American Idol?

[lasvegas]

I cannot believe it, sure did want`Adam to win.

[Shirleevee]

Rod Stewart looked so frail to me. He is one of my all time favorites.

[Karen83]

I was rooting for Kris or Danny all the way. :pepper2: Adam is very talented, but was way too polished for an amatuer and I thought the premise of the show was to find a diamond in the rough, with no previous professional experience.

Adam will go on to greater things for sure and it was so nice to see the underdog win. I just wanted to jump through the TV and give Kris a big ole hug!

The judges certainly did all they could to ensure Adam's win, which may have hurt him in the end.

[MinnieM]

Adam is in a better position by not winning. He is only obligated to American Idol until the tour is over. Adam will still be a big star on his terms not by corporate American Idol. I can't wait to buy his cd's.

MinnieM

[barb1191]

I think he was as surprised as I was. What was up with Rod Stewart?

Rod Stuart looked "tipsy" to me.

I'm so pleased that Kris won. He's so talented with playing piano, guitar and a beautiful voice. He will go a long way especially with his personality that his ego has not taken over; he's a real down-to-earth talent; a delight.

Adam is quite a performer and he will go a long way as most do that may not take first prize. I do think that he outdid himself with the kinky ways of his personality as well as the screaming that drowns out the tune, but I guess that's this generation's "thing."

I noticed that poo-face Simon didn't stand up and applaud when the winner was announced. Simon felt that Adam was a shoe-in, but they'll still make big bucks on such a talented group this year.

I recorded the show and thank goodness as I not only fast forwarded thru the commercials, but also the guests like "KISS" et al. Not my genre. Yuk

[LELANDJANE]

I'm very happy for Kris. Every song he sang was different and showed different sides of his musical talents. Did you notice that Adam had the same formula for every song-dramatic beginning-screaming middle-big ending. I'm sure he will find his place in the music world.


I thought Kris would win tonight because: Danny's fans probably would have voted for Kris; Kris's fan base was said to be young teenage girls who could lie in bed and continue to try to vote for hours while I gave up after about 5 minutes; the pics of Adam performing in drag were all over the internet this week; I believe there was a backlash against Simon's proclamation week after week that Adam was the best!

Anyway, the Idol concerts will be good this Summer and I hope they all do well.

[senior citizen]

I was rooting for Kris or Danny all the way. :pepper2: Adam is very talented, but was way too polished for an amatuer and I thought the premise of the show was to find a diamond in the rough, with no previous professional experience.

Adam will go on to greater things for sure and it was so nice to see the underdog win. I just wanted to jump through the TV and give Kris a big ole hug!

The judges certainly did all they could to ensure Adam's win, which may have hurt him in the end.

I couldn't have said it better. You are right on target. Personally, I believe Kris also got Danny's overflow vote, another wholesome, humble, all American guy.

When visiting with our grandchildren this past weekend, they all were rooting for Kris Allen to win......while acknowledging Adam was awesome as well.

Adam , although extremely talented with probably the better voice and stage presence is very very experienced. I've read that he relocated from his hometown of San Diego at age 18 to pursue his theatrical music career in Hollywood, living in West Hollywood. With 10 years experience (not counting his schooling in a professional music school) he's no amatuer in my book; although my husband does say the show isn't necessarily for amatuers.

Adam will have no problems at all succeeding in life.......but it was indeed nice to see the "dark horse" win. He seemed shocked by it all at the end.
Both exhibited very good sportsmanship. Personally, I think Adam's drama queen persona and over the top makeup (although understandable in a stage musical) might have cost him some votes.......at least in my husband's opinion.

But, then what do we know, living in Vermont. In today's daily newspaper, "Dear Abby" column has the cutest letters from readers of not well known states and the strangest queries they get.

The people from Rutland, Vermont who honeymooned in Alaska, on a cruise ship, were asked where they were from.

When they replied, "Vermont", they were then asked what state it was in:
Maine or Massachusetts?

They replied politely, "Vermont is the 14th state".

Other people wrote that visitors didn't know English was spoken in Hawaii nor which side of the road people drove on, etc., etc. plus where could they exchange their money?

A bank teller in Florida, when asked to wire some money to Minnesota, asked if it was in the United States. Go figure.

Other people didn't know upstate New York was a state or that Delaware was a state. Sorry, off track from Kris and Adam.....but it was cute and makes one wonder whatever happened to geography in school.

I am very happy that Kris won. We have followed Idol since it's conception.
Love the auditions in the beginning. They get us through a long cold winter.

[JeanneBeannie]

I really enjoyed the show last night. I am happy for both Kris and Adam. They are both great, they will both have great futures ahead of them. I had tears in my eyes (happy tears lol) when Kris was singing with Keith Urban! I cant even imagine the excitement he must have been feeling at that moment. A moment he will never forget I am sure, they looked like they were having so much fun singing together! :pepper2:

[chelsea24]

Adam is in a better position by not winning. He is only obligated to American Idol until the tour is over. Adam will still be a big star on his terms not by corporate American Idol. I can't wait to buy his cd's.

MinnieM

I absolutely agree! Adam is worldwide superstar talent, that's for sure. I know they will both have phenomenal careers. But, I don't think Kris will have staying power. He's too soft and forgettable for me.

Adam is still :eclipsee_gold_cup:

[sschuler1]

I agree with Chels! This is like when Clay Aiken didn't win, but then went on to be the bigger star. If this was a true singing competition and not a popularity contest, Adam would have won hands down! :bowdown::bowdown::bowdown:

[arabianhorse59]

You could have knocked me over with a feather when Kris won. I was SOOO pulling for Adam. :cus: Adam didn't have a chance with all the "tweeners" sitting in their Hannah Montana pajamas, in their rooms filled with Jonas Brothers posters, texting votes for 4 hours to Kris. It had nothing to do with singing ability...it was all about "Oh, he's so cute". Granted, Kris can sing but he's not the star Adam is!

[GatorFan]

Will turn out the same way. Adam will become the Star, make millions. A year from now, record label will drop him like they have dropped Reuben. He best invest that $1,000,000 he won because he will not make much more.

Adam is a Star and will continue to grow and make lots of money.

[LELANDJANE]

I guess we'll have to wait and see. Remember, when you're listening to a CD you don't see the "guyliner" and drama. I think that'll make a big difference in Adam's career.

[JohnN]

I'm glad Kris won, Adam is/was getting a bit too full of himself.

[macgolfnut]

I had a bad feeling that Kris would win because more teeny boppers could relate to Kris, but to me he is totally forgetable. Adam continually show his versatility to do both soft ballads and hard rock. What a range! He has the most talent I have witnessed in the history of the show. I just don't think Kris has anything "special." A cute face and being a nice guy is just not enough. :cus:

[Barefoot]

Will turn out the same way. Adam will become the Star, make millions. A year from now, record label will drop him like they have dropped Reuben. He best invest that $1,000,000 he won because he will not make much more.

The winner of American Idol wins a million dollars? :shocked: I didn't know that.

[graciegirl]

I must be the only living breathing soul who hasn't watched any of the eight seasons.

I am certainly watching next year.

[nONIE]

No Gracie, Your not! LOL

[Hawkwind]

The winner of American Idol wins a million dollars? :shocked: I didn't know that.

That is also news to me. I knew that they rceived a record contract with a top recording producer and company but this is the first I ever heard of the 1 mil.

[Taltarzac]

That is also news to me. I knew that they rceived a record contract with a top recording producer and company but this is the first I ever heard of the 1 mil.

It's the AI winner's record contract which is worth $1 million. He/
she does not get a check for $1 million like Survivor.

[Taltarzac]

http://www.rollingstone.com/rockdaily/index.php/2009/05/27/att-accused-of-aiding-kris-allens-american-idol-victory/

[Taltarzac]

Does Simon seem like he is not critical enough with this season's AI wanna-bes?

There are only one or two contestants this season whom I would consider buying recoordings from -- Lee Dewyze and Crystal Bowersox.

[bkcunningham1]

This is the first season of Idol I have ever watched. I have to agree with Taltarzac about Lee Dewyze and Crystal Bowersox. Watching tonight (Tuesday) and wow...Crystal Bowersox blew me away...I just wished she'd clean-up. Sorry, those dreadlocks just look nasty to me. Lee Dewyze has an amazing voice and seems to be getting his confidence.

[Barefoot]

This is the first season of Idol I have ever watched. I have to agree with Taltarzac about Lee Dewyze and Crystal Bowersox. Watching tonight (Tuesday) and wow...Crystal Bowersox blew me away...I just wished she'd clean-up. Sorry, those dreadlocks just look nasty to me. Lee Dewyze has an amazing voice and seems to be getting his confidence.

I think Tim Urban is next to be eliminated. I agree that Bowersox and Deyze will be two of the finalists.

[bkcunningham1]

Yeah, Tim Urban is not going to make it much further. I missed Casey James' performance tonight. How'd he do?

[RichieLion]

I think Tim is going to squeak by again and that it will be either Didi or Katy that sings the show out tomorrow.
Andy is the comeback kid for tonight. Siobhan had a surprising horrid night and Andy was boring and everyone else did real well. Lee was the by far the standout performance tonight.

[barb1191]

It seems to me than none of the contestants are being taught to take over the stage, connect with the audience (sing directly to the audience) and the song choices are terrible.

I do believe that it shows the absence of Paula Abdul as a choreographer who obviously was involved in teaching the contestants how to dance and take over the stage. You don't see any of them moving around and showing emotions or connections with the audience or with the songs.

I would love to see them have the contestants choose a few songs from the 60's and 70's when songs could be understood, had a story, along with a tempo and tune, rather than the repititous words in these new songs with no tempo at all. B O R I N G.

Songs like Sinatra's, Bobby Darren (Mac The Knife), Ella Fitzgerald, and so many more greats in that era.

I love music, but can't stand the yelling and belting out the same lines over and over.

[chelsea24]

I thought that Didi was, by far, the worst performance of the night and quite frankly, I'm sick of her crying. This girl has had issues from day one. I loved Lee and Casey. I sooooooooooo wish Tim Urban would go home!!! I call him Monkey Hair Boy. Does anyone remember The Monkeys???? He could step right in. But I'm sure millions of 10 year old girls are voting for him like crazy.

I also like Crystal and Siobhan (even though she had a bad night.

But, frankly I wouldn't buy a ticket to see any one of this year's contestants.

[Barefoot]

I would love to see them have the contestants choose a few songs from the 60's and 70's when songs could be understood, had a story, along with a tempo and tune, rather than the repititous words in these new songs with no tempo at all. B O R I N G. Songs like Sinatra's, Bobby Darren (Mac The Knife), Ella Fitzgerald, and so many more greats in that era.

Barb, LOL. I bet when you were growing up listening to music from the 60s and 70s, especially Elvis, your parents were saying "turn that noise off".

I feel the same way that you do about some of the "mindless" modern music. However American Idol caters to teenagers. If they started singing Ella Fitzgerald and Mac The Knife, you'd hear the sound of a million of teenagers sighing in disgust! :yuck:

[Taltarzac]

I think Tim is going to squeak by again and that it will be either Didi or Katy that sings the show out tomorrow.
Andy is the comeback kid for tonight. Siobhan had a surprising horrid night and Andy was boring and everyone else did real well. Lee was the by far the standout performance tonight.

...though I only watched the first hour of American Idol last night and missed seeing half or so of the contestants. Tim Urban I expect will be in the bottom three again though along with Katie Stevens.

[Taltarzac]

I expect that Tim Urban will squeak by again and make it to the Top 8. Katie Stevens sounded really good last night and hopefully will get out from the Bottom Three. If not her in the Bottom Three it is kind of hard to guess who might else be in it??

Aaron Kelly?

Andrew Garcia perhaps leaving tonight??

See Tim Urban, Andrew Garcia and Katie Stevens in the bottom three seats with Stevens getting out from Bottom two face-off with Ryan Seacrest.

