Talk of The Villages Florida

Talk of The Villages Florida (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/)
-   Current Events and News (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/current-events-news-541/)
-   -   The Big Con (https://www.talkofthevillages.com/forums/current-events-news-541/big-con-307706/)

Steve9930 06-14-2020 11:09 AM

There are two places that influence a child as they grow up. The parents and the schools. Those are the two entities in control of a child's development. Both are failing their job in many cases. Discipline and education.

dewilson58 06-14-2020 11:14 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jimjamuser (Post 1784091)
I could go on and on etc.


please don't, i can't stop laughing as it is.

dewilson58 06-14-2020 11:18 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by kenoc7 (Post 1784046)
You obviously haven't been paying attention - lots of real changes in a number of places already, e.g., banning chokeholds.


Choke holds does not respond to OP's, "...........detail plans to disrupt the on going black issues."


:ohdear:

jbrown132 06-14-2020 11:18 AM

Thank God you didn’t

bpascani 06-14-2020 11:19 AM

Thank you for sharing this U Tube. These men are amazing, and a wonderful inspiration.

kathy1516 06-14-2020 11:37 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Polar Bear (Post 1783778)
No. Claiming that statistically a “solid 2-parent family” is not more beneficial to children than a single parent home is a really stupid insertion. And I mean REALLY stupid.

I think your missing the point. The black multigenerational family lacks strong parenting against having children out of wedlock. It appears to be a rite of passage to have children no matter what the consequences. The change to black lives isn’t from carrying banners with black lives matter, but should come from within the home. There is no consequences to these single women as they have grown up with the thought government will take care of us. This comes from generations of living off the government. The black issues start at home. Their parents and their parents’ parents provide no parenting skills and the cycle continues. The liberals want to keep the blacks oppressed and dependent on the government. In all the years of Jesse Jackson and Al Sharpton stirring up hate and violence has not helped anyone. Where have they been for decades? Why aren’t they encouraging education and having children when they marry and can afford them. Where are their plans for real change in the communities? What have they accomplished to change race relations? NOTHING!!!

Byte1 06-14-2020 11:41 AM

IMO the real "CON" is all those supposed bleeding hearts that believe that there is a "plight of the black person." The plight is history and that cannot be erased no matter how many reminders are destroyed. The black person and the females in this country have the same Constitutional protections and rights as any other citizen. I am not going to apologize for what someone did in the past that has no bearing on how I treat people. America has learned from our forefathers' mistakes so that we do not make the same ones. Time for bleeding hearts to find something else to protest, demonstrate or to be activists for. What's a matter, tree hugging is going out of style?
My motto for this year is going to be "NEWS FLASH: I DON'T CARE." Come up with a legitimate problem and if I can help, I will. I am not going to carry anyone on my back just because someone in our past was a big meanie.

I do not believe we have a law enforcement problem. I believe in every profession we have some bad employees, but they are not the majority or the average. They are the exception. If you do not want to meet those bad actors in the police force, then don't commit unlawful acts and do not run or fight a COP when he approaches you. If a career criminal dies in an unfortunate act, I am sorry, but do the crime and do the time.

It is no longer the black man that has the "plight." I am not going to apologize for an element's failure in our society when EVERYONE has bent over backwards to make EVERYONE feel part of the American family. How much more free stuff and free hands to the top before some of us realize that some folks need to walk on their own instead of being carried?
I am not a racist. I believe in equal rights and treatment that is decent to ALL people. But, like I said I am not going to apologize to anyone for what someone else did many years ago. And I do not apologize for what the police did to Floyd. I didn't do it and I have no idea of the motivation or cause of the death. All I know is that because of it, at least one good man died (Capt Dorn) as a result. Whether Floyd is responsible or not, he was part of the cause. As much as the police that may or may not have handled the situation with bad intent.
Maybe if some folks would just treat minorities the same, not special, then folks would become color blind.

jjombrello 06-14-2020 11:43 AM

What you say may be true, however, you conveniently glossed over the word "solid" in the statement of a "solid, 2-parent family". Statistics and studies, over many years and situations, have proven that children raised in solid, 2-parent homes have a better chance at success in the world than those that don't. This has been particularly true of those families that have lived and survived in the housing complexes occupied for the most part by our black, fellow Americans. It's sad that those conditions prevail, but they will not be resolved if one sticks their head in the sand and fails to admit they exist. Throwing money at this problems has totally failed as a solution so, until we get people who really care, in places of governance, with the fortitude to take politics out of the equation, and enact something meaningful, this problem may be with us for a long time.

jacksonbrown 06-14-2020 11:48 AM

PennBF, you might enjoy this

Years of teaching blacks to have grievances against white people for things that happened centuries ago have come to fruition. Rioting and looting are not enough, the violent thugs and ignorant woke creatures are pulling down historic monuments in public parks and defacing public buildings while police and public authorities stand down.

