Talk of The Villages Florida

Talk of The Villages Florida (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/)
-   The Villages, Florida, General Discussion (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/villages-florida-general-discussion-73/)
-   -   Concealed carry guns (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/villages-florida-general-discussion-73/concealed-carry-guns-30277/)

The Shadow 07-12-2010 09:14 AM

Let’s have a contest. Does anyone have more that 5 snub nose 38s?

Taltarzac 07-12-2010 09:54 AM

What about Ft. Hood though?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Talk Host (Post 274751)
Think for a moment about the tragic events of the past few years. 21 students shot to death at Virginia Tech. 13 people massacred at the Civic Association in Binghamton, New York. 8 people killed in an Omaha shopping mall. 12 students and teachers dead at Columbine High School and on and on and on.

Oh that 1 person had a concealed weapon to stop the carnage.

This happened on a military base where you assume the people there have thorough knowledge of the use of all kinds of weapons. It took a while to take the shooter down.

Even in the Wild West very few people actually knew how to use a handgun against someone who is firing back.

bkcunningham1 07-12-2010 10:02 AM

Following the Ft. Hood murders by radical Muslim Nidal Malik Hasan, Lt. General Cone stated: "As a matter of practice, we do not carry weapons on Fort Hood. This is our home. Military weapons are only used for training or by base security, and personal weapons must be kept locked away by the provost marshal."

Specialist Jerry Richard, a soldier working at the Readiness Center, expressed the opinion that this policy had left them unnecessarily vulnerable to violent assaults: "Overseas you are ready for it. But here you can't even defend yourself."

Taltarzac 07-12-2010 10:13 AM

What about base security?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bkcunningham1 (Post 274765)
Following the Ft. Hood murders by radical Muslim Nidal Malik Hasan, Lt. General Cone stated: "As a matter of practice, we do not carry weapons on Fort Hood. This is our home. Military weapons are only used for training or by base security, and personal weapons must be kept locked away by the provost marshal."

Specialist Jerry Richard, a soldier working at the Readiness Center, expressed the opinion that this policy had left them unnecessarily vulnerable to violent assaults: "Overseas you are ready for it. But here you can't even defend yourself."

Why did it take so long for base security to re-act to a shooter on the base?

bkcunningham1 07-12-2010 10:31 AM

The terrorist attack took place inside the very crowded Soldier Readiness Center, where personnel receive routine medical treatment immediately prior to and on return from deployment.

Eyewitnesses said he took a seat at an empty table, bowed his head for several seconds, and then stood up and opened fire. Hasan reportedly jumped onto a desk and shouted: "Allahu Akbar!", (Which means Allah is Greater) before, according to reports, firing more than 100 rounds at soldiers processing through cubicles in the center, and on a crowd gathered for a college graduation ceremony scheduled for 2 p.m. in a nearby theater. It was reported that Hasan was focused on soldiers in uniform.

I suppose it was difficult for unarmed men and women in the vicinity to gain control of the situation. He had two handguns: an FN Five-seven semi-automatic pistol, which he had purchased at a civilian gun store, and a .357 Magnum which he may not have fired.

He is charges with 13 counts of premeditated murder and 32 counts of attempted murder.

duffysmom 07-12-2010 11:51 AM

Gracie Say it ain't so....
 
Gracie, I for one do not think you are an airhead. As a matter of fact, I enjoy your posts immensely and want you to be a resident of TV. We need intelligent, savy and feisty women like you. I live very happily in TV with absolutely no fear but I am vigilent. There is a difference.
I don't own any weapons other than my very protective watch dog Duffy. He can be very intimidating, all 4 lbs of him. By the way, I too was surprised to hear that many people carry concealed weapons but I think that is probably true in most communities. We just have a very active website where people share their experiences.

