from the UK. They serve the biggest piece of fried Cod I have ever seen, incredible. Also have British beer on tap and an attached store selling British condiments.

601 Cagan Park Ave
Suit 401
Clermont FL. 34714

retiredguy123 06-15-2023 09:38 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Stu from NYC (Post 2226670)
Piccadilly circus has a really good pub serving fish and chips but have no clue as to address. Just remember it is around the corner from a half price theater booth.

Agreed that it must be made using a good batter.

I was going to check it out, but it is about 4,300 miles, and I am not that fond of fish and chips anyway.

Keefelane66 06-15-2023 09:44 AM

You’re making me hungry. Going for Fish&Chips this afternoon Galileo RI options are Haddock or Flounder with a side of Clam Chowder with Clam Cakes. Other options may be Cod or Pollock for catch of the day

ohioshooter 06-15-2023 09:56 AM

Love to find some great NE clam chowder here. The only place I’ve found it is O Shucks, and it’s just average.

SIRE1 06-15-2023 10:16 AM

I'm no expert on what "great" fish & chips should be, but I really like Cedar River Seafood in Inverness for fish & chips. It is on US41, just south of the intersection with SR 44. And you can order either Flounder or Icelandic Cod.

REDCART 06-15-2023 10:43 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dtennent (Post 2226613)
You might try McCracken’s Irish Pub on Main St. in Leesburg. While the fries were freshly cut, they come with Parmesan cheese. You could ask to have the cheese left off.

We also thought McCracken’s fish and chips was better than McGrady’s pub!

margaretmattson 06-15-2023 10:58 AM

A neighbor suggested orange blossom country club. She said she tried their fish fry about a year ago,. She remembers it being crisp and light. Said she enjoyed it very much. Has anyone tried the fish there recently?

Stu from NYC 06-15-2023 11:04 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by retiredguy123 (Post 2226678)
I was going to check it out, but it is about 4,300 miles, and I am not that fond of fish and chips anyway.

Actually just over 3000 miles and who knows they might even deliver too you.:bigbow:

Would expect you to give me the mushy peas as a finders fee.

Keefelane66 06-15-2023 11:08 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ohioshooter (Post 2226686)
Love to find some great NE clam chowder here. The only place I’ve found it is O Shucks, and it’s just average.

I make my own when I return to TV order clam juice and chopped clams thru Amazon 51oz containers some very good recipes online. Canned Clams and juice can be frozen. We make RI red chowder, New England cream and clear chowder. Less expensive than buying those little cans of clams and small bottles of juice.
A good canned Chowder made in Florida is Tony’s Chowder from Cedar Key won the Newport RI Chowder festival 2 years in a row available Publix.

427dave 06-15-2023 11:26 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ohioshooter (Post 2226686)
Love to find some great NE clam chowder here. The only place I’ve found it is O Shucks, and it’s just average.

Cedar Key, Tony's best clam chowder. Sometimes Publix has Tony's in the can and it is pretty good

Two Bills 06-15-2023 03:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bimmertl (Post 2226632)
It's amazing that not one person commented on what type of fish is being served. Haddock, Cod, Tilapia, Swai or whatever.

Type of fish can make a big difference.

In UK Cod is/was the most served, then Haddock, and my favorite, Rock Eel/Rock Salmon/Hus/Flake (any one of those names, depending on location of Chippy in UK.)
Anything apart from Cod, was a special order back in my days of going down our local Chippy.

A good Wally went down well with a nice piece of Lilian Gish, and I used to pick them up in the old Haddock and Bloater.

Stu from NYC 06-15-2023 03:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Two Bills (Post 2226777)
In UK Cod is/was the most served, then Haddock, and my favorite, Rock Eel/Rock Salmon/Hus/Flake (any one of those names, depending on location of Chippy in UK.)
Anything apart from Cod, was a special order back in my days of going down our local Chippy.