Education Is Offensive and Racist and so is America

BarryD 06-14-2020 11:59 AM

What plan or solution did you have in mind?

jammendolia 06-14-2020 12:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by OrangeBlossomBaby (Post 1783691)
The "solid 2-parent family" is a really stupid insertion. There are 2-parent families with unwanted kids in them. There are 2-parent families where one of the parents abuses their spouse. Others where one parent abuses the kid(s). There are 2-parent families that have no love within the home. There are 2-parent families where the parents are criminals. There are 2-parent families...etc. etc. etc.

Single parents have it harder - in general. But when you get down to specifics, you'll find there are kids who are raised with just one parent who grow up to be amazing adults, and there are kids who are raised with two parents who grow up to be monsters.

Just take that out of the equation. It is a disservice to single parents, and a disservice to kids of malfunctioning two-parent households.

two orange blossom baby:
it has been well documented that being raised in a married couple household led the poverty rate for black children to go down 73% compared to mother only households and 67% compared to father only households and as evidence of the power of family structure to descend race, 31% of white children raised in mother only household live in poverty versus just 12% of black children living with the married parents this is a stunning realization.
- National center for education statistics (NCES)
please do some research before you start quoting statistics.

Byte1 06-14-2020 12:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jimjamuser (Post 1784091)
Return the tax code to the % percentages used in the 1950s. Eliminate charter schools and return the money and resources to public education. Require ALL new real estate developments to provide affordable homes in the proportion to the ethnicity of the area, which would allow schools to NOT need busing and meld the races together socially and by DNA, hopefully in the future. Have MORE IRS auditors to prevent tax cheating. Reduce Supreme Court terms to 6 years, not lifetime. Cross-train ALL police officers approaching retirement within 5 or 10 years into the Post Office or Peace Corps. Keep Police in rookie academies for 3 years like Denmark to properly evaluate the and eliminate the power/aggresive, violence prone individuals. I could go on and on etc.

Tax code of yesteryear is not likely going to help. Charter schools are great. My grandchildren did very well in them. Forcing someone to build for a certain segment of the population is not FREE ENTERPRISE, it's gov control and that leads to .......... If the police officer needed cross training before retirement, he/she would seek it. Many have second jobs to pay the bills because of the low pay, so they are prepared. Unlike some folks in this country, the police do NOT need personal life choice supervision. They are adults. Explain to me WHY a community in a free country would be forced to have residential quotas? Tax cheating has nothing to do with this subject. Term limits for Supreme Court judges I can agree with, but that is for another subject. Other countries, especially tiny countries find practices that work for them. They also have different laws and different cultures of their own. We do not need to copy anyone else when we have the best in the world; always improving. I do not know where you will find the funding to provide three years of police training.

The only problem we have in law enforcement is how unions protect the few bad cops in this country. VERY FEW. And this is NOT a race thing. I sincerely believe there is a higher percentage of bag politicians than bad COPs. And the people choose the politicians with their votes.

ColdNoMore 06-14-2020 12:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by LoisR (Post 1784028)
Try this for size: "Treat all people the way you expect you be treated."

Exactly!

And THIS...says it all. :ohdear:



Polar Bear 06-14-2020 12:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ColdNoMore (Post 1783783)
So stay married...regardless?...

Did you see the word “statistically”?

Practice what you preach.

Bucco 06-14-2020 12:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by silverh (Post 1784071)
More folks should watch you-tube video's of Shelby Steele and Candace Owens. Explains quite a bit about this unrest in history and what should be done.

While those with "other" interests are oft criticized on here, we find solace in well known political activists. Not sure these are biased folks. They sure will tell you what you want to hear, if that is what you want.

