Talk of The Villages Florida

Talk of The Villages Florida (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/)
-   The Villages, Florida, General Discussion (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/villages-florida-general-discussion-73/)
-   -   Is it me or 2 lane roundabouts just don't work? (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/villages-florida-general-discussion-73/me-2-lane-roundabouts-just-dont-work-316194/)

dhdallas 02-12-2021 09:12 AM

Old people can't even park correctly much less navigate a roundabout safely. The Villagers should have to drive "Bumper Cars" like at amusement parks (that's what TV is, isn't it?).

dave from deland 02-12-2021 09:41 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Byte1 (Post 1900439)
I've been saying all along that roundabouts in The Villages, with folks that have never seen them before and are inherently bad drivers anyway, should be single lane. You can explain the proper procedure of maneuvering through them all you want, but the simple point is that there is not a given hour of the day, of the year, decade, etc. that you won't find that 90% of the operators handle a roundabout incorrectly.

Single lane is the only solution. Instruction fails miserably.

Do not pass another vehicle while in the two lane roundabout which eliminates a lot of problems.

sloanst 02-12-2021 09:45 AM

The signs posted before entering a round-about show how it should be navigated. The outside lane is limited to 2 exits. You can exit the circle at the first exit or the 2nd from the outside lane but you can never travel to the 3rd exit. The inside lane can exit at the 2nd and 3rd exits. Stay in the same (inside) lane to exit the 2nd exit. To exit the at the 3rd, change from the inside lane to the outside lane after passing the 2nd exit IF the exit is only one lane, otherwise stay in the inside lane.

If you travel more than 2 exits in the outside lane and get into an accident, be prepared to pay the ticket and all other accident costs.

bobnyce 02-12-2021 10:23 AM

Seems to me ridiculous to make a turn from the center lane. Anyone over 60 knows that is a mistake anywhere you drive to make a right turn from the left lane. Yet, here in Florida that is the suggested method. Why not just continue around the roundabout until you can merge into the right lane and then turn right? Crossing lanes to make a turn was always a no-no. I simply do not understand the concept. For example, those idiots who cut you off on the interstate to make a right onto an exit ramp! Roundabouts are very similar.

rwfisher1969 02-12-2021 10:25 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jayhawk (Post 1900448)
I'll call your Traffic Circle threads and raise you 50 Dog Poops.

Costco and Trader Joe's threads beats them all!

Byte1 02-12-2021 10:27 AM

Funny how so many say, you can't make a right turn from the left lane unless you are going straight or turning left. When going around a circle, there is ONLY right turns. If you are in the center lane (left lane) you are allowed to make a right turn anytime after the first two(2) exits. Fine, but if some one finds that they are in the right lane and discover that they need to go one more exit or even two more than the original two allotted when entering the circle, they can still turn right. You have to. You are not going to say "oh my, I need to go to the third exit, therefore I need to move out of my right lane to the center so that I can turn right at the next exit. Folks on the inside CAN turn right onto the left lane on the turn only, but anyone that has just entered the circle from the previous entrance, wishing to go to the second exit can easily Tbone them if the one on the left is not observant enough to realize that the car in the right lane is not turning with them. Confusing? Yep and that is why two lane roundabouts are bad for at least 50% of The Villagers driving here. If traffic is busy, just stay in the right lane no matter which exit. You will be safe.

Byte1 02-12-2021 11:08 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by rwfisher1969 (Post 1901033)
Costco and Trader Joe's threads beats them all!

Nope, right now it's "masks."

petiteone 02-12-2021 11:37 AM

The problem is the people who are navigating correctly in the inside lane to exit 3/4 around will often get hit by people entering the turnaround in the outside lane and will broadside them. Everyone takes the round-a-bouts too fast. I've lived here for since 2011 and still think I'm safer staying in the outside lane no mater where I'm exiting especially when there's a lot of traffic.

Joeint 02-12-2021 11:52 AM

If you did a search, there are probably 10 threads in past that are at least 80 posts each, it's the most discussed topic in history.
I'll call your Traffic Circle threads and raise you 50 Dog Poops.


I'll call your dog poop and raise you 20 executive course condition threads...