[Barefoot]

I expect that Tim Urban will squeak by again and make it to the Top 8. Katie Stevens sounded really good last night and hopefully will get out from the Bottom Three. If not her in the Bottom Three it is kind of hard to guess who might else be in it??

Aaron Kelly?

Andrew Garcia perhaps leaving tonight??

See Tim Urban, Andrew Garcia and Katie Stevens in the bottom three seats with Stevens getting out from Bottom two face-off with Ryan Seacrest.

I think it may be Garcia leaving tonight. I find him quite boring.

Speaking of boring, how about Kate Gosselin on Dancing with the Stars? Whoops, off topic.

Bowersox and Casey James definitely look like finalists to me. I like Lee Dewyze and I thought that the fact that he used a bagpipe player was cute. He lacks confidence though. And he is best friends with Garcia. So if Garcia gets voted off, that might really demoralize Dewyze.

[Taltarzac]

He has been one of the contestants I like the most in this Season's competition.

[barb1191]

He has been one of the contestants I like the most in this Season's competition.

I agree, Tal....He's been a fav of mine as well and seems to be the only one out of the group that actually connects with the audience......b

[BritParrothead]

We have been watching this all season. First time for us. We get it 24 hours after USA, so I try not to read any posts regarding the show.
Our favourites from the start are Christal Bowersox and Big Mike, least favourite, the girl who screams her last notes, (awful!!)
I hope big mike gets through, he did pick the wrong song this time :cry:

[Taltarzac]

Hopefully, enough people voted for Big Mike this week to keep him around a few more weeks.

[escapequeen]

I like Crystal Bowersox best, then Lee, then Mike.

[Taltarzac]

I like Crystal Bowersox best, then Lee, then Mike.

I agree.

[Barefoot]

I like Crystal Bowersox best, then Lee, then Mike.

I like Crystal best and then Lee Dewyze. I find Big Mike boring and I'm surprised the judges used their one save for him. I like looking at Casey James.

I think Garcia is on his way out for sure.

I thought Adam Lambert did a great job Tuesday night. There is a guy with lots of self confidence.

[BritParrothead]

We watched tonight, and honestly, we did not know who Adam Lambert was! Did not like him. :icon_bored: Sorry!
Again, Crystal , and Big Mike were the best :) :)
Looking forward to Thursday night.

[Barefoot]

We watched tonight, and honestly, we did not know who Adam Lambert was! Did not like him. :icon_bored: Sorry!
Again, Crystal , and Big Mike were the best :) :)
Looking forward to Thursday night.

I used to be a big Adam Lambert fan. But then he ridiculed Susan Boyle's top-selling CD, which outsold Adam's CD a trillion to one. Sour grapes. I am still fascinated by Adam's stage presence and his personal self-confidence.

I know that someone has to be eliminated every week. That is what the show is all about. I think last night's eliminations were justified. But it is very difficult to see the sadness of the contestants, both those eliminated and those remaining. I think the courage that the eliminate contestant shows by singing a last song is amazing.

And off topic, can you believe that Kate Gosselin is still a contestant on Dancing, and hasn't been eliminated?

[Taltarzac]

See Aaron Kelly, Big Mike, and maybe even Crystal Bowersox in the bottom three tonight. With the youngest -- Aaron--leaving AI.

[NJblue]

Unfortunately, I think Krystal gave what may be perceived as being the weakest performance last night. However, it would be a shame if she were voted out since she has consistently had at least one of the top three performances throughout the competition. It would be a shame to have one poor performance/song selection ruin her chances. Perhaps the way the competiton works is that each performer acquires their own loyal fan base who will overlook one iffy performance. (That certainly seemed to be the case for Tim Urban whose fan base overlooked a multitude of poor performances.)

[Bonny]

I think everyone did a great job last night. I don't think Crystal was bad, it's just not the type of song she's been doing. She has an awesome voice & great control over it. I would doubt she would be in the bottom three. But, no matter what happens, that girl's going to have an awesome future. I definitely think it was Casey's best night !

[LELANDJANE]

I thought, as a whole, the performances last night were the best of the season. It was fun watching Shania Twain being so moved by the performances of her songs. I have a feeling we might be down to one girl after tonight. Sioban is beginning to feel very one dimensional in her performances, a fact that even her cute, eccentric style can't continue to cover. I think young Aaron is growing weekly in confidence and style. It's becoming better than I thought this season was going to be.

[sschuler1]

I think you are right Lelandjane, Sioban is getting very annoying! Some of her high notes are literally screamed!!!!! I really didn't like her performance last night at all! I know the judges didn't like Krystal's performance last night, but I really thought it was good! Aaron is gonna have a very bright career ahead of him, because he is only going to continue to improve and grow. He is a lump of clay that can be molded as he learns who he is as an artist. Someone like Casey who is already established in his style, you aren't going to see much growth once he gets out there in the real world. I really like Aaron, and I think his "cuteness" factor will save him tonight. I think the bottom three will be : Sioban, Lee and Mike.........with hopefully Sioban leaving!

[Bonny]

I think you are right Lelandjane, Sioban is getting very annoying! Some of her high notes are literally screamed!!!!! I really didn't like her performance last night at all! I know the judges didn't like Krystal's performance last night, but I really thought it was good! Aaron is gonna have a very bright career ahead of him, because he is only going to continue to improve and grow. He is a lump of clay that can be molded as he learns who he is as an artist. Someone like Casey who is already established in his style, you aren't going to see much growth once he gets out there in the real world. I really like Aaron, and I think his "cuteness" factor will save him tonight. I think the bottom three will be : Sioban, Lee and Mike.........with hopefully Sioban leaving!

I agree with your bottom three. That's who I think should be there. I know they like Lee, but frankly I don't get it. I couldn't listen to a whole album with his voice. I also like Aaron.

[jaspal]

I'm with you. I feel the one who has the biggest success ahead is Crystal Bowersox.

[redwitch]

Now that the screamer is gone (I want to see her live, front row seat and see if I can toss grapes in Siobhan's mouth when she screams), I hope Casey is next. I think he's a great bar act but not much more than that. Being a bluesy type of gal, I'm rooting for Big Mike but think it will either by Crystal or Aaron to win it all. I like Crystal but I don't see her ever getting to be really big. Janis came and went a long time ago -- folk singers aren't all that popular today and, no matter what style she sings, Crystal really is reminiscent of that era. As was said, Aaron is young and can go so very far. Let's just hope he doesn't get locked into the boy singer group and breaks out much like Justin Timberlake did.

[jaspal]

My opinion is that there is an obvious winner at it is:chilout
Crystal Bowersox
The other all fall in the same rating.chilout

[memason]

My opinion is that there is an obvious winner at it is:chilout
Crystal Bowersox
The other all fall in the same rating.chilout

I couldn't agree more, but I don't believe she'll win. I believe it's Aaron's to loose, simply due to the voting public, which are probably lots of tweeners.

In the end, it's probably better for Crystal if she doesn't win. That way, she will not be locked into a recording contract with Clive Davis. Loosing was probably the best thing that ever happened to Chris Doughtery and Adam Lambert...free to go their own way. Although, it would be nice to start out with that million dollars in the bank...

...

[Barefoot]

My opinion is that there is an obvious winner at it is:chilout Crystal Bowersox

IMHO, Crystal is the most talented performer. I think she should win. But .... as we've seen in the past, the best performer doesn't always win. :popcorn:

I think Lee Dewyze is a long shot but I like him.

[Taltarzac]

I couldn't agree more, but I don't believe she'll win. I believe it's Aaron's to loose, simply due to the voting public, which are probably lots of tweeners.

In the end, it's probably better for Crystal if she doesn't win. That way, she will not be locked into a recording contract with Clive Davis. Loosing was probably the best thing that ever happened to Chris Doughtery and Adam Lambert...free to go their own way. Although, it would be nice to start out with that million dollars in the bank...

...

If the past winners are any indication, it will probably be Aaron Kelly who wins. Personally, Crystal Bowersox is the most talented for me. I did not care that much for Adam Lambert but Chris Doughtery sure went a long way without winning Idol.

[Barefoot]

IMHO, Crystal is the most talented performer. I think she should win. But .... as we've seen in the past, the best performer doesn't always win. :popcorn:

I think Lee Dewyze is a long shot but I like him.

I wasn't surprised to see Aaron go home tonight. Next week it will probably be Casey James or Big Mike to be voted off the island.

[barb1191]

I wasn't surprised to see Aaron go home tonight. Next week it will probably be Casey James or Big Mike to be voted off the island.

Crystal, Dewyze, and Casey have talent but lacking big time in personality and stage presence like Big Mike is a natural. He knows how to play the stage and audience and also with the best personality of any. Don't think any of the others have the charisma of the big guy Mike. Hope he wins.

Harry Connick did a superb job of coaching these novices and customized arrangements of songs for each contestant. The pop era of Sinatra songs sure improved their voices as well. Harry sure shared sooo much of his show-biz knowledge and experience as well as his expertise for the individual arrangements for each. He's amazing and such a great talent and of all the guest stars they had there, Harry worked with the group the most and it sure paid off with such an improvement over the dull and horrible songs before.

[Russ_Boston]

The pop era of Sinatra songs sure improved their voices as well.

I agree. Makes you wonder about why so many people think singers were better 'back in the day'. Perhaps the songs are just easier for vocalists?

[LELANDJANE]

It was sad to see Aaron go. He was really improving weekly. His farewell performance last night was great. Crystal's stock seems to be falling now. Lee has been the biggest surprise to me recently. I just wish he'd cheer up and enjoy himself. I thought last night's result show was the most fun so far.

[memason]

Well, I said last week, that it was Aaron's to loose. I guess he did.

I like Casey, but I thought he was terrible with the Sinatra song. His voice just isn't suited for that type of music...He should be singing Joe Cocker or Stevie Ray Vaughn. I believe he'll be going home next, followed by Big Mike.

I have to agree... Harry was a fantastic mentor, this week. A true professional!

I'm still a Bowersox fan. I think it'll be Crystal and Lee in the finale...

[chelsea24]

It's getting down to the wire! I just loved Aaron as a person. He seems like such a nice young man.

Of course, I'm still swooning over Adam last season. He really knows how to rock a room.

My vote is for Lee! But, you know me, I'll always vote for a good Chicago guy!!! You go Homie!!!! :laugh:

He's so cute and really talented. Didn't live far from me either. hmmm... not why didn't I ever buy my paint in Mt. Prospect??? hahaha!

[chelsea24]

I wasn't surprised to see Aaron go home tonight. Next week it will probably be Casey James or Big Mike to be voted off the island.


Are you watching the right show Ms. Foot??? Or do they have American Idol Survivor in Canada??? hahaha!!! Big kiss and hug! I miss you! xxoo, chels

[Taltarzac]

I wasn't surprised to see Aaron go home tonight. Next week it will probably be Casey James or Big Mike to be voted off the island.

He seemed to be the most off his game last night.

If you liked the "Falling Slowly" song sung by Lee and Crystal, the movie it is from is well worth a look. It is from Once. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Once_(film)

[redwitch]

If it were my choice, Casey would be long gone. He really was pitchy and downright off tune a couple of times last night. Sorry, Chels, but Lee isn't much better IMO. However, I think it will be Mike who goes tonight. I'm going to miss him. I really do love R&B and he really does it well.

[Russ_Boston]

Agree Red - not sure why people like Lee's voice. Don't see much success long term for him.

[Barefoot]

Casey seems to want to lose, judging by the songs he is choosing. "Hello Mrs Robinson" ... Goodbye Casey! And I think Big Mike is hanging by a thread. :sing:

In my humble opinion, the duet by Lee and Crystal last night was fabulous. I actually picked up the phone and voted five times, something I never do!

[Russ_Boston]

Funny how the producers paired the duets. I think they are sure that Mike and Casey are gone by the finale.