Taltarzac 07-12-2010 11:58 AM

What club number would you use on a prowler?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by duffysmom (Post 274783)
Gracie, I for one do not think you are an airhead. As a matter of fact, I enjoy your posts immensely and want you to be a resident of TV. We need intelligent, savy and feisty women like you. I live very happily in TV with absolutely no fear but I am vigilent. There is a difference.
I don't own any weapons other than my very protective watch dog Duffy. He can be very intimidating, all 4 lbs of him. By the way, I too was surprised to hear that many people carry concealed weapons but I think that is probably true in most communities. We just have a very active website where people share their experiences.

I would think that all the golf clubs would deter many burglars from entering occupied homes in the Villages.

On the subject of welcome posters, I like Graciegirl's posts even though she will soon be the person with the most posts on TOTV if she keeps up the rate she is going.

bkcunningham1 07-12-2010 12:04 PM

And who might that be?

Taltarzac 4364
graciegirl 4270
chelsea24 3739
Barefoot 3720
Talk Host 3564
KathieI 3423
redwitch 3146
nONIE 3060
Donna 2724
Russ_Boston 2687

Pturner 07-12-2010 12:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Yoda (Post 274688)
As soon as I saw 6 pages in one day, I just knew...
... If you don't want people to carry concealed guns close your eyes and imagine a world with no guns. That will make you feel better but don't interfere with the rights of other people. The same people with the same arguments.Yoda

Hi Yoda,
As you admittedly prejudged the discussion before read the posts, I wonder if you think it possible that your expectations could have influenced how you viewed the actual posed.

Some people said they are uncomfortable around guns, some gave heartfelt reasons why they carry guns for personal protection, and some said that fear was not a motivating factor in their choice to carry.

Some thought carrying a concealed weapon is a good idea; some thought not. Regardless of shades of opinion, personal experiences were shared. I didn't see any posts that argued for interfering with anyone's right to bear arms.

To paraphrase your comment and put it in a different perspective:
If you don't want to see a variety of opinions on a topic raised for discussion on a discussion board, close your eyes and imagine a world with no opinions other than your own. That will make you feel better.

See how that feels.

BTW, I mean no insult to you and don't actually suggest you close your eyes. I just hoped perchance to demonstrate how that statement can be hurtful, disrepectful and belittling. I respect your opinions on guns and other topics, regardless of whether I agree. I appeal to you and others for the same respect toward me and my beloved colleagues on this site.

Vinny 07-12-2010 12:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by graciegirl (Post 274733)
Bk and Red.

Your considered and kind responses brought tears to my eyes. Thank you for your posts. I can see that you two are not afraid.

We are all different here. That is good.

Gracie, people carry concealed guns in your state. I think you are just becoming aware that about 44 states allow their citizens to carry concealed firearms. The overall percentage of people legally carrying guns is small and the penalties for brandishing or showing it in a non life and death situation are harsh with no chance of parole.

Pats2010 07-12-2010 12:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pturner (Post 274797)
Hi Yoda,
As you admittedly prejudged the discussion before read the posts, I wonder if you think it possible that your expectations could have influenced how you viewed the actual posed.

Some people said they are uncomfortable around guns, some gave heartfelt reasons why they carry guns for personal protection, and some said that fear was not a motivating factor in their choice to carry.

Some thought carrying a concealed weapon is a good idea; some thought not. Regardless of shades of opinion, personal experiences were shared. I didn't see any posts that argued for interfering with anyone's right to bear arms.

To paraphrase your comment and put it in a different perspective:
If you don't want to see a variety of opinions on a topic raised for discussion on a discussion board, close your eyes and imagine a world with no opinions other than your own. That will make you feel better.

See how that feels.

BTW, I mean no insult to you and don't actually suggest you close your eyes. I just hoped perchance to demonstrate how that statement can be hurtful, disrepectful and belittling. I respect your opinions on guns and other topics, regardless of whether I agree. I appeal to you and others for the same respect toward me and my beloved colleagues on this site.

p.s., If you so choose, belittle away on political. Everyone knows to go there at their own risk.

Belittling people on any of these forums is against policy. Why do people enjoy polarizing political?

I am not saying this to any particular person on this forum. I'm just curious about the animosity that I see here occasionally.

