Talk of The Villages Florida

Talk of The Villages Florida (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/)
-   The Villages, Florida, General Discussion (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/villages-florida-general-discussion-73/)
-   -   Is it me or 2 lane roundabouts just don't work? (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/villages-florida-general-discussion-73/me-2-lane-roundabouts-just-dont-work-316194/)

tsmall22204 02-12-2021 06:02 AM

If directions are followed, they work well.

mike1946 02-12-2021 06:08 AM

I'm a Brit !! A word of advice to American drivers ... don't even think of hiring a car and driving in the UK !! We have 1000's of roundabouts of all shapes and sizes some with multi lanes - I think the one around Marble Arch is 5 lanes and there are a few more like that ....don't get me started on the magic roundabouts ...one in Swindon and one in Milton Keynes where you join the big one via a little one ...so you can go the wrong way round if you want to. Google it !! They are great fun. All this while driving on the 'correct' side of the road ...so remember to go clockwise around a roundabout not anti-clockwise. Seriously guys ...you will die !!

Leadbone1 02-12-2021 06:08 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by boxcarwilly (Post 1900410)
IMOP....too compact to be safe..drivers are more confused than a goat on astroturf.:MOJE_whot: I treat all roundabouts like a single lane rotary and use a turn signal when exiting.

You know, it’s not rocket science but you would think it is. The lanes are clearly marked in the roundabouts on how they are to be used, but unfortunately there are way too many people that don’t get it. On two occasions I have had to lock my breaks up right in the middle of the circle because someone in the outside lane cut across right in front of me to continue around the circle as I was on the inside lane and going straight. And yes it’s a good idea to put a blinker on when you’re going to exit. Common sense and caution are definitely called for.

golfing eagles 02-12-2021 06:12 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Regor (Post 1900582)
You're thinking like it's okay to take a right from the left lane is what causes accidents. The inner lane is not the "straight" lane. That would ONLY work if the right lane entering the roundabout HAD to take the first exit. They don't have to take the 1st exit.

Wrong! WRONG!! VERY VERY WRONG!!!

You can, and in some cases should, use the left/inner lane to go straight through a RB. It is posts like this one that leads to the belief that it's OK to enter a RB if the only traffic coming around is in the inner lane. WRONG! That's what leads to accidents. ALL traffic must pass before you can enter a RB.

Hiltongrizz11 02-12-2021 06:18 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by golfing eagles (Post 1900427)
Yes, but the blue car at the top SHOULD NOT EVEN CONSIDER ENTERING THE RB until traffic in both lanes has cleared. He may intend to turn into the first exit in the outer lane, but the car in the RB already may have come from the first entrance to his left and intend to (legally) go straight to the same exit

WRONG! Nobody should stop

Skunky1 02-12-2021 06:20 AM

These roundabouts remind me of European vacation.

golfing eagles 02-12-2021 06:25 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by golfing eagles (Post 1900427)
Yes, but the blue car at the top SHOULD NOT EVEN CONSIDER ENTERING THE RB until traffic in both lanes has cleared. He may intend to turn into the first exit in the outer lane, but the car in the RB already may have come from the first entrance to his left and intend to (legally) go straight to the same exit

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hiltongrizz11 (Post 1900805)
WRONG! Nobody should stop

WHAT!!!!. Drive much???????
I feel sorry for anyone who never stops entering a RB when an 18 wheeler is coming around. Of course you HAVE to stop when traffic is coming. Another example of people not understanding a VERY simple concept of navigating the RBs

Have you noticed that triangular YIELD sign at the entrance to all the RBs???? It is NOT a suggestion and it is NOT there for decoration. I just hope I corrected the misconception posted before someone gets killed.

J1ceasar 02-12-2021 06:39 AM

You hit the nail on the head, these roundabouts are way too small to work correctly and the speed of the cars are about 20 miles per hour too fast. I come from Jersey and the random pads are at least 100 or 200 ft across larger. Also it is ridiculous to say stay on the inside or staying on the outside Lane depending on where you get off the only safe way to drive them is to stay on the outside Lane make sure no one is next to you or trying to come in when you're going around. I really wish they would have some lights

banjobob 02-12-2021 06:40 AM

Best answer yet, and never be side by side with another car .

Joerogers723 02-12-2021 06:41 AM

By making up your own rules, you will certainly create a future accident with someone that does follow the standard rules.

