[Fredman]

Notre Dame proved it did not belong in the top 4. Neither did oklahoma. Georgia and Ohio state should have been in the top 4. ND I believe only played 4 rranked teams.

[Rapscallion St Croix]

Bama and Clemson had to work harder in scrimmages than in those two games.

[npwalters]

Originally Posted by Fredman

Notre Dame proved it did not belong in the top 4. Neither did oklahoma. Georgia and Ohio state should have been in the top 4. ND I believe only played 4 rranked teams.

Georgia yes. Ohio State...….not so much.

[jim1941]

Ohio State.......come to Glenview and I will buy you a boilermaker!

[John_W]

...

[Polar Bear]

Originally Posted by John_W

...I think they got the final 4 right, it's just that Alabama and Clemson are both so much better than anyone else.

Pretty much my feelings.

[MarkinMd]

Notre Dame should join a conference and play in a conference championship game. If they joined the ACC they would have had to play Clemson to get the playoff, if they joined the SEC they would have to play Ala or UGA. Of course then they would have to share the revenues with the other conference members, right now its all their money.
I personally would like to see a 6 team format with the top 2 teams getting a bye and the #3 seed play the #6 seed and the #4 seed play the #5 seed.