Talk of The Villages Florida

Talk of The Villages Florida (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/)
-   The Villages, Florida, General Discussion (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/villages-florida-general-discussion-73/)
-   -   Not happy with changes to the gate card system (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/villages-florida-general-discussion-73/not-happy-changes-gate-card-system-335899/)

coffeebean 10-15-2022 02:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bill14564 (Post 2146742)
Odd that many others haven't mentioned replacing window motors. You aren't the only one rolling your window down, I know I do it all the time and most of the cars in front of me do also. With 70,000+ homes and all the traffic and all the gates and all the people going through those gates you would expect hundreds of motors to need replacing every year.

A system that did not require rolling down a window would be better. This system *might* work through the window (it does for some). Perhaps once this upgrade is completed a mirror device will be investigated but it is sure to come with a cost both to the CDDs/PWAC and to each resident who desires to use it.

I will be happy to pay for the convenience of not needing to use any card.

coffeebean 10-15-2022 02:52 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by twoplanekid (Post 2146787)
As I started this thread to alert Villagers about changes to the gate system, let me make these three points to present my current take on this situation at this moment in time.

If the numbers presented pan out to be true for future cost savings, the District CDDs should save money on some maintenance costs by making this change.

Will the cloned cards work after these changes are made? I still am not sure from the replays received from District staff and am still waiting on the answer to this question. โ€œAre you going to let the Villagers that have cloned cards and the people that are selling them know about your stopping their cards from working? And, is there a gate that I can test my cloned card on to make sure it doesn't work?โ€

Why make Villagers go outside the system to have a better system (in my opinion) for activating the gates? If the cloned coin cards still work using the new system, why doesnโ€™t the District provide the option of receiving coin cards from them that can be placed in car mirrors to activate the gates without human intervention? I will ask them that question!

I thank you for your time and effort to make life just a bit easier for us Villagers. I appreciate your gumption.

twoplanekid 10-15-2022 05:55 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by coffeebean (Post 2146940)
I thank you for your time and effort to make life just a bit easier for us Villagers. I appreciate your gumption.

I appreciate all of the comments made in this thread and especially yours as I would hope everyone is trying to make this place an even better place to live in during our late years in life. District staff is impressed by the interest show in this thread. Again, they are good people working for us and will try to accommodate improvements to the systems if feasible. So, I am hopeful that everyone will end up happy in this great place called the Villages.

dewilson58 10-15-2022 07:18 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by coffeebean (Post 2146937)
I was also put off by that comment. .

:cryin2:
what were you discouraged from doing??
:shrug:

JMintzer 10-15-2022 09:28 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by BrianL99 (Post 2146900)
Originally Posted by retiredguy123

According the The Villages customer service office, there is no rule that prohibits the use of a cloned gate card on your vehicle mirror.



That also means that The Villages has no obligation to make sure "cloned cards" will continue to work nor supply any sort of "support" to continue their usage.

If Villages' upgrades make existing clones obsolete and someone's "side gig" gets harmed in the process ... tough luck.

How the first statement "also means" that "The Villages has no obligation to make sure "cloned cards" will continue to work nor supply any sort of "support" to continue their usage." escapes me...

And this thread has nothing to do with someone's "side gig"...

JMintzer 10-15-2022 09:34 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by coffeebean (Post 2146914)
You need to pull close enough to the card reader. I'm so used to it and I know where I need to be when I pull up to the gate reader. I understand it is the same deal with those card cloned strips that are installed in the side view mirrors.

We pulled up so close we scraped the tires. The "hold it up to the window" trick does NOT work with our cards...

The mirror chip works if the tires are a foot or so away from the curb...

TrapX 10-15-2022 12:19 PM

The solution should be the one to lower costs for everyone.
Best savings: That would be no gates at all.
2nd best: If doing thigs the old way is really adding some warm and fuzzy benefit, make them work like the exit gates. That's next lowest cost because: No buttons. No cards, No new systems. No staff salaries to administer the system. No costs for new hardware, computers and ongoing yearly maintenance. Fewer broken arms to repair.
Worst thing: Spend $270k to replicate something that has zero actual value. Spend our money to do all the things that the first 2 solutions can avoid. Spend even more to "enhance" the system so it behaves like the exit gate arms. Seems like a huge waste of OUR money.