Pturner 07-12-2010 12:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by graciegirl (Post 274719)
Reading all of this has given me second thoughts about this place. We are planning to sell our house up north and to live here full time.

I wonder about living where people carry guns about and live in such fear that they feel they have to carry guns.

We have had a home in Hadley for two years. Nothing has happened here. No one has had anything stolen on our street or the next few that I know about. No one has had any attempted break ins. It is just like in Ohio, as far as I can see. Why in the world would anyone be afraid? I don't know of any break ins in Hadley.

Of course I support the Constitution and the right to bear arms.

I know that there are areas in this country where it is dangerous. Orlando is always reporting killings and so does downtown Cincinnati. It is usually young black men shooting young black men and it is over drugs. Now that sentence is not meant to be racist.

Yes. There are bad people trying to do harm to old defenseless people. It would be pretty tough to do that here with most people not working and everyone watching out for others.

I have been really troubled after reading this thread. I don't want to live in a climate of fear.

And kinda mad. I don't like for people to think I am an airhead. And uninformed. Just what do most of you think is the percentage of people who carry guns in TV?

Please, please, please say it ain't so! Gracie you are to airhead what... what... what... Furmar is to bad-looking. ;)

Seriously, it's people like you who make TV a wonderful place to live. You are smart, funny, warm hearted and a bit onery. ;)

I'm using my bear arms to give you a big heart-felt hug.

graciegirl 07-12-2010 01:00 PM

Dear Vinny.

I know that there are guns carried in many states.

I also know that somewhere, someone is reading this who has never been here. What are they envisioning?

This lovely, PEACEFUL, tranquil, animated, enlivened, safe, joyful, place is not somewhere where you are in extreme danger nor where you are in moderate danger....it is one of the safest places in the U.S.

People leave here a lot to go to live in the village of Heavenly but they don't leave because they have been SHOT.

I haven't seen anything here that is a cause for concern. People lose their purses and their purses are returned to them most of the time. Golf clubs are sometimes stolen on the square and probably by people who intend to steal them, but not a HUGE problem.

There are workers in and out and other than that there aren't people who are strangers or people from off the res just waiting to attack or steal from people. People have guests but really most of the teens are well behaved.

I just want the people who have never lived here to realize that in my humble opinion the last thing I would carry is a gun here.

But if I ever need protection from some yet unknown invading force, I will not hesitate to call "My cousin Vinny".

Cause I think he could get the bad guys....or girls.

GG

r_foye 07-12-2010 01:27 PM

As a retired police officer I had a gun attached to my hip everyday. I stared down the barrel many times at people who were a heartbeat away from having me kill them. Can I live with killing someone? Absolutely, I would have not second guessed myself at all. There are evil people in this world and as far as Im concerned killing evil would not cause me to lose a moments sleep. Having seen just about every form of evil I will tell you something that you may or may not believe, but I guarantee you is true. There are evil people living in The Villages, the odds dictate this to be true. Just because you are living in a retirement community doesnt make you immune. Having said that I will say that now that Im retired I dont even own a weapon, why?, I just dont feel a huge need to have one. Im willing to take my chances with the bad people of this world. I feel the odds of having to use it are just about nil. Now Im sure this will **** some people off but I think that most people who have concealed weapons permits probably shouldnt have them. Just because you took a course and blasted the target at the local range doesnt mean you are qualified to carry a gun. Just my two cents worth.

Pats2010 07-12-2010 01:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Taltarzac (Post 274818)
....I cannot think of any intruder being shot by a Villager nor any incident involving a concealed gun. There was a domestic dispute which escalated into a wife shooting her husband, an attempted shooting at one of the postal stations over an unwanted suitor by the lady's son, at least one shotgun related suicide (Melinda Duckett), and a "kidnapping" which involved a conspiracy to use a Village couple's bank cards planned it sounded by their daughter. Her mother was killed by a gun used in the hands of one of the conspirators. The domestic dispute involved two retired law enforcement officers.

Those are the facts as close as I can remember even though I am a little fuzzy on a lot of how each exactly went down.

