Talk of The Villages Florida

Talk of The Villages Florida (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/)
-   Clubs of the Villages (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/clubs-villages-76/)
-   -   Should Earthlings travel to and inhabit Mars? A discussion. (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/clubs-villages-76/should-earthlings-travel-inhabit-mars-discussion-348060/)

Topspinmo 04-13-2024 11:00 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ThirdOfFive (Post 2305548)
No worries. With Elon calling the shots we’ll have a Mars colony by 2035 and will be mining the asteroid belt soon after.

As it should be.


SpaceX will probably be only one that can make trip.

Topspinmo 04-13-2024 11:02 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by fdpaq0580 (Post 2309229)
"God-like egos". Hardly! If I believed I could control the climate by myself with just a thought, that would be God-like. But, with the help of over 8 billion of my human brothers and sisters and all the ingenuity and machines and factories, ships, etc, it is more than possible. Hardly God-like.
Great endeavors bring amazing scientific discovery that save lives, and can help protect our country and much more. Hardly what I would call frivolous spending. It is a normal part of living as part of a society.

The only way to control climate change is to control population of humans.

fdpaq0580 04-13-2024 08:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Topspinmo (Post 2321343)
The only way to control climate change is to control population of humans.

One of many pieces of the puzzle which need to be considered.

JerryLBell 04-14-2024 08:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by manaboutown (Post 2305475)
Unless we become a space going race we die when the sun expires.

In about a billion years, our local star will get enough brighter to cause the oceans of our little planet to boil away, so we really don't need to wait until the sun runs out of hydrogen and starts to expand radically (out to or just past the orbit of Earth) to find the neighborhood no longer what it used to be.

Besides, even if we could come up with the technology to live further out in the solar system or even to send humanity to the starts, it's not that likely that we'd live that far into the future anyway. Humans haven't been around for all that long compared to some dinosaur species, but even they didn't last a billion years. If we last another hundred thousand years or so, we will have had quite a nice run of it. Given how we have been as stewards to the planet, we probably won't last nearly that long.

fdpaq0580 04-14-2024 10:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by JerryLBell (Post 2321664)
In about a billion years, our local star will get enough brighter to cause the oceans of our little planet to boil away, so we really don't need to wait until the sun runs out of hydrogen and starts to expand radically (out to or just past the orbit of Earth) to find the neighborhood no longer what it used to be.

Besides, even if we could come up with the technology to live further out in the solar system or even to send humanity to the starts, it's not that likely that we'd live that far into the future anyway. Humans haven't been around for all that long compared to some dinosaur species, but even they didn't last a billion years. If we last another hundred thousand years or so, we will have had quite a nice run of it. Given how we have been as stewards to the planet, we probably won't last nearly that long.

All true. So, what do you suggest our species should do? Take the pessimistic approach, assume the position, head between legs and kiss our buttons goodbye? Or, take an optimistic approach, try to be better stewards of our planet, invest in scientific plans that promote space travel for long-term survival and exploration? Or, lastly, ignore it all and play another round of golf and pretend everything is just fine?
Personally, I like option 2. Just because I love my species, that doesn't blind me to our faults. No kids means I have no stake in the future. Still, I'd like to think there is hope for my species, even though I will never know.

MrFlorida 04-15-2024 09:13 AM

Men are from Mars, women are from Venus.

fdpaq0580 04-15-2024 10:17 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MrFlorida (Post 2321795)
Men are from Mars, women are from Venus.

Sometimes it seems that way. But when my woman kisses me, I realize she is from heaven.

Battlebasset 04-15-2024 05:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by manaboutown (Post 2305475)
Unless we become a space going race we die when the sun expires.

Reminds me of a joke:

A scientist was giving a public lecture, and explained that the sun would go out in 5 billion years.

After the lecture, a woman came running up and asked, very panicked "Did you say the sun was going out in five million years?".

"No madam:, he responded, "I said 5 billion years".

Visibly relieved, the woman said "Oh thank God!" as she walked away.

There are many things I can worry about, but the earth ending is not even remotely on my list.