JMintzer 10-15-2022 12:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by coffeebean (Post 2146933)
That is unfortunate for you. Sorry, but mine works every time. And......I HAVE read every post in this thread so far.

Then why would you post this?

"You need to pull close enough to the card reader."

You can't pull up any closer than when your tires are scraping the curb...

JMintzer 10-15-2022 12:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by coffeebean (Post 2146934)
I am very friendly and very careful at the gates whether I'm driving a car or golf cart. I much prefer to wait until all vehicular traffic is clear before I proceed in my golf cart when waiting at the gates. I also do not proceed when a car driver waves at me to proceed. Cars have the right of way in that case. I do not make eye contact and will wait to proceed when traffic is cleared.

Great response... But of course it was not what I was responding to.

I was responding to your comment that they should do away with all gates and just make golf carts wait...

JMintzer 10-15-2022 12:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by coffeebean (Post 2146938)
I will be happy to pay for the convenience of not needing to use any card.

Put a chip in your mirror... I've yet to find a gate where that doesn't work...:icon_wink:

Mrs.Guy 10-15-2022 12:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TrapX (Post 2147171)
The solution should be the one to lower costs for everyone.
Best savings: That would be no gates at all.
2nd best: If doing thigs the old way is really adding some warm and fuzzy benefit, make them work like the exit gates. That's next lowest cost because: No buttons. No cards, No new systems. No staff salaries to administer the system. No costs for new hardware, computers and ongoing yearly maintenance. Fewer broken arms to repair.
Worst thing: Spend $270k to replicate something that has zero actual value. Spend our money to do all the things that the first 2 solutions can avoid. Spend even more to "enhance" the system so it behaves like the exit gate arms. Seems like a huge waste of OUR money.

:22yikes: Did they put up those gates AFTER you moved here or did you NOT notice them and how they worked?

Or another possibility could be that people move here because they love how things are done and then once here enjoy complaining about things????? I can't figure it out.....:shrug:

golfing eagles 10-15-2022 01:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TrapX (Post 2147171)
The solution should be the one to lower costs for everyone.
Best savings: That would be no gates at all.
2nd best: If doing thigs the old way is really adding some warm and fuzzy benefit, make them work like the exit gates. That's next lowest cost because: No buttons. No cards, No new systems. No staff salaries to administer the system. No costs for new hardware, computers and ongoing yearly maintenance. Fewer broken arms to repair.
Worst thing: Spend $270k to replicate something that has zero actual value. Spend our money to do all the things that the first 2 solutions can avoid. Spend even more to "enhance" the system so it behaves like the exit gate arms. Seems like a huge waste of OUR money.

You might not feel this "best" if you get rammed by some bozo entering their village at 50 mph.

Altavia 10-15-2022 01:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mrs.Guy (Post 2147179)
:22yikes: Did they put up those gates AFTER you moved here or did you NOT notice them and how they worked?

Or another possibility could be that people move here because they love how things are done and then once here enjoy complaining about things????? I can't figure it out.....:shrug:

Well, when I moved in, our gate was still in construction mode and essentially worked like the exit gates with no card or button press required.

I was "hopeful" they were changing to this method in the new areas.

Gpsma 10-15-2022 03:18 PM

Get rid of these gates...what are they here for? To protect golf carts?
Golf carts should be only on a golf course...thats why they are called GOLF carts.

dewilson58 10-15-2022 03:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gpsma (Post 2147234)
Get rid of these gates...what are they here for? To protect golf carts?
Golf carts should be only on a golf course...thats why they are called GOLF carts.

& to protect walkers, runners, roller-bladers, segwayers.

So let's get rid of everything and everyone.