Maybe the good citizens of the Villages could partition for the right to place signs that say this is a gun-free zone. I bet that would be a deterrent. :police:

BobKat1 07-12-2010 01:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by r_foye (Post 274821)
As a retired police officer I had a gun attached to my hip everyday. I stared down the barrel many times at people who were a heartbeat away from having me kill them. Can I live with killing someone? Absolutely, I would have not second guessed myself at all. There are evil people in this world and as far as Im concerned killing evil would not cause me to lose a moments sleep. Having seen just about every form of evil I will tell you something that you may or may not believe, but I guarantee you is true. There are evil people living in The Villages, the odds dictate this to be true. Just because you are living in a retirement community doesnt make you immune. Having said that I will say that now that Im retired I dont even own a weapon, why?, I just dont feel a huge need to have one. Im willing to take my chances with the bad people of this world. I feel the odds of having to use it are just about nil. Now Im sure this will **** some people off but I think that most people who have concealed weapons permits probably shouldnt have them. Just because you took a course and blasted the target at the local range doesnt mean you are qualified to carry a gun. Just my two cents worth.

Interesting perspective...

graciegirl 07-12-2010 02:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pturner (Post 274802)
Please, please, please say it ain't so! Gracie you are to airhead what... what... what... Furmar is to bad-looking. ;)

Seriously, it's people like you who make TV a wonderful place to live. You are smart, funny, warm hearted and a bit onery. ;)

I'm using my bear arms to give you a big heart-felt hug.

Thank you for your lovely hug.

This place is full of good stuff and lovely kind people like P.

BUT....I am thinking about getting a water pistol.

I have always been a joiner.

Not worried.

GG

redwitch 07-12-2010 02:06 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by graciegirl (Post 274841)
BUT....I am thinking about getting a water pistol.
GG

Skip the water pistol and go for the big stuff -- get a water cannon. Much more fun.

Pturner 07-12-2010 02:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by redwitch (Post 274843)
Skip the water pistol and go for the big stuff -- get a water cannon. Much more fun.

Or maybe we should all get together and have a good ole-fashion pillow fight!
:crap2:

redwitch 07-12-2010 02:14 PM

Too hot -- I vote for the water guns. Sundown at the Polo Grounds.

Talk Host 07-12-2010 02:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by r_foye (Post 274821)
I think that most people who have concealed weapons permits probably shouldnt have them. Just because you took a course and blasted the target at the local range doesnt mean you are qualified to carry a gun. Just my two cents worth.

I could not agree more with this. As a police officer, you were in the near occasion of evil many times. You were trained. Your justification for shooting could be clear in most cases. Private citizens who bellow that they would "KILL ANY SON OF A ***** THAT COMES INTO MY HOUSE," in most cases are not trained to make the same decisions as a police officer or a court. You likely would shoot out of self defense, not for punishment.

And, those people who say, if he's outside when you shoot him, drag him in the house. Isn't that murder?

Ironic, another mass killing today in New Mexico. 6 known dead.

Annabelle 07-12-2010 03:01 PM

How did this thread which asked a simple question by Vinny
{"Does anyone know where in the Villages you cannot carry a concealed handgun?"}
deteriorate into a heated discussion about whether "TV is a safe place to live?"

I see no reason to interrupt an innocuous remark regarding "handguns" as some hidden message that TV is not a safe place to retire.

The only assumption that I made regarding Vinny's question is that he is a law abiding citizen who is going to make those around him a good neighbor.

There are some who feel (well intentioned I'm sure) they must "defend" TV even when there is nothing to defend. TV speaks well for itself. It is a lovely retirement community and is "right" for some, yet "wrong" for others.

As far as the comments hurled at those who post on the "Political Forum," I find that one must "thread" more lightly on the "General Discussion Forum" because they tend to become a bit more volatile than others especially when any subject is controversial.

Annabelle

Pats2010 07-12-2010 03:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Annabelle (Post 274858)
How did this thread which asked a simple question by Vinny
{"Does anyone know where in the Villages you cannot carry a concealed handgun?"}
deteriorate into a heated discussion about whether "TV is a safe place to live?"