Battlebasset 04-15-2024 05:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MDLNB (Post 2308587)
"NO" because it is not habitable for humans, UNLESS you can live without oxygen and survive the cold. You are better off building a habitat under the ocean than on Mars. Just remember that any emergency assistance is about 9 months away....if you are lucky. On the other hand, what the private sector does is none of my business. What the gov does with taxpayer money IS our business and they spend frivolously as it is. In my opinion, if we are serious about migration to Mars, we should first use unmanned equipment to make the planet habitable, before sending humans on one way suicide missions. Let the private sector fund the experiment.

Agree 100%. People downplay the immense distances to points in space. There is nothing there that would allow items to be refined/built there. Everything would need to come from earth. Unless there is something there of immense worth to offset the cost, there is no way this is economically feasible.

While still insanely expensive, it would be better to colonize the moon. It would require everything moving to Mars would require, but it is closer, and could be used as a platform for deeper space exploration. With unmanned probes. There is no reason to send a human anywhere in outer space, other than ego.

fdpaq0580 04-16-2024 10:51 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Battlebasset (Post 2321927)
Agree 100%. People downplay the immense distances to points in space. There is nothing there that would allow items to be refined/built there. Everything would need to come from earth. Unless there is something there of immense worth to offset the cost, there is no way this is economically feasible.

While still insanely expensive, it would be better to colonize the moon. It would require everything moving to Mars would require, but it is closer, and could be used as a platform for deeper space exploration. With unmanned probes. There is no reason to send a human anywhere in outer space, other than ego.

Ego has nothing to do with it. Curiosity has everything to do with it. Without curiosity to drive us forward, our species would have died off long, long ago. Eventually there will be bases on the moon, then Mars, then farther out. Our species will always want to know what is over the next hill. Eventually, Star Trek and Star Wars will be scifact more than sci-fi. And, probably far sooner then we realize.

MrFlorida 04-16-2024 06:46 PM

On a Twilight Zone episode, they came to Earth with a book, " How to serve man" , it was a cook book.!

fdpaq0580 04-17-2024 08:33 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MrFlorida (Post 2322198)
On a Twilight Zone episode, they came to Earth with a book, " How to serve man" , it was a cook book.!

I remember that episode. Apparently, we are delicious. A bit like pork .... Or so I've been told. 👽😱👽

Topspinmo 04-17-2024 08:57 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by golfing eagles (Post 2305941)
If we were "colonized" or more likely genetically manipulated by those aliens, it would have been the aliens, not humans that visited those worlds. Besides, it is highly unlikely that anything organic could stand on the "surface" of Jupiter.

Also, consider modifications of the Drake equation with the numbers we now have from space-based telescopes. It suggests that in the observable universe there are 40 TRILLION civilizations equal to or more advanced than our own. However, the distances are so great that it is unlikely any 2 would stumble over each other. Plus, Einstein would have to be wrong and FTL travel possible, or the technology to create stable artificial wormholes would have to be possible. And even then we are an insignificant planet at the edge of an insignificant galaxy far from the center of the universe that didn't even have EM transmissions of any power until 90 years ago. Could we have been found and helped by benevolent aliens in the distant past---possible, but highly improbable. Yes, there are mysteries such as the Great Pyramid, Puma Punko and Gobekli Tepe that we can't explain, but applying Occam's razor, more likely they were built with human technology and labor that was lost to us over the millennia than "aliens"

Funny we can’t cut big blocks of stone that accurately today and still can’t lift them in place due to weight. We can’t find the technology cause we never had it. :shocked:

Topspinmo 04-17-2024 09:04 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by fdpaq0580 (Post 2322092)
Ego has nothing to do with it. Curiosity has everything to do with it. Without curiosity to drive us forward, our species would have died off long, long ago. Eventually there will be bases on the moon, then Mars, then farther out. Our species will always want to know what is over the next hill. Eventually, Star Trek and Star Wars will be scifact more than sci-fi. And, probably far sooner then we realize.

We are species of greed and blind following. The have nots want what the haves have. Man only species that kill for fun (some call it sport). Sure majority are weak and must follow, but don’t get out of line or face the raft.

fdpaq0580 04-17-2024 10:15 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Topspinmo (Post 2322391)
We are species of greed and blind following. The have nots want what the haves have. Man only species that kill for fun (some call it sport). Sure majority are weak and must follow, but don’t get out of line or face the raft.