J1ceasar 02-12-2021 06:43 AM

This is why there should be no roundabouts and we should just have traffic lights. Everybody is an idiot when they're driving and I don't know anyone over the age of 50 that can change lanes three times in the space of 100 ft safely

golfing eagles 02-12-2021 06:45 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by J1ceasar (Post 1900823)
You hit the nail on the head, these roundabouts are way too small to work correctly and the speed of the cars are about 20 miles per hour too fast. I come from Jersey and the random pads are at least 100 or 200 ft across larger. Also it is ridiculous to say stay on the inside or staying on the outside Lane depending on where you get off the only safe way to drive them is to stay on the outside Lane make sure no one is next to you or trying to come in when you're going around. I really wish they would have some lights

So, are you advocating staying in the outside lane to go to the third (270 degree) exit? Sounds like it. Please post a schedule of when and where you will be navigating the RBs so the other 129,999 of can avoid the area.

banjobob 02-12-2021 06:46 AM

I think that if the roundabouts were traffic lights in season the villages would become a giant parking lot. Check traffic backups at Morse and 466 ,traffic flow around El Camino Real roundabout and imagine what it would be with traffic light and all the turn signal wait times. Thank God we have roundabouts.

golfing eagles 02-12-2021 06:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by J1ceasar (Post 1900828)
This is why there should be no roundabouts and we should just have traffic lights. Everybody is an idiot when they're driving and I don't know anyone over the age of 50 that can change lanes three times in the space of 100 ft safely

Still don't get it? There is NO NEED to change lanes in a RB (if you know what the rules are and not making up your own). As far as EVERYBODY being an idiot, I'm not, but I can name at least one driver who is........

golfing eagles 02-12-2021 06:52 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by banjobob (Post 1900831)
I think that if the roundabouts were traffic lights in season the villages would become a giant parking lot. Check traffic backups at Morse and 466 ,traffic flow around El Camino Real roundabout and imagine what it would be with traffic light and all the turn signal wait times. Thank God we have roundabouts.

It would be a nightmare.

I hate government regulation, but based on the posts in this thread, I would be willing to advocate a special written and road test just for navigating RBs in TV, with a license endorsement. You fail, you use your golf cart inside the bubble, and if leaving the bubble have a friend drive your car to the city limit and meet him there.

People who like Draconian solutions would LOVE this one:1rotfl::1rotfl::1rotfl:

Girlcopper 02-12-2021 06:52 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by golfing eagles (Post 1900424)
All true, and add
***watch out for drivers going the wrong way in the RB
***watch out for cyclists in a pack of 20 blowing through the yield sign as if they were one entity
***beware non-street legal golf carts cutting across lanes in front of you
***beware cars going 270 around the RB in the outer lane, and cars exiting at 90 from the inner lane
***Be especially concerned if a car with out of state handicapped plates is approaching the entrance to the RB
***and my favorite, beware the driver who just stops dead in the middle of a RB, usually just far enough ahead that you can't see her around the circle

Enjoy your drive today!:1rotfl::1rotfl::1rotfl:

A very accurate post!!

noslices1 02-12-2021 06:55 AM

Single lane?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by boxcarwilly (Post 1900410)
IMOP....too compact to be safe..drivers are more confused than a goat on astroturf.:MOJE_whot: I treat all roundabouts like a single lane rotary and use a turn signal when exiting.

You can treat them like a single lane rotary if you still follow the rules and only turn right or go straight from the right hand lane, and only go straight or turn left or make a U-turn from the left-hand lane. Other than that, you are doing it wrong.

MandoMan 02-12-2021 06:58 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DeanFL (Post 1900416)
.
.
My #1 rule re roundabouts.

Keep eyes and head on a swivel, NEVER go side-by-side with another vehicle, distrust all signals etc, NEVER assume that the vehicle will stop before entering the roundabout as you're approaching them, be ready to brake at any time, and ALWAYS assume the worst from other drivers.
.
.

Correct. The two land roundabouts work great for everyone who pays attention and stays in the lane without clipping corners. They save so much time! But they require constant alertness. I usually can merge at 20 mph and rarely need to stop, but my reaction speed is fast. Plenty of people here don’t react that quickly. Yesterday I got behind someone who actually stopped at all roundabouts when there was NO oncoming traffic. I always need to be alert for people like that. Don’t ever change lanes IN a roundabout. Figure out which lane you need before you enter the roundabout and stay in it. I think the roundabouts in The Villages are marvels of clarity and good design. “Clarity and good design” are not always attributes of the minds of drivers, unfortunately.

Surf Daddy 02-12-2021 06:59 AM

I can make it simpler. "Just don't get hit"

Girlcopper 02-12-2021 07:02 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Arctic Fox (Post 1900514)
This is the key, along with indicating your intention to exit the roundabout.