I see no reason to interrupt an innocuous remark regarding "handguns" as some hidden message that TV is not a safe place to retire.

The only assumption that I made regarding Vinny's question is that he is a law abiding citizen who is going to make those around him a good neighbor.

There are some who feel (well intentioned I'm sure) they must "defend" TV even when there is nothing to defend. TV speaks well for itself. It is a lovely retirement community and is "right" for some, yet "wrong" for others.

As far as the comments hurled at those who post on the "Political Forum," I find that one must "thread" more lightly on the "General Discussion Forum" because they tend to become a bit more volatile than others especially when any subject is controversial.

Annabelle

:beer3: Touche!!!

entemedor 07-12-2010 05:14 PM

What seems like 10 years ago, some poor guy started this thread by asking for info about carrying a firearm here in TV....

Much emotion and some information that is flat-out wrong ensued. OK, here's my suggestions:

1. Ask a lawyer, admitted to the Florida Bar, who knows about this kind of thing.

2. Failing that, get a copy of Florida Firearms, Law, Use, and Ownership. You can get this on-line here:

http://www.floridafirearmslaw.com/

Vinny 07-12-2010 06:01 PM

Gracie, I agree with you. I feel no need to carry a gun in TV. But there are those times when you are leaving The Villages or are in and out of it throughout the day when I will be armed as it safer to keep the gun on you then in the car. Quite frankly it is uncomfortable to carry a gun in this heat but we do it to protect ourselves and those around us. It is also very inconvenient to carry a gun due to the places you cannot carry one. The last two days are good examples. I was out but ran into friends who wanted me to join them for drinks at a bar. If I was carrying I could not go into the bar. Today I was out and got a call to pickup a prescription. Once again guns are not allowed in pharmacies so you see how much of a pain it can be to carry a gun. Some people feel that it is best to carry all the time rather than play the odds. Personally I would rather take my chances and only carry outside of TV.

Vinny 07-12-2010 06:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Annabelle (Post 274858)
How did this thread which asked a simple question by Vinny
{"Does anyone know where in the Villages you cannot carry a concealed handgun?"}
deteriorate into a heated discussion about whether "TV is a safe place to live?"

I see no reason to interrupt an innocuous remark regarding "handguns" as some hidden message that TV is not a safe place to retire.

The only assumption that I made regarding Vinny's question is that he is a law abiding citizen who is going to make those around him a good neighbor.

There are some who feel (well intentioned I'm sure) they must "defend" TV even when there is nothing to defend. TV speaks well for itself. It is a lovely retirement community and is "right" for some, yet "wrong" for others.

As far as the comments hurled at those who post on the "Political Forum," I find that one must "thread" more lightly on the "General Discussion Forum" because they tend to become a bit more volatile than others especially when any subject is controversial.

Annabelle

You are absolutely right. My brother-in-law asked me so I asked the forum. Unfortunately guns are a hot button topic. At least I learned a lot about who carries and who does not and different views on the subject. I never felt that words could hurt me or whist other people think of me. I am an island unto myself in this regard.

Now I can report back to NJ whose homes to stay away from. :-).

Pturner 07-12-2010 08:04 PM

Imagine starting a thread that "triggers" a conversation. :faint:

...Oh wait. I thought that was what discussion boards were for.

:wine:

BJinTX 07-19-2010 10:58 AM

Thank you for the leveled headed discussion on concealed weapons. Yes, I do carry a concealed weapon. And I did carry yesterday to San Antonio. There are many reason I chose to carry: I do drive to the city alone, I do live in a small town with open land behind me and I do feel the need.
I do have to say, I went through 12 hours of training to receive my license here in Texas. A lot of the course was aimed a conflict management and how to handle situations by not drawing your gun. Yes I do have a laser sight.
Would I have a hard time using it - not if I feel myself, my husband or my property is truly threatened.
Unfortunately as some have said there are bad people in the world.

