[Marine1974]

Originally Posted by Topspinmo

If it was hanging over my property I’d just cut it off at property line.

It would be best to inform owner of tree before doing any trimming and if trimming requires tree trespassing. You want to avoid litigation. The owner might consider having their maintenance people handle it and possibly bill the homeowner . That way if tree is damaged and dies the homeowner would not be responsible.

[gighilton]

Originally Posted by swooner

Have had similar situation. Villages golf management will tell you can trim anything that overhangs your property. That's it. Trust me, they will not remove the tree just because it blocks your view.

Determine if or if not the tree is on your property. Or if it splits the line? Everything is subjective speculation until you know. If its very close to the line, then your construction could easily damage the roots and eventually kill the tree. If its on your property, then of course you can do what you want. The actual location will determine your course of action. Good luck!

[blueash]

Originally Posted by TeresaA

He didn’t say anything about uprooting a tree for a better view 😳 He wants to add a pool, the tree branches are obviously hanging on his property.

Oh yes he did

My Wife and I purchased a home on the golf course with golf course and water views.
Unfortunately, there is a huge Magnolia tree that blocks a major portion.

The tree blocks a major portion of his golf and water views.

[forebubba]

Originally Posted by anthony.giaimo

My Wife and I purchased a home on the golf course with golf course and water views.
Unfortunately, there is a huge Magnolia tree that blocks a major portion. We are planning to build a pool and as much as I love trees and nature this tree needs to be addressed. I was planning on trimming or transplanting the tree but did not realize it was on the golf course property line. Has anyone encountered this type of scenario? And what results if any? Naysayers need not respond. I have seen all the jokes and negativity before on this site and it is disappointing. Loving the Villages Life in The Friendliest hometown in America. Sincerely appreciate your advice.

WARNING do not touch, trim or cut the tree in any way. It will be a very expensive lesson. You can request a visit from the course but don't expect any relief in viewing. I know of a person who trimmed a magnolia and the course put in a larger tree.

[justjim]

Originally Posted by Marine1974

It would be best to inform owner of tree before doing any trimming and if trimming requires tree trespassing. You want to avoid litigation. The owner might consider having their maintenance people handle it and possibly bill the homeowner . That way if tree is damaged and dies the homeowner would not be responsible.

You are spot on.

[HORNET]

The tree was there before you purchased the home, should have realized that! Trees grow and that’s why The Villages planted. The view was set up for the Golf Course also! Not going to the right authorities could cost you fines and expenses to The Villages Golf Course property. The Championship Courses are owned by the Morse Family and is Private Property!

[HORNET]

I also have The Villages Palm trees and Oaks and Magnolia’s behind my home, but they were there when I bought ( new home ) .

[Villagesgal]

Talk to the course manager before doing anything.

[FredMitchell]

FE962/FE962: Handbook of Florida Fence and Property Law: Trees and Landowner Responsibility pretty much covers it.

In general, you may cut the limbs and roots at or inside your property line at your expense. I would have a survey done before doing that if you are going to cut it close.

A surprising result was a case that prevailed when the owner cut down a tree and the owner of the adjoining property was compensated for the impact, loss of shade!

If you do it, it may look unsightly.

(This is not legal advice. IANAL)

[karostay]

If you want it done right It would bolster his case if he mentions his intention to hire a professional arborist

[Bwanajim]

You can always buy a couple of big copper nails and drive them into the trunk. The tree will be gone in a couple years.😂😂😂

[jimjamuser]

Originally Posted by anthony.giaimo

My Wife and I purchased a home on the golf course with golf course and water views.
Unfortunately, there is a huge Magnolia tree that blocks a major portion. We are planning to build a pool and as much as I love trees and nature this tree needs to be addressed. I was planning on trimming or transplanting the tree but did not realize it was on the golf course property line. Has anyone encountered this type of scenario? And what results if any? Naysayers need not respond. I have seen all the jokes and negativity before on this site and it is disappointing. Loving the Villages Life in The Friendliest hometown in America. Sincerely appreciate your advice.

I would rather look at a tree than golfers golfing!.

[tophcfa]

Originally Posted by jimjamuser

I would rather look at a tree than golfers golfing!.

That’s why you didn’t pay a premium for a home on a golf course.

[jimjamuser]

Originally Posted by tophcfa

That’s why you didn’t pay a premium for a home on a golf course.

True !

[Shipping up to Boston]

Originally Posted by blueash

There are some trees that have been planted to prevent the hooks and slices from hitting the homes. If this is one of those trees I would be surprised if the golf gods will allow its removal.

It’s a good point