SacDQ 06-14-2020 12:13 PM

You might want to go back to the President Johnson administration to better understand the single parent family structure effecting much of our poor population regardless of color. The welfare system was restructured to allow for larger monthly payments based on a singly parent structure and the number of dependents. This well meaning idea created the mess were in today across the country in rural and intercity locations.

jimjamuser 06-14-2020 01:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Byte1 (Post 1784149)
Tax code of yesteryear is not likely going to help. Charter schools are great. My grandchildren did very well in them. Forcing someone to build for a certain segment of the population is not FREE ENTERPRISE, it's gov control and that leads to .......... If the police officer needed cross training before retirement, he/she would seek it. Many have second jobs to pay the bills because of the low pay, so they are prepared. Unlike some folks in this country, the police do NOT need personal life choice supervision. They are adults. Explain to me WHY a community in a free country would be forced to have residential quotas? Tax cheating has nothing to do with this subject. Term limits for Supreme Court judges I can agree with, but that is for another subject. Other countries, especially tiny countries find practices that work for them. They also have different laws and different cultures of their own. We do not need to copy anyone else when we have the best in the world; always improving. I do not know where you will find the funding to provide three years of police training.

The only problem we have in law enforcement is how unions protect the few bad cops in this country. VERY FEW. And this is NOT a race thing. I sincerely believe there is a higher percentage of bag politicians than bad COPs. And the people choose the politicians with their votes.

I agreed with 1point (out of about 5)....The Police Unions are to heavily invested in protection of bad Police behavior at all costs. Solving that would be a good thread. The statement MY grandson did well at a charter schooland turned out wonderfully......is heavy on the MY and is an N of 1 young man and an N of 1 Charter school. I was talking "big picture". Public schools need help... NOT money and people running away to gated communities and picture-book schools. Of course, with those resources, those schools SHOULD be good. Need a long term study to see if better than gifted ed in public schools. 3 years of rookie police training would be paid by making the tax code fair as it was in the 1950s. Note: there was a REAL middle class from 1950 to 1975. That went away, to a large degree, by flattening the tax system. The statement that the US is the best at everything is very ethnocentric. Check the world list of countries. WE were best after WW2, NOT today. Today we are about 20th in UPWARD MOBILITY and 30th in many other gauges of QUALITY OF LIFE. Check it out, dare to do that! The US has turned its back on its own principles and the world judges and is laughing at us. Why would government have residential quotas? Because there is a problem. The US is burning! We need solutions, that was the point of the thread. I offered solutions. The government installed speedbumps to solve a problem. And speed limits. And the FDA. The government is the referee for solutions to help people. Obviously, people need help with racial justice.

jimjamuser 06-14-2020 01:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SacDQ (Post 1784166)
You might want to go back to the President Johnson administration to better understand the single parent family structure effecting much of our poor population regardless of color. The welfare system was restructured to allow for larger monthly payments based on a singly parent structure and the number of dependents. This well meaning idea created the mess were in today across the country in rural and intercity locations.

Agreed, true that.

psgolf@comcast.net 06-14-2020 01:44 PM

missing the point !!!!!!

PennBF 06-14-2020 01:59 PM

No Retraction
 
I am happy that I don't have to retract the contents of my original submission. In all the responses there was not one that listed, to the best of the writers knowledge the multiple issues surrounding the Minority and corresponding recommendations for solutions. There were some consistent observations as in the case of parenting, some that decided to attack the assertions, e.g. thought the term "label" was misused? this one lost me and one suggested the original note somehow was "another white person pointing out how a black person should be? Again, for the life of me I can't understand how my note could ever be assumed to mean any of that?? I do appreciate the majority of the comments were valid observations
but unfortunately not followed up with meaningful solution and ideas. To say it is a complicated subject is an understatement. Some issues to be addressed and suggested solutions to come forward are (1) Restoring the dignity, (2) Restoring the self worth (3) Bringing action plans to the Urban Housing project, (4) Correcting any inequities in the various level of Education (k-12 and Higher Education (5) Developing respect for the rules of law (6) Providing meaningful opportunities for work for the citizens who are not employed (7) Programs which do not allow or permit the police to be the targets of certain minority groups. (8)ensuring there are rewards and consequences.(9) Fill in the blanks in addition to these!! These are some of the reasons this is not a one solution fits all and why it is a very complicated issue which no one has picked up the flag and run with it. I am use to the slings and arrows fired at this list, etc. and am use to them I just hope that out of them comes a leader not afraid to take them on. :ho:

mjpuleo 06-14-2020 02:06 PM

for one thing, i wish people would stop criticizing our policemen. mind you, i have no police officers in my family so that's not the reason i say this. it is society that is a mess and too many police officers have met their fate because they are not allowed to shoot first when in danger with someone else with a gun and this is what it's all about. you have some "animals" out there that are uncontrollable when confronted by a police officer. again, Floyd's death was wrong, but that officer and the others are being punished for it, so what else do they want? how about Capt. Dolan who was killed by rioters for trying to stop looters--how come his name is not splattered all over the place and no one is protesting about that? i am sick and tired of hearing how police enforcement needs a change. if anything, our law enforcement needs more protection from the "animals" on the streets and the protesters that defend them!

