[memason]

Originally Posted by jaspal

My opinion is that there is an obvious winner at it is:
Crystal Bowersox
The other all fall in the same rating.

I couldn't agree more, but I don't believe she'll win. I believe it's Aaron's to loose, simply due to the voting public, which are probably lots of tweeners.

In the end, it's probably better for Crystal if she doesn't win. That way, she will not be locked into a recording contract with Clive Davis. Loosing was probably the best thing that ever happened to Chris Doughtery and Adam Lambert...free to go their own way. Although, it would be nice to start out with that million dollars in the bank...

...

[Barefoot]

Originally Posted by jaspal

My opinion is that there is an obvious winner at it is: Crystal Bowersox

IMHO, Crystal is the most talented performer. I think she should win. But .... as we've seen in the past, the best performer doesn't always win.

I think Lee Dewyze is a long shot but I like him.

Originally Posted by memason

I couldn't agree more, but I don't believe she'll win. I believe it's Aaron's to loose, simply due to the voting public, which are probably lots of tweeners.

In the end, it's probably better for Crystal if she doesn't win. That way, she will not be locked into a recording contract with Clive Davis. Loosing was probably the best thing that ever happened to Chris Doughtery and Adam Lambert...free to go their own way. Although, it would be nice to start out with that million dollars in the bank...

...

If the past winners are any indication, it will probably be Aaron Kelly who wins. Personally, Crystal Bowersox is the most talented for me. I did not care that much for Adam Lambert but Chris Doughtery sure went a long way without winning Idol.

[Barefoot]

Originally Posted by Barefoot

IMHO, Crystal is the most talented performer. I think she should win. But .... as we've seen in the past, the best performer doesn't always win.

I think Lee Dewyze is a long shot but I like him.

I wasn't surprised to see Aaron go home tonight. Next week it will probably be Casey James or Big Mike to be voted off the island.

[barb1191]

Originally Posted by Barefoot

I wasn't surprised to see Aaron go home tonight. Next week it will probably be Casey James or Big Mike to be voted off the island.

Crystal, Dewyze, and Casey have talent but lacking big time in personality and stage presence like Big Mike is a natural. He knows how to play the stage and audience and also with the best personality of any. Don't think any of the others have the charisma of the big guy Mike. Hope he wins.

Harry Connick did a superb job of coaching these novices and customized arrangements of songs for each contestant. The pop era of Sinatra songs sure improved their voices as well. Harry sure shared sooo much of his show-biz knowledge and experience as well as his expertise for the individual arrangements for each. He's amazing and such a great talent and of all the guest stars they had there, Harry worked with the group the most and it sure paid off with such an improvement over the dull and horrible songs before.

[Russ_Boston]

Originally Posted by barb1191

The pop era of Sinatra songs sure improved their voices as well.

I agree. Makes you wonder about why so many people think singers were better 'back in the day'. Perhaps the songs are just easier for vocalists?

[LELANDJANE]

It was sad to see Aaron go. He was really improving weekly. His farewell performance last night was great. Crystal's stock seems to be falling now. Lee has been the biggest surprise to me recently. I just wish he'd cheer up and enjoy himself. I thought last night's result show was the most fun so far.

[memason]

Well, I said last week, that it was Aaron's to loose. I guess he did.

I like Casey, but I thought he was terrible with the Sinatra song. His voice just isn't suited for that type of music...He should be singing Joe Cocker or Stevie Ray Vaughn. I believe he'll be going home next, followed by Big Mike.

I have to agree... Harry was a fantastic mentor, this week. A true professional!

I'm still a Bowersox fan. I think it'll be Crystal and Lee in the finale...

[chelsea24]

It's getting down to the wire! I just loved Aaron as a person. He seems like such a nice young man.

Of course, I'm still swooning over Adam last season. He really knows how to rock a room.

My vote is for Lee! But, you know me, I'll always vote for a good Chicago guy!!! You go Homie!!!!

He's so cute and really talented. Didn't live far from me either. hmmm... not why didn't I ever buy my paint in Mt. Prospect??? hahaha!

[chelsea24]

Originally Posted by Barefoot

I wasn't surprised to see Aaron go home tonight. Next week it will probably be Casey James or Big Mike to be voted off the island.

Are you watching the right show Ms. Foot??? Or do they have American Idol Survivor in Canada??? hahaha!!! Big kiss and hug! I miss you! xxoo, chels

Originally Posted by Barefoot

I wasn't surprised to see Aaron go home tonight. Next week it will probably be Casey James or Big Mike to be voted off the island.

He seemed to be the most off his game last night.

If you liked the "Falling Slowly" song sung by Lee and Crystal, the movie it is from is well worth a look. It is from Once. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Once_(film)

[redwitch]

If it were my choice, Casey would be long gone. He really was pitchy and downright off tune a couple of times last night. Sorry, Chels, but Lee isn't much better IMO. However, I think it will be Mike who goes tonight. I'm going to miss him. I really do love R&B and he really does it well.

[Russ_Boston]

Agree Red - not sure why people like Lee's voice. Don't see much success long term for him.

[Barefoot]

Casey seems to want to lose, judging by the songs he is choosing. "Hello Mrs Robinson" ... Goodbye Casey! And I think Big Mike is hanging by a thread.

In my humble opinion, the duet by Lee and Crystal last night was fabulous. I actually picked up the phone and voted five times, something I never do!

[Russ_Boston]

Funny how the producers paired the duets. I think they are sure that Mike and Casey are gone by the finale.