Curtisbwp 02-12-2021 11:55 AM

The roundabouts are NOT confusing it is the driver that is confused. Being from Boston there roteries every where.

jimjamuser 02-12-2021 12:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by golfing eagles (Post 1900424)
All true, and add
***watch out for drivers going the wrong way in the RB
***watch out for cyclists in a pack of 20 blowing through the yield sign as if they were one entity
***beware non-street legal golf carts cutting across lanes in front of you
***beware cars going 270 around the RB in the outer lane, and cars exiting at 90 from the inner lane
***Be especially concerned if a car with out of state handicapped plates is approaching the entrance to the RB
***and my favorite, beware the driver who just stops dead in the middle of a RB, usually just far enough ahead that you can't see her around the circle

Enjoy your drive today!:1rotfl::1rotfl::1rotfl:

Probably was not NICE to say "HER" in that last statement, at least not politically correct, or even a "good" joke. "Her" implies that women are stupid and worse drivers than men, which insurance statistics say is NOT true. If it was intended as a JOKE that is not TOO terrible and misogynistic - but it is still a too -old joke and ceased to be funny after 1950!

jimjamuser 02-12-2021 12:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by billethkid (Post 1900426)
Just assume the other drivers will not stop, cut into your lane, cut you off or hit you and you will be fine!!
:duck:

Just buy a Hummer and add extra bumpers to the front, back, and both sides. No problem, then you are good to go!

jimjamuser 02-12-2021 12:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Byte1 (Post 1900439)
I've been saying all along that roundabouts in The Villages, with folks that have never seen them before and are inherently bad drivers anyway, should be single lane. You can explain the proper procedure of maneuvering through them all you want, but the simple point is that there is not a given hour of the day, of the year, decade, etc. that you won't find that 90% of the operators handle a roundabout incorrectly.

Single lane is the only solution. Instruction fails miserably.

I agree with that - and I rarely agree with poster Mr. B. The world truly IS full of surprises.

golfing eagles 02-12-2021 12:57 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by xcaligirl (Post 1900889)
I do the same. I'll never understand the inside lane able to turn right!! I will always think they are set up for more crashes.

That's only because you don't understand. The inner lane is NOT making a right turn from the left lane

clgill 02-12-2021 01:12 PM

2 lane roundabouts
 
Most states have 2 roundabout lanes (like we do) so that fire trucks, semi's, motor homes, etc. can get through the roundabout easily using both inner and outer lanes. Most states raise the inner lane surface approximately an inch and use bricks that have a rougher surface so cars naturally stay off the inner lane. That way everyone in the roundabout is in single file so there is no need for complemented and confusing instructions. It's that easy folks! I would imagine The Villages will retrofit all roundabouts to conform with this method thus eliminating the majority of roundabout accidents that occur on a daily basis. To make it further uncomplicated (for those that need it) a sign reading 'INNER LANE FOR COMMERCIAL VEHICLES ONLY' could be placed at each entrance to the roundabout, although that's not needed in most states.

golfing eagles 02-12-2021 01:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jimjamuser (Post 1901103)
Probably was not NICE to say "HER" in that last statement, at least not politically correct, or even a "good" joke. "Her" implies that women are stupid and worse drivers than men, which insurance statistics say is NOT true. If it was intended as a JOKE that is not TOO terrible and misogynistic - but it is still a too -old joke and ceased to be funny after 1950!

Too bad. Get a life!

Bill14564 02-12-2021 01:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by clgill (Post 1901155)
Most states have 2 roundabout lanes (like we do) so that fire trucks, semi's, motor homes, etc. can get through the roundabout easily using both inner and outer lanes. Most states raise the inner lane surface approximately an inch and use bricks that have a rougher surface so cars naturally stay off the inner lane. That way everyone in the roundabout is in single file so there is no need for complemented and confusing instructions. It's that easy folks! I would imagine The Villages will retrofit all roundabouts to conform with this method thus eliminating the majority of roundabout accidents that occur on a daily basis. To make it further uncomplicated (for those that need it) a sign reading 'INNER LANE FOR COMMERCIAL VEHICLES ONLY' could be placed at each entrance to the roundabout, although that's not needed in most states.

Seriously? There are signs at the roundabouts now that provide perfect instructions on how to navigate them safely. This thread (and I take it there are several others) exist because some drivers choose to ignore those signs.

Also, I can't see turning a two lane circle into a one lane circle by changing the surface of the inside lane and then adding a sign that references a lane that visually doesn't exist as a way to uncomplicate anything.

How many roundabout accidents happen on a daily basis? Granted, I don't visit many roundabouts each day, but in over five months of living here I have seen exactly zero accidents; I would have expected to see at least one.

Leave the two-lane circles alone and spend time on driver training. Driver training will be less costly, will not create bottlenecks to increase congestion, and will benefit the drivers when they encounter circles elsewhere.