Byte1 06-14-2020 02:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jimjamuser (Post 1784186)
I agreed with 1point (out of about 5)....The Police Unions are to heavily invested in protection of bad Police behavior at all costs. Solving that would be a good thread. The statement MY grandson did well at a charter schooland turned out wonderfully......is heavy on the MY and is an N of 1 young man and an N of 1 Charter school. I was talking "big picture". Public schools need help... NOT money and people running away to gated communities and picture-book schools. Of course, with those resources, those schools SHOULD be good. Need a long term study to see if better than gifted ed in public schools. 3 years of rookie police training would be paid by making the tax code fair as it was in the 1950s. Note: there was a REAL middle class from 1950 to 1975. That went away, to a large degree, by flattening the tax system. The statement that the US is the best at everything is very ethnocentric. Check the world list of countries. WE were best after WW2, NOT today. Today we are about 20th in UPWARD MOBILITY and 30th in many other gauges of QUALITY OF LIFE. Check it out, dare to do that! The US has turned its back on its own principles and the world judges and is laughing at us. Why would government have residential quotas? Because there is a problem. The US is burning! We need solutions, that was the point of the thread. I offered solutions. The government installed speedbumps to solve a problem. And speed limits. And the FDA. The government is the referee for solutions to help people. Obviously, people need help with racial justice.

We don't NEED any more gov. especially more gov control. Sorry, but I do not NEED someone telling me where or where I cannot live, or who my neighbors must be. I see nothing wrong with gated communities, if one wishes to live in them.
"Racial Justice?" Is that different than any other JUSTICE? Why does Justice have to be segregated to race, gender, religion or sexual preference? Why can't one law fit all? Do some have special needs? I am an adult and do not need MORE gov control. The reason the economy did well in the last couple years was because of LESS gov control; less regulations.
The Constitution is color blind and gender blind, therefore if we are TRULY living and moderated by it, then there is NO racial justice, just plain old JUSTICE for all American citizens.

Scorpyo 06-14-2020 03:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by silverh (Post 1784071)
More folks should watch you-tube video's of Shelby Steele and Candace Owens. Explains quite a bit about this unrest in history and what should be done.

I've said the same thing many times and even had a link. The intelligent people that want to get unbiased and informative information already know about Shelby Steele. The others do not want to know anything of Shelby Steele. It might interfere with their bias. If folks really want to educate themselves they should research Alicia Garza, Patrisse Cullors, and Opal Tometi the founders of Black Lives Matter. When I say research I don't mean simply read the headlines that support your narrative. Do real research. I've found that the organizers of many activist type organizations, both left and right, advertise one thing yet have a more radical and, sometimes, violent agenda.

Number 10 GI 06-14-2020 03:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by J1ceasar (Post 1783860)
a majority of single parents with children or however white on social welfare

That stands to reason seeing as how the white population is far larger than the minority populations. That is an intentionally misleading statement, the percentage of each group on social welfare is the meaningful fact.

jimjamuser 06-14-2020 03:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Byte1 (Post 1784226)
We don't NEED any more gov. especially more gov control. Sorry, but I do not NEED someone telling me where or where I cannot live, or who my neighbors must be. I see nothing wrong with gated communities, if one wishes to live in them.
"Racial Justice?" Is that different than any other JUSTICE? Why does Justice have to be segregated to race, gender, religion or sexual preference? Why can't one law fit all? Do some have special needs? I am an adult and do not need MORE gov control. The reason the economy did well in the last couple years was because of LESS gov control; less regulations.
The Constitution is color blind and gender blind, therefore if we are TRULY living and moderated by it, then there is NO racial justice, just plain old JUSTICE for all American citizens.