:MOJE_whot:

golfing eagles 10-15-2022 03:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gpsma (Post 2147234)
Get rid of these gates...what are they here for? To protect golf carts?
Golf carts should be only on a golf course...thats why they are called GOLF carts.

Yeah, right. You did know this is a golf cart community???

Mrs.Guy 10-15-2022 04:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gpsma (Post 2147234)
Get rid of these gates...what are they here for? To protect golf carts?
Golf carts should be only on a golf course...thats why they are called GOLF carts.

:what:

JMintzer 10-15-2022 06:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gpsma (Post 2147234)
Get rid of these gates...what are they here for? To protect golf carts?
Golf carts should be only on a golf course...thats why they are called GOLF carts.

The Developer thought otherwise...

https://i0.wp.com/www.roamingabout.c...2/DSC05573.jpg

coffeebean 10-15-2022 07:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dewilson58 (Post 2147011)
:cryin2:
what were you discouraged from doing??
:shrug:

You lost me here. Don't quite know what you are referring to.

coffeebean 10-15-2022 07:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by JMintzer (Post 2147115)
We pulled up so close we scraped the tires. The "hold it up to the window" trick does NOT work with our cards...

The mirror chip works if the tires are a foot or so away from the curb...

Good that the mirror chip works for you. I've never had one installed on our vehicle so will just continue to use the card.

coffeebean 10-15-2022 07:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by JMintzer (Post 2147173)
Then why would you post this?

"You need to pull close enough to the card reader."

You can't pull up any closer than when your tires are scraping the curb...

I get it. Your card does not work through the window even if you are on top of the card reader. I just read a couple of posts ago that you scraped your tires trying to get the card reader to work through the window. My comment to pull close to the card reader was several posts ago.

coffeebean 10-15-2022 07:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by JMintzer (Post 2147176)
Put a chip in your mirror... I've yet to find a gate where that doesn't work...:icon_wink:

I would love to use the chip in the mirror but hubby and I have one car and he does not want to have the chip installed. Oh well, he won that one. I really don't mind having to put the card up to the window but it surely would be nice not having to do that.

coffeebean 10-15-2022 07:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gpsma (Post 2147234)
Get rid of these gates...what are they here for? To protect golf carts?
Golf carts should be only on a golf course...thats why they are called GOLF carts.

Oh no, no, no. You cannot be serious. Many people here use their golf carts as their main mode of transportation here in The Villages. That is what makes this community so unique. Our infrastructure is fantastic and one of a kind in the world to accommodate golf cart transportation to so many restaurants, doctors, retail stores, pharmacies and all sorts of stuff that people go to on a daily basis. The MM Paths is what makes our community special.

OrangeBlossomBaby 10-15-2022 07:55 PM

I really don't understand why people think it's such a hardship to use the card. Are y'all the wicked witch of the west, that you melt when exposed to water - when it's raining? Do you never take showers, or go to the pool? Or wash your faces or hands? Are you afraid your custom-woven virgin raw silk upholstery in your Rolls Royce will get bleached if you have to roll the window down on a sunny day, long enough to stick a card out and pull it back again?

I mean - what kind of obsessive compulsive disorder or phobia must one have, to be SO averse to using a gate card to get through a gate, in a community where the advertisement shows that there are gates, that people use cards to get through? Why in the world did you move to the Villages at all, if this is so profoundly offensive to your sensibilities that the very thought of using a gate card to get a gate open sends your mind spiraling into rage?

It's a gate. It's a card. It's not a big deal. The [religious] Space Lasers aren't going to come out of the card and steal your soul like the cameras in the microwave ovens do.

Such silliness.

fdpaq0580 10-15-2022 08:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gpsma (Post 2147234)
Get rid of these gates...what are they here for? To protect golf carts?
Golf carts should be only on a golf course...thats why they are called GOLF carts.