Give others room to move - if you are in the outside lane and someone is in the inside lane and wants to turn right, it is up to you to let them do so.

Having both lanes of Buena Vista merge into one before every roundabout would result in far more accidents.

Morse Blvd roundabout just east of 441 is survival of the fittest. Cars just go lane to lane looking like they dont know where they want to turn or else they dont know how to maintain a lane. Ive had them cut in front of me almost taking my bumper off, had them stop for no apparent reason causing me to almost bond with them, honk at me when Im in my lane, bikers just come zipping by like they own the road, golf cart drivers just stare straight ahead and go. I guess if they act like they dont see you it gives them right of way. Roundabouts arent difficult. Many times its just inconsideration

Bridget Staunton 02-12-2021 07:37 AM

Thank you SIR, a lady cut my hubby & I off coming into Hillsborough she was rude & thought she didn’t do anything wrong. I am familiar because we have lots of roundabouts in Ireland. Thank you good neighbor

Skunky1 02-12-2021 07:52 AM

The signs entering a roundabout are misleading

Skunky1 02-12-2021 07:53 AM

And contradictory

xcaligirl 02-12-2021 07:59 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by boxcarwilly (Post 1900410)
IMOP....too compact to be safe..drivers are more confused than a goat on astroturf.:MOJE_whot: I treat all roundabouts like a single lane rotary and use a turn signal when exiting.

I do the same. I'll never understand the inside lane able to turn right!! I will always think they are set up for more crashes.

Two Bills 02-12-2021 08:02 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by J1ceasar (Post 1900823)
You hit the nail on the head, these roundabouts are way too small to work correctly and the speed of the cars are about 20 miles per hour too fast. I come from Jersey and the random pads are at least 100 or 200 ft across larger. Also it is ridiculous to say stay on the inside or staying on the outside Lane depending on where you get off the only safe way to drive them is to stay on the outside Lane make sure no one is next to you or trying to come in when you're going around. I really wish they would have some lights

Size in the case of roundabout does not matter.
All a roundabout does is regulate the flow of traffic at a junction.
So simple!

Doug Thomas 02-12-2021 08:03 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Surf Daddy (Post 1900844)
I can make it simpler. "Just don't get hit"

That’s my motorcycle mantra, “Just don’t get hit”!
Everything else will be fine!

CFrance 02-12-2021 08:05 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by boxcarwilly (Post 1900410)
IMOP....too compact to be safe..drivers are more confused than a goat on astroturf.:MOJE_whot: I treat all roundabouts like a single lane rotary and use a turn signal when exiting.

If you do that, you are part of the problem. The inside lane is to be used to go 3/4 of the way around from where you entered. Yield to both lanes when entering and never enter beside another car. Check behind/beside you when exiting for people who are treating the roundabout as a single lane.


Here we go again.

rlcooper70 02-12-2021 08:05 AM

If you want safety in the rotaries ... avoid being directly next to and parallel to another car. Watch the wheels of adjacent vehicles - the front wheel turns before the body of the car.

NotGolfer 02-12-2021 08:06 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jayhawk (Post 1900448)
I'll call your Traffic Circle threads and raise you 50 Dog Poops.

Add to that covid and vaxx threads as well....ALL of these have been "talked" to death!!

wbwolf 02-12-2021 08:07 AM

Roundabout
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by boxcarwilly (Post 1900410)
IMOP....too compact to be safe..drivers are more confused than a goat on astroturf.:MOJE_whot: I treat all roundabouts like a single lane rotary and use a turn signal when exiting.

I am with you 100%, do not understand why there are 2 lanes to exit??? I was trained to exit only from the right lane. 😜

CFrance 02-12-2021 08:22 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dewilson58 (Post 1900523)
I'll see you and raise you a Reverse Mortgage.

Reverse Mortgage has a long way to go to catch up to Dog Poop. It's the new kid on the block. :blahblahblah:

Bill1701 02-12-2021 08:48 AM

Having only one lane would work fine on the less used ones, but the traffic on Morse and Buena Vista needs two lanes. One lane would stop the people who try to drive as straight as possible. They enter in the outside lane, but cut to the inside one, and then back to the outside lane to exit.

toeser 02-12-2021 08:50 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by John_W (Post 1900420)
If you did a search, there are probably 10 threads in past that are at least 80 posts each, it's the most discussed topic in history.