And did anyone look up the point about the US being low in rankings for "quality of Life" or am I preaching to the wind? Are we not men?----from the movie" The Island of Dr. Moreau"

ColdNoMore 06-14-2020 03:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jacksonbrown (Post 1784127)

:1rotfl:

Talk about a totally ignorant/biased/prejudiced 'opinion' piece. :oops:

Quote:

Davis, like Robert E. Lee, and so many others from Southern states spent their life in service to the United States.

They rallied to the Confederacy only because Lincoln invaded their states.


The author. :oops:

Paul Craig Roberts - Wikipedia

Quote:

He has been a regular guest on programs broadcast by RT (formerly known as Russia Today).
:ohdear:

Stu from NYC 06-14-2020 03:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Byte1 (Post 1784226)
We don't NEED any more gov. especially more gov control. Sorry, but I do not NEED someone telling me where or where I cannot live, or who my neighbors must be. I see nothing wrong with gated communities, if one wishes to live in them.
"Racial Justice?" Is that different than any other JUSTICE? Why does Justice have to be segregated to race, gender, religion or sexual preference? Why can't one law fit all? Do some have special needs? I am an adult and do not need MORE gov control. The reason the economy did well in the last couple years was because of LESS gov control; less regulations.
The Constitution is color blind and gender blind, therefore if we are TRULY living and moderated by it, then there is NO racial justice, just plain old JUSTICE for all American citizens.

Very well said.

One of lifes biggest lies is I am here from the govt to help you.

Number 10 GI 06-14-2020 03:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ele201 (Post 1783978)
Hello. OBB. I couldn’t agree with you more! I have seen 2-parent systems fail, with quite traumatic effects on the children. On the other hand, I’ve seen single parent households operate under tremendous financial strain.

You completely ignore study after study done throughout the years that show children raised in single parent homes have a higher percentage of criminals than children from two parent families.

Stu from NYC 06-14-2020 04:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Number 10 GI (Post 1784249)
You completely ignore study after study done throughout the years that show children raised in single parent homes have a higher percentage of criminals than children from two parent families.

Your completely correct but some people would rather not have to deal with facts when they do not agree with their opinions.

Joe C. 06-14-2020 05:29 PM

Hey !
Do you want a slogan that works all the time ...everywhere?

"OBEY THE LAW"

600th Photo Sq 06-14-2020 05:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by HelenLCSW (Post 1783917)
Actually, Governor Cuomo has come up with a very detailed plan and requiring every mayor to have implemented it by April of next year or they will not receive state financial aid. The plan includes most of the things we have just been talking about. There is no chance, however, that our Florida governor will follow suit🙁

So Gov. Cuomo has finally come up with a cure all plan for this latest fiasco that is taking place.

Well based on his Covid-19 track record which was a complete disaster. thanks but no thanks. :doggie:

Stu from NYC 06-14-2020 05:57 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Joe C. (Post 1784284)
Hey !
Do you want a slogan that works all the time ...everywhere?

"OBEY THE LAW"

But than the people that come after you dont get to loot and destroy and pillage.

LoisR 06-14-2020 06:34 PM

What can you expect from people who have never had any type of social or economical relationship with a person of color? Having been a HS Principal and Asst. Supt of Schools (local and county wide), there is discipline in schools. Expect more of the same unless we, yes, all of us, change.

ALadysMom 06-14-2020 06:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ColdNoMore (Post 1783776)
What do you expect, when privileged whites are given much lighter sentences or let off...for the same things in which blacks are prosecuted & incarcerated?

Or do you think it's just a coincidence, that 70% of those cleared by DNA in the 'Innocence Project' are minorities...and 63% are black?
:oops:

Innocence Project (click here)



Simply a coincidence?

I don't think so.
:ohdear:

Do you have a source for “ privileged whites are given much lighter sentences or let off...for the same things in which blacks are prosecuted & incarcerated?”

Your link to the Innocence Project does not prove your point since your point was how many of each race are “let off”(not charged or simply not arrested but GUILTY of what?) or are “given lighter sentences (again, how many of each race get what sentence for exactly the same crime, in the same jurisdiction and have exactly the same criminal record/rapshee?)

Arrest, Charging with an Offense & Sentencing all occur prior to the Innocence Project ever reviewing the case.

ALadysMom 06-14-2020 06:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Maryc7878 (Post 1783828)
Thank you for the video link. Very informative. Many men giving their perspective. As Denzel Washington states, it all starts with the family.