You could be describing most any predatory species that live in groups, like lions, hyena, apes, orcas, etc. And man is not the only species that kills when it isn't necessary. (Seemingly for fun. Chasing down an animal, toying with it, then leaving the dead when it no longer provides entertainment. Cats, dogs, dolphins, apes, and more.)

Battlebasset 04-17-2024 11:45 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by fdpaq0580 (Post 2322092)
Ego has nothing to do with it. Curiosity has everything to do with it. Without curiosity to drive us forward, our species would have died off long, long ago. Eventually there will be bases on the moon, then Mars, then farther out. Our species will always want to know what is over the next hill. Eventually, Star Trek and Star Wars will be scifact more than sci-fi. And, probably far sooner then we realize.

I love Star Trek. But it totally sidesteps the issues of faster than light travel and the issues with space/time when you approach the speed of light. A quick google search will verify this. Even at the speed of light, the closet star, Alpha Centauri, is 4.3 years away.

And this isn't an issue of developing better technology. It's physics. Unless you can figure out a way to suspend those laws, we are stuck pretty much in our own solar system neighborhood.

Stu from NYC 04-17-2024 12:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by fdpaq0580 (Post 2322370)
I remember that episode. Apparently, we are delicious. A bit like pork .... Or so I've been told. 👽😱👽

So we dont taste like chicken?

Davonu 04-17-2024 02:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Battlebasset (Post 2322442)
I love Star Trek. But it totally sidesteps the issues of faster than light travel and the issues with space/time when you approach the speed of light. A quick google search will verify this. Even at the speed of light, the closet star, Alpha Centauri, is 4.3 years away.

And this isn't an issue of developing better technology. It's physics. Unless you can figure out a way to suspend those laws, we are stuck pretty much in our own solar system neighborhood.

You’re letting an individual human being’s short lifespan affect forecasting of humanity’s long term (and I do mean lllloooooong term :) ) potential. There are no known limits…even considering all the speed-of-light and other ‘restrictive’ laws of physics.

Engage!

Battlebasset 04-17-2024 04:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Davonu (Post 2322481)
You’re letting an individual human being’s short lifespan affect forecasting of humanity’s long term (and I do mean lllloooooong term :) ) potential. There are no known limits…even considering all the speed-of-light and other ‘restrictive’ laws of physics.

Engage!

Sorry. I'm "following the science". I hope I'm wrong. But I've seen nothing yet that makes me believe otherwise.

And the reality is, neither you or I will ever know. No chance anything close to light speed travel takes place in our lifetimes. I don't even know of anyone/organization working on it.

Topspinmo 04-17-2024 04:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by fdpaq0580 (Post 2322427)
You could be describing most any predatory species that live in groups, like lions, hyena, apes, orcas, etc. And man is not the only species that kills when it isn't necessary. (Seemingly for fun. Chasing down an animal, toying with it, then leaving the dead when it no longer provides entertainment. Cats, dogs, dolphins, apes, and more.)

But, we’re supposed to be smarter than animals? :oops:

jimbomaybe 04-18-2024 03:42 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Stu from NYC (Post 2322468)
So we dont taste like chicken?

The villages has all manor of clubs perhaps some day a cannibalism club, donate you body to the next BBQ.

fdpaq0580 04-18-2024 08:18 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Stu from NYC (Post 2322468)
So we dont taste like chicken?

Not likely. Cannibals refer to humans as long pig because that is what, apparently, what humans meat tastes like.

fdpaq0580 04-18-2024 08:36 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jimbomaybe (Post 2322551)
The villages has all manor of clubs perhaps some day a cannibalism club, donate you body to the next BBQ.

I would be happy to donate mine once I've died. I won't be using it, and then the question would be answered once and for all without having to rely on the reports of explorers and sailors.
A word to my cooks. I will be best rare to medium-rare with roased potatoes and asparagus, and a sauvignon blanc lightly chilled. I apologize in advance if you find me tough and stringy. I'm old and no longer very tender.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:48 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Search Engine Optimisation provided by DragonByte SEO v2.0.32 (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2025 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.