Hope to be there soon ......BJ

graciegirl 07-19-2010 12:33 PM

There isn't much in the way of bad guys here. I keep saying it. I keep saying it. I keep saying it.

K9-Lovers 07-19-2010 12:39 PM

Read the facts, read the facts, read the facts.

Bogie Shooter 07-19-2010 01:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by K9-Lovers (Post 276813)
Read the facts, read the facts, read the facts.

What are you inplying??

K9-Lovers 07-19-2010 01:38 PM

I'm not implying anything. There are bad guys everywhere, even here in TV. As much as I'd like to believe there is no crime here, it's just not so, unfortunately.

Pats2010 07-19-2010 01:51 PM

Evil people are everywhere. They don't lock them up like they used to.

graciegirl 07-19-2010 02:10 PM

Relatively speaking, this is a safe place.Now how many times do you think there has been a situation where a gun was needed in the two years I have lived here? NONE!

Fourpar 07-19-2010 02:15 PM

C weapons
 
Vinny,
Anyone who has such a permit knows, or should know where it is okay to carry. That is a very prominent part of the licensing process. If the person does not know that information, they should probably not have such a permit...

Pats2010 07-19-2010 02:52 PM

Gracie
 
Perception is everything. Even thugs have it. If TV has the reputation of having people who are conservative law-abiding citizens, then that means that a good percentage will be armed.
On the other hand, if people have an image of TV as aging hippies who walk around giving people the "peace sign" they will project an image of helpless victims. IMHO

BJinTX 07-19-2010 03:12 PM

Gracie is right....
 
Gracie, you are right. Perception means a lot. I do hope TV is not a bunch of old hippies, I want a lively bunch when we get there.
I do know a girl here (our town is 22,000) that went to Austin. She did get lost. At a stop sign, a car with 4 guys next to her where checking her out. They were not regular nice guys. She just placed her gun on the dash and had no problems!

Chi-Town 07-19-2010 03:18 PM

Forget all this pistol packing Paladin nonsense. The only way to travel with a gun is with an Easy Rider Rifle Rack on the back of your golf cart.

billethkid 07-19-2010 03:29 PM

Relatively speaking, I am sure we can all say where ever we have been
 
is relatively safe with no need to carry/have concealed weapon. The same is iron clad true for insurance of any kind...but we still all (most of us) spend a lifetime of never having had to make a claim. Ditto for being an armed citizen.

There will never be a reconciliation of acceptance of the notion of being an armed citizen. Nor will there ever be a valid argument why not to.

Gun owners, 99% or higher, ARE responsible citizens with their version of insurance. It has nothing to do with the perceived or real need or not.

It is in the category of religion or politics. Nobody is right or wrong, it is a personal choice.

For those who have never been around guns, or those who have lived with them in family sporting....both have a distorted view of the subject. That is not a negative subject...just reality.

btk

graciegirl 07-19-2010 03:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by billethkid (Post 276964)
is relatively safe with no need to carry/have concealed weapon. The same is iron clad true for insurance of any kind...but we still all (most of us) spend a lifetime of never having had to make a claim. Ditto for being an armed citizen.

There will never be a reconciliation of acceptance of the notion of being an armed citizen. Nor will there ever be a valid argument why not to.

Gun owners, 99% or higher, ARE responsible citizens with their version of insurance. It has nothing to do with the perceived or real need or not.

It is in the category of religion or politics. Nobody is right or wrong, it is a personal choice.

For those who have never been around guns, or those who have lived with them in family sporting....both have a distorted view of the subject. That is not a negative subject...just reality.

btk

Now that is a good argument Billy. I haven't trouble with you or any other responsible person carrying a gun if it it what you believe is the right thing to do. It aches my heart for anyone who hasn't been here to think we are a .....dangerous armpit of the world. Plus there are a lot of people who are not aging hippies, who are very law conscious, who are decent people, who do not think it necessary to own a gun...YET. Now I'm done.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 03:25 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Search Engine Optimisation provided by DragonByte SEO v2.0.32 (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2025 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.