My six year old grandson has no idea what color his friend is, what ethnicity or religion he might be. He just knows he likes his friend, they like to do things together.
Maybe we can learn from our grandchildren. It is their future we should be trying to build.

You may be imposing your own wishful thinking as you under-estimate the ignorance and innocence of your grandson. Children learn what they live and one of their talents is perceiving things that are unsaid through gestures, vocal tones, facial expressions, and even their perceptions of others’ emotional stress. Very young infants often correctly demonstrate their perceptive abilities when reading and reacting to their mother or other primary caregiver as they mirror them.

Stu from NYC 06-14-2020 06:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by LoisR (Post 1784317)
What can you expect from people who have never had any type of social or economical relationship with a person of color? Having been a HS Principal and Asst. Supt of Schools (local and county wide), there is discipline in schools. Expect more of the same unless we, yes, all of us, change.

We are from NY and they had lots of discipline in the school systems. Many teachers thought they spend more time being a policeman than in teaching.

the local jr high that our son was about to go to made all students go thru metal detectors before heading off to their classrooms. Do you think the school district did this for no reason?

Luckily my job relocated us in the nick of time so we did not have to deal with it.

Do you think that most school districts in disadvantaged areas have no problems with discipline?

ColdNoMore 06-14-2020 07:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ALadysMom (Post 1784320)
Do you have a source for “ privileged whites are given much lighter sentences or let off...for the same things in which blacks are prosecuted & incarcerated?”

Your link to the Innocence Project does not prove your point since your point was how many of each race are “let off”(not charged or simply not arrested but GUILTY of what?) or are “given lighter sentences (again, how many of each race get what sentence for exactly the same crime, in the same jurisdiction and have exactly the same criminal record/rapshee?)

Arrest, Charging with an Offense & Sentencing all occur prior to the Innocence Project ever reviewing the case.

Yep...but more like sources (plural).;)

Here's but a couple of examples.

If you really want to learn more (and I hope you do), there's lots more studies in PDF...that can't be posted here.

I strongly encourage yours (and others)...further education. :ho:


Sentencing different for blacks (poke here)

Quote:

Key Findings

Consistent with its previous reports, the Commission found that sentence length continues to be associated with some demographic factors. In particular, after controlling for a wide variety of sentencing factors, the Commission found:

Black male offenders continued to receive longer sentences than similarly situated White male offenders. Black male offenders received sentences on average 19.1 percent longer than similarly situated White male offenders during the Post-Report period (fiscal years 2012-2016), as they had for the prior four periods studied. The differences in sentence length remained relatively unchanged compared to the Post-Gall period.

Non-government sponsored departures and variances appear to contribute significantly to the difference in sentence length between Black male and White male offenders. Black male offenders were 21.2 percent less likely than White male offenders to receive a non-government sponsored downward departure or variance during the Post-Report period.

Furthermore, when Black male offenders did receive a non-government sponsored departure or variance, they received sentences 16.8 percent longer than White male offenders who received a non-government sponsored departure or variance. In contrast, there was a 7.9 percent difference in sentence length between Black male and White male offenders who received sentences within the applicable sentencing guidelines range, and there was no statistically significant difference in sentence length between Black male and White male offenders who received a substantial assistance departure.

Violence in an offender’s criminal history does not appear to account for any of the demographic differences in sentencing. Black male offenders received sentences on average 20.4 percent longer than similarly situated White male offenders, accounting for violence in an offender’s past in fiscal year 2016, the only year for which such data is available. This figure is almost the same as the 20.7 percent difference without accounting for past violence. Thus, violence in an offender’s criminal history does not appear to contribute to the sentence imposed to any extent beyond its contribution to the offender’s criminal history score determined under the sentencing guidelines.


Punishment for racial perceptions (click here)

Quote:

Race and Punishment: Racial Perceptions of Crime and Support for Punitive Policies

Whites misjudge how much crime is committed by African Americans and Latinos.


White Americans overestimate the proportion of crime committed by people of color, and associate people of color with criminality. For example, white respondents in a 2010 survey overestimated the actual share of burglaries, illegal drug sales, and juvenile crime committed by African Americans by 20-30%. In addition, implicit bias research has uncovered widespread and deep-seated tendencies among whites – including criminal justice practitioners – to associate blacks and Latinos with criminality.