Thanks. We needed a HAHA now. HAHA! ๐Ÿ˜„๐Ÿ˜ƒ

fdpaq0580 10-15-2022 08:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by OrangeBlossomBaby (Post 2147288)
I really don't understand why people think it's such a hardship to use the card. Are y'all the wicked witch of the west, that you melt when exposed to water - when it's raining? Do you never take showers, or go to the pool? Or wash your faces or hands? Are you afraid your custom-woven virgin raw silk upholstery in your Rolls Royce will get bleached if you have to roll the window down on a sunny day, long enough to stick a card out and pull it back again?

I mean - what kind of obsessive compulsive disorder or phobia must one have, to be SO averse to using a gate card to get through a gate, in a community where the advertisement shows that there are gates, that people use cards to get through? Why in the world did you move to the Villages at all, if this is so profoundly offensive to your sensibilities that the very thought of using a gate card to get a gate open sends your mind spiraling into rage?

It's a gate. It's a card. It's not a big deal. The [religious] Space Lasers aren't going to come out of the card and steal your soul like the cameras in the microwave ovens do.

Such silliness.

I don't have a Rolls Royce, I have a Hyundai and the seats are plastic/vinyl? When the rain comes in the seat gets slick, so when I hit the breaks I slide onto the floor. So embarrassing! ๐Ÿ˜ก

Snowbirdtobe 10-15-2022 11:44 PM

Make your own tag clones for under $25.
Get the following from Amazon.
HENA 125KHz Card Programmer, Upgraded Handheld RFID Reader Writer Duplicator Copier
ARONGTECH 125khz rewritable T5577 Sticker Coin Adhesive Back Dia 25mm Thickness 1mm

You can read your own card and write coin sized chips.
This will work with all the gates in the villages and I used them to clone my card and tested it in many gates.
This sort of access card can be made secure with passwords encoded on the card during manufacture of the chip and by writing a password on the chip during initial programming. I don't think that this was done and maintained over the 20 years that these cards were issued. I guess we'll all know the answer to that question in a year or so when the project is done.

JMintzer 10-16-2022 08:18 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by OrangeBlossomBaby (Post 2147288)
I really don't understand why people think it's such a hardship to use the card. Are y'all the wicked witch of the west, that you melt when exposed to water - when it's raining? Do you never take showers, or go to the pool? Or wash your faces or hands? Are you afraid your custom-woven virgin raw silk upholstery in your Rolls Royce will get bleached if you have to roll the window down on a sunny day, long enough to stick a card out and pull it back again?

I mean - what kind of obsessive compulsive disorder or phobia must one have, to be SO averse to using a gate card to get through a gate, in a community where the advertisement shows that there are gates, that people use cards to get through? Why in the world did you move to the Villages at all, if this is so profoundly offensive to your sensibilities that the very thought of using a gate card to get a gate open sends your mind spiraling into rage?

It's a gate. It's a card. It's not a big deal. The [religious] Space Lasers aren't going to come out of the card and steal your soul like the cameras in the microwave ovens do.

Such silliness.

I used to keep mine in my wallet. That meant I had to dig out my wallet from my back pocket every time I wanted to used it.

And people complain when they're stuck behind someone digging out their card...

Have you seen people drop them when reaching out the window? I have. It's a comedy of errors watching them try to pick up the card since they can't get out of their car...

IIRC, there was a days long thread about a "nasty" gate attendant who didn't run out and pick up someone's card who had dropped it on the ground...

But just clip it to the visor! Okay, what to I use when I'm in a different car?

You're right... Complaining that people don't want to use the card is such silliness...

Altavia 10-16-2022 08:45 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by JMintzer (Post 2147429)

...

Have you seen people drop them when reaching out the window? I have. It's a comedy of errors watching them try to pick up the card since they can't get out of their car...

...

After doing that once, I put a small lanyard on the card ;-)

I loved the driver who smacked the red button with her hair brush :-)

OrangeBlossomBaby 10-16-2022 08:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Altavia (Post 2147444)
After doing that once, I put a small lanyard on the card ;-)

I loved the driver who smacked the red button with her hair brush :-)

I've seen some folks with a lanyard for their card. I figured that was why the card has that hole in the top near the edge. I keep mine in the back of my cell phone. The phone goes in the change shelf in the car when I'm driving that, or in the phone-holder in the golf cart when I'm driving that. So I never have to dig for it. I never go anywhere without my phone.