[LELANDJANE]

I don't see any future "idols" in this group but I definitely think Crystal will win. She just seems more confident and a step above the guys.

[jaspal]

I agree. At this time the only one I hope wins is Christel. I don't have any opinions for the others

[N'awlins Lady]

In my humble opinion, the duet by Lee and Crystal last night was fabulous. I actually picked up the phone and voted five times, something I never do!

I didn't know you could vote more than once...doesn't it skew the results by casting more than one vote? Wonder if that happened with the Presidential election too! :evil6:

Trudy

[Barefoot]

I didn't know you could vote more than once...doesn't it skew the results by casting more than one vote? Wonder if that happened with the Presidential election too! :evil6:

Trudy

Idol is a popularity contest! If you want to spend two hours trying to get through on the phone lines, you sure can vote on Idol as many times as you want. And I'm sure a lot of teenagers text.

[Barefoot]

I thought Lee Dewyze was fabulous last night! :popcorn:

I think Casey is definitely headed home tonight. Golden-boy good looks can only take you so far!

[redwitch]

Barefoot, I'm with you -- Lee absolutely blew me away last night. It was the first time I could see why the judges chose him to be one of the finalists. That being said, I can't see any of the finalists being Idols this time around. Crystal will probably have moderate CD sales (think Ruben Stoddard). To me, Casey is worth a drink or two at my favorite bar but not someone I would spend money to purchase a CD or buy a ticket to see. As I said, Lee surprised me last night. Simon truly hit the nail on the head on his song choice for Lee -- it put him way over the top in my book. I'm not convinced I'd buy a ticket to see him as the headline act, but I know I'd be very happy to hear he was the opening act for a favorite group.

So, here's hoping Casey is finally history. Crystal should ultimately win justr because she's been consistently good. I'd like Lee to win just on the basis of his performance last night.

[Taltarzac]

I thought Lee Dewyze was fabulous last night! :popcorn:

I think Casey is definitely headed home tonight. Golden-boy good looks can only take you so far!

...saying that Casey James has already been eliminated. Page A13-- "James kicked off 'Idol', 2 contestants remain". That's erroneous but right on the money from his performances last night. Unless the hormone voting section of the voters is much bigger than many anticipates.

[LELANDJANE]

I think Lee's continued growth every week has won me over. Crystal is a good club entertainer but Janis Joplin is really over! Like others, I don't think we had a Carrie Underwood in the race this year.

[sschuler1]

I think Ellen's song choice really hurt Crystal last night, even though the judges all liked it. If Simon had picked a song for Crystal, everyone would be swooning over her today! I still think Crystal is the better performer all around, and I'm sure the finale will prove that to be true. Casey should have been kicked off about 5 weeks ago in my opinion.

[N'awlins Lady]

Now that I know you can vote more than once, I voted three times last night! One for each contestant...that way no matter who wins, I'm happy! :D

Trudy

[Barefoot]

I think Ellen's song choice really hurt Crystal last night, even though the judges all liked it. If Simon had picked a song for Crystal, everyone would be swooning over her today! I still think Crystal is the better performer all around, and I'm sure the finale will prove that to be true. Casey should have been kicked off about 5 weeks ago in my opinion.

SueS is our TOTV specialist because she is a professional singer! :sing:

I have to admit that I liked Ellen's song choice for Crystal, and I loved Simon's song choice for Lee.

I don't understand why the contestants often pick such lame songs for themselves. I mean, Casey James picking "Hello Mrs. Robinson" .. memo to Casey ... you deserve to be voted off!!

[NJblue]

I doubt that anyone was surprised by last night's results. I am now having a hard time deciding who is my favorite to win it. All season it has been Crystal, but, after Lee knocked it out of the park with his rendition of Hallelujah, I am having second thoughts. (For the first time, I was even going to download an Idol song from iTunes, but then saw that the only version that they have available is the shortened version that they played on the air.)

Since Lee and Crystal were so good together in the duet, perhaps the best result is co-winners with them making an album together. If they did, I would certainly buy it.

As an aside, does anyone know if there is any behind-the-scenes manuevering going on with the song selections and in particular, the production of the songs? Whereas the two others had very simple productions for their songs, Lee had the full orchestra and a choir. If this was Lee's doing, then he really has a lot of talent over and above just singing.

[memason]

It should be Crystal's win! She was amazing last night, especially her original song. Lee peaked one week too early.

She's been the one to beat since day one....

[jebartle]

It's Crystal Clear to me.....Now let's send Crystal for a new set of "pearly whites":a040:

[Bettiboop]

It should be Crystal's win! She was amazing last night, especially her original song. Lee peaked one week too early.

She's been the one to beat since day one....

Agree! They are both winners, but Crystal has been my favorite since the beginning.

[Barefoot]

I think Crystal is more talented, and probably "deserves" to win. However, I think Lee Dewyze has a good chance of winning. He also has talent, and is humbly appealing. Remember, the voting is done predominantly by women. Most men don't multi-vote, in fact most men don't vote at all.

There is something very appealing about Lee. I think he is the kind of guy that a lot of women would like for a husband, or a son, or a grandson. Does that mean he should win a talent contest? Probably not. But I have to confess that I voted for him. :icon_wink:

It will be interesting finale, especially with Simon saying goodbye. :popcorn:

[BritParrothead]

We saw it tonight here in England. Both I & hubby thought Chrystal was the best :a040:
From the first time we saw Chrystal & Lee, we said they were the ones to beat!! :)
We hope we are not wrong !!

[Barefoot]

YAY :clap2::clap2::clap2: Lee is the new American Idol. I hope he does us proud!

[RichieLion]

I'm betting Crystal Bowersox has a Recording Contract in short order. She was great last night and tonight singing with Alanis Morrisette and Joe Cocker was nothing short of amazing. I'm feeling it's a result like last year where the bigger, but controversial, talent lost. Lee Dewyse will have a good career, I think, but I'm anticipating a star to emerge when Crystal starts her inevitable career.

[Barefoot]

I'm betting Crystal Bowersox has a Recording Contract in short order. She was great last night and tonight singing with Alanis Morrisette and Joe Cocker was nothing short of amazing. I'm feeling it's a result like last year where the bigger, but controversial, talent lost. Lee Dewyse will have a good career, I think, but I'm anticipating a star to emerge when Crystal starts her inevitable career.

I agree that Crystal has a lot more raw talent than Lee. I think her star is about to shine!

[redwitch]

I don't think either one of them will ultimately shine. There's just a star quality missing. They both of talent but not idol-type talent.

I'm wondering what AI will be like without Simon. Simon at least was accurate in his criticisms and made sense if you really listened to what he said. Too much nicey-nice or "dawg" and they'll lose it all. Of course, that might not be such a bad idea given there was little true talent this year. It seemed, at least to me, that most of the contestants would be great at a karaoke bar, good bar/street singers, but no one with the power to sell the tix for a large venue.

Of the two, I think Lee has the bigger drawing power but he has a long way to go before he'll be much more than a warm-up act for a Vegas show. Crystal will always have a small, loyal following and will do well in small venues and intimate clubs. I did notice she tried to open up more on Tuesday night, shaking people's hands, walking around the stage, smiling more, but, to me, it was fake -- just not what Crystal would/should do. Here's hoping I'm wrong on both counts. They both seem like nice people and I'd like to see them do well.

[hoseman]

I don't think either one of them will ultimately shine. There's just a star quality missing. They both of talent but not idol-type talent.

I'm wondering what AI will be like without Simon. Simon at least was accurate in his criticisms and made sense if you really listened to what he said. Too much nicey-nice or "dawg" and they'll lose it all. Of course, that might not be such a bad idea given there was little true talent this year. It seemed, at least to me, that most of the contestants would be great at a karaoke bar, good bar/street singers, but no one with the power to sell the tix for a large venue.

Of the two, I think Lee has the bigger drawing power but he has a long way to go before he'll be much more than a warm-up act for a Vegas show. Crystal will always have a small, loyal following and will do well in small venues and intimate clubs. I did notice she tried to open up more on Tuesday night, shaking people's hands, walking around the stage, smiling more, but, to me, it was fake -- just not what Crystal would/should do. Here's hoping I'm wrong on both counts. They both seem like nice people and I'd like to see them do well.

I agree with this post in entirety. I wish Big Mike had won - unique style, talented and very likeable fellow.

Today is a day to celebrate as AI is finally over this season. Dancing was way better this year (however the wife saw it the other way around and of course she wins so now on Tuesday night, we don't have to fight on which to watch). Without Simon, AI might fall off the charts as he was the only person in the know on the entire AI program.

[Barefoot]

I don't think either one of them will ultimately shine. There's just a star quality missing. They both of talent but not idol-type talent.

I think most of the winners of previous years have also lacked "Idol-type" talent. When I watched the lineup of previous Idol winners last night, I saw few true stars.

The biggest star on the program, Simon, has left the building. They are really going to have to scramble to find someone to fill his shoes. Like him or not, he really knew the music business, and he kept us entertained. The contestants always really respected his opinion.

[sschuler1]

All of the previous Idol winners showed up last night except Kathryn McPhee. I wonder what happened to her? I disagree that none of them have become stars. Kelly Clarkson and Carrie Underwood have gone on to be BIG stars! Fantasia is doing very well on Broadway and has made a few hit records. Reuben Studdard has made a few R&B records, and is doing very well.


I think this is another year that the second place person is going to outshine the winner in the real world. Unfortunately, there have been too many of those seasons!

[ajbrown]

All of the previous Idol winners showed up last night except Kathryn McPhee. I wonder what happened to her?

I think it was David Cooke that was absent..... and I have no idea why. Was a pretty good show using DVR to fast forward once in a while. Once again, my skills at predicting the outcome failed. Just before the announcement, I told my wife, no doubt Crystal won this.... to which she replied, I think Lee won....

Nice try AJ :)

I also notice I have this physical issue that I had forgotten, whenever Paula Abdul talks my eyes roll :jester:

[Russ_Boston]

I think it was David Cooke that was absent.....

That's correct. McPhee was the second pick behind Taylor Hicks (Daughtry was fourth). Good choice that year America!:)

[Taltarzac]

Who would you stick in Simon's seat in next season's AI?

[collie1228]

The only rumors I've seen about Simon's replacement have been Howard Stern and Madonna. Either one would end my viewing pleasure, and I believe would be the beginning of the end for AI (if Cowell's departure hasn't already started the beginning of the end). Frankly, I believe that Simon was the soul of AI, and is probably irreplaceable. I was looking forward to Paula being replaced by Ellen, but I don't see where that has worked out all that well. I like Ellen a lot, but she hasn't added much to the show. Mostly platitudes, cliches and weak attempts at humor - to the point where I missed Paula, believe it or not. Maybe all the exposure for Harry Connick, Jr. this season was intended to measure his likeability with the audience, to be followed by a "surprise" announcement that he is replacing Cowell? Just a thought . . . .

[memason]

I agree with everyone here...Simon will be nearly impossible to replace. They will need someone with music industry credibility. Randy has experience, but he's just not a Simon.

Simon will be back on Fox with X-Factor. I have watched this on BBC and it is essentially Idol in the UK, with a bit of a twist. Near the end of the show, the judges "adopt" one of the contestants and assist with song choice, staging, arrangements, etc. When the elimination shows air, the judges are on stage with their adopted contestent. I predict X-Factor will displace Idol as the show to watch....

Anyway, I believe the wrong person won this year.....again.

[barb1191]

Anyway, I believe the wrong person won this year.....again.

Agree with you there. Crystal had so much more stage presence as well as talent than Dewyze who has NO personality at all; never smiles or connects with the audience.

I am somewhat skeptical about the procedure they profess to use for choosing the winner; very doubtful if it's the public response that chooses the winner. All that seems to be kept somewhat vague.

Doubt that Simon's absence will change anything. Most of the time he was too busy flirting to concentrate on the performance. Glad to see him go; Mr Ice Cube with no respect for people in general; just a "little" man with a "huge" ego who will be quickly forgotten by AI fans.