Researchers have shown that white Americans who more strongly associate crime with people of color are more likely to support punitive criminal justice policies. When individuals believe that those who commit crime are similar to them, they more readily reflect on the underlying circumstances of the crime and respond with empathy and mercy. But when people perceive a racial gap between themselves and those who commit crime, they are less compassionate and react instead with anger and outrage.




retiredguy123 06-14-2020 07:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ColdNoMore (Post 1784329)
Yep...but more like sources (plural).;)

Here's but a couple of examples.

If you really want to learn more (and I hope you do), there's lots more studies in PDF...that can't be posted here.

I strongly encourage yours (and others)...further education. :ho:


Sentencing different for blacks (poke here)




Punishment for racial perceptions (click here)

Interesting report. I would just make a few observations about the sentencing differences report. First, the study only applies to Federal crimes, not state crimes. Also, I would expect whites to receive lighter sentences than blacks, not because of their race, but because of their economic advantage. In our justice system, defendants are allowed to hire their own defense attorneys. And, whites have a huge advantage when it comes to paying for a legal defense because they have more money. So, if you want equality in sentencing, then you need to totally change the system to prohibit a defendant from paying for their own defense. O.J. Simpson is a perfect example of how an expensive legal defense can produce a favorable result.

ALadysMom 06-14-2020 07:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by LoisR (Post 1784317)
What can you expect from people who have never had any type of social or economical relationship with a person of color? Having been a HS Principal and Asst. Supt of Schools (local and county wide), there is discipline in schools. Expect more of the same unless we, yes, all of us, change.

Be real. The officers undoubtedly have interacted many times with people of various cultural and ethnic backgrounds as youth, in college, and on the job. They aren’t living in a vacuume.

The question posed by this thread was what specific changes do you think would have meaningful and lasting effects? How did you keep order & gain respect from your students? Did any of them become beat cops on the street?

Do you think would have happened if (like happened in Atlanta) a young white man who was reportedly suspected of driving under the influence resisted arrest by punching a cop in the face then stole his taser and ran then tried to taze the cop? I don’t know if the outcome would have been different but why didn’t the cop allow the other cop to use his taser to subdue the offender? Perhaps the shooter cop did not realize the weapon was his taser? Did he fear the suspect had a gun that he was aiming & discharging? Intense Stress, the darkness of night affecting visual perception, fear of harm to the public nearby could all have caused that officer to have made errors in his judgment. Or he could simply be a power-hungry bully who would probably have demonstrated that flaw many times before. The Atlanta case is very different from the case in Minneapolis yet the two elicit similar responses from protestors.

My relationship to a few cops and my own interactions with them lead me to believe the police forces seek, hire, promote and train far too many bullies. Doing a Myers-Briggs test or other psychological profile on police might be a useful screening tool to guide appropriate hiring and training.

The social media exposure of our young people cannot be overlooked as contributing to the aggressive responses in some instances. Aggression and violence is everywhere young people look...movies, videos, games, social media and many times in their own real life situations too.

Changes should include training of strategic thinking skills and conflict resolution for everyone on both sides. I remember Smokey the Bear’s simple public service commercials, for example. Similar messages could be placed to benefit everyone through social media, commercials, billboards and in a mandated civics course, preferably in elementary schools before dangerous trouble occurs.

Some lessons from the school of hard-knocks: apologizing should come easily since it costs you nothing, being forced to empathize is the only way some people ever put themselves in another’s shoes, respect must be earned and shared both ways, forgiveness is protective & powerful, while having & sharing abundant gratitude changes almost everything.

Change must come. If this continues, who will want to be a cop?

ALadysMom 06-14-2020 08:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by retiredguy123 (Post 1784338)
Interesting report. I would just make a few observations about the sentencing differences report. First, the study only applies to Federal crimes, not state crimes. Also, I would expect whites to receive lighter sentences than blacks, not because of their race, but because of their economic advantage. In our justice system, defendants are allowed to hire their own defense attorneys. And, whites have a huge advantage when it comes to paying for a legal defense because they have more money. So, if you want equality in sentencing, then you need to totally change the system to prohibit a defendant from paying for their own defense. O.J. Simpson is a perfect example of how an expensive legal defense can produce a favorable result.

Legal representation can make a huge difference but you did not mention the differing individual criminal histories of sentencing for similar crimes. A defendant with little or no criminal history is often given consideration over one who has lead a life of crime.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:38 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Search Engine Optimisation provided by DragonByte SEO v2.0.32 (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2025 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.