Topspinmo 02-12-2021 02:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Regor (Post 1900582)
You're thinking like it's okay to take a right from the left lane is what causes accidents. The inner lane is not the "straight" lane. That would ONLY work if the right lane entering the roundabout HAD to take the first exit. They don't have to take the 1st exit.


They have to take the first or second exit. Regardless you enter in the outside right lane you are commenting to turn at the first or second exit. It you don’t you better be yielding at the second exit. If you hit car in the left lane going STRAIGHT through at second exit you will be at fault.

OrangeBlossomBaby 02-12-2021 02:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Psacc0 (Post 1900952)
One main reason this legal maneuver would be a problem is because people coming from the east and north would not yield before entering. All traffic, in the roundabout, both lanes, have the right of way. Entering vehicles must yield to all traffic, both lanes.

You can't always SEE traffic in both lanes. Traffic directly across from you is obscured by trees. You have no idea that they're even there, until you've already entered the circle and they come around behind you.

OrangeBlossomBaby 02-12-2021 03:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by golfing eagles (Post 1901142)
That's only because you don't understand. The inner lane is NOT making a right turn from the left lane

Yes, you are. If you are in the inside lane of a 2-lane roundabout, then you are in the LEFT lane. You are LEFT of the outside lane, of a roundabout that only has two lanes. Only one can be the left one, and only one can be the right one. The inside lane in a roundabout that goes counter-clockwise, is a LEFT lane.

If you are exiting the roundabout, no matter where that exit is when you get to it - you are exiting to your RIGHT. You -cannot- exit to the left. You're already left. Any further left, and you will be in the MIDDLE of the roundabout, and not in any lane at all.

golfing eagles 02-12-2021 04:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by OrangeBlossomBaby (Post 1901210)
Yes, you are. If you are in the inside lane of a 2-lane roundabout, then you are in the LEFT lane. You are LEFT of the outside lane, of a roundabout that only has two lanes. Only one can be the left one, and only one can be the right one. The inside lane in a roundabout that goes counter-clockwise, is a LEFT lane.

If you are exiting the roundabout, no matter where that exit is when you get to it - you are exiting to your RIGHT. You -cannot- exit to the left. You're already left. Any further left, and you will be in the MIDDLE of the roundabout, and not in any lane at all.

NO, YOU'RE NOT. Of course you can't exit left, that's why you are NOT making a right turn from a left lane when you choose to go straight through a RB in the inner lane. DOH!!! Maybe it would help you, and all the others that don't understand, to not think of it as a left lane, just an inside lane

stebooo 02-12-2021 05:42 PM

The only issue I have is if I am taking the second exit I have to fear a car in the right lane who isn't in the right lane. I have to either slow down or speed up and signal. I'm on but most aren't. Not sure our generation will ever get it right.

OrangeBlossomBaby 02-12-2021 05:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by golfing eagles (Post 1901230)
NO, YOU'RE NOT. Of course you can't exit left, that's why you are NOT making a right turn from a left lane when you choose to go straight through a RB in the inner lane. DOH!!! Maybe it would help you, and all the others that don't understand, to not think of it as a left lane, just an inside lane

Here's a little experiment for you:

Look at an old fashioned watch. See how the hands connect in the middle. Now change the time to exactly 6 o'clock.

Look at those hands. They go straight up and down. Or, if you were in a roundabout, straight north and south. Or straight east and west.

Notice there is no way to go STRAIGHT through that clock, from south to north, without running into the center of the clock where the two hands meet.

If that were a traffic circle, and you were going STRAIGHT through the roundabout, you would do the same thing with your car. I can assure you, the results would be unpleasant.

No, in order to move your finger around counter-clockwise from "near-center" (the inside lane), you go around, UNTIL you see the 12 o'clock coming up on your...what is that called? Oh yeah. On your right. When you see that 12 o'clock number coming up on your right, you veer away from the counter-clockwise movement, and instead, go to your RIGHT.

If you don't go to your right, you will simply continue going around in circles, endlessly, until you run out of gas or get a blister on your finger (depending on whether you're driving a car or moving your finger around a watch face).

You are physically, literally, moving RIGHT when you exit out of a traffic circle. That is what you are doing with your hands on the wheel, it's what your car is doing, and that's why you're supposed to put on your RIGHT turn signal when you exit.