A good Wally went down well with a nice piece of Lilian Gish, and I used to pick them up in the old Haddock and Bloater.

How does one translate this into proper English?:mmmm:

Pinball wizard 06-15-2023 03:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ohioshooter (Post 2226499)
Agreed, I like Cody’s and O’Shucks in addition to Havana.

I second O'Shucks on 301 and 44

ton80 06-15-2023 03:26 PM

Translations Required
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Two Bills (Post 2226777)
In UK Cod is/was the most served, then Haddock, and my favorite, Rock Eel/Rock Salmon/Hus/Flake (any one of those names, depending on location of Chippy in UK.)
Anything apart from Cod, was a special order back in my days of going down our local Chippy.

A good Wally went down well with a nice piece of Lilian Gish, and I used to pick them up in the old Haddock and Bloater.

Two Bills, I spent 8 yrs in England over 3 work assignments. I know a small part of the slang but certainly not enough to decipher your comment fully.

Huss/Rock salmon/rock eel/huss I have heard and we called sand sharks or dog fish.

Lillian Gish may be fried potatoes

Wally may be an insult or a large gherkin (dill pickle)

During one of my assignments, there was a surplus of farmed salmon and actually atlantic salmon was reportedly cheaper than cod. The Chippy's served a lot of salmon but I preferred the cod.

Interesting memories. I never got the nerve to eat conger eel that I know of.

Cheers!

Caymus 06-15-2023 06:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Two Bills (Post 2226777)
In UK Cod is/was the most served, then Haddock, and my favorite, Rock Eel/Rock Salmon/Hus/Flake (any one of those names, depending on location of Chippy in UK.)
Anything apart from Cod, was a special order back in my days of going down our local Chippy.

A good Wally went down well with a nice piece of Lilian Gish, and I used to pick them up in the old Haddock and Bloater.

Is it fried with or without the skin?

kkingston57 06-15-2023 07:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Stu from NYC (Post 2226708)
Actually just over 3000 miles and who knows they might even deliver too you.:bigbow:

Would expect you to give me the mushy peas as a finders fee.

3000 miles? Just did a search. 4344 miles Orlando to Heathrow. Noted all of the responses. Have not found good Fish and Chips in TV. Usually mystery soft fish is what we have found. Hate to say it, but best fish I have found is at Culvers and they advertise that it is cod.

MrChip72 06-15-2023 07:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kelevision (Post 2226462)
I don’t know what area you’re in but south of 44 has 2 options. Fenney Grill has good Fish and Chips but I always get the potato chips because they’re homemade. I’ve never had the fries. Or you could go to McGrady’s Pub at Sawgrass which even comes with mushy peas but I’m not sure about the fries.

Tried Fenney Grill in April. The fish and chips was pretty bad. Also the "farm to table" vegetables they served on the side were basically the frozen peas and carrots mix like they sell at Publix in the frozen section. I heard it "used to be good" according to some people.

In Wildwood, O'Shucks serves a nice Fish and chips, pretty consistent and usually you get a nice sized piece.

Best in the Villages I had was at Evans Prairie one night, was exceptional unlike much of the food they serve at FMK restaurants.

mike234 06-16-2023 04:32 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by margaretmattson (Post 2226537)
This is why I am asking. Spent quite a bit of money on Vilages restaurant food only to leave it on the table. Some restaurants seem to be hit or miss while others are just not up to par. Am I too picky? Is it just me?

yup.....the consensus is that the seafood in florida, is terrible. and so is the Chinese food..........without naming names of restaurants, the one in wildwood, on 301?, near 44? did that a reopen? they seen to be shut regularly for violations....

JudyLife 06-16-2023 04:35 AM

Yep, mushy peas is a British thing & in my humble opinion if you want truly good fish & chips you’ll need to come over here to the U.K. and get the genuine article. 👍


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 02:32 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Search Engine Optimisation provided by DragonByte SEO v2.0.32 (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2025 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.