[Hawkwind]

Who would you stick in Simon's seat in next season's AI?

Take Ellen out of the judges chair and make her the host and make Ryan Seacrest the judge. Aslo get rid of the other babe and get back to 3 judges.

[barb1191]

All of the previous Idol winners showed up last night except Kathryn McPhee. I wonder what happened to her? I disagree that none of them have become stars. Kelly Clarkson and Carrie Underwood have gone on to be BIG stars! Fantasia is doing very well on Broadway and has made a few hit records. Reuben Studdard has made a few R&B records, and is doing very well.


I think this is another year that the second place person is going to outshine the winner in the real world. Unfortunately, there have been too many of those seasons!

Jennefer Hudson has done well winning an Oscar in her first ever film. Think that she will continue her acting over singing talents.

[barb1191]

Maybe all the exposure for Harry Connick, Jr. this season was intended to measure his likeability with the audience, to be followed by a "surprise" announcement that he is replacing Cowell? Just a thought . . . .

The best show this season was when Harry Connick, Jr worked with the contestants over and above what other pro's did on the show. HCJ would be a tremendous replacement for Simon; what a talent!!

[BritParrothead]

Elton John

[NJblue]

OK, we just got back from vacation and our daughter's graduation and intentionally avoided any contact with Idol or shows talking about the results until we could watch it on DVR. Having now done so, it's hard to knock the final result. However, had Crystal won, I wouldn't knock that result either. I think they both had some incredible performances over the course of the season. From the beginning of the season I thought Lee was the only male that had a chance. There were a number of strong females on the show, but Crystal was the best during the entire season.

As to their future success, it depends on what kind of support each are given. Where Lee excelled was in the heavily produced numbers like "Hallelujah" and I loved the creativity that he showed with the bagpipe number. Assuming that he was instrumental with the creativity that went into these productions and if he links up with backers that can provide the financial support to offer these productions, I would definitely pay to see him in concert (I probably replayed the Hallelujah number 15 times, I liked it so much).

However, if these performers have to claw their way to stardom with a more modest budget and backing, I think that Crystal has a better chance. She has the talent to carry a show just by herself and a small backup band/vocalists. I was impressed that with some the numbers that she had with the "stars" on the final night that it was her voice that was much better and more likeable than that of the stars.

[Barefoot]

Take Ellen out of the judges chair and make her the host and make Ryan Seacrest the judge. Aslo get rid of the other babe and get back to 3 judges.

Actually, that idea really makes a whole lot of sense! Ellen is way too nice to be a believable judge. Idol needs at least one judge who "tells it like it is". Not just gives compliments. And Seacrest would probably do that.

It was always evident that the contestants and the audience were anxious to hear Simon's comments after each song. Although the contestants liked the praise from the other three judges -- they really valued Simon's praise because it was tough to earn it.

[Taltarzac]

They seem to be getting 2 new judges on AI and going back to a 3 judge panel format. The new judges are supposedly Jennifer Lopez and Steven Tyler.




http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Idol

[Patty55]

My nominations for new judges-

Joe Jackson
Yoko Ono
Phil Spector (via Skype)

[brostholder]

Does anyone know if Crystal has made any music I can buy yet? I still think her rendition of "People Get Ready" was the best thing I have ever heard on Idol.

[Taltarzac]

Does anyone know if Crystal has made any music I can buy yet? I still think her rendition of "People Get Ready" was the best thing I have ever heard on Idol.



http://music.aol.com/artist/crystal-bowersox

[bkcunningham1]

According to a June 17, Billboard.com article, she is working on her first album but her touring schedule is slowing it down somewhat. She signed a recording deal with 19 Recordings and Jive Records.


http://www.billboard.com/news/crystal-bowersox-s-album-going-great-says-1004098924.story?tag=prevart#/news/crystal-bowersox-s-album-going-great-says-1004098924.story?tag=prevart

[Taltarzac]

It looks like officially Randy Jackson is the only surviving judge from last season's AI.

Personally, I really liked Simon Cowell's honesty and will miss his comments about various contestants. Do not see Mr. Jackson adding all that much to the show with all his "hey, dog" comments.

[Barefoot]

It looks like officially Randy Jackson is the only surviving judge from last season's AI.

Personally, I really liked Simon Cowell's honesty and will miss his comments about various contestants. Do not see Mr. Jackson adding all that much to the show with all his "hey, dog" comments.

I agree, Tal. I think Simon was the glue that held the program together and made it interesting. The performers all respected his comments and opinions.

I don't know much about Stephen Tyler, perhaps he has a unique style?

[Taltarzac]

I watched the first show of the new season of American Idol and liked the new judges. Kind of wish they would have dumped Ryan Seacrest and Randy Jackson too though.

[LI SNOWBIRD]

My nominations for new judges-

Joe Jackson
Yoko Ono
Phil Spector (via Skype)

Hahaha very funny :coolsmiley:

[2newyorkers]

I have to watch a few more shows to see if I like the judges or not. It was strange to see so many youngsters due to the new rules.

[Barefoot]

There was a documentary last night on Oprah's new TV channel about Simon Cowell. What a fascinating man. I miss him on Idol.

[Taltarzac]

There was a documentary last night on Oprah's new TV channel about Simon Cowell. What a fascinating man. I miss him on Idol.

I miss him too. He also seems to be the Yang to Ryan Seacrest's Yin. You kind of need both of them for the show to work well.

[RichieLion]

I think Idol was long due for a change. Steven Tyler is the best thing to happen to this show. He funny and honest and you know just by looking at him when a performer is doing real well by his great reactions. Jennifer Lopez, I thought, was going to be a problem, but she comes across so professional and sweet and just, real.
I'm liking this years Idol, so far, better than the last couple of years

Simon who?

[barb1191]

I think Idol was long due for a change. Steven Tyler is the best thing to happen to this show. He funny and honest and you know just by looking at him when a performer is doing real well by his great reactions. Jennifer Lopez, I thought, was going to be a problem, but she comes across so professional and sweet and just, real.
I'm liking this years Idol, so far, better than the last couple of years

Simon who?

Good post, Richie; my feelings exactly. I really didn't think that I would like Steven Tyler, but looks can be deceiving as he turns out to be a delight with antics that are amusing. Each judge is respectful to the contestants which is so much better than Simon's rudeness, as well as Simon's flirtations with Paula (yuk).

[escapequeen]

Idol has never been better. Simon who???:highfive:

[2BNTV]

I like this years panel because they are quick to give a yes or no to the contestant. The contestant seem to have a little more respect for the newer member panel opinions as Jennifer and Stephen are superstars.

I will watch this year because I think it will flow more smoothly and not have unecessary drama.

[mikeandnancy1112]

We are loving this year's Idol. Such a fresh change in judges.

[Taltarzac]

We are loving this year's Idol. Such a fresh change in judges.

Randy has seemed to have picked up Simon Cowell's attitude. They seem to have more delusion singers on this series of city auditions. I wonder how they get past the screeners unless they are put through purely for entertainment purposes. There must be a couple of hundred decent singers that could have made it to the Jennifer-Steven-Randy panel in place of the singers who are just plain bad.

I am not complaining though as I enjoy the lousy singers more than the many average to above average singers who could have had their places.

[collie1228]

I was ready to hate Steven Tyler as a judge - never liked his music or his band all that much. And I always had an impression of J-Lo that she was arrogant. I was wrong on both fronts based on what I've seen so far. Both are funny, likable and knowledgeable. My problem is the new rules that allow younger singers. Way too many 15 year old's "going to Hollywood", and I'm afraid many may "get chewed up" by the system.

[nitakk]

I think Idol has been off their game for a while. No more Carrie Underwoods or Jennifer Hudsons, just years of people who have fizzled out. Seems like they've juveniled the show and are looking for Justin Biebers now. Will always miss Simon - he's the only one who told the truth!

[Russ_Boston]

I think Idol has been off their game for a while. No more Carrie Underwoods or Jennifer Hudsons, just years of people who have fizzled out. Seems like they've juveniled the show and are looking for Justin Biebers now. Will always miss Simon - he's the only one who told the truth!

Not sure what you mean. Do you mean in terms of success or the style of singers? For example Adam Lambert (semi finalist two years ago) has been successful with two top 40 songs.

[Taltarzac]

I take it back in writing earlier about my enjoyment of lousy auditioners. Just watched the Thursday night (2-3-11) Los Angeles American Idol episode and could not believe anyone with any musical sense at all would have put 80% of those candidates through to the judges table without thinking "that's entertaining" enough to get some ratings.

Three people on Thursday night had talent the rest caused something of an earache and headache.

[Taltarzac]

Anyone have any favorites among the competitors in Season 10 of American Idol? I know that as of this writing there are about 168 people still in the running.

[Taltarzac]

What do you think of Season 10's Top 24? Anyone really stand out for you. I liked the guy with the stand up bass-- Casey Abrams.

[mikeandnancy1112]

I think the top 24 are awesome. Some of the best ever. I love the guy with the deep voice, can't think of his name, senior moment. lol

[redwitch]

Many truly great singers this year, but not convinced any of them are idol material. Casey Abrams definitely is high on my list, but I love jazz and the blues. The deep voice will probably go far in the CW genre -- that young man has class as well as a voice. The wild redhead is interesting but I don't think he was the best choice for the last male. The women really don't stand out for me other than I was truly relieved the new bride was sent packing -- wayyyyyy too much drama from that girl for my taste.

[barb1191]

The new judges have surpassed the expectations of most. I find them so much more pleasant personalities and sincere empathy for the candidates. So far, the two candidates I find most outstanding are the young guy with the beautiful low voice with a fantastic range and the standup bass player, Casey Abrams. Oh yes, there's also a gal who can really belt out a tune with a red-hot-mama rasp to her delightful voice. They're all so new that they really haven't become known by their names which will come with time.

Jennefer seemed truly emotional about having to turn down candidates this week. Randy is Randy, and Steven Tyler is a hoot; I like him adding his amusing personality which is soooooo much more entertaining and sincere than his predecessor....what's his name.

[Taltarzac]

Paul McDonald may be going home tonight. Think he, Ashton Jones and Karen Rodriquez will be in the bottom three.

[mikeandnancy1112]

This is without a doubt the best of the 10 years. Awesome talent and awesome judges. We don't miss Simon at all.

[collie1228]

I agree that the singing is the best in years, but I disagree about Simon. I miss his ascerbic comments. There are a couple of singers that need to hear that they sound like karaoke at the neighborhood bar, but none of the three judges seem to be able to say it. Randy tries his best to interject some reality into the judging, but the other two can't seem to bring themselves to say anything even slightly negative. I like them both, but they need to start helping us differentiate the good from the great. Right now I'm putting my money on Pia, with the guy who sang the Joe Cocker song a close second.

[Shirleevee]

Paul McDonald may be going home tonight. Think he, Ashton Jones and Karen Rodriquez will be in the bottom three.

I agree!!!! Pia disappointed me last night and she is one of my favs

[Taltarzac]

I agree!!!! Pia disappointed me last night and she is one of my favs


She was a little off but still really good among the girl singers. The girls were overall rather weak last night.

[ducati1974]

I agree!!!! Pia disappointed me last night and she is one of my favs

Wow, I was not A Pia fan before but I thought she did really well last night! A really good group this year and I am enjoying the judges.

[RichieLion]

I loved the pure voice of Thia Megia and thought she was wonderful but the judges thought she was just so-so. I didn't think that Casey Abrams "Joe Cocker" take showed his voice to advantage, but he was lauded.

In my opinion the only standouts were Scotty McCreavy, with his masterful take on Garth Brooks "The River", and James Durbin's great rendition of Paul McCartney's "Maybe I'm Amazed".

I've loved listening to the incredibly talented Jacob Lusk, but I thought last night his voice was lost in the over the top instrumentals and back up singers, and he sounded like he was all over the place with his vocals.