Here is a quick lesson, if you follow this you will be more than OK. Just think of a 2 lane roundabout as a 2 lane 4 way stop. If you were making a left turn you would be in the left land (inside lane 3rd exit) and if you were making a right turn you would in the right (outside lane 1st exit). If you were going straight you would be in either lane (2nd exit is straight). There is even a sign before every roundabout showing where each lane can go.

https://www.drivesmartbc.ca/sites/de...rningPaths.jpg

https://i.ytimg.com/vi/8wIoR7fpPJM/hqdefault.jpg

In this diagram, the yellow car at the bottom in the left lane, where can he proceed to? He can go straight using either lane, or go to the third exit using the left lane.


It's not always that simple. Let's say you are entering the Villages on Morse off from #441. When you proceed to the gates after going around the roundabout, those who use the resident gate must be in the right lane and those wishing to use the guest gate must exit from the left lane and pray no one hits the right side of their car.

chrissy2231 02-12-2021 08:51 AM

I hold back and let other car go first or I speed and go first. It works.

Aacosner 02-12-2021 08:52 AM

1 Attachment(s)
Here's a better idea . Let's get some of these installed here -- they're called Magic Roundabouts in England (hopefully my first try at uploading a picture works). This is basically five roundabouts organized in a circle. Watching from the side, the inner ring rotates in the opposite direction of the individual roundabouts or the outer ring. Very efficient, though not for beginner drivers.

OrangeBlossomBaby 02-12-2021 08:54 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by xcaligirl (Post 1900889)
I do the same. I'll never understand the inside lane able to turn right!! I will always think they are set up for more crashes.

The only way you CAN turn - is right. All exits are to your right, once you approach them. Since you're not allowed to turn into the outer lane in the RB while travelling, the only way to exit the RB, once you get to your exit, is to take a right from the inside lane.

OrangeBlossomBaby 02-12-2021 08:58 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by toeser (Post 1900933)
It's not always that simple. Let's say you are entering the Villages on Morse off from #441. When you proceed to the gates after going around the roundabout, those who use the resident gate must be in the right lane and those wishing to use the guest gate must exit from the left lane and pray no one hits the right side of their car.

Well no, actually that isn't true. What is true: visitors MUST use the left lane. Residents MAY use either lane. It still creates confusion and distraction though, if the person ahead of you who came from 3 "exits" away, is already in the inner lane, and is trying to get over to the right lane because he's not a resident.

024engine 02-12-2021 09:01 AM

Everyone that moves to the Villages should be required to take a roundabout driving course. It is explained in your welcome packet, but no one reads it. No right turns from left lanes except on through streets. (Morse and Buena Vista)

Psacc0 02-12-2021 09:04 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by OrangeBlossomBaby (Post 1900735)
After getting over the terror that is "first-time experiencing two-lane roundabouts occupied by a lot of people who might need cataract surgery and younger reflexes" - I realized the fully two-lane roundabouts are entirely manageable as long as you pay attention. And as long as YOUR reflexes are better than the other guy's.

What IS a big problem - is the two-lane roundabouts that exit into one lane exits. Imagine the circle - north, south, east, west...

I'm coming FROM the south. Heading West. If it were a normal intersection it'd be a left turn. But it's not a normal intersection. It's a circle. By the time I get to that exit, it is now a right turn.

But I'm coming from the INSIDE lane, because that's the rule. If you are entering a 2-lane roundabout and you're wanting to go to the "third" exit, you have to enter into the inside lane.

And you now have to make a right turn, from the inside lane, into a single lane where people who are coming from the east, and from the north, also exit.

If you're coming from the south, you won't always even SEE someone heading toward that western exit, if they are coming from the north. Because you are entering while looking to your left. And to your left - is the western exit. You're not looking north. You're looking west. Entering from the south, going in a counter-clockwise position.

So that's where I think roundabouts are horribly flawed. Entering a two-lane roundabout with the intention of exiting into a one-lane exit 3/4 of the way around the circle.

One main reason this legal maneuver would be a problem is because people coming from the east and north would not yield before entering. All traffic, in the roundabout, both lanes, have the right of way. Entering vehicles must yield to all traffic, both lanes.

DOGSAREKEEPERS 02-12-2021 09:08 AM

Originally Posted by John_W View Post If you did a search, there are probably 10 thr
 
Many good suggestions and comments on how to drive in a roundabout.

One thing many people don't do is stay in their lane when they are on a curve.(not just roundabouts)
They let their vehicle drift over the lane line causing either an accident or a frantic reaction from the car in the next lane.
Just as on regular streets many people don't make their turn from a left lane to a left lane or from a right lane to a right lane, they also don't stay in their lane on curves streets.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:31 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Search Engine Optimisation provided by DragonByte SEO v2.0.32 (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2025 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.