[Danube]

Originally Posted by OrangeBlossomBaby

Yes, it is one of the few truly gated sections of The Villages. It's not the only one, but it is the first.

And while it is in the municipality known as Lady Lake, it is in Sumter County.

No. All of the Town of Lady Lake is in Lake County.

Hickory Head Hammock is in Sumter County.

Here's the official Town of Lady Lake map: Zoning and FLU Map Viewer | Lady Lake, FL

[Danube]

Originally Posted by OrangeBlossomBaby

https://www.realtor.com/realestatean...9_M65477-20325

That specific house, plus scroll down and you'll see a list of homes in the vicinity. Most of the ones in the Hammock are listed as being in Lady Lake.

The search result page itself has Lady Lake > Sumter County as the filters.

And when I sign up for certain things online, and have to put my address and say Lady Lake, FL, it will often require me to check on a drop-down and select Lake or Sumter county.

Just because a place uses the Lady Lake post office doesn't mean it's in the Town of Lady Lake.

The Post Office has no say in what town/city/county any specific property lies. The town or city and county decide what is legally where, and it's on the property deed. The PO delivers mail, nothing more.

[jimhoward]

I think the situation where the postal address is different from the actual town in which the house is located is common.

We had that situation in Nashville and it was at times quite confusing. I lived in Brentwood, TN a very affluent town with top rated schools. The Brentwood post office sat right on the Brentwood/Nashville line. People in Nashville who lived near the Brentwood post office had a Brentwood mailing address. If you asked them where they lived, they would say "Brentwood" All their mail said "Brentwood". Their driver's licenses, all similar paperwork said "Brentwood". But they sent their kids to Nashville schools, not Brentwood, and taxes went to Nashville. They actually lived in Nashville.

I think it is a similar situation here.

[Traveling lady]

Originally Posted by kbrkr

I've noticed my new address is listed many places with both "The Villages" and "Lady Lake" as the city. Can I choose to use either one, or is one preferred over the other?

My credit card company suggested that I use lady Lake. Because when they put 32159 in the computer, that’s how it comes up. And if I put The Villages it confuses them.

[kschwi]

Originally Posted by Jolson

Really all that matters is the zip code. We used to live in 32163. Moved to Well Point 34762 and had a very difficult time trying to get the car insurance company to understand we did not live in Leesburg (Lake County) but in Sumter. The cost difference for car insurance was $1800 more if we lived in Leesburg. We switched to another company.

What insurance company do you have now? We are in 34762 as well but are in Lake County. You would think being in the same zip code we would have similar rates.

[Crazyladycruz]

You can use either one… depends who you’re trying to impress!🤭