Bogie Shooter 02-12-2021 06:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by clgill (Post 1901155)
Most states have 2 roundabout lanes (like we do) so that fire trucks, semi's, motor homes, etc. can get through the roundabout easily using both inner and outer lanes. Most states raise the inner lane surface approximately an inch and use bricks that have a rougher surface so cars naturally stay off the inner lane. That way everyone in the roundabout is in single file so there is no need for complemented and confusing instructions. It's that easy folks! I would imagine The Villages will retrofit all roundabouts to conform with this method thus eliminating the majority of roundabout accidents that occur on a daily basis. To make it further uncomplicated (for those that need it) a sign reading 'INNER LANE FOR COMMERCIAL VEHICLES ONLY' could be placed at each entrance to the roundabout, although that's not needed in most states.

Accidents on a daily basis,,,,I think not. More accidents at intersections.
Darn it I told myself not to post on anymore roundabout threads.

Bill14564 02-12-2021 06:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by OrangeBlossomBaby (Post 1901270)
Here's a little experiment for you:

Look at an old fashioned watch. See how the hands connect in the middle. Now change the time to exactly 6 o'clock.

Look at those hands. They go straight up and down. Or, if you were in a roundabout, straight north and south. Or straight east and west.

Notice there is no way to go STRAIGHT through that clock, from south to north, without running into the center of the clock where the two hands meet.

If that were a traffic circle, and you were going STRAIGHT through the roundabout, you would do the same thing with your car. I can assure you, the results would be unpleasant.

No, in order to move your finger around counter-clockwise from "near-center" (the inside lane), you go around, UNTIL you see the 12 o'clock coming up on your...what is that called? Oh yeah. On your right. When you see that 12 o'clock number coming up on your right, you veer away from the counter-clockwise movement, and instead, go to your RIGHT.

If you don't go to your right, you will simply continue going around in circles, endlessly, until you run out of gas or get a blister on your finger (depending on whether you're driving a car or moving your finger around a watch face).

You are physically, literally, moving RIGHT when you exit out of a traffic circle. That is what you are doing with your hands on the wheel, it's what your car is doing, and that's why you're supposed to put on your RIGHT turn signal when you exit.

Or you could think about the center of the circle like a box in the road - you steer around the box in order to continue going straight.

golfing eagles 02-12-2021 06:14 PM

1 Attachment(s)
Quote:

Originally Posted by OrangeBlossomBaby (Post 1901270)
Here's a little experiment for you:

Look at an old fashioned watch. See how the hands connect in the middle. Now change the time to exactly 6 o'clock.

Look at those hands. They go straight up and down. Or, if you were in a roundabout, straight north and south. Or straight east and west.

Notice there is no way to go STRAIGHT through that clock, from south to north, without running into the center of the clock where the two hands meet.

If that were a traffic circle, and you were going STRAIGHT through the roundabout, you would do the same thing with your car. I can assure you, the results would be unpleasant.

No, in order to move your finger around counter-clockwise from "near-center" (the inside lane), you go around, UNTIL you see the 12 o'clock coming up on your...what is that called? Oh yeah. On your right. When you see that 12 o'clock number coming up on your right, you veer away from the counter-clockwise movement, and instead, go to your RIGHT.

If you don't go to your right, you will simply continue going around in circles, endlessly, until you run out of gas or get a blister on your finger (depending on whether you're driving a car or moving your finger around a watch face).

You are physically, literally, moving RIGHT when you exit out of a traffic circle. That is what you are doing with your hands on the wheel, it's what your car is doing, and that's why you're supposed to put on your RIGHT turn signal when you exit.

Let me try to educate you a different way:

It's a CIRCLE, with traffic continually moving around. It is NOT a traditional intersection with a left lane and a right lane. You are NOT making a "right" turn, EVER. You are exiting right, if you prefer that terminology. If it were an intersection of two 4 lane roads, you would go left from the left lane, right from the right lane, and straight from EITHER lane. That is exactly what happens in the RB, except the left turn is a 270 degree "travel" through the RB, a right turn is a 90 degree travel, and straight is 180 degrees. When you use the inner lane to go straight, YOU ARE NOT TURNING RIGHT.

Also, consider this. Ever travel of the turnpike to Orlando? Many "exits" are 2 lane exits, where the right lane MUST exit and the 2nd from the right lane MAY exit. If you view that situation in isolation, your premise is that the car in the inner/left exit lane is making a right turn from the left lane. Don't argue, it's EXACTLY the same thing as the RBs. To take it further, if there is an entrance lane just before the exit, those cars that are coming into the turnpike MUST YIELD to traffic in BOTH exit lanes, just like in a RB

Get it now??????

golfing eagles 02-12-2021 10:06 PM

This thread is amazing. Something as simple as a traffic circle has people confused and befuddled. Two posters, whom I often disagree with, still don't get it. They are NOT dumb, I respect them both as highly intelligent and articulate (although a bit misguided:1rotfl::1rotfl::1rotfl:) What is it about these RBs?

