[gatorbill1]

Getting quotes now and confused

[Jobia]

Originally Posted by gatorbill1

Getting quotes now and confused

Neighbor used them

[gatorbill1]

Thank You

[bilcon]

Originally Posted by gatorbill1

Getting quotes now and confused

Eustis Roofing did mine in December and they were great in every way.

[dewilson58]

Sack Roofing is very good.

[tophcfa]

Based on both our experience and a couple of friends, I would recommend McGinniss.

[gatorbill1]

Originally Posted by dewilson58

Sack Roofing is very good.

Went with Sack - better price for same product quoted by 3 other roofers that also had good rating.

[rjn5656]

Several of us in my neighborhood used McGinnis. Excellent.

[barbara828]

Originally Posted by gatorbill1

Getting quotes now and confused

McHale

[Pairadocs]

Originally Posted by Jobia

Neighbor used them

and their assessment was ?

[Pairadocs]

Originally Posted by rjn5656

Several of us in my neighborhood used McGinnis. Excellent.

Just curious, not only about your neighbor's, but others on here, who have given various companies an "excellent" rating. Is it more on the merit of TECHNIQUES used (there are a LOT of little ways to cut corners in application, the number of nails per strip (obviously a using a 12 is going to cost the contractor more than 6 or 8 to a strip, and there are several ways to do the valleys, drips, etc. but are the techniques why some villagers give an "excellent" and others only "average" ? Or is it more that the company has a very personable sales person ? Or because the company has been very responsive to others who may have encountered a problem with their "new roof" ? Or, do most people base their rating on the lowest price ? Or the ability to set a quick date for the job ? Or a fast one day job and a very careful cleanup (of nails) of debris ? Or do people generally take ALL of those into consideration before rating ?

[Pairadocs]

Originally Posted by barbara828

McHale

I see and hear that name often also, but on what factual basis do you (or others) put them above other choices in the area. What makes them stand out ? It's very confusing because in most areas, people can give you a recommendation for a mechanic, or an appliance repair person, and tell you exactly what makes them stand out, what their skills are and what techniques they use, but when it comes to roofers, all we've been able to get from people is just _____ is excellent. When you begin to ask for any kind of details, can't seem to get anything to help sort them all out ! ? ? ?