[2BNTV]

This years American Idol is better than ever because the judges get to the point immediately and are positive for the most part with their comments. I agree Randy is leading the pack with his insightful criticism as he should. I thought it was going to be a dud show after Simon left but the talent level is really good. It is extremely enjoyable to watch, as some of the vocals are amazing.

My favorite is Pia. Beautiful with vocals that are like Celine Dion. The judges want her to sing a faster song than a ballad. I was thinking RESPECT by the great Aretha Franklin. I think she has the voice that can handle it. It's a big song.

Jacob Lusk has an amazing voice. James Durbin can really belt out some crazy vocals. Who would have thought Casey would be the bottom vote and needed to have a save from the judges.

If you had asked me last week would be singing for the winner of American Idol, 2011, it would have been PIA, Jacob and Casey.

I know it is a popularity contest but some of these contestant could have big careers even if they don't win. They have amazing talent.

[BritParrothead]

We get this 24 hours after you. So I am very careful not to read any posts :D I dont want toknow who has gone. I like Pia anf the young country singer :BigApplause:

[Barefoot]

I agree that the singing is the best in years, but I disagree about Simon. I miss his ascerbic comments. There are a couple of singers that need to hear that they sound like karaoke at the neighborhood bar, but none of the three judges seem to be able to say it. Randy tries his best to interject some reality into the judging, but the other two can't seem to bring themselves to say anything even slightly negative. I like them both, but they need to start helping us differentiate the good from the great. Right now I'm putting my money on Pia, with the guy who sang the Joe Cocker song a close second.

I can see from the comments that I'm in the minority, but I agree with Collie, I also miss Simon. He wasn't the kindest judge in the world, but he certainly could zero in on what was great, and what needed to be improved.

[ajbrown]

I can see from the comments that I'm in the minority, but I agree with Collie, I also miss Simon. He wasn't the kindest judge in the world, but he certainly could zero in on what was great, and what needed to be improved.

I agree that the singing is the best in years, but I disagree about Simon. I miss his ascerbic comments. There are a couple of singers that need to hear that they sound like karaoke at the neighborhood bar, but none of the three judges seem to be able to say it. Randy tries his best to interject some reality into the judging, but the other two can't seem to bring themselves to say anything even slightly negative. I like them both, but they need to start helping us differentiate the good from the great. Right now I'm putting my money on Pia, with the guy who sang the Joe Cocker song a close second.

Dying to use the "multi quote" I learned in another thread :)

I had said this last week to my wife. IMO, Jennifer is a great trade up from Paula, but I think it would be a better show for ME personally if Simon was there instead of Steven and I have always been a big fan of Steven Tyler.

[redwitch]

I, too, miss Simon but I'll give the new judges credit -- they do tell the singers what they need to improve, just are way too gentle about it. I don't think the singers quite "hear" what is being told to them.

I love James Durbin! Pia bores me to tears. I couldn't figure out how she made it past the auditions, let alone this far. I think Casey's voice is interesting and I would definitely go to see him but I don't think he's Idol material. Scotty has a great future singing C&W and I'd definitely buy his CDs. I'm truly amazed that he is only 17 and has such poise and knows himself so well. Jacob is good and will definitely go far in the R&B field (at least he should). I definitely think the girls are way too weak this year. They are totally overwhelmed by the guys. So, my top three woulld be James, Scotty and probably Jacob. In reality, I think it will be James, Scotty and Pia. Hopefully, James will take it all.

[Russ_Boston]

I think that fans are being swayed into thinking the talent is that good BECAUSE Simon is missing and the current judges are too kind. I'll admit I haven't watched it much this year but I only see a couple of keepers (the country voiced guy and the R&B guy). Casey and the other guy with the high voice are interesting but doubt they'll be successful. None of the girls are very good IMO.

[aljetmet]

I, too, miss Simon but I'll give the new judges credit -- they do tell the singers what they need to improve, just are way too gentle about it. I don't think the singers quite "hear" what is being told to them.

I love James Durbin! Pia bores me to tears. I couldn't figure out how she made it past the auditions, let alone this far. I think Casey's voice is interesting and I would definitely go to see him but I don't think he's Idol material. Scotty has a great future singing C&W and I'd definitely buy his CDs. I'm truly amazed that he is only 17 and has such poise and knows himself so well. Jacob is good and will definitely go far in the R&B field (at least he should). I definitely think the girls are way too weak this year. They are totally overwhelmed by the guys. So, my top three woulld be James, Scotty and probably Jacob. In reality, I think it will be James, Scotty and Pia. Hopefully, James will take it all.

I agree with everything you wrote. Great insight!:BigApplause::BigApplause:

[Bosoxfan]

Pia bores me to tears. l.

I'm hoping you mean Thia the young shy ,timid mouse that wouldn't win a community auditions prize.The only reason she's still in it is the 15 year olds across the country is voting for her.Pia has an amazing voice!!

[redwitch]

No, I meant Pia. But, then, Celine Dion bores me or, worse yet, hurts my ears when she screeches. To me, Pia is in the exact same category. She has a strong voice but one that either gets me out of a room in a heartbeat or puts me to sleep. So far, it is has been putting me to sleep.

[Bosoxfan]

Red although I disagree with you about Pia ..I do agree James has a good shot at winning it all!!

[Freeda]

I think Casey would be much better looking and come off better as a singer if he shaved his beard. I like some beards; not his though; it is too 'fuzzy-looking' (no offense to anyone!), and to me ages him and keeps him from having that star 'look' that is so important, in addition to how well they sing. This is just me, but personally I think some young guys look good with a full beard like he has, but not very many. I like seeing their entire face; jawline etc, adds so much character to the face, especially when singing. I find it a distraction to listening to his singing, which I really do like, even though he is not my favorite. (Even my beloved good-looking Willie Nelson and Kenny Rogers would, I think, have looked even greater without the beards).

My favorite to win is Jacob, even though some of his songs lately have not been as good as when he sang early on in the season. I think he'll finish strong. (I think that maybe some of them have problems when trying to sing songs of the required genre for that week, which may be out of their normal type of song). I also think that James is great.

[NJblue]

Just as in art, beauty is in the eye/ear of the beholder/listener. I agree with red regarding Thia ... but not Celine. Whereas Celine's big voice has qualities that make me want to listen, I get absolutely nothing out of Pia. She may be a great "tribute" artist for a future "Celine Show" at the Savannah Center, but I doubt that she will make it on her own. (Just as Paul McDonald would be a great Rod Stewart tribute artist.)

While there is some decent talent this year, I am not convinced that it is better than previous years. Maybe as different themes are introduced a star will emerge, but so far I have heard nothing that I like as much as Crystal Bowersox or Lee DeWyze from last year. James can be decent, but he is in danger of being too much of a one-dimensional, Adam Lambert wannabee.

[memason]

... James can be decent, but he is in danger of being too much of a one-dimensional, Adam Lambert wannabee.

I have to agree with this comment...as much as I really like James, I will be surprised if he makes it much past the top 5. Pure rockers just don't do well on American Idol... Chris Daughtry comes to mind. American Idol is pretty much Pop music oriented...

I like Casey, but if America voted him to go, I doubt he will survive too much longer.

In the end, I believe America will vote the top 3 to be Jacob, Pia and Scotty.

[Taltarzac]

...this season. He was great in the first few auditions but has really shown poor showmanship after they weeded the contestants down to the Top 14 or so.

The Entertainment Weekly 3/18/2011 issue had Casey Abrams to win at 3-1 odds.

Then, it listed the next 12 contenders:

Lauren Alaina-- 4-1 odds.
Scotty McCreery-- 6-1
Jacob Lusk-- 8-1
Pia Toscano-- 10-1
Paul McDonald-- 12-1
Karen Rodriguez-- 15-1
Thia Megia-- 20-1
James Durbin-- 25-1
Ashthon Jones-- 30-1
Stefano Langone-- 50-1
Haley Reinhart-- 100-1
Naima Adedapo-- 250-1.

Karen R. and Ashthon Jones are gone already.

Have no idea why Paul McDonald is still around??

I like Jacob, Pia, and Lauren. Those three and Scotty McCreery I expect to be in the Top 5. Not sure about who the 5th would be though. Lots more songs to sing.

[2BNTV]

Two contestants will go tonight. No saves.

Who do you think will be voted off tonight?

[Bonny]

Hopefully Paul & Naima. They must go !!!!! :wave:

[redwitch]

I think Paul definitely should go. I like Naima. I certainly wouldn't miss Thia -- another one I'm not sure why she's there. I think Lauren might go. And the lounge act guy (Stefano?) -- the one they keep telling to connect with the audience. Won't miss those three.

And if Pia sings one more ballad, I'm gonna scream. Surely there is something else she can sing? As much as I love James, he needs to start changing it up, too.

Okay, off to brave the weather. YUCK

[memason]

Sadly, I believe Casey will be back in the bottom and likely the one to go. I don't believe he did enough to redeem himself with the American public... I believe Stefano is done too...

[Freeda]

Hopefully Paul & Naima. They must go !!!!! :wave:

I also think Paul and Naima.

[Bonny]

Thia can go. Pia is getting a little over the top for me. I do like the way James entertains everyone. I liked Lauren & Haley. I don't think Casey is really Idol material. The drama from Jacob is really irritating me. What was with those faces he was making last night ?? Was he supposed to be crying ? :cry:

[Shirleevee]

Two contestants will go tonight. No saves.

Who do you think will be voted off tonight?

OMG! I have so many favs.......and I liked Naima too tonight.....Paul, Thia and or the bearded one.......are possibilities

[Taltarzac]

OMG! I have so many favs.......and I liked Naima too tonight.....Paul, Thia and or the bearded one.......are possibilities

Also think Paul, Thia and Casey as the bottom three with Thia and Paul leaving tonight.

[aljetmet]

Hopefully Paul & Naima. They must go !!!!! :wave:

:BigApplause::BigApplause::D

[collie1228]

I was really disappointed in much of the show last night. Scotty chanelling George Strait singing Elton John. Pia impersonating Celine Dion singing Elton John. Paul (who really is Rod Stewart, but with whiter teeth) singing Elton John. Naima masquerading as Ziggy Marley singing Elton John. Etc., etc., etc. How I miss Simon - he would have had a classic night last night . . . . Bottom three should be Naima, Thia and Casey, with the girls probably going out. They all have talent, but I'm sincerely hoping that these niche singers can find a way to break out of their molds and do something interesting next week. So far the show has too many "one trick ponies".

[RichieLion]

1. I think Naima Adedapo is underated. I thought her reggae version of "I'm Still Standing" was excellent. Maybe her best performance yet. Loved the way she rolled the lyrics around in her mouth with that Caribbean accent. The judges often suggest the contestants make a song their own. No one did that better than Naima. Still they dis her.

2. I'm not a big fan of the quirky "Rod Stewart-ish" (good catch Collie) Paul McDonald, but my wife loves him and Rod Stewart.

3. Jacob Lusk has a huge voice, but I don't like the way he's been using it of late. He keeps losing me, but the judges think he walks on water.

4. Lauren Alaina has a fine voice, but doesn't connect with me and I get bored before her song ends. Again, my wife thought her excellent.

5. Thia Megia is a doll, and she has excellent tonal qualities to her voice. She had a very good performance with "Daniel". I don't know if she's connecting with enough people, though. My Filipino daughter-in-law and her huge family loves her.

6. Stefano Langone doesn't have enough charisma or talent in my book to be a top shelf performing artist. He would be great in the gazebo at Lake Sumter Landing, but the next American Idol. Well, not yet anyway.

7. Casey Abrams redeemed himself with his lovely version of "Your Song". I don't think the judges should have saved him though. I guess it'll all work out in the end.

8. Pia Toscano of Queens NY is a big fave of my family up north. This week she had an excellent performance and didn't go over the top like she often does. She has a real shot to be the next American Idol.