Topspinmo 02-12-2021 11:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Byte1 (Post 1900439)
I've been saying all along that roundabouts in The Villages, with folks that have never seen them before and are inherently bad drivers anyway, should be single lane. You can explain the proper procedure of maneuvering through them all you want, but the simple point is that there is not a given hour of the day, of the year, decade, etc. that you won't find that 90% of the operators handle a roundabout incorrectly.

Single lane is the only solution. Instruction fails miserably.


Too much traffic for single lane. If that was the solution all roads should be single two lane roads. Just imagine how long it would take to go down 441 or 75.

Marty94 02-13-2021 12:09 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Papa_lecki (Post 1900552)
What if you’re discussing Reverse Mortgages, wearing a mask, in a round about and your dog poops?

Then get out your white cross and pray that you aren’t headed to Traders Joe’s, Cosco or an Executive Golf Course.

Abner50 02-13-2021 01:53 AM

When I taught my kids to drive I cautioned them to drive as if every other driver was out to kill them. Watch them like a hawk.
That is the best way to go through the roundabouts.

swooner 02-13-2021 06:15 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by boxcarwilly (Post 1900410)
IMOP....too compact to be safe..drivers are more confused than a goat on astroturf.:MOJE_whot: I treat all roundabouts like a single lane rotary and use a turn signal when exiting.

It's the dumb drivers, not the roundabouts.

golfing eagles 02-13-2021 06:37 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by swooner (Post 1901377)
It's the dumb drivers, not the roundabouts.

:bigbow::bigbow::bigbow:

rjn5656 02-13-2021 07:48 AM

I don't have a problem with them. Just follow the rules and everyone will be ok. But be cautious for others .

golfing eagles 02-13-2021 10:00 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by rjn5656 (Post 1901450)
I don't have a problem with them. Just follow the rules and everyone will be ok. But be cautious for others .

IF ONLY that was what actually happens.........

tophcfa 02-13-2021 10:05 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by boxcarwilly (Post 1900410)
IMOP....too compact to be safe..drivers are more confused than a goat on astroturf.:MOJE_whot: I treat all roundabouts like a single lane rotary and use a turn signal when exiting.

Roundabouts are only as safe as the worst driver in the roundabout. If the GOAT on astroturf is TB12, there is no confusion.

OrangeBlossomBaby 02-13-2021 10:07 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by rjn5656 (Post 1901450)
I don't have a problem with them. Just follow the rules and everyone will be ok. But be cautious for others .

It's not that bad when it's 2 lanes exiting onto 2 lanes, or 1 lane exiting onto 1 lane. But when it's 2 lanes exiting onto 1 lane it's confusing, dangerous, and a little scary.

ESPECIALLY when it's 2 lanes exiting onto 1 lane PLUS a golf cart path slicing right at that spot, AND the golf cart path is somewhat obscured by a wall, before everyone gets to that point.

golfing eagles 02-13-2021 10:14 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by OrangeBlossomBaby (Post 1901567)
It's not that bad when it's 2 lanes exiting onto 2 lanes, or 1 lane exiting onto 1 lane. But when it's 2 lanes exiting onto 1 lane it's confusing, dangerous, and a little scary.

ESPECIALLY when it's 2 lanes exiting onto 1 lane PLUS a golf cart path slicing right at that spot, AND the golf cart path is somewhat obscured by a wall, before everyone gets to that point.

All true

shut the front door 02-13-2021 10:51 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by boxcarwilly (Post 1900410)
IMOP....too compact to be safe..drivers are more confused than a goat on astroturf.:MOJE_whot: I treat all roundabouts like a single lane rotary and use a turn signal when exiting.

You are doing it wrong and you are the problem, not the solution.

mgkw1 02-13-2021 11:17 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by boxcarwilly (Post 1900410)
IMOP....too compact to be safe..drivers are more confused than a goat on astroturf.:MOJE_whot: I treat all roundabouts like a single lane rotary and use a turn signal when exiting.

You must be from the north. We all learned how to drive a rotary and it is one lane one car. Whoever is in the circle has the right of way otherwise you wait. Unless you are making an immediate right and think you an beat the car coming around the corner. I see at least one accident a week on Morse Blvd and these poorly planned circles. A true round about is one lane off set the the right designed to slow down traffic at an intersection.

MFNOWLIN52 02-13-2021 03:05 PM

So do I!


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:10 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Search Engine Optimisation provided by DragonByte SEO v2.0.32 (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2025 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.