JMintzer 10-17-2022 10:52 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by OrangeBlossomBaby (Post 2147682)
I've seen some folks with a lanyard for their card. I figured that was why the card has that hole in the top near the edge. I keep mine in the back of my cell phone. The phone goes in the change shelf in the car when I'm driving that, or in the phone-holder in the golf cart when I'm driving that. So I never have to dig for it. I never go anywhere without my phone.

Can you still charge your phone on the pad charger with cards on the back?

I found it to be a problem with my phone...

Garywt 10-17-2022 11:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by JMintzer (Post 2147429)
I used to keep mine in my wallet. That meant I had to dig out my wallet from my back pocket every time I wanted to used it.

And people complain when they're stuck behind someone digging out their card...

Have you seen people drop them when reaching out the window? I have. It's a comedy of errors watching them try to pick up the card since they can't get out of their car...

IIRC, there was a days long thread about a "nasty" gate attendant who didn't run out and pick up someone's card who had dropped it on the ground...

But just clip it to the visor! Okay, what to I use when I'm in a different car?

You're right... Complaining that people don't want to use the card is such silliness...

You do know you can move the card from car to car or even to the golf cart. Another option is to get additional cards.

billethkid 10-17-2022 11:57 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Garywt (Post 2147895)
You do know you can move the card from car to car or even to the golf cart. Another option is to get additional cards.

or simply push the little red button

Bilyclub 10-17-2022 12:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mustang428j (Post 2147874)
Gate Card Mirror Chip Installed at your Home. Want to save your Driver side window motor or stay dry while entering your Village Gate. Have a Gate Card Mirror Chip installed in your driver side car mirror and you will not have to open your window at the gate again. Installations are available for Cars, Golf Carts and Motorcycles. Installations done throughout the Villages. Call today to set up an Installation appointment. Installed by a Village resident. Cost is $25 and includes an additional gate card.


Apparently you haven't read the whole thread. They are updating the system and are not stating if the current cloned stuff will still work with the new system.

golfing eagles 10-17-2022 12:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by fdpaq0580 (Post 2147292)
I don't have a Rolls Royce, I have a Hyundai and the seats are plastic/vinyl? When the rain comes in the seat gets slick, so when I hit the breaks I slide onto the floor. So embarrassing! ๐Ÿ˜ก

I'm sorry:1rotfl::1rotfl::1rotfl:

JMintzer 10-17-2022 12:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Garywt (Post 2147895)
You do know you can move the card from car to car or even to the golf cart. Another option is to get additional cards.

I found it easier to get the mirror chip...

Good thing we have choices, isn't it?

Garywt 10-17-2022 10:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by JMintzer (Post 2147921)
I found it easier to get the mirror chip...

Good thing we have choices, isn't it?

Yes but the new gate readers are supposedly eliminating the cloned cards from working. Sounds like the Villages only wants the given cards to work.

Altavia 10-18-2022 06:57 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Garywt (Post 2148063)
Yes but the new gate readers are supposedly eliminating the cloned cards from working. Sounds like the Villages only wants the given cards to work.

This is technically unlikely unless all cards are replaced..

MrFlorida 10-18-2022 07:29 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DARFAP (Post 2145874)
Just push the red button.

Pushing the red button as well as waving your gate card is easy enough, However people with the duplicate in the mirror don't have to roll down the window to do it....that's the reason people are upset.

retiredguy123 10-18-2022 07:36 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MrFlorida (Post 2148115)
Pushing the red button as well as waving your gate card is easy enough, However people with the duplicate in the mirror don't have to roll down the window to do it....that's the reason people are upset.

Envy?


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:08 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Search Engine Optimisation provided by DragonByte SEO v2.0.32 (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2025 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.