9. Haley Reinhart had a timely great performance. She's a singer with a quirky style that appeals to me. She could last a few more rounds if she keeps it up.

10. Scotty McCreery knows who he is and performs to his strength every week. He's got a big career in country music no matter how this competitions turns out. Another nice performance.

11. James Durbin's is getting carried away with himself as Adam Lambert did last year. He's got tons of talent, but I didn't think his performance of "Saturday's All Right For Fighting" was great for him. But he's definitely here to the top 5.


Bottom Three? Up to me it would be Paul McDonald, Thia Megia and Stefano Langone

[Shirleevee]

1. I think Naima Adedapo is underated. I thought her reggae version of "I'm Still Standing" was excellent. Maybe her best performance yet. Loved the way she rolled the lyrics around in her mouth with that Caribbean accent. The judges often suggest the contestants make a song their own. No one did that better than Naima. Still they dis her.

I agree with most of your critique and ESPECIALLY the above........yeah Naima!!!!!:BigApplause:

[redwitch]

Richie, pretty much agree with you. I'm not a reggae fan, but I think Naima did a good job of turning it into her own. I'm really hoping Paul and Thia go home tonight. My gut, sadly, says Thia and Naima. Hope my gut is wrong.

[RichieLion]

Thanks Shirleevee and Red; I really appreciate your response to my amateur music reviews. I'm really tickled.

I'm watching the show, and Idol mentor Jimmy Iovine gives a little individual feedback before each performance, in those backstage clips, and it seems to me that the "judges" are using his comments to form their own reviews and it's coloring their assessment of the contestants performance. They keep referring to what he said before the contestants even sing live before the audience. They have to ignore that and just judge that live performance.

They should be listening with an open mind, but I feel they already have their favorites and are critical of contestants they have predetermined opinions about. Naima, in particular, who rarely catches a break. This weeks performance was better than last weeks Motown which they praised. (for her dancing, unbelievably)

[Barefoot]

I was really disappointed in much of the show last night. Scotty chanelling George Strait singing Elton John. Pia impersonating Celine Dion singing Elton John. Paul (who really is Rod Stewart, but with whiter teeth) singing Elton John. Naima masquerading as Ziggy Marley singing Elton John. Etc., etc., etc. How I miss Simon - he would have had a classic night last night . . . . Bottom three should be Naima, Thia and Casey, with the girls probably going out. They all have talent, but I'm sincerely hoping that these niche singers can find a way to break out of their molds and do something interesting next week. So far the show has too many "one trick ponies".

IMHO, you totally nailed it.

I miss Simon. I know I'm in the minority, but I do. The judges think that each and every contestant walks on water. I thought their job was to critiique singers, not to swoon over them all.

[Bosoxfan]

I'm not disappointed with the results this week.Next week Stephan?

[RichieLion]

I'm not disappointed with the results this week.Next week Stephan?

I don't think it was fair last week for the judges to save Casey Abrams when he was #11. Now he's on the 10 Idols tour and someone else was knocked out of the opportunity they won fair and square. They didn't say who was the lowest vote getter this week making her the #11 and out of the tour contestant.

I thought there was something special about Naima Adedapo. I know she wasn't going to be the winner, but I would have sent both Stefano Langone and Paul McDonald home before her.

[Shirleevee]

I don't think it was fair last week for the judges to save Casey Abrams when he was #11. Now he's on the 10 Idols tour and someone else was knocked out of the opportunity they won fair and square. They didn't say who was the lowest vote getter this week making her the #11 and out of the tour contestant.

I thought there was something special about Naima Adedapo. I know she wasn't going to be the winner, but I would have sent both Stefano Langone and Paul McDonald home before her.

Last week it was announced that all 11 finalists would be going on tour....so my dear Naima will be touring......lol

[redwitch]

Richie, I think Casey should have been saved. There is no way he didn't deserve to be one of those on the tour (and all 11 will be touring). I totally agree that Stefano and Paul both need to go. Stefano is a LV lounge act at best. I think Paul is just too "soft." Paul Simon's voice seems to project better than his does. YAWN

At least Thia is gone. Now if only Pia would go. Maybe Stefano could open for her at a 2nd-level casino? (Okay, I'm being mean, but it's morning, I'm tired and grumpy. Mornings shoulld be banned from life!)

[katezbox]

1. I think Naima Adedapo is underated. I thought her reggae version of "I'm Still Standing" was excellent. Maybe her best performance yet. Loved the way she rolled the lyrics around in her mouth with that Caribbean accent. The judges often suggest the contestants make a song their own. No one did that better than Naima. Still they dis her.

I agree with most of your critique and ESPECIALLY the above........yeah Naima!!!!!:BigApplause:

Shirlee - that is exactly what I thought. Very disappointed she was eliminated. I think she has far more talent than some of the others.

[katezbox]

I don't think it was fair last week for the judges to save Casey Abrams when he was #11. Now he's on the 10 Idols tour and someone else was knocked out of the opportunity they won fair and square. They didn't say who was the lowest vote getter this week making her the #11 and out of the tour contestant.

I thought there was something special about Naima Adedapo. I know she wasn't going to be the winner, but I would have sent both Stefano Langone and Paul McDonald home before her.

Richie,

Totally in agreement! (WOW) I would also have sent Casey home before her.

[RichieLion]

Shirleevee and Red; Thanks for updating me on the upcoming tour status. I guess I missed that announcement. Good for Naima. She hooks up with the right producer I think she could have a good career.

Kate; I agree with you, although I think Casey has something to offer that's different, and he has a way of surprising the listener with quirky vocal runs that makes you smile.

This is the first year I really don't have an odds on favorite I think should be the winner. Usually I've picked one by now. It's not for lack of talent because this has got to be one of the most talented groups ever. The evidence is in the group performances on the results show that have been surprisingly good as compared to past years when they mainly had to rely on lip syncing.

[aljetmet]

I don't think it was fair last week for the judges to save Casey Abrams when he was #11. Now he's on the 10 Idols tour and someone else was knocked out of the opportunity they won fair and square. They didn't say who was the lowest vote getter this week making her the #11 and out of the tour contestant.

I thought there was something special about Naima Adedapo. I know she wasn't going to be the winner, but I would have sent both Stefano Langone and Paul McDonald home before her.


No one gets knocked out of the tour!!

At the end of the show last week, RS made that very clear.
Idol producers had the foresight to make the tour of 11 people if some one was saved.

My son who watched a recorded version last week was not aware cause the recording cut before that little tidbit.

My Directv recording did not cutoff.

My wife and I enjoy Idol but we cannot watch it live. Need to FF thru commercials:D

Thought Scottie and Lauren were great last night, especially Lauren...
I vote on line and didn't vote fore the bottom three, but I did vote the most for Casey this week and last.

[bobcat]

No one gets knocked out of the tour!!

At the end of the show last week, RS made that very clear.
Idol producers had the foresight to make the tour of 11 people if some one was saved.

My son who watched a recorded version last week was not aware cause the recording cut before that little tidbit.

My Directv recording did not cutoff.

My wife and I enjoy Idol but we cannot watch it live. Need to FF thru commercials:D

Thought Scottie and Lauren were great last night, especially Lauren...
I vote on line and didn't vote fore the bottom three, but I did vote the most for Casey this week and last.

Just FYI for those you watch American Idol.....Lauren goes to the high school that's across the street from our house! She's quite the hometown hero lately. We're hoping she continues to do well. Who knows, maybe that will help sell our house when we put it on the market! LOL

[Russ_Boston]

It's not for lack of talent because this has got to be one of the most talented groups ever. The evidence is in the group performances on the results show that have been surprisingly good as compared to past years when they mainly had to rely on lip syncing.

You may be right Richie but the point of AI is to look for THE next talent. There are a lot of choral groups that are great but they are looking for solo talent. Doesn't have to be the winner (think Daughtry) but group performance is not much indication of a successful solo artist. I predict that the most successful person this year will be the deep voiced country singer. A CW voice like his is hard to find. But I don't think he'll win AI this year.

[RichieLion]

You may be right Richie but the point of AI is to look for THE next talent. There are a lot of choral groups that are great but they are looking for solo talent. Doesn't have to be the winner (think Daughtry) but group performance is not much indication of a successful solo artist. I predict that the most successful person this year will be the deep voiced country singer. A CW voice like his is hard to find. But I don't think he'll win AI this year.

I just meant their group sing alongs are an indication of the depth of talent, this year. Also Scotty and Lauren's duet was beautiful. One of Lauren's best efforts in my book.

I not going to disagree about Scotty. He's definitely headed for stardom. Maybe the only sure thing on Idol.

I think the winner is going to be James Durbin or Pia Toscano, and they won't have surefire mega successful careers after Idol careers, in my opinion.

[collie1228]

I have no doubt that Scotty will be the most successful of the current Idol singers - with the right producers and management, he is the next George Strait. He can't win American Idol, but I think he'll be the most successful. And I don't really like country music. Every time I hear that beautiful low voice coming from that young kid, I'm totally impressed.

[RichieLion]

I have no doubt that Scotty will be the most successful of the current Idol singers - with the right producers and management, he is the next George Strait. He can't win American Idol, but I think he'll be the most successful. And I don't really like country music. Every time I hear that beautiful low voice coming from that young kid, I'm totally impressed.

I wouldn't count Scotty out of the running. Country music is bigger than ever and he just might be in the right place at the right time.

[NJblue]

I like Scotty as welll. However, I'm not sure of his success in the country field. It seems as if country music has moved away from that "classic" style of country music. I'm not sure how large the fan base of this type of country music is.

[Russ_Boston]

I like Scotty as well. However, I'm not sure of his success in the country field. It seems as if country music has moved away from that "classic" style of country music. I'm not sure how large the fan base of this type of country music is.

I agree with the style comment but I think his voice can be used effectively in many CW songs. I agree with Richie about the duet he sang. CW producers will be lining up.

His voice is very similar to Josh Turner who is very successful - Try this - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nADTbWQof7Y

[RichieLion]

Well this was an interesting week. I can't believe the judges outrage on the viewers vote ousting Pia Toscano. Very unprofessional conduct and a slap in the face to the top 8. What "no talent" slob did they feel should be the next to go?

Pia is an very good singer, but in my view, not very unique. I'm sure she has a career ahead of her, but her style wasn't singularly dynamic, in my opinion.

If the viewers vote had sent someone else home, I could have lived with that and that's how the judges should have reacted. They actually insulted us, if you think about it.

[redwitch]

It amazed me that the judges didn't "get" it. Jalo (how do you spell that?)tells her she needs to learn how to move on stage (very, very true) and then is angry when she's sent home. HUH??? To me, it was very much between Pia and Stefano. They never really connected in my mind. That Jacob was in the bottom three surprised. I really thought his performance was pretty darn close to great. Loved Scotty's Elvis.

This group is exceptional in my mind. Once Stefano goes (soon, I hope), fans are going to be hard-pressed to send someone home. If I had to predict, it will Stefano leaving next week; then Paul, Jacob, Lauren and Casey. Right now, my vote goes to Scotty for the top spot but James will always have a special spot in my heart.

[collie1228]

I still like AI, but there are two problems with the show that may end up being its downfall. One is the judges, who aren't doing anyone, audience or contestants, any favors. Fawning over every contestant just doesn't cut it . I'll say it again, they need another Simon Cowell (but I have to admit that Tyler and J-Lo are a lot more interesting than Ellen or Kara ever were). The second problem is that fact that the majority of voters are young girls, who tend to vote for the "cute guys" which is a big disadvantage to the female contestants. Pia was the fifth girl in a row eliminated this season. It will take an awful lot of talent to overcome the built in bias of the young girl voters.

[memason]

What a shocker! But, I didn't vote, so I can't complain... It's really easy to vote via the net, so there's really no excuse for not voting, I guess :(

James is still my favorite, although I don't think he can win Idol. I want him to make it to the finale, because Steven Tyler said he would do a duet with him on that show. That would be entertaining!

You can bet I'll be voting from here on out!

[2BNTV]

At the beginning of last night's show, as Ryan Seacrest said the results would be shocking, I got a feeling that Pia was the one that would be sent home. To find Jacob in the bottom three was another surprise.

I hope that Pia will still find a way to become a star like Jennifer Hudson did.

Bad News -The American public has spoken and I don't agree that Pia should have been the one to go. I am very disappointed in the voting.

Good news - This will save me a lot of television viewing time as I have lost confidence the most talented person will win.

I will tune into the final show show to see if Jacob is still a contestant.

It's just my opinion.

[RichieLion]

At the beginning of last night's show, as Ryan Seacrest said the results would be shocking, I got a feeling that Pia was the one that would be sent home. To find Jacob in the bottom three was another surprise.

I hope that Pia will still find a way to become a star like Jennifer Hudson did.

Bad News -The American public has spoken and I don't agree that Pia should have been the one to go. I am very disappointed in the voting.

Good news - This will save me a lot of television viewing time as I have lost confidence the most talented person will win.

I will tune into the final show show to see if Jacob is still a contestant.

It's just my opinion.


You have to consider all the factors in a successful performer. Talent is a big one, I'll grant you that. Just as important is charisma. You either have that or you don't. There are plenty of successful performers who parlay their charisma into successful careers with little actual singing talent. Last show's guest star Iggy Pop is a great example.

[collie1228]

Frankly I originally though Jacob Lusk would be a final three finalist, but I'm afraid a lot of people must have heard his comment at the end of his performance Wednesday, landing him in the bottom three. Just my opinion - but you probably won't win over many voters by telling them "If I am in the bottom three after this performance, it just means America is not ready to look at themselves in the mirror". Wow - at the least it was cocky; at worst sanctimonious.

[Number 6]

The judges used their one save to keep Casey in the top eleven. Now they are upset that Pia was voted off. If they want to know whose fault that was, they should look in the mirror. Where is Cowell when we need him?

[Shirleevee]

It amazed me that the judges didn't "get" it. Jalo (how do you spell that?)tells her she needs to learn how to move on stage (very, very true) and then is angry when she's sent home. HUH??? To me, it was very much between Pia and Stefano. They never really connected in my mind. That Jacob was in the bottom three surprised. I really thought his performance was pretty darn close to great. Loved Scotty's Elvis.

This group is exceptional in my mind. Once Stefano goes (soon, I hope), fans are going to be hard-pressed to send someone home. If I had to predict, it will Stefano leaving next week; then Paul, Jacob, Lauren and Casey. Right now, my vote goes to Scotty for the top spot but James will always have a special spot in my heart.

As much as I love her voice, I thought Pia and Stefano and Jacob would be the bottom three. My feeling is that they do not connect with that 18-39 y.o., age group that Nielsen ratings cancels my favorites show for. With that in mind Stefano will be next..........

[mikeandnancy1112]

My husband and I agree completely with you, Redwitch. Scotty is the best and James is amazing!

[Bosoxfan]

At the beginning of last night's show, as Ryan Seacrest said the results would be shocking, I got a feeling that Pia was the one that would be sent home. To find Jacob in the bottom three was another surprise.

I hope that Pia will still find a way to become a star like Jennifer Hudson did.

Bad News -The American public has spoken and I don't agree that Pia should have been the one to go. I am very disappointed in the voting.

Good news - This will save me a lot of television viewing time as I have lost confidence the most talented person will win.:BigApplause:I will tune into the final show show to see if Jacob is still a contestant.

It's just my opinion.

:agree:

American Idol? American Idol? It should be named teenie bopper idol.The voters wouldn't know talent if it bit them in the a## !

:spoken:

[barb1191]

My choice was Scotty from the very start; he's got it all and will do well.

[marybb]

Very disappointed Pia voted off, amazing voice,. I'm sure she will be picked up by some label. Hope James wins. Jacob has a great voice, for broadway.

[Barefoot]

:agree:The judges used their one save to keep Casey in the top eleven. Now they are upset that Pia was voted off. If they want to know whose fault that was, they should look in the mirror. Where is Cowell when we need him?

Exactly. :popcorn:

I still like AI, but there are two problems with the show that may end up being its downfall. One is the judges, who aren't doing anyone, audience or contestants, any favors. Fawning over every contestant just doesn't cut it . I'll say it again, they need another Simon Cowell

:agree: :popcorn:

[Russ_Boston]

AI would never change the voting structure since they are still a #1 show. Let's not forget that this is not about them signing a talent, it's about the television ratings. They can still sign the talent even if that person loses.

But if they really wanted to have the least talented person go every week then just change the voting to 'vote out the least talented'. That way there would be a consensus most likely. This is what they do on Survivor until the last vote.

Or...

They could still vote for their favorite but have that vote be 50% and the judges be 50% (I think this is what they do Dancing with the Stars). This would insure no early off for the most clearly talented. Seems to work on "Dancing".

[Freeda]

I like most of the singers that have made it this far; I think Paul was the right choice to be eliminated tonight.

It's interesting to see how Casey's beard and hair have become a little more refined each week. He is a terrific performer.

I'm still pulling for Jacob as my favorite to win; but there are several others who I think are also in the running; my top two picks to win are Jacob and James.

[barb1191]

Still rooting for Scotty; truly the best.....voice, personality and stage presence.

[barb1191]

AI would never change the voting structure since they are still a #1 show. Let's not forget that this is not about them signing a talent, it's about the television ratings. They can still sign the talent even if that person loses.

But if they really wanted to have the least talented person go every week then just change the voting to 'vote out the least talented'. That way there would be a consensus most likely. This is what they do on Survivor until the last vote.

Or...

They could still vote for their favorite but have that vote be 50% and the judges be 50% (I think this is what they do Dancing with the Stars). This would insure no early off for the most clearly talented. Seems to work on "Dancing".

There's a tremendous incentive for hitting #1 and with that goes something like one million dollars (not sure of the amount other than it's sizeable) and a contract.

[collie1228]

Last night when Paul got the boot, there were no tears from the judges or from him - he seemed very comfortable with where he finished in the contest. I happen to think he was overdue to leave, but he showed a lot of class in losing. Strangely, I was rooting for Stephano, who I've never liked all that much, but who I thought had the best performance on Tuesday. The kid is coming around, but it's looking more and more like AI is Scotty's to lose. I just wish he'd try something out of his comfort level.

[RichieLion]

Last night when Paul got the boot, there were no tears from the judges or from him - he seemed very comfortable with where he finished in the contest. I happen to think he was overdue to leave, but he showed a lot of class in losing. Strangely, I was rooting for Stephano, who I've never liked all that much, but who I thought had the best performance on Tuesday. The kid is coming around, but it's looking more and more like AI is Scotty's to lose. I just wish he'd try something out of his comfort level.

Country music is bigger than ever. That's why I believe you'll see Scotty and Lauren facing off in the finale.

Even Randy tells Scotty not to try to fix what ain't broken.

At this point music careers for these talented kids won't depend on their ranking in this contest. If it's meant to happen, it will. Except for Carrie Underwood and Kelly Clarkson, the most successful contestants have not been the winners.

[Russ_Boston]

Country music is bigger than ever. That's why I believe you'll see Scotty and Lauren facing off in the finale.

Even Randy tells Scotty not to try to fix what ain't broken.

At this point music careers for these talented kids won't depend on their ranking in this contest. If it's meant to happen, it will. Except for Carrie Underwood and Kelly Clarkson, the most successful contestants have not been the winners.

Agree on all points Richie.

I agree, Barb, that being #1 might be an incentive but that hasn't hurt Daughtry or Hudson or McPhee or Pickler or others. But yes the 1M is a nice way to begin your career.

[aljetmet]

There's a tremendous incentive for hitting #1 and with that goes something like one million dollars (not sure of the amount other than it's sizeable) and a contract.

I was curious as to how much the winner gets in AI contracts.

Found this article on line.
(http://www.nytimes.com/2010/02/24/arts/television/24idol.html

Not so much. I think this year's group is going to do the best ever in the $ dept.

We'll see.

Scottie and Casey are my faves but I'd be surprised if they are in the finals. I hope at least one is. Only James has not made the bottom three.
I was liking him but that heavy metals junk just turned me off.
I thought Joplin and Hendrix were great. The times have been a changing.

[Freeda]

This is just for fun, but, really, who does this look like . . . . just a little?!

http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3469/3789232145_597875b224.jpg

[aljetmet]

..

[barb1191]

Hoping Scotty will win AI... Stefano Langone got axed tonight.

[marybb]

This is just for fun, but, really, who does this look like . . . . just a little?!

http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3469/3789232145_597875b224.jpg

Omg! Could that be the next ai? I'm hoping James will win.

[Freeda]

Whew, my favorite, Jacob, almost got the ax tonight, but he made it through! He's going to have to step up to more fiery and exciting songs; which he has the talent to carry off.

I liked Stefano, but it was his time.

At this point, I really like most of the ones that are left. I think Casey, Hayley, or Scotty should be the next to go.

[ajbrown]

We thought Jacob would be the one gone this week. It is really getting tough to pick the bottom three as the number of competitors is reduced.

AI is fun to watch as long as it is on DVR so you can fast forward thru commercials and most judges comments :duck:

Freeda: The first time I saw Scotty I thought of Mad Magazine... pretty funny

[Freeda]

I love all kinds of music, and although I only like some country music, such as George Strait, Faith Hill, and a few others, with Johnny Cash having been my all time favorite, I must admit that Scotty has grown on me, and he does have an endearing face! Here he is in his AI audition, singing 'Your Man' by Josh Turner, which has been my favorite of his performances:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SV1do6TuMBw&feature=related

[Russ_Boston]

Win or lose in AI, you'll be hearing him for a long time on CW radio.

[Freeda]

Win or lose in AI, you'll be hearing him for a long time on CW radio.

Definitely!

[collie1228]

Agree, but someone in the country music scene has to give him some lessons on handling a microphone. It's getting ridiculously funny sometimes . . . . But the kid can sing country like nobody I've heard since George Strait.

[BritParrothead]

This is just for fun, but, really, who does this look like . . . . just a little?!

http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3469/3789232145_597875b224.jpg

I am glad that it is not just me!! I told my husband that this is who Scotty looks like :1rotfl:

[BritParrothead]

From the get go, I was a Scotty fan, Lauren has grown on me:)
I love Country music, we do not get enough over here. SO, very happy to see 2 such good entertainers still going strong:BigApplause:

[redwitch]

So, who's gonna leave? I was amazed by James D last night. I'd always liked him but his voice is much truer than I expected. Wowser!! My guess is that Jacob and Casey will be at the bottom (number three is up for grabs -- probably Lauren). I really like Scotty but he's too country. I doubt he could ever do a cross-over song, let alone an album and you need that to be a true idol IMO. I think Jacob should leave; his voice broke a time or two too often for my taste, but I think it will be Casey. I can't imagine the teenyboppers voting for his jazzy style, but I do love it.

[memason]

It's getting really tough to call, but I believe the bottom 3 will be Jacob, Casey and Haley.... Of those 3, I would expect Haley to finally exit tonight, although personally, I'd like to see Jacob go...just not my cup of tea.

James was unbelievable last night. It's to the point, I never know what to expect from James.....

SHould be an interesting show tonight...

[aljetmet]

I agree that James was excellent last night. I think Lauren will go...

[redwitch]

James was unbelievable last night. It's to the point, I never know what to expect from James....


Do remember that James is an Aspie (high-functioning autistic) with Tourettes. Something tells me that even James doesn't know what to always expect. I have noticed that sometimes his tics are pretty pronounced. That has to make it so hard for him to concentrate on singing.

[Mudder]

It's really a hard call for tonight. I think Jacob will go but could be Lauren. They're all so good. I'm starting to feel like Casey is acting a little to over confident.

[collie1228]

I agree with Memason - Jacob, Casey and Haley in the bottom three. I just can't see how Jacob can last another week. He's been in the bottom three a lot, and even the non-judgmental judges can't keep him around much longer. I don't get Casey's act at all, but I'll give him credit for doing something different (was that singing?) James was far and away the best last night.

[diskman]

I agree with Memason - Jacob, Casey and Haley in the bottom three. I just can't see how Jacob can last another week. He's been in the bottom three a lot, and even the non-judgmental judges can't keep him around much longer. I don't get Casey's act at all, but I'll give him credit for doing something different (was that singing?) James was far and away the best last night.

Final outcome I say it will eventually be down to Scott or James:BigApplause::BigApplause::BigApplause:

[Freeda]

After last night James is my new favorite; Jacob still my #2. I think tonight we will say goodbye to Casey, Scotty or Hailey. They are all good at this point.

[2newyorkers]

James gets a WOW for last nights performance. He appeals to all generations and I think that gives him a edge. At the same time, even though country western music is not my style, it is well loved by the majority of the country which is a positive for Lauren and Scotty. I think Haley or Jacob will go tonight.

[NJblue]

I think a lot of people's jaws dropped with how James began his song - it was nice to see that he has a real singing voice as opposed to just a rock voice. His arrangement would have been really fabulous if he had gone from acapella to rock and then back to acapella to finish the song.

I was ready for Casey to go; I have grown weary of his growl which he just can't seem to sing without. I am also very weary of Jacob's style. I could never see myself going to either of their concerts.

My favorite right now is Hailey (but admit that part of this is based on her looks). My guess is that James will win it.

[barb1191]

Have been rooting for Scotty, but now feeling that Haley may be the winner; she's got everything going for her, beautiful, comfortable stage presence and personality, and a fabulous voice for any genre. She's got it all. I also feel that Scotty will make out very well whether or not he takes #1.

[memason]

James gone.... similar to Daughtry.

What about the final three? Any favorites?

I believe Lauren will be hard to beat....

[aljetmet]

Haley is my girl.
Last week is the first time didn't vote for Scotty....

Actually very disturbed with the voting process altogether.

I spent probably 15 minutes because it was online and I was in front of my TV.

Actually Dancing WTS does it much better. The key is to limit the number of votes one individual can make...

20 million girls are going to vote four hours for Scotty....

[islandgal]

I was sad to see James go. He is so versatile, amazing stage presence and perfect pitch.
I guess the metal bit turned some off. I hope his talents will be appreciated elsewhere very soon.

[Freeda]

Doug and I were stunned to see James go; thought he would win. We think that he will still be a star. He looked so crushed; he didn't see it coming, and neither did we.

Of the three that are left who are all great singers, I think that Lauren will win. Hard to tell though because so much depends on the popular vote.

[redwitch]

I can't believe James was voted off. I like Scotty, but he's a one-trick pony. He'll do well in the C&W world but, to me, James was IT!!!!

I'm not sure I even care who wins now. James deserved to be in the top three at the very least. Hopefully, he will do as well, if not better since he has the better voice and range than Daughtry.

[RichieLion]

I don't think we TV'ers are the core Idol Audience, and like Islandgirl points out, Metal isn't the popular music with the teens anymore, and that hurt James, I think. The "cool" music right now is Country and Pop; Taylor Swift and Lady Antebellum, Lady GaGa and Adele. James is not in that genre (although, he could have been. He can sing anything). Also he wasn't being humble anymore. I think the humbleness of Scotty McCreery is very appealing, and James lost his. (The judges acting like he had it won already didn't help him)

The youngsters sit and vote over and over and over. You heard Lauren's brother say he was voting for 2 hours. He obviously kept calling until he was able to get through the phone traffic to vote multiple times, maybe on the phone and on Facebook. The kids will do that; would you?

Scotty seems to be the favorite because the young girls love him. Maybe he's a one trick pony, as Redwitch says, but it's a darn good trick. I think Haley is the performer with the most sheer talent, and she seems to be resonating with the voters even with 2 of the judges constantly criticizing her (unfairly in my mind. I thought she nailed the songs they disliked, last week and this week). Lauren is almost as erratic as my golf game, but her sweetness is very appealing.

My money is on Scotty McCreery. (although I'm not a lucky gambler)

[Freeda]

I find texting the easiest way to vote; and you can keep forwarding it to send multiple votes. Probably is also what alot of the young people are doing. (... I mean, not that I'm not young, as are we all).

[kathyzapp]

I can't believe James was voted off. I like Scotty, but he's a one-trick pony. He'll do well in the C&W world but, to me, James was IT!!!!

I'm not sure I even care who wins now. James deserved to be in the top three at the very least. Hopefully, he will do as well, if not better since he has the better voice and range than Daughtry.

I totally agree! James was IT!

[DaleMN]

It was probably more James' personality than his talent that caused him to be voted off. And lest I be criticized nothing to do with his Torette's. He was starting to come off as a little cocky and "coached". And screaming can only get you so far.

[Russ_Boston]

since he has the better voice and range than Daughtry.

Not! Don't predict anywhere near the sucess that Daughtry has had. It's all about the song writing and Daugherty has had two very, very good albums.

[redwitch]

Sorry, Russ, I still think James has more talent. He can hold a note, he can sing a ballad. Good songwriters are pretty easy to find, so, if James picks the right talent, I do think he can go further than Daughtry (and I liked him a lot on AI, too). And I'm still not sure I'm going to bother watching it any more this season. Just doesn't seem right that James is out and Lauren is in.

I really didn't see that James was becoming cocky. More confident, yes. Remember, that besides Tourette's, he also has Asperger's. Most Aspies come across as arrogant, not because they are but because they don't have the necessary social graces. In reality, most Aspies are pretty insecure -- it's hard when you never know if you're going to say something that will offend another regardless of your intent. Add Tourette's to the mix and you have to have a young man with enough insecurities to choke a horse. To hear you are good and have it confirmed has got to make you a little more confident and perhaps make you look cocky, but there's too much underlying pain and insecurity to really let you be as arrogant as you might appear.

[Russ_Boston]

I guess time will tell but Daughtry has sold millions. James would do well if he was a close second to him.

[pauld315]

I currently live in the Raleigh area and this weekend was when the final 3 went to their hometowns. Scotty came home and really conquered ! He was mobbed everywhere he went and gave a concert for approximately 30,000 fans, Some of them having staked out a spot in the park it was given for over 8 hours and it was hot and humid yesterday ! The concert and much of his trip was televised on a local station here. During the concert, he started singing Josh Turner's "Your Man" , got about 30 seconds into the song, turned around and Josh Turner was standing there. He was so surprised he about fell on the floor. They ended up singing 2 songs together. You could tell that the whole day was very emotional for him and he cried openly several times during the day.

He is truly a sincere, talented young man with God given abilities. I don't know if he will win the whole thing but he really doesn't need to. He will have a very good professional career when this is all over and you couldn't ask for more for such a nice young man.

If you are interested, WRAL TV recorded much of his visit. Here is a link to an article which has several links on the left hand side including the entire concert he gave.

http://www.wral.com/entertainment/story/9596709/

[redwitch]

What a lovely story about Scotty. He impressed me from the beginning when he stated he hadn't been a "man" when one of the kids was kicked out of his group. For a 17 YO kid, that was a heck of a statement. And I totally agree, he will go far. I just hope someone tells him to quick cocking his head and he finds another way to hold the mike -- it gets old fast. (But I still love James!)

[RichieLion]

I currently live in the Raleigh area and this weekend was when the final 3 went to their hometowns. Scotty came home and really conquered ! He was mobbed everywhere he went and gave a concert for approximately 30,000 fans, Some of them having staked out a spot in the park it was given for over 8 hours and it was hot and humid yesterday ! The concert and much of his trip was televised on a local station here. During the concert, he started singing Josh Turner's "Your Man" , got about 30 seconds into the song, turned around and Josh Turner was standing there. He was so surprised he about fell on the floor. They ended up singing 2 songs together. You could tell that the whole day was very emotional for him and he cried openly several times during the day.

He is truly a sincere, talented young man with God given abilities. I don't know if he will win the whole thing but he really doesn't need to. He will have a very good professional career when this is all over and you couldn't ask for more for such a nice young man.

If you are interested, WRAL TV recorded much of his visit. Here is a link to an article which has several links on the left hand side including the entire concert he gave.

http://www.wral.com/entertainment/story/9596709/

Thanks so much for this link. I posted in on Facebook for my family and friends to see. I think Scotty is some kid, and the sort of American boy that can be a real positive role model. I'm not and have never been a huge country music fan, but I'm rooting for him.

[babs1199]

Sorry, Russ, I still think James has more talent. He can hold a note, he can sing a ballad. Good songwriters are pretty easy to find, so, if James picks the right talent, I do think he can go further than Daughtry (and I liked him a lot on AI, too). And I'm still not sure I'm going to bother watching it any more this season. Just doesn't seem right that James is out and Lauren is in.

I really didn't see that James was becoming cocky. More confident, yes. Remember, that besides Tourette's, he also has Asperger's. Most Aspies come across as arrogant, not because they are but because they don't have the necessary social graces. In reality, most Aspies are pretty insecure -- it's hard when you never know if you're going to say something that will offend another regardless of your intent. Add Tourette's to the mix and you have to have a young man with enough insecurities to choke a horse. To hear you are good and have it confirmed has got to make you a little more confident and perhaps make you look cocky, but there's too much underlying pain and insecurity to really let you be as arrogant as you might appear.

I agree with you 100 %

[BritParrothead]

Thank you for the link. Very enjoyable :coolsmiley:
I love country music, but we do not get much of here in England:confused:

[pauld315]

Thank you for the link. Very enjoyable :coolsmiley:
I love country music, but we do not get much of here in England:confused:

You are welcome..I am looking forward to see the show Wednesday/Thursday when they show their home trips. BTW, Scotty will be singing Kenny Rodgers "She Believes in Me" for one of his songs on Wednesday.

[Barefoot]

I just hope someone tells him to quick cocking his head and he finds another way to hold the mike -- it gets old fast. (But I still love James!)

I agree Redwitch, I really liked James also. I'm disappointed that the judges used their "save" so early in the game. I think James deserved to stay.

I agree that Scotty needs to quit cocking his head. You would think one of the many mentors would have told him that. But he is extremely talented nevertheless.

Regardless of what we wrinklies think, the teenagers will probably decide the outcome.

[Freeda]

I like Scotty more and more as a singer. In addition to the comments above, I think he should always dress like a star, and ditch the blue jeans and shirt tails out. In comparison to how the others dress, it is not a good contrast IMHO.

[BritParrothead]

You are welcome..I am looking forward to see the show Wednesday/Thursday when they show their home trips. BTW, Scotty will be singing Kenny Rodgers "She Believes in Me" for one of his songs on Wednesday.

We get Idol on Thursday and Friday, so I have to keep away from the forum until it is over! :) I dont want to know what happens :)

[2BNTV]

The tweens wil decide who the winner is. I sure hope it's your favorite.

[RichieLion]

My nephew David in New York saw James Durbin outside the studios of Regis & Kelly and got this picture with him that he shared on Facebook.

http://i921.photobucket.com/albums/ad51/wakytimes/231102_2068385235049_1407363297_2402629_437578_n.j pg

[kathyzapp]

My nephew David in New York saw James Durbin outside the studios of Regis & Kelly and got this picture with him that he shared on Facebook.

http://i921.photobucket.com/albums/ad51/wakytimes/231102_2068385235049_1407363297_2402629_437578_n.j pg

Thanks for sharing the pic!

[VillagesFlorida]

The show tonight is under way but there is someone who is sorely missing.....James! This is not the same American Idol anymore! Waughhhhhhh!

[Freeda]

I missed James tonight too! I pick Lauren to win! But what do I know - both of my